NGT tells citizen to suggest alternatives to fog machines for air pollution control in Pune
The machines reportedly consume 6,000 litres of water per day per vehicle and cost over Rs 6 crore, raising concerns about resource wastage and environmental impact.Singh also requested for involvement of an institution of repute under the National Clean Air Programme to guide interventions and urged establishment of guidelines, high-grade air quality monitors, and regular meetings of the city-level air quality committee."We are of the view that it would not be wise at this stage to direct stopping the use of machines, which are already purchased or in the process of being purchased, till we find some other better solution to the problem," said the bench of Justice Dinesh Kumar Singh and expert member Vijay Kulkarni. In response, Singh sought time till the first week of June to suggest measures which need to be undertaken to bring air pollution under control in the city."After receiving additional pleadings with respect to alternative measures to be adopted in place of what is being done at present by respondent No.1 – PMC, we will consider issuing notice to the respondents," added the bench. Singh requested the tribunal to direct PMC to monitor and provide accurate data on air pollution, to install sensors in Pune city to track air pollution at appropriate locations. He also argued that ineffective technologies were being adapted to tackle air pollution in Pune, including the proposed use of fog cannon machines costing over Rs 6 crore without any scientific study."Around Sept 2023, without any search being conducted, respondent No.1 – PMC proposed the adoption of mist-spraying machines to control air pollution. Huge sums of money have been spent on purchase of these machines without any study regarding their efficacy. Even fresh tenders have been issued for installation of these machines," said Singh in the application, adding that the tenders were withdrawn after reconsideration by the corporation.He also added that in the information provided to him by the corporation, it was stated that the fog cannon machine vehicles would cover 80 kilometres per day and use 6,000 litres of water. Keeping this in mind, Singh sought scientific support to be extended to the planning authority of each city by an institute of repute identified by Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change and in collaboration with the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board.The tribunal, however, refrained from halting ongoing procurements but allowed time till early June this year for citizens to submit alternative, scientifically grounded pollution mitigation measures, instead of the measures adopted above. Over Rs 262 crore has been spent so far in the past four years from National Clean Air Programme funding without making a real difference to the air quality in Pune. If PMC spent as much on planting new trees, a substantial amount of air pollution could be mitigated, Singh argued at the tribunal and told TOI.The matter has been further listed for June 17.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
Giriraj Singh targets oppn, says those questioning Bihar SIR lack constitutional knowledge
Giriraj Singh, a Union minister, has responded to the opposition's concerns regarding the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision of Bihar electoral rolls. He stated that those who question it lack constitutional knowledge. Singh suggested their concern lies more with foreign nationals than Indian voters. He defended the Election Commission's duty. The opposition fears the revision will disenfranchise eligible voters. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Union minister Giriraj Singh on Monday countered the opposition's objections to the Election Commission 's ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Bihar electoral rolls , saying those questioning it lack basic constitutional knowledge and seem more concerned about foreign nationals than Indian to reporters outside Parliament here, Singh said the Election Commission (EC) is doing its duty and asked why should this make anyone uncomfortable."I think those raising such questions should have some understanding of the Constitution. The Election Commission is simply doing what the Constitution mandates," he 22 years, the EC is carrying out SIR in Bihar to weed out ineligible people from the electoral rolls and to ensure that all eligible citizens are included in the list. It will also help remove duplicate entries of voters who have enrolled themselves in multiple places, according to the poll opposition, however, has claimed that the exercise will disenfranchise crores of eligible people who fail to produce relevant these fears, Singh said the EC is only performing its constitutional said, "They (EC) have asked for just two things: whether the person is an Indian citizen or not, and whether the documents are genuine or fake. Why is that making anyone uncomfortable?""Are they (opposition leaders) worried about foreigners? Whether it is Rohingyas or Bangladeshis, is that where their concern lies? Such people cannot be called patriots," the minister about the opposition's assertion that even constitutional institutions can be questioned, Singh said, "They can ask questions, but one should at least have enough knowledge to know that only an Indian citizen has the right to vote. If someone is not (an Indian citizen), their name will be removed. Why are they restless about this?" PTI UZM DIV DIV DIV
Indian Express
27 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Bengaluru Hebbal–Silk Board tunnel road may add to traffic snarls, add 22 gridlock situations: Detailed Project Report
