Exclusive-Meta, X and LinkedIn appeal unprecedented VAT claim by Italy
MILAN (Reuters) -U.S. tech giants Meta, X and LinkedIn have lodged an appeal against an unprecedented VAT claim by Italy that could influence tax policy across the 27-nation European Union, four sources with direct knowledge of the matter said on Monday.
This is the first time that Italy has failed to reach a settlement agreement after bringing tax cases against tech companies, resulting in a fully-fledged judicial tax trial being launched.
According to the sources, this came about because the case went beyond agreeing on a settlement figure and sought to establish a broader approach focused on how social networks provide access to their services.
Italian tax authorities argue that free user registrations with X, LinkedIn and Meta platforms should be seen as taxable transactions as they imply the exchange of a membership account in return for a user's personal data.
The issue is especially sensitive given wider trade tensions between the EU and the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump.
Italy is claiming 887.6 million euros ($1.03 billion) from Meta, 12.5 million euros from X and around 140 million euros from LinkedIn.
Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, Elon Musk's social network X and Microsoft's LinkedIn filed their appeals with a first instance tax court after mid-July, when the deadline for responding to a tax assessment notice issued by Italy's Revenue Agency in March passed.
According to several experts consulted by Reuters, the Italian approach could affect almost all companies, from airlines to supermarkets to publishers, who link access to free services on their sites to users' acceptance of profiling cookies.
It could also eventually be extended across the EU where VAT is a harmonised tax.
In a statement to Reuters, Meta said that it had cooperated "fully with the authorities on our obligations under EU and local law".
It added that the company "strongly disagrees with the idea that providing access to online platforms to users should be subject to VAT".
LinkedIn said it had "nothing to share at this time".
X did not respond to a request for comment from Reuters.
ROME SEEN SEEKING EU ADVISORY
It is uncertain whether a full trial of the matter, which involves three levels of judgement and takes an average of 10 years, will go ahead.
Following discussions with the three companies, Italy is preparing as a next step to seek an advisory opinion from the European Commission, the sources said.
The Italian Revenue Agency will have to prepare specific questions, which the Economy Ministry will then send to the EU Commission's VAT Committee, which meets twice a year.
Rome aims to submit its questions for the meeting scheduled to be held by early November, in order to receive the EU's comments in time for the following meeting in spring 2026.
Italy's Economy Ministry and Revenue Agency declined to comment.
The EU Commission's VAT Committee is an independent advisory group. While its assessment will be non-binding, a "No" could prompt Italy to halt the case and ultimately drop the criminal investigation by Italian prosecutors, according to the sources.
The dispute is one of several between Europeans and U.S. Big Tech.
On July 11 Reuters exclusively reported that Meta would not be tweaking its pay-or-consent model further despite the risk of EU fines.
According to a Financial Times report on July 17, the European Commission has stalled one of its investigations into Musk's platform X for breaching its digital transparency rules while it seeks to conclude trade talks with the U.S.
($1 = 0.8588 euros)
(Reporting by Emilio Parodi, editing by Giselda Vagnoni and Keith Weir, Kirsten Donovan)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
Nikkei, EU stocks surge as US-Japan trade deal avoids the worst
SYDNEY: Japanese shares surged to a one-year high on Wednesday as the country struck a trade deal with the United States that lowers tariffs on its autos, while also reviving hopes for a EU-US agreement that boosted European stock futures. President Donald Trump on Tuesday said a trade deal with Tokyo will include Japan paying a lower-than-threatened 15 per cent tariff on shipments to the US It followed an agreement with the Philippines that will see the US collect a 19 per cent tariff rate on imports from there. Trump also said representatives from the European Union were coming for trade negotiations on Wednesday. That stirred hopes for a deal with Europe, even as the EU was reportedly refining countermeasures in case of a deadlock before the August 1 deadline. EUROSTOXX 50 futures jumped 1.3 per cent, while Germany's DAX futures climbed 0.6 per cent. "Expectations for a breakthrough (on the US-Japan talks) were low, so Trump's announcement delivers a mild upside surprise — providing near-term relief for Japanese equities," said Charu Chanana, chief investment strategist at Saxo. "Strategically, the deal allows Japan to sidestep immediate tariff escalation, while Trump's attention shifts elsewhere." Japan's Nikkei bolted 3.7 per cent higher as shares of automakers surged on news the deal would cut the US auto tariff to 15 per cent, from a proposed 25 per cent. Mazda Motor rallied 17 per cent, while Toyota Motor jumped 13.6 