
Race, national identity, Dr Mahathir Mohamad, Malays
Malays do not need to be under a 'big umbrella' to achieve economic progress in the country. Only hard work, honesty and a positive mindset pay.
Times have changed and former prime minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad's big umbrella non-political concept, as he defined it, to unite the Malays is nothing more than a hidden political agenda criticised by the Malay political leaders themselves.
Malays are already well represented at all levels of the country's administration since the country's independence.
There are also numerous Malay-based political parties in the country, each claiming to champion the rights of the Malays. Can these parties be dissolved and melded into one single party for all the Malays?
This is politically impossible, as each of these parties has its own agenda – that is to seek power for themselves.
And to achieve this, they cannot work in isolation but associate themselves with Malaysian-centric political parties.
Just accept the fact that the demographics of Malaysia are represented by its multiple ethno-linguistic groups that exist in the country.
There are more than 30 major ethno-linguistic groups in the country and despite the diversity of its people there are earnest politicians working towards unifying and not dividing them.
The population is already divided by race, language and religion and they should not be further divided with divisive policies for political gains. The country hence does not need a big umbrella of any sort for any single race.
A Malaysian nation
Ironically, it was Mahathir during his first stint as prime minister who came up with an ideal concept of 'Bangsa Malaysia', which translates to Malaysian nation. It was an inclusive policy for all races.
This has to be nurtured in the country today.
It is a concept and policy to create a unified national identity for all citizens of Malaysia, regardless of ethnicity or background. It aims to foster a sense of belonging and unity across the diverse populations of the country.
The policy seeks to replace the focus on a Malay-centric national identity and embrace a more inclusive approach that encompasses all Malaysian citizens, sharing a sense of national identity and belonging, encouraging cooperation and understanding among different ethnic groups.
The policy emphasises values like cooperation, moderation, and the spirit of give-and-take, aiming to build a nation based on these principles and accepting the Malaysian Constitution as its key component.
The aim here is to create a national identity for everyone in Malaysia replacing the old focus on Malay identity.
Bangsa Malaysia in this context refers to the idea of togetherness and comradeship among the various races. It is not the creation of a Malaysian race as it is impossible unless, of course, all the races assimilate biologically and grow into a race with a single cultural identity.
The problem lies with the system
Imagine studying or working in a foreign country and you meet a person from your homeland: be it a Malay, Chinese, Indian, Kadazan or Dusun, you would feel elated with an urge to become acquainted with the person despite our differences.
When we are away, we feel that we belong to the same nation and we share our experience coming from a country we call ours. This is one measure of Bangsa Malaysia and we have nearly achieved this.
The experience of Malaysians studying or working overseas testifies to this comradeship.
Why then the prejudice at home? The problem lies with the system. We cannot deny that politics, economic disparity and social and cultural preferences have made us perceive ourselves as divergent groups of people living together.
We label every person by his race and religion and, in the process, polarise people further.
From kindergarten to the workplace and until death, we come across countless forms and processes requiring us to identify our race and religion but not nationality first. A child can't help but grow up with prejudice as he is always made to feel different.
We are culturally different but can still share our experiences to create a nationality. The whole notion of creating a Bangsa Malaysia is to foster a deep love for the country, that is, patriotism.
To achieve this, all races should be represented at all levels to create a sense of belonging to this nation.
A state need not belong to one race, one religion or one way of life to be called a nation.
Differences may lead to conflicts, but we should not let them deny us the aspiration of creating a Bangsa Malaysia.
We need more tolerance, mutual support and respect for each other to achieve unity, even with all the diversity around us. Let us then achieve unity despite our diversity.
It is the Malaysian-first mindset that would nurture Bangsa Malaysia. Mahathir's latest Malay centric focus after no more in power is nothing more than another desperate political agenda to further divide the people.
Moaz Nair is an FMT reader.
The views expressed here are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Free Malaysia Today
30 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Umno, Amanah divisions lock horns over Kota Iskandar seat
Amanah's Dzulkefly Ahmad (left) said PH should contest the Kota Iskandar state seat, while Umno's Abd Aziz Sapian said they would let the people judge who truly served their interests. PETALING JAYA : The Iskandar Puteri divisions of Umno and Amanah are gearing up for a possible clash in the next Johor state election, as both stake their claim for the Kota Iskandar seat. Iskandar Puteri Amanah chief Dzulkefly Ahmad had recently said Pakatan Harapan should contest the state seat currently held by Umno, even if it meant a three-cornered fight with its ally Barisan Nasional. 'There is no issue if PH has to face a three-way contest there, including against BN,' he was reported as saying. Dzulkefly, the former Kota Iskandar assemblyman, added that the division had agreed to make this call during its annual general meeting on July 20. 'This shows Amanah's commitment to strengthening the party's presence in Johor and PH's position in such strategic areas,' he said. In response, Iskandar Puteri Umno said it respected the right of any political party to contest any seat and that it was not intimidated by the Amanah man's challenge. The Umno division's information chief, Abd Aziz Sapian, said the party remained committed to bolstering Johor's political stability for the sake of the state's development and the people's welfare. He added that seat negotiations were the prerogative of the leaderships of each party and coalition, not something decided by the divisions. 'The BN assemblyman for Kota Iskandar will continue to serve until the end of his term, unaffected by Amanah's political rhetoric. 'If Amanah chooses to split the votes, Umno sees this as proof of PH's weakness in managing internal consensus. The people will judge who truly serves their interests, and who is merely chasing power,' he said. In the 2022 Johor polls, the Kota Iskandar state seat was won by Umno's Pandak Ahmad with a majority of 4,360 votes ahead of Dzulkefly. Dzulkefly, the Johor Amanah deputy chief, previously said PH might consider going solo in the next state election as BN seemed unwilling to negotiate seat allocations. Johor is currently governed by BN, which has 40 elected representatives, while PH's 12 assemblymen only serve as backbenchers in the state assembly. The opposition comprises Perikatan Nasional's three assemblymen and one representative from Muda.


