Bahrain: 2% tax on remittances is rejected
Financial and economic affairs committee chairman Khalid Al Maskati yesterday said the bill would have a negative impact on the economy and encourage blackmarket and unauthorised cryptocurrencies.
He said MPs had overlooked several factors while approving the legislation in Parliament.
'This disastrous legislation will only reduce remittances made through official channels in favour of illegal money transfer systems,' Mr Al Maskati said during the weekly session yesterday.
In January, Parliament insisted on imposing the levy more than a year after the proposal was unanimously rejected by the Upper Chamber of the National Assembly – following a previous unanimous approval by MPs.
A joint vote of the National Assembly will be scheduled on the issue.
A joint vote has not been taken since 2002 to resolve disputed legislations, which means the topic would likely be put on hold until new MPs and Shura members in 2026 decide to take it up for reconsideration.
Mr Al Maskati further explained that the proposed legislation contradicted mutual and international agreements and conventions and would harm plans to attract investments.
'For instance, adopting the legislation would mean breaching the Unified Arab Investment Agreement which disallows imposing any restrictions – whether administrative, legal or financial – on Arab capital and investments,' he said.
Committee rapporteur Sadiq Al Rahma said the negatives far outweighed the positives and that the proposal was impractical.
'The expected revenue from two per cent tax is low and doesn't constitute as proper government income, while the damage to revenues from other related avenues would be grave,' he added.
'Around 72pc of expats earn less than BD200 a month and they will seek alternative illegal channels to send money.
'It means that either employers will have to increase wages or increase the cost of service.
'Besides, the move could encourage money laundering and result in losses for money transfer agencies, leading to a sequence of other disastrous outcomes.'
Member Ali Al Aradi said legislations are introduced to solve problems and foreign remittance wasn't a problem.
'I have been asking myself, why did MPs propose 2pc and not 0.5pc or 1pc or even 5pc – it is because the legislation was introduced without a comprehensive study,' he said.
Member Abdulla Al Nuaimi said approval of the legislation could lead to Bahrain becoming a haven for fraudsters.
'Instead of focusing on resolving issues related to foreign manpower and associated costs, MPs are putting emphasis on remittances as if it is the main problem,' he said.
Finance and National Economy Ministry officials, represented by the National Bureau for Revenue, earlier said the levy contradicted the basic principles of freedom of money transfer. It also violated the concept of tax as such levies should be inclusive, without anyone being singled out, which was not the case with this legislation, they added.
'The move will have a negative impact on the economy, in general, and the financial and commercial sectors, in particular,' said ministry officials.
'Imposing such a tax would cause massive damage as it will lead to the emergence of illegal transfer channels.
'The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund have, in numerous studies, shown that countries that took the approach have faced trouble controlling transfers and we do not want the same situation here.'
The officials added that such taxes wouldn't be paid by workers and would be forced on sponsors, which would add to the burden on businessmen.
'Such taxes will hugely affect expatriates in leadership positions in companies and banks in Bahrain and it could even lead to them moving to other countries,' they added. 'Bahrain is working towards being a more competitive regional hub. There are also companies that make regular transfers every day, in bulk, and such tax is just illogical and frustrating for them.'
Copyright 2022 Al Hilal Publishing and Marketing Group Provided by SyndiGate Media Inc. (Syndigate.info).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
10 minutes ago
- Zawya
Joint Meeting of Police and Justice Committees Adopts Report on Ad Hoc Committee to Consider Mkhwanazi Allegations
A joint meeting between the Portfolio Committee on Police and the Portfolio Committee on Justice and Constitutional Development today officially adopted its report recommending to the National Assembly (NA) that an Ad Hoc Committee should be established to consider allegations made by the South African Police Service KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Commissioner, Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkwanazi. The report reflects the committees' considered view that an Ad Hoc Committee represents the most effective Parliamentary mechanism to fully investigate and deliberate on the matters raised. The committees recommended the establishment of an Ad Hoc Committee in accordance with NA Rule 253, indicating that the scope of such a committee is task specific and time bound, contrary to the general oversight function of portfolio committees which, in contrast, is ongoing and often requires juggling competing priorities. The report also emphasised the need for the NA to ensure an expeditious process. Without being prescriptive, the committees propose that the NA takes into account, should it resolve to establish an Ad Hoc Committee as recommended, the need for the process to be concluded within 90 days of the committee being established, provided that the timeframe may be amended or extended if necessary. Given the gravity of the allegations and their potential implications for the rule of law, governance, and accountability within the criminal justice sector, the committees have resolved that a focused, multi-party Ad Hoc Committee will ensure a transparent, thorough and fair process. The committees further noted that actual composition of such a committee, as well as its terms of reference, does not reside with the joint meeting. The meeting has reiterated Parliament's constitutional responsibility to exercise oversight over state institutions and to uphold the principles of justice, integrity and accountability. The committees also reaffirmed their commitment to ensuring that this matter is handled with the seriousness it deserves and in line with the Constitution and the rules of Parliament. The report adopted today will be submitted to the NA for consideration. Distributed by APO Group on behalf of The Presidency of the Republic of South Africa.