The Detailed Project Report (DPR) for Bengaluru's ambitious Hebbal–Silk Board underground tunnel has indicated that fewer vehicles are expected to use the corridor in a no-toll scenario than in one where tolls are levied, both towards the city and the airport, suggesting more traffic congestion with tolls. This anomaly, revealed through a review of the traffic projections for the proposed 16.75 km tunnel, has raised eyebrows about the integrity of the demand modelling used to justify the project's viability. Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister D K Shivakumar had earlier emphasised that 'without toll, the tunnel road project will not work.' The numbers defy logic, say mobility experts, who argue that tolling infrastructure generally reduces traffic volumes, as price-sensitive daily commuters, especially those heading into the city, tend to avoid toll roads. According to the final DPR prepared by Rodic Consultants for the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP), the number of vehicles (measured in Passenger Car Units or PCUs) projected during the morning peak hour in 2031 is 34,796 in a no-toll scenario. However, if toll is charged, the number drops to 33,057 PCUs (Scenario 2), and even further to 32,304 PCUs in Scenario 3 (alternative alignment with toll). DPR forecasts higher or similar volumes in toll scenarios, especially airport-bound trips in 2041, where Scenario 2 surprisingly shows more traffic than the no-toll scenario. In the morning peak hour projections for 2031, DPR estimates that 19,932 PCUs will travel towards the city and 14,864 PCUs towards the airport in a no-toll scenario, adding to 34,796 PCUs. However, in the toll-based Scenario 2, these numbers drop to 18,731 PCUs towards the city and 14,326 towards the airport at 33,057 PCUs. Scenario 3, another toll-aligned option, shows an even lower 18,405 PCUs city-bound and 13,899 PCUs towards the airport, totalling 32,304 PCUs. The pattern remains similar in 2041, with the no-toll scenario projecting 26,215 PCUs towards the city and 19,489 towards the airport (at 45,704 PCUs), compared to Scenario 2's 24,949 city-bound and 19,994 airport-bound PCUs (total: 44,943), and Scenario 3's 24,809 city-bound and 19,664 airport-bound PCUs (total: 44,473). DPR also proposes a toll of Rs 330 (one-way) for a distance of 16 km. The report also highlights that tolls for subsequent years are calculated based on a 5 per cent annual increase in the wholesale price index, with a 40 per cent restriction. Additionally, DPR also warns of at least 22 gridlock situations at entry and exit ramps if ramp capacities are not adequately designed or if traffic management is not strengthened. Some of the potential gridlock locations include the Chalukya Circle, Race Course Road junction, Minerva Circle, Cauvery Junction, Lalbagh West Gate, and other areas. The report recommends the need for additional slip lanes and turning lanes, signal optimisation and real-time monitoring systems. Satya Arikutharam, an urban mobility expert, said, 'BBMP's Tunnel Road proposal upends economic theory. Its traffic analysis outputs suggest that more cars will use the Tunnel Road facility when tolled. The entire transport modelling work is flawed, and the all-important modal share is just arbitrarily lifted from the old Comprehensive Mobility Plan (CMP). The DPR is flawed and unreliable, and I do not expect any credible bids for the tender.' Rajkumar Dugar, convenor, Citizens4Citizens forum, said, 'The tunnel road project is likely to do the exact opposite of what it promises. Any minor gain from commuting at an average speed of 50 kmph inside the tunnel will be almost entirely wiped out at the entry and exit points. Worse, it will create traffic chaos for those who aren't even using the tunnel. If the goal is truly to free up the roads, what's needed is a serious push for public transport — buses, metro, suburban rail and more.' Sanath Prasad is a senior sub-editor and reporter with the Bengaluru bureau of Indian Express. He covers education, transport, infrastructure and trends and issues integral to Bengaluru. He holds more than two years of reporting experience in Karnataka. His major works include the impact of Hijab ban on Muslim girls in Karnataka, tracing the lives of the victims of Kerala cannibalism, exploring the trends in dairy market of Karnataka in the aftermath of Amul-Nandini controversy, and Karnataka State Elections among others. If he is not writing, he keeps himself engaged with badminton, swimming, and loves exploring. ... Read More
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Uncertainty looms over supply of eggs to Anganwadi centres, welfare hostels across Telangana
HYDERABAD: The tendering process for supplying eggs to Anganwadi centres and residential welfare hostels — Gurukuls — across the state is once again mired in uncertainty. Despite multiple efforts to streamline procurement and ensure continuous supply of nutritional eggs to children and students, the process now faces renewed political lobbying, demands for dilution of eligibility norms, and the threat of legal hurdles. The previous egg supply contracts expired in February 2025. However, the Model Code of Conduct for the Hyderabad Local Authorities Constituency MLC elections put the process on hold. In the meantime, the Women and Child Welfare Department continued procurement through existing contractors, after a report published in this newspaper exposing the gaps in the system. Although fresh tenders were floated in March, subsequent court cases, revisions to tender norms, and pending approvals delayed the finalisation till the end of June. While the High Court had previously upheld the eligibility norms — such as minimum turnover, prior experience in supplying eggs to government institutions, and Agmark certification — fresh attempts are being made to alter these very conditions. According to highly placed sources in the Woman and Child Welfare department, several poultry operators and a few ruling party leaders are reportedly exerting pressure to dilute these criteria, arguing for relaxation of norms related to minimum turnover and experience. The officials warn that any such changes could invite renewed legal challenges, further delaying the tender process. They assert that criteria like Rs 5 crore turnover and prior experience are not arbitrary but are standard safeguards in any public procurement process, especially one involving perishable food for children. 'If minimum conditions are removed to accommodate ineligible bidders, who will be held accountable if the supply fails midway?' an official said, seeking anonymity. The State government has expanded the scope of the egg tender in a major change from previous years. Earlier, tenders covered only Anganwadi centres, with an annual requirement of about 36 crore eggs. Now, the supply includes welfare hostels and various residential educational institutions, pushing the estimated annual demand to over 80 crore eggs. Besides, the government has moved to a district-wise model covering all 33 districts, putting an end to the earlier seven-zone tender system.
