When everyone is having a menty B
Influencers give pretty speeches in which they claim 'Mental health is important!' and give a cheerful thumbs-up of support.
According to its own mission statement, Active Minds, the American non-profit organisation behind this latest ice bucket challenge, claims to foster a 'diverse movement of peer mental health champions' that 'transform mental health norms across society'.
And while that is a well-intentioned cause, what exactly does it have to do with mental health awareness?
The non-profit's website bats around words such as depression, anxiety, advocacy and change, but it's unclear what exactly this organisation is doing with the US$300,000 (about RM1.29mil) raised by the ice bucket challenge – and the actual impact of these efforts is murky to discern at best.
Besides, if the success of the original ice bucket challenge in raising awareness of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) was questionable, why do we think it would work for mental health now?
A little knowledge is not enough
The problem nowadays with mental health isn't that it's taboo to discuss; it's how much we've turned mental health terms into buzzwords and online trends that spread misinformation.
Youths may think their limited exposure to, and experience with, mental illness, be it in health class or through a stint of now-very-common depression or anxiety, means that they understand all there is to the endless ocean that is mental health.
This false security in knowledge means that they aren't likely to seek out more information and may dismiss people who tell them to educate themselves.
For example, when I asked people at my lunch table to stop gossiping about a classmate's recent suicide, I was told that I was overreacting and that they 'understood' because of going through a rough patch during Covid-19 – despite knowing that I had a close friend die under similar circumstances the week before.
And now these youths are being turned into 'champions'.
Don't get me wrong.
It's a good thing that there are 'more than 15,000 young adults... (who are) passionate advocates and educators for mental health,' as Active Minds reports.
But this may be like having someone with melanoma (a skin cancer) advocating for those dealing with leukaemia (a blood cancer) and claiming they have personal connections to this battle because of their experience with melanoma.
Instead of actually educating themselves about serious mental illnesses, these youths may be convinced to douse themselves in water and throw around terms such as 'Menty B', meaning 'mental breakdown'.
Romanticising mental illness
The danger of using these terms so flippantly, particularly as internet slang, is illustrated by the 'prevalence inflation hypothesis', as presented in a 2023 paper by researchers from Britain and Australia.
I repeatedly hear kids say they're having a panic attack when in fact they're mildly stressed by an upcoming test – so much to the point that I may not get the help I need for an actual panic attack.
As kids hear these disorders referenced more often, through trends such as the ice bucket challenge, they may 'misinterpret milder and more transient forms of distress as mental health problems,' the researchers conclude.
ALSO READ: The difference between being mentally unhealthy and mentally ill
Active Mind's #SpeakYourMIND promotes exactly this.
If we hear the concept enough times, we may start applying it to our daily lives, leading to incorrect self-diagnoses.
We're following the trend of romanticising mental illnesses.
As a Texas State University student put it: 'We are a culture of extremes, and attempts to destigmatise mental illness have inadvertently glamorised it', so much so that it's seen as having ''beautifully tragic' qualities'.
Life-threatening conditions have been turned into what can only be called microtrends, but many people still don't under- stand what those illnesses entail.
Seasonal affective disorder, better known as SAD, isn't just when you feel tired in the winter.
People who have schizophrenia aren't dangers to society, and bulimia and anorexia certainly aren't the same thing!
We must reform our use of mental health language so that we're not propagating stereotypes and allowing them to be turned into an 'interesting' facet of our personalities.
This all begins with a more critical look at what the #SpeakYourMIND ice bucket challenge actually is: a dumb trend for people chasing internet virality while trying to look cute, who are not raising awareness for mental health. – By Abigail AuYeung/Chicago Tribune/Tribune News Service
Abigail AuYeung is a senior (final-year student) at Hinsdale Central High School near Chicago in the United States.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
Ex-teacher hoards 32 tonnes of rubbish
Compiled by CHARLES RAMENDRAN, TAN SIN CHOW and R. ARAVINTHAN A FORMER teacher landed himself in trouble with the authorities for hoarding rubbish at his house in Taman Sentosa in Johor Baru, Harian Metro reported. The hoarder had filled his two-storey house with more than 32 tonnes of rubbish over the course of three decades, which posed a health hazard to himself and his neighbours. Following neighbours' complaints of a bad stench emanating from the house, the Johor Baru City Council (MBJB) issued a notice to the man and carried out a massive clean up with the help of 35 volunteers. Workers also found the place infested with termites, snakes, rats and cockroaches. MBJB councillor Sally Ng said the man claimed the items he had stored were worth RM8,000. To make the man happy, she said, the volunteers gathered recyclable items found in the house but learnt that it could only fetch less than RM1,000. Ng said she will persuade the man to seek help for his mental health. 'He had previously turned down an offer to be placed at a home run by the Welfare Department,' she said. > The burden of caring for sick family members often takes a toll on the emotional and physical wellbeing of caregivers. Local actress Diana Danielle Danny Beeson, also known as Diana Danielle, shared her experience. She said having mixed feelings and facing a myriad of situations can test the patience of caregivers. Although the 33-year-old American-born actress did not divulge details, it is understood that she was referring to her experience of caring for her cancer-stricken mother, Utusan Malaysia reported. She had to skip school for a year to do so when she was just 13 years old. 'It really tests one's patience and can sometimes cause siblings to fight. 'We are also burdened with the fear of losing the family member, especially when the person is the backbone of the family. 'Everyone has different experiences caring for the sick. For me, the biggest challenge was the financial aspect of it,' Diana recalled. Since her mother Norsiah Ramli could not work at the time due to her illness, life was tough for Diana, who ended up living with family and friends and surviving on small portions of sliced bread and instant noodles. She said as a caregiver, she could not break down and be emotional as she had to show strength to comfort her mother. Diana advised those visiting the sick to also take time to show concern for the emotional wellbeing of caregivers. 'Caregivers also need space to express their feelings, especially when they are fatigued,' she said. The above articles are compiled from the vernacular newspapers (Bahasa Malaysia, Chinese and Tamil dailies). As such, stories are grouped according to the respective language/medium. Where a paragraph begins with a >, it denotes a separate news item.