Gulf Today
an hour ago
- Gulf Today
Nahyan graces 23rd July Revolution event at Egyptian Embassy
Sheikh Nahyan Bin Mubarak Al Nahyan, Minister of Tolerance and Coexistence, and Khalifa Shaheen Al Marar, Minister of State, attended on Monday evening the reception hosted by Sharif Mahmoud Said Eissa, Ambassador of the Arab Republic of Egypt to the UAE, on the occasion of the 73rd anniversary of the 23rd July Revolution. The event, held at the Egyptian Embassy in Abu Dhabi, was attended by a number of senior officials, members of the Arab and foreign diplomatic corps accredited to the UAE, and members of the Egyptian community residing in the country. In his speech on the occasion, Ambassador Sherif Eissa emphasised the depth and strength of the relations between the Arab Republic of Egypt and the United Arab Emirates, built on the principles of brotherhood laid down by the late Sheikh Zayed Bin Sultan Al Nahyan. He noted that the past two years have witnessed both qualitative and quantitative transformations in UAE-Egypt relations, with Emirati direct investment in Egypt reaching an unprecedented level of nearly $70 billion, making the UAE the top investing country in Egypt. He also highlighted the UAE's substantial investments in the Ras El Hekma project on Egypt's northern coast, and noted that bilateral trade between the two countries exceeds $4 billion annually. Earlier, the fourth edition of the Youth Knowledge Forum (YKF), titled 'Knowledge Economy and Human Development,' commenced at the Cairo University Theatre, garnering wide participation both regionally and internationally. It is being organised by the Mohammed Bin Rashid Al Maktoum Knowledge Foundation (MBRF), in collaboration with the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and Egypt's Ministry of Youth and Sports (MOYS) through the Youth Knowledge Office, under the patronage of Dr. Mostafa Madbouly, Prime Minister of Egypt. The opening ceremony was attended by Dr. Ashraf Sobhy, Egypt's Minister of Youth and Sports, along with several other ministers and senior officials, including Dr. Khaled Abdel Ghaffar, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Health and Population; Dr. Ahmed Fouad Hanno, Minister of Culture; and Counsellor Mahmoud Fawzy, Minister of Parliamentary and Legal Affairs. The inaugural session was also graced by the presence of Jamal Bin Huwaireb, CEO of MBRF; Dr. Mohamed Sami Abdel Sadek, President of Cairo University; and Eng. Hany Torky, Project Manager of the Knowledge Project at UNDP, as well as a distinguished group of partners and experts. Furthermore, attendees enjoyed a vibrant lineup of musical and artistic performances by the 'Percussion' troupe. Dr. Ashraf Sobhy stressed that as the host of the Forum's fourth edition, Egypt has demonstrated its strong commitment to investing in human capital and capacity building. Moreover, he stated that the knowledge economy is the backbone of the nation's ongoing development efforts. He further stated: 'The forum serves as a dynamic platform for impactful dialogue and youth policymaking, redefining benchmarks of how government institutions should engage with youth in an era of digital and knowledge transformation. Through such initiatives, we strive to enhance the creativity, awareness, and leadership qualities of Arab youth, since empowering them today is fundamental to building a cohesive society and a sustainable, competitive economy.' Jamal Bin Huwaireb, CEO of MBRF, expressed his delight at the Forum's return to Cairo, following the success of last year's edition. He further underscored that Arab youth empowerment remains a cornerstone of the Foundation's strategic vision. Meanwhile, Eng. Hany Torky, Project Manager of UNDP's Knowledge Project, emphasised that the world's greatest challenge today is not a lack of professional opportunities, but a growing skill gap, which is hindering individuals' ability to keep pace with digital transformation and artificial intelligence. Following the opening, the first session titled 'Knowledge Economy and Human Development' was moderated by Mostafa Magdy, Assistant Minister of Youth and Sports for Strategic Affairs and Information, and a member of the Technical Secretariat of the Ministerial Group for Human Development. The session explored the importance of formulating a comprehensive vision for the knowledge economy and examined the role of Egypt's development policies in supporting the same. The event also featured a second session titled 'Formulating Development Policies in the Era of the Knowledge Economy,' which was moderated by Fathi Emad, Director of the Egyptian Knowledge Youth Office. The session facilitated discussions on enhancing public policies, in line with global shifts in knowledge and innovation. WAM