Free Malaysia Today
31 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Join ‘united opposition front' at own risk, Muda warned
On July 18, Bersatu president Muhyiddin Yassin met with leaders from Muda, Parti Sosialis Malaysia, Pejuang, Putra, the Malaysian Advancement Party and Urimai to discuss the proposed united opposition front. (Bernama pic) PETALING JAYA : Muda risks eroding its modest support base by aligning with Bersatu on its proposed 'united opposition front', two political analysts have warned. Universiti Sains Malaysia's Azmil Tayeb said joining the pact would tarnish Muda's image as a moderate party. Oh Ei Sun. Oh Ei Sun of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs said Muda draws much of its support from middle- to upper-class moderates and liberals in urban and suburban areas. He said this voter demographic tends to abhor the conservative and regressive leanings associated with Perikatan Nasional (PN), the opposition coalition led by Bersatu president Muhyiddin Yassin. 'By associating itself with PN, Muda risks losing these core supporters,' he told FMT. 'They will make for the doors the moment they hear Muda is affiliating itself with PN.' Azmil Tayeb. Azmil warned Muda against associating itself with far-right parties like Berjasa, Mukhriz Mahathir's Pejuang, and Parti Bumiputera Perkasa Malaysia (Putra), led by the controversial Ibrahim Ali. 'In my opinion, this coalition (the united opposition front) has no clear ideology and agenda other than to bring down Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim. It's an unstable coalition with parties that are so different from one another,' he said. '(Joining it will) reflect badly on Muda's image and reputation as a multiethnic and multireligious party.' Last week, Bersatu's Supreme Council agreed that Muhyiddin should spearhead efforts to build a united opposition front in preparation for the 16th general election. Following that, on July 18, the Bersatu president held a meeting with the heads of various parties opposed to the government, including Muda, Parti Sosialis Malaysia (PSM), Pejuang, Putra, the Malaysian Advancement Party and P Ramasamy's Urimai. PAS did not attend the meeting, citing 'other commitments' involving its senior leadership. Ramasamy has since expressed his support for the pact, but PSM and Muda said they remain undecided. Azmil said Muda should instead focus on bolstering its existing partnership with PSM and working at the grassroots level 'regardless of the reward'. Oh, however, said Muda must align itself with one of the three grand coalitions in Malaysia's political arena — PN, Pakatan Harapan or Barisan Nasional. He said that, to date, no political party has emerged on its own as a credible third force capable of reshaping the national political landscape. 'It will be a prolonged struggle if Muda were to remain unaligned,' he added. Muda contested under the PH banner in the 2022 general election. However, Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman, its founder and sole MP, withdrew the party's support for the unity government in September 2023 . The party also signed a pact with PSM in the lead-up to the six state elections held in August 2023. However, both saw their candidates soundly beaten at the polls.


Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
US says Indonesia to cut tariffs, ease critical mineral limits with deal
President Donald Trump hailed a 'huge win' for companies as the US-Indonesia agreement eases restrictions on critical mineral exports. (AFP pic) WASHINGTON : The US tariff deal with Indonesia is set to ease critical mineral export restrictions from the Southeast Asian country to the US, the White House said Tuesday, as President Donald Trump hailed a 'huge win' for companies. The deal, first announced last week, notably lowered a threatened US tariff on Indonesian products from 32% to 19%. Goods deemed to have been transshipped to avoid higher duties elsewhere, however, will be tariffed at 40%, a US official told reporters Tuesday. 'It is agreed that Indonesia will be Open Market to American Industrial and Tech Products, and Agricultural Goods, by eliminating 99% of their Tariff Barriers,' Trump said on his Truth Social platform. The US leader added that 'Indonesia will supply the United States with their precious Critical Minerals' and sign deals to buy Boeing aircraft and US agriculture and energy products. The country is a key producer of minerals like copper, cobalt and nickel. A joint statement separately released by the White House noted that, apart from the lower 19% tariff Indonesian goods will face, certain commodities not available in the United States could also be eligible for an even lower levy. 'Indonesia will remove restrictions on exports to the United States of industrial commodities, including critical minerals,' the statement added. Meanwhile, Indonesia will drop its effort to tax the flow of data, the US official said, speaking on condition of anonymity. The official called this a 'revenue grab' on US companies. The country will also remove pre-shipment inspection or verification requirements on US goods imports, and has agreed to accept US federal motor vehicle safety standards. Both countries are set to finalise the deal in the coming weeks, the joint statement said. Indonesia remains among the first of a surge in deals the Trump administration promised in recent weeks, ahead of a deadline for higher tariffs to take effect on dozens of economies come Aug 1. Washington had imposed a 10% levy on most trading partners in April and hiked duties on dozens among them – before postponing their imposition twice. Apart from Indonesia, the US has announced pacts with Britain, Vietnam and the Philippines. Washington and Beijing also reached an agreement to temporarily lower tit-for-tat tariffs on each other's products, although the pause is due to expire in mid-August. The US official said the Indonesia deal was 'worth at least US$50 billion' to the US in terms of new market access and purchases that Indonesian companies intend to make.