New Straits Times
4 days ago
- New Straits Times
#SHOWBIZ: Justin Timberlake reveals battle with 'relentlessly debilitating' Lyme disease
NEW YORK CITY: Justin Timberlake has disclosed that he was diagnosed with Lyme disease, describing it as "relentlessly debilitating." The singer made the candid revelation in an Instagram post after the final show of his Forget Tomorrow tour in Turkey. The 44-year-old artiste said he had been silently dealing with health issues throughout the tour. "I've been battling some health issues and was diagnosed with Lyme disease. I'm sharing this to shed light on what I've been up against, and not for sympathy," he wrote. Lyme disease is a bacterial infection spread by tick bites that can cause symptoms such as nerve pain, extreme fatigue, and cognitive difficulties. Timberlake said the diagnosis explained the nerve pain and exhaustion he experienced while performing. Despite the challenges, the *NSYNC alum chose to continue with the tour. "The joy that performing brings me far outweighs the fleeting stress my body was feeling. I'm so glad I kept going," he said. Timberlake added that he chose to go public to avoid misunderstandings and to demonstrate his resilience. "I wanted to be transparent, so my struggles wouldn't be misinterpreted. I'm proud of my mental tenacity," he explained. The tour, which began in April 2024, spanned Europe, North America, and Asia. It received mixed reviews, with some critics noting underwhelming performances, which now make more sense in light of his health battle. Timberlake, who has sold over 88 million records and won ten Grammy Awards, is married to actress Jessica Biel, 42. They share two sons, Silas and Phineas. He joins other celebrities like Avril Lavigne and Bella Hadid who have also spoken out about their experiences with Lyme disease. The US public health agency, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, estimates that the illness affects nearly half a million Americans each year.
The Sun
4 days ago
- The Sun
Trump pressures 17 pharma CEOs to cut US drug prices
WASHINGTON: President Donald Trump sent letters to the leaders of 17 major pharmaceutical companies outlining how they should slash U.S. prescription drug prices to match those paid overseas, the White House said on Thursday. Trump signed a sweeping executive order in May demanding drugmakers cut U.S. medicine prices to match those abroad, saying that if companies did not comply, the government could use rulemaking to bring prices down or pursue other measures, such as importing cheaper medicines from overseas. Trump sent the letters to the chief executives of Eli Lilly , Sanofi, Regeneron, Merck & Co , Johnson & Johnson, and AstraZeneca, among others, the White House said. 'Most proposals my Administration has received to 'resolve' this critical issue promised more of the same; shifting blame and requesting policy changes that would result in billions of dollars in handouts to industry,' Trump wrote in the letters, copies of which were posted on his Truth Social account. Shares of Pfizer, Eli Lilly and Gilead Sciences closed down about 2% each, while the NYSE Arca Pharmaceutical Index fell 3% on Thursday. Trump called on drugmakers to provide so-called most-favored-nation prices to every patient enrolled in the government Medicaid health program for low-income people, and to guarantee such pricing for new drugs. The policy is aimed at cutting U.S. prescription drug prices to the lowest possible price paid by members of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, which includes most of the world's largest economies. Trump also said companies must return excess overseas revenue from raising prices in other countries to offset lower prices in the U.S. to American patients and taxpayers through an agreement with the government. He is requiring drugmakers to stipulate they would not offer other developed nations better prices than what they offer the United States, and said his administration would provide ways to cut out middlemen and sell directly to patients, provided they do so at most-favored-nation prices. Trump gave companies until September 29 to respond with binding commitments to those terms. 'If you refuse to step up, we will deploy every tool in our arsenal to protect Americans from abusive drug pricing practices,' he warned. Analysts, lobbyists and drug pricing experts said it seemed unlikely that the pharmaceutical companies would comply with Trump's demand to lower U.S. prices. 'I might expect them to try to determine if any of their current products might be made available via direct sales (one of the requests) at a lower price than currently available in the U.S.,' said Stacie Dusetzina, professor of health policy at Nashville's Vanderbilt University. UBS analyst Trung Huynh said Trump's letters were a repeat of earlier demands and played down any likely industry impact, calling it 'just another shot in the dark.' Trump has already pushed for voluntary changes and some companies have pledged to build new U.S. manufacturing plants. U.S. patients pay by far the most for prescription medicines, often nearly three times more than in other developed nations. The country also invests heavily in pharmaceutical research and development. Drugmakers have said drastic price cuts would stifle innovation. Pharmaceutical companies including Pfizer, Novartis , AbbVie, and German Merck KGaA's U.S. division, EMD Serono, said they were open to working with the Trump administration. Pfizer is working closely with the Trump Administration and Congress to improve access and affordability for American patients, said spokeswoman Amy Rose. 'Our discussions have been productive,' she said-REUTERS