Sharjah 24
3 hours ago
- Sharjah 24
Sharjah hosts second session of Arab Parliament for the Child
The session welcomes participation from 14 Arab countries, with official delegations representing national children's parliaments and childhood institutions from across the Arab world. A unique Arab platform for young voices This session is being held in an atmosphere of notable Arab engagement, as Sharjah — a hub of intellectual, cultural and developmental initiatives for the Arab child — hosts 56 young parliamentarians representing their countries in this pioneering parliamentary experience. The initiative has become a prominent Arab platform for the voice of the child and a means of reinforcing values of dialogue, citizenship and belonging — serving as a model in empowering the Arab youth to express their opinions on issues that concern them. Wide official presence from Arab states The session will be attended by representatives of the Women, Family and Childhood Department of the Arab League, alongside official delegations from participating countries, representatives from the Arab Parliament, experts and media professionals. The participation of this number of Arab countries reflects the prominent status of the Arab Parliament for the Child and the high level of trust placed in its role in shaping the awareness and developing the promising talents of Arab children. Debate on cultural identity of Arab children The young parliamentarians will discuss a highly important topic during this session: 'The cultural identity of the Arab child.' This theme is considered a key foundation for addressing contemporary challenges, preserving the civilisational and cultural heritage of the Arab nation, and enhancing the sense of belonging among emerging generations. Rich and engaging programme A comprehensive agenda has been prepared for the session, including specialised workshops, dialogue sessions, and a general session where the young parliamentarians will present their views and ideas on the subject of cultural identity. These presentations will be based on working papers prepared by the children themselves, along with analytical studies to be presented in educational, social and cultural contexts. Sharjah's pivotal role in child advocacy Hosting the session in Sharjah affirms the UAE's vital role in supporting childhood issues at the Arab level. It also crowns the civilisational vision of the Emirate of Sharjah, established by His Highness the Ruler of Sharjah, in making the emirate a lasting icon for the Arab child. This is achieved through cultural and intellectual projects such as the Arab Parliament for the Child, which stands as a fruitful collaboration between the Emirate of Sharjah and the Arab League. Statement from the Parliament Secretary-General His Excellency Ayman Othman Al Barout, Secretary-General of APC, stated: 'We are proud to convene the second session of the fourth cycle of the Arab Parliament for the Child amid broad Arab participation, reflecting everyone's commitment to investing in children's capacities and enhancing their involvement in public affairs.' Cultural identity as foundation for the future He added: 'The topic of cultural identity, which our children will discuss, is one of the fundamental pillars in safeguarding the Arab personality against challenges. We firmly believe that empowering the Arab child with enlightened and free expression is the cornerstone of a prosperous and cohesive future.' Gratitude for continuous support Al Barout continued: 'This distinguished event would not have been possible without the generous support and continuous patronage of His Highness Sheikh Dr Sultan bin Mohammed Al Qasimi, who believes in the Arab child's potential for excellence and leadership. We also appreciate the close follow-up of the Secretary-General of the Arab League, His Excellency Ahmed Aboul Gheit, and his commitment to ensuring the success of this ambitious initiative.' Outcomes to support Arab strategies He confirmed that the session is expected to yield important recommendations on the cultural identity of the Arab child, to be submitted to relevant Arab bodies and utilised in supporting national strategies in this area. Since the Arab Parliament for the Child established its permanent headquarters in Sharjah in 2019, it has served as a leading Arab platform that amplifies the voice of children and contributes to preparing them as future decision-makers and active participants in the sustainable development of their communities and nations.