per cent. South Korean automakers also rallied as the Japan deal fuelled optimism over potential progress in tariff negotiations between South Korea and the United States. Analysts noted the trade deal reduced a major risk to the fragile Japanese economy, providing more scope for the Bank of Japan to raise interest rates to fight inflation. That slugged the bond market, with yields for 10-year JGBs rising a whopping 8.5 basis point to 1.585 per cent. There were also reports Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba would soon step down to take responsibility for the ruling coalition's defeat in Sunday's upper house election. The political uncertainty reversed an early trade-inspired rise in the yen and helped the dollar nudge up 0.2 per cent to 146.95 . Saxo's Chanana said Ishiba's departure could set the stage for leadership more aligned with pro-market policies and closer US ties. "His exit is also seen as clearing a path for continuity in Japan's accommodative fiscal and monetary stance." EXTENDED DEADLINES In another positive development, US and Chinese officials will meet in Stockholm next week to discuss an extension to the August 12 deadline for negotiating a trade deal, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said. Chinese blue-chips rose 0.7 per cent and Hong Kong's Hang Seng index gained 0.8 per cent. MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan added 1.0 per cent. Wall Street was more restrained with S&P 500 futures up 0.2 per cent, while Nasdaq futures added 0.1 per cent. US corporate earnings reports were showing signs that Trump's trade war was hitting profit margins. General Motors tumbled 8.1 per cent after the automaker reported a US$1 billion hit from tariffs to its quarterly results. Investors are now awaiting results from Tesla and Google's parent Alphabet - two of the Magnificent 7 stocks that have driven much of the market rally fuelled by AI optimism. In the foreign exchange market, the dollar consolidated having slipped overnight in line with Treasury yields. The dollar index was a shade firmer at 97.45, after losing 0.4 per cent on Tuesday in its third session of declines. The euro dipped 0.1 per cent to US$1.1737, after rising 0.5 per cent the previous day. The European Central Bank is expected to hold rates steady on Thursday after eight consecutive rate cuts, with the prospect of steeper-than-expected US tariffs looming. Benchmark 10-year US Treasury yields ticked up 2 basis points to 4.36 per cent, after slipping 3 bps overnight. While Trump continued to lash out at Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell for not cutting interest rates, Bessent said there was no need for Powell to step down immediately and could stay until next May if he chose. Investors have been worried the politicisation of the Fed could ultimately lead to rates being cut too far, fuelling inflation and pushing up long-term borrowing costs. In commodity markets, Spot gold prices eased a touch to US$3,422 an ounce. Oil prices nudged higher, helped by rising prices for diesel in the US where stockpiles are at their lowest levels for this time of the year since 1996. US crude rose 0.4 per cent to US$65.60 per barrel, while Brent was at US$68.88 per barrel, up 0.4 per cent.
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Trump piles up trade deals as Asia agrees to open up to American goods: Analysis
AUSTIN: It's no easy feat to catch Washington's formidable trade lobbies and relentless, scoop-hungry journalists off guard. Yet on Tuesday (July 22), US President Donald Trump managed to do exactly that. On a day when experts and analysts were poised to dissect a potential deal with the Philippines, awaited after President Ferdinand Marcos Jr's visit to the White House, Trump blindsided everyone by announcing a 'massive' deal with Japan. 'We just completed a massive deal with Japan, perhaps the largest deal ever made,' he said on his social media platform Truth Social. 'Japan will invest, at my direction, $550 billion dollars into the United States, which will receive 90 per cent of the profits. This deal will create hundreds of thousands of jobs - There has never been anything like it,' he added. US$550 billion is S$703 billion. Confirmed by Japan's chief negotiator Ryosei Akazawa, the deal slashes US tariffs on imports from Asia's second-largest economy to 15 per cent, well below the 25 per cent threat that loomed after the July 9 tariff pause ended. Japan will also accede to a key White House demand and open its market to American cars, trucks, rice and certain other agricultural products. In a win for Japan's powerful carmakers, their exports to the US will attract lower tariffs of 15 per cent from the current 25 per cent. The announcement stole the thunder from the Philippines deal, which had been previewed only hours earlier on Truth Social. Trump said the Philippines exports to the US will be subject to a 19 per cent tariff - higher than the 17 per cent initially proposed in April but lower than the 20 per cent threatened earlier in July. In contrast, the Philippines will levy zero tariffs on US goods. Threaten steep tariffs to make others buy more and invest more On the same day, further details emerged on the July 16 agreement with Indonesia, South-east Asia's largest