Supreme Court rejects Ilaiyaraaja's plea for transfer of copyright case from Bombay HC to Madras HC
A bench comprising Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justices K Vinod Chandran and N.V. Anjaria did not agree to the submissions of senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for the musician, that the case be transferred to the Madras High Court.
At the outset, the counsel for Sony Music Entertainment told the Bench that the case by the firm was filed in the Bombay High Court when no case was pending in the Madras High Court.
The plea is dismissed, the bench said.
The legal case started from a lawsuit initiated by Sony Music Entertainment India in 2022 before the Bombay High Court. Sony has sought an injunction to restrain Ilaiyaraaja Music N Management Pvt Ltd (IMMPL) from using 536 musical works.
The company claims it acquired the rights to these works through Oriental Records and Echo Recording, the entity with which Ilaiyaraaja has long been embroiled in litigation.
The IMMPL, however, alleged that 310 of the 536 disputed works are already under judicial scrutiny in a parallel case before the Madras High Court.
That case, originally filed by Ilaiyaraaja in 2014 against Echo Recording, challenges the latter's claim over his compositions and seeks recognition of the composer's moral and economic rights under the Copyright Act.
The 2014 Madras suit led to a significant 2019 judgment, which upheld Ilaiyaraaja's moral and special rights as a composer.
Ilaiyaraaja is one of India's most prolific composers with over 7,500 songs across 1,500 films.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
Pavalar Brothers' musical journey rooted in songs, lullabies of our parents, recollects Gangai Amaran
The musical journey of the Pavalar Brothers – Pavalar Varadharajan, Ilaiyaraaja, Gangai Amaran, and Bhaskar – is rooted in the 'songs of our father' and the 'lullabies of our mother', recalls music composer Gangai Amaran. In a freewheeling conversation, moderated by B. Kolappan, Senior Deputy Editor, The Hindu, at the newspaper's head office in Chennai on Friday, Mr. Amaran spoke about his debut film song, Sendhoora Poove, in Bharathi Raja's Pathinaaru Vayathinile, and recalled that he got a high fever from the excitement of knowing that his name would appear in the title card [as lyricist] of the movie. The song earned a National award for playback singer S. Janaki. Reflecting on his musical grounding, Mr. Amaran credited his elder brother Ilaiyaraaja for teaching him to play instruments and giving opportunities to write lyrics for film songs. 'Anna [Ilaiyaraaja] is the one who made me a musician. I would sit next to him during recordings and play the guitar. The guitar portion in the song Machana paathingala malavaazha thoppukulley gained a lot of appreciation,' he said. 'My journey as a music director began when Anna became overwhelmed with many film commitments. My friends, including Malaysia Vasudevan, convinced a producer to let me handle the music for the film Malargalilae Oru Malligai. Initially, the producer wanted Ilaiyaraaja to compose the music, but my friends persuaded the producer by saying: 'Let Amar do it.' I was shocked because I had never composed tunes. I always imagined film titles showing credits like 'Music: M.S. Viswanathan; Lyrics: Kavignar Kannadasan', and hoped to see 'Music: Pavalar brothers; Lyrics: Gangai Amaran,' he added. He further said that initially, Mr. Ilaiyaraaja had not yet begun writing lyrics. Later, he wrote songs with striking depth. Recalling a particular moment, Mr. Amaran shared how a song penned by Mr. Ilaiyaraaja, about their mother, stunned her. 'We recorded it on a tape recorder and played it back to her.' He added that their mother was the source of their musical inheritance. 'Our first recorded song was Annakili unnai theduren, a lullaby our mother used to sing. The tune of Sondhamillai bandhamillai song in Ilaiyaaraja's debut film, Annakili, was inspired by a traditional kummi folk song sung by our mother,' he said. Mr. Amaran's use of colloquial language in lyrics set him apart. 'While many wrote in literary Tamil, I used the spoken language. For instance, instead of writing Odhungi kol odhugi kol rukkumani vandi varugiradhu in poetic Tamil, I just wrote, Oram po oram po rukkumani vandi varudhu, which struck a chord with the masses,' he said. Speaking about his directional blockbuster Karagattakaaran, he recalled how the idea for the film took shape. 'I took inspiration from festivals near our native village [in Theni district], where Karagattam artists would come from Pallavarayanpatti. Many of them came from very modest families, and they found work only during temple festivals. That reality, along with comedy, shaped Karagattakaaran,' he added.
