Brock Purdy won't be elite until he improves in one specific area
He long ago cleared all reasonable expectations for his draft position. There are new expectations now that Purdy has received a five-year, $265 million contract extension. There's one major area Purdy has to improve if he's going to meet or exceed those expectations.
The raw data tells us Purdy has been an extremely productive signal caller since stepping in as the 49ers No. 1 QB in Week 13 of the 2022 season. There have been debates about Purdy's impact on a very productive 49ers offense, but he continues to be a really good player by virtually every metric.
One thing about Purdy's statistical profile stands out, though, and it may be the thing holding him back from being a consensus "elite" quarterback. He is not good when the 49ers are trailing.
Here are Purdy's career numbers in three game scenarios via Pro Football Reference:
49ers lead: 363-527 (68.9%), 4,942 yards (9.4 YPA), 35 TD, 7 INT, 115.2 RTG
49ers tied: 146-220 (66.4%), 1,801 yards (8.2 YPA), 14 TD, 4 INT, 105.1 RTG
49ers trail: 213-322 (66.2%), 2,775 yards (8.6 YPA), 15 TD, 16 INT, 87.9 RTG
There is some expected drop off with his team behind. The interceptions could tick up especially if the 49ers are trailing late and they have to throw. A leap in interception rate from 1.4% with the 49ers tied or leading, to 7.5% when they're behind is catastrophic.
This is something Purdy has to clean up if he's going to launch himself into the upper echelon of NFL QBs.
And it isn't even about the production. It's just about the back-breaking turnovers Purdy is prone to when the 49ers are behind late in a game. Last season he threw four interceptions on 49 attempts (8.2% INT rate) with his team behind with fewer than four minutes to play. It's also worth noting he has zero touchdowns in those situations in his career along with eight interceptions.
Those are wasted opportunities to not only come back, but to stamp himself as a player who can carry the 49ers to wins.
Purdy ideally won't have to carry the 49ers to anything. A well-rounded team that is consistently dominant is the preferred route to victory. There will be times the club leans on its franchise QB to lead them to victory, however, and his ability to do that instead of struggling when they're behind will ultimately determine if he can elevate himself into the NFL's elite QB tier.
More 49ers: 49ers WR laughs at offseason trade talks as he recovers from season-ending injury
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Sauce Speaks Out On Jets QB Justin Fields as Matchup Nightmare
Sauce Speaks Out On Jets QB Justin Fields as Matchup Nightmare originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The New York Jets this offseason gave Justin Fields a two-year, $40 million contract ... and they have given him the starting job. Advertisement There is no doubt about all of that. The real question surrounding New York's new signal-caller is whether he can prove himself able to develop into a quality "franchise quarterback'' - regardless of the price tag. Through the first four seasons, Fields was unable to establish that he was "that guy.'' Amid a number of athleticism-based highlights, struggled mightily for both the Chicago Bears and Pittsburgh Steelers in terms of being a consistent performer, especially as a passer. His time in Pittsburgh - ah, those highlights! - stood out to the Jets, though. While he sat on the bench for most of the team's 2024 Week 7 win over New York, Fields was still someone the Jets had to key on whenever he went on the field. Advertisement "We didn't know if Justin was going to play or not and who was going to be the starter," Jets' All-Pro cornerback Sauce Gardner recalled Wednesday on "The Pat McAfee Show regarding his new quarterback. "We had to change the whole game plan for Justin, just for him to not even play that game, just for Russ (Russell Wilson) to be the starter. So then we went back to the other game plan like the night before or something like that." Gardner's comments show the kind of matchup nightmare Fields can be when he plays at a high level. ... but as a true dual threat. That's why the Jets wanted to bring Fields in the first place. They wanted a quarterback who could win from the pocket and make plays with his legs. Those kinds of signal-callers are very difficult to stop. Advertisement That is what New York is banking on. So long as Fields improves as a passer, the Jets are thrilled with what they have gotten from their new starting quarterback. ... and Gardner's speak-out endorsement is just the latest example of that. Related: Jets Urged To Trade for 15-TD Receiver from NFC Contender Related: Jets' Garrett Wilson-Led Receiver Room Keys Training Camp Watch List This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jul 4, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Jets' Sauce Gardner Aims To Trick A 'Wizard' In Week 1 vs. Aaron Rodgers' Steelers
Jets' Sauce Gardner Aims To Trick A 'Wizard' In Week 1 vs. Aaron Rodgers' Steelers originally appeared on Athlon Sports. By the time the 2025 NFL season gets underway, in part highlighted by Aaron Rodgers leading the Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 1 against his former New York Jets team, Sauce Gardner plans to be ... Advertisement Richer. Bigger. Trickier. Rodgers, of course, spent the last two seasons with the Jets before he was dumped this offseason, and now he and the Steelers will be visiting MetLife Stadium to play his former team in the season opener. The Jets have made major changes in many ways, but a featured guy remains cornerback Sauce Gardner, who recently told ESPN's The Pat McAfee Show that he's "looking forward to the challenge" of opposing Rodgers in large part due to the brain game of football. "He might think he knows all the tendencies that I have, but this offseason has really been me trying not to give nothing away," Gardner said. "I've been trying to work on literally everything because I already know I'm about to go against a wizard Week 1. Advertisement "I already know what time it is.' Gardner has long said positive things about Rodgers as a teammate ... but now must do any he can to take down the 41-year-old legend. Sauce is now bigger; he is listed at 190 pounds, but the Pro Bowl-level performer has added 10 pounds of muscle this offseason. 'I'm sitting about 200 pounds right now and I don't think I've ever really played that heavy,'' he said. "But it's like the more weight I've put on, the more muscle, the more explosive and the faster I become with that muscle that I've put on.' Gardner is also looking for a contract extension and has said that he believes that talks with the Jets are moving in the proper direction. ... maybe toward the $30 million APY level. Advertisement Gardner was named NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year in 2022, as well as being named First Team All-Pro in both of his first two seasons. He also led the NFL in passes defended in his rookie year with 20 ... and he's ready to do even more in 2025 ... Starting in Week 1 when he'll try to "trick'' a "wizard.'' Related: Jets 'Potential Landing Spot' For Ex-Cowboys $100 Million Receiver This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jul 3, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Justin Fields' Jets Weapons Receive Horrifying Ranking
Justin Fields' Jets Weapons Receive Horrifying Ranking originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The New York Jets offense under Tanner Engstrand hasn't gotten much love this offseason, with Justin Fields and his weapons not the flavour of the month. Advertisement But we are all basing it on what we "think" will happen, and with only Garrett Wilson as the consistent outlet, it could be tough sledding for the Jets offensively. And it appears that Kyle Long of NFL on CBS thinks so, too. In ranking all pass-catching units from 32 teams with the help of Mike Renner, the Jets' weapons come in the F tier. Yuck. Horrifying. 'The Jets, it's funny, Garrett Wilson, great receiver,' Long said. 'Allen Lazard, some drop issues, but a guy that is a big target, somebody that I think Justin Fields can lean on. But they're going to run the football a lot. So, I hope that they run the rock. It's an O-lineman's dream to play in that offense. You're not going to give up a lot of sacks. Let's just hope that Justin Fields and this receiving core can figure something out and Allen Lazard is not going to drop the ball.' Advertisement Vincent Carchietta - Imagn Images Behind Wilson, it is Josh Reynolds and Lazard, both of whom haven't been high-stat getters over the past couple of seasons, and behind that duo are young, unproven players like Malachi Corley, Tyler Johnson, and Arian Smith. Yes, the Jets will be a run-first offense, with Breece Hall, Braelon Allen, and Isaiah Davis, but Fields has to be able to complement that with a solid passing game, and Long isn't sure he has the weapons to do it. Of course, this is all a projection, and the proof will be when real NFL bullets are flying in the regular season, but New York's biggest red flag this offseason has been its receiver room. Advertisement And until they prove otherwise, many will doubt their ability to put up enough points to win enough games in 2025. Related: Sauce Speaks Out On Jets QB Justin Fields as Matchup Nightmare Related: Jets Urged To Trade for 15-TD Receiver from NFC Contender This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jul 5, 2025, where it first appeared.