economy. Key provisions included the elimination of nearly all Indonesian tariffs on US goods and a 19 per cent US tariff on Indonesian exports, with certain goods containing content from 'nonmarket economies', read China, to be tariffed at 40 per cent. It was also agreed that Indonesia would provide critical minerals to the US and would purchase Boeing aircraft and American farm products. Such details are still missing from the first deal struck by the Trump administration with a South-East Asian nation, Vietnam, in early July. While negotiations are reportedly still underway, Trump's July 2 Truth Social post revealed key terms of the Vietnam deal, including a 20 per cent tariff on Vietnamese imports to the US and a 40 per cent tariff on transshipped goods, in exchange for Hanoi's commitment to eliminate all tariffs on American exports. Within the span of a month, thus, the White House has unveiled deals not only with Asia's second-largest economy but also with three key Asean economies. For the Asian partners yet to strike deals, such as India and Singapore, these deals set a precedent and create pressure to negotiate similar terms to avoid punitive tariffs and maintain strong trade relations with the US. High-level talks between the US and South Korea talks are scheduled for July 25, with Seoul considering politically sensitive concessions, for example in agriculture and autos, to avert steep US tariffs, which currently stand at 25 per cent but have been postponed to Aug 1. As part of a broader US effort to reset global trade relationships, it would seem that Mr Trump's aggressive tariff strategy is delivering some visible results. All four deals share a common goal: opening markets to American goods to cut trade deficits and support domestic industries. Two other trends are also clear: Trump's steep tariff threats have been effective, and despite falling short of the promised 90 deals in 90 days, analysts are noting a surprising surge in agreements. 'I was very surprised to hear this deal announced today,' Dr William Chou, the deputy director of Hudson Institute's Japan Chair, told The Straits Times. The US$550 billion on top of Japan's current US$860 billion foreign direct investment in the US would make Japan the top investor in the US, head and shoulders above any other country, he noted. Will there be purchase, investment agreements in deal with China? The deals with Asian partners have also attracted the notice of those monitoring US-China trade. 'There was a lot of attention on what would come out of these deals, especially (with) Vietnam, on transshipment and rules of origin. Unfortunately, the devil is in the details and we don't have any details,' said a source who spoke on the condition of anonymity because he advises American companies engaged in business with China. But the Japan agreement signals that the US is expecting purchase agreements in trade deals and that has high significance for a highly anticipated visit to China by Trump, he added. During a press conference alongside Marcos, Trump hinted at a visit to China 'not too far into the future' to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping. But no firm date has been set yet and Chinese imports could be subject to tariffs higher than 50 per cent unless new agreements are reached. 'Many of us are wondering if there will be a focus on purchase agreements similar to phase one trade deal with China in Trump's first term.' The huge investment component in the Japan deal has also sparked the idea that a deal with Beijing might involve large investment commitments from China. 'President Trump in the Oval Office has welcomed Chinese investment in the US. This is obviously in contrast to the hawks in his administration and in Congress, but Trump is ultimately the one that determines China policy,' said the source. However, Dr Chou said a direct geopolitical implication of the flurry of trade deals - with Japan, Indonesia, Vietnam, the Philippines, and likely soon South Korea - is expected to be for China. He said it meant that China can no longer use trade as a wedge issue between the US and Indo-Pacific countries. 'Given the White House's desire to negotiate a good deal with China - and in the wake of China's use of rare earths as economic coercion in the past few months - these trade deals by the White House strengthen Washington's negotiation position with Beijing,' Dr Chou noted. 'I think the administration's demonstration of its priorities, the 10 per cent baseline and long-term frameworks for balanced trade, have become increasingly clear to trading partners,' he said. 'Combined with Trump's willingness to live with tariffs, and the news of customs duties of US$27 billion last month, it provided impetus for trading partners to strike a trade deal,' he added. Customs duties fetched about US$27 billion in June, three times higher than in the same month of 2024, after Trump levied across-the-board 10 per cent tariffs on imports in April on top of other selective duties. On an annual basis, tariff collections have totaled US$113 billion, rise of 86 per cent over last year. Minimising imports doesn't augur well for any economy Less impressed was Frank Lavin, senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, a veteran trade negotiator and