The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
Sujatha Mohan on five decades as a singer
Sujatha Mohan began her career at a time when society believed girls should not sing in public. She recently completed five decades in singing, and has a strong fanbase that spans generations. There are those who remember her as the girl with an angelic voice and smile, a gossamer bow holding up her hair as she sang with popular singer K.J. Yesudas. Some others will recall her early hits such as 'Kannezhuthy pottuthottu' (composed by M. K. Arjunan for the Malayalam movie Tourist Bungalow) and 'Odakkuzhal vili' (composed by M.G. Radhakrishnan for All India Radio), 'Kaalai paniyil' and 'Oru iniya manadhu' (both composed by Ilaiyaraaja for the Tamil films Gayathri and Johnny respectively). Her A.R. Rahman phase in the 1990s is remembered for 'Pudhu vellai mazhai' (Roja), 'Netru illadha maatram' (Pudhiya Mugam) and 'Poopookum osai' (Minsara Kanavu), etc. Today's teens and young adults know Sujatha more as a genial judge at music reality shows. Mention all this, and you can sense Sujatha smiling at the other end of the phone. 'I've always gone with the flow, and it just worked out. Even singing was not something that I planned. It happened. I believe in destiny,' she adds. Trained in Carnatic music The way she traverses the octaves with ease shows she is a trained singer. Sujatha learnt Carnatic music from Neyyattinkara Vasudevan and Ochira Balakrishnan, while musicians Rex Isaac and Emile Isaac trained her in light music. 'I lost my father when I was just two years old. Because I grew up in a single parent household, there were many restrictions. I remember sneaking into the house at 2 a.m. after stage shows.' Despite the huge popularity Sujatha enjoyed, the disciplined environment at home ensured she remained grounded. 'I was expected to study well and get married. I did that too,' she laughs. But, once Sujatha realised music is her calling, she put in the work to create her own niche. 'I am fortunate to have got the support of stalwarts such as Yesudas, M. Jayachandran, Ouseppachan, Raveendran, Ilaiyaraaja, Rahman, Vidyasagar, Sirpi and Keeravani,' says the singer, who has recorded close to 8,000 songs across languages. Sujatha sang her way to fame, she took great care of her voice. 'I did not want to do anything that would have affected my singing.' So, Sujatha gave up offers to judge reality shows early on in her career since that would have meant staying put in studios for long hours. Despite all this, she suffered vocal issues in 2010, when even speaking became a chore. But she worked hard to regain her voice. Sujatha's is a voice that carries a certain wonder for the world around her — think 'Pudhu vellai mazhai', and you can imagine someone looking wide-eyed at Nature's magnificence. If you listen to 'Ishq Bina' (from the Hindi film Taal), you experience a fresh, tender love, with innocence filling its depths. There's a certain purity of sound that serves the demand of the song. The flourishes are there only when needed. Else, what you get is sheer melody. Over the years, Sujatha says she's never really found any song difficult or been nervous about getting it right, barring a couple of occasions. 'I remember 'Anandam anandam' composed by Vidyasagar for Murai Maaman. Unnikrishnan sang the male portion, and it had a lot of Carnatic influences. I wondered if I could manage. When I recently met the film's producer, he mentioned how I ended up recording it very fast. But, I was not so lucky with 'Kaathu kaathu dinam kaathu' for Uzhavan, with music by Rahman. I had a throat infection, and gave up after three or four attempts. Chitra eventually sang the song.' There have also been songs where the popularity was way above the effort. ''Edho oru paatu' from Unnidathil Ennai Koduthaen was easy to sing, but I instinctively knew it would go places, because of the emotion behind the song.' A lifelong student of music, Sujatha even learns from reality shows. 'I signed up for these shows, thinking it will be a great chance to pass on acquired knowledge. But, now, I have realised that children are great teachers too. They have a way of simplifying some sangathis with ease. So much so that I would think: 'Ada, ippadi kooda paadalaama?' (ah, this can be sung this way too!)' Sujatha delights in the joy of getting a chance to mould young talent. 'Sometimes, you just need to hear two phrases to know a child will go places. It is a privilege to see their growth during the course of the show. I am very attached to these children, and stay in touch. Some like D. Sathyaprakash (Super Singer 3 runner-up) still send across their new work. It feels good to have a ringside view of their journey.' Because she had been a child performer, Sujatha also understands the state of mind of children – their fears and insecurities. 'As Baby Sujatha, everything was given to me on a platter. Members of the orchestra always encouraged me. Even later, I never faced any difficulty, because, across industries, I was known as the child who sang with Das anna.' Even when re-establishing herself after a break, Sujatha kept her spirits up. 'I had kept my practice going. And, it helped when I was back behind the mic. Director Priyadarshan called me for Chitram. Then, Rahman entered the scene. A new set of songs came my way.' Sujatha's ability to pronounce Tamil words well has impressed many. 'My vacations would be in Chennai and so, Tamizh came easily though we did not speak it at home. For pronunciation, I would listen to the songs of P. Susheela amma and S. Janaki amma. Moreover, during recording, the lyricists would be around, guiding us. All these years, I've operated only on the principle that every song should be sung like it is one's debut song. A singer is the first one translating the music composer's idea into vocals, and it is important to get into the mood of the song. When you think it is your maiden song, you'll be full of butterflies, and that instils a certain discipline,' says Sujatha. And, while practice and the quest for perfection are important, the singer says, her first take is usually the best. Carrying forward Sujatha's legacy is daughter Shweta Mohan, who's a splitting image of her mother and sounds quite similar too. 'She showed spark, but I did nothing to further her career. She figured it out on her own,' she smiles, adding: 'A good voice alone won't do. You need dedication and the ability to learn from one's mistakes.' Sujatha used to be a livewire stage performer before she decided to give it up, because she felt she was not able to give her 100 per cent. 'People pay, because they like the experience of a live show. And, they should get that. Younger singers who deserve a chance. There are other roles to play in life.' Sujatha has sung across genres in Malayalam, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Hindi and Badaga, but is partial to melodies, especially love songs. She has also recorded devotional numbers. 'I like to sing songs with soul, songs that are happy.' Now, other than private concerts, Sujatha sings for her granddaughter, whom she looks after when Shweta is travelling on work. 'My mother was there for me. I have to be there for Shweta. But I hope to sing till I can. It is a joy unlike any other,' says Sujatha.
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Depression, 2-hour sleep, 40 days of pain: Yuzvendra Chahal opens up on trauma after divorce with Dhanashree
Live Events Is Yuzvendra Chahal dating RJ Mahvash? Chahal on his viral 'sugar daddy' T-shirt (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel India leg-spinner Yuzvendra Chahal has spoken candidly about the emotional toll of his divorce from Dhanashree Verma , revealing he was wrongly branded a 'cheater' and suffered intense mental health struggles , including suicidal thoughts In a deeply personal conversation on the Raj Shamani Podcast , Chahal said the split had been in discussion for some time, even though it appeared sudden to the public.'After my divorce, I was called a cheater. But I have never cheated in my life. I'm extremely loyal — probably more than most. For my loved ones, I've always thought from the heart,' he 34-year-old admitted he went through a dark phase emotionally, struggling to cope with public judgment amid his separation.'I had suicidal thoughts. I was tired of my life. I would cry for two hours a day, sleep just two hours. This went on for over 40 days. I had anxiety attacks, depression. Only those close to me knew what I was going through,' he mental strain pushed him to consider stepping away from cricket, though he eventually chose to on the separation, Chahal pointed to increasing professional commitments as a contributing factor.'It was going on for a while. We decided we wouldn't go public until we were sure. On social media, we looked like a normal couple, but the issues had started to build up. A relationship requires compromise — if both people are always busy, there's bound to be distance,' he Chahal and Dhanashree Verma's divorce was finalized in early 2025, with the Bombay High Court waiving the six-month cooling-off period and directing the Bandra Family Court to expedite the process. The final decree of divorce was granted on March 20, 2025. They had been living separately for over two and a half also addressed the speculation and gossip that followed the divorce, calling it deeply hurtful.'Just because you are seen with someone, people link you up. I have two sisters. I know how to respect women,' he denied the rumours about dating influencer RJ Mahvash. 'No, there's nothing. People can think whatever they want to think," said further shared how his and Mahavash's every outing and spotting was taken out of context-- from their appearance at the Champions Trophy or Christmas dinner with on the same, he said, 'We had a Christmas dinner with five people, but the photo was cropped to make it look like just the two of us were on a dinner date.'.He also recalled a video, which went viral when Mahavash offered Yuzi a pickup ride to the airport. The two were standing outside a hotel when someone recorded them, 'I was just fixing my hair, and people started saying all sorts of cheap things. That really hurt me.'On whether he's open to love again, Chahal admitted, 'It will take time to process. I need to gather myself. I'm not afraid to fall in love again, but I'm scared of losing the person because I get attached with all my heart.'One viral moment — his appearance in court wearing a T-shirt with the message 'Be your own sugar daddy' — was his way of responding without creating more controversy.'I didn't want drama, but something happened from the other side. So, I gave my message through the T-shirt. I didn't abuse anyone,' he the turmoil, Chahal said the separation was ultimately peaceful. 'If things happen between two people, they can still happen peacefully,' he Chahal is playing county cricket for Northamptonshire. He recently picked up a six-wicket haul (6/118) in the first innings against Derbyshire in the County Championship Division Two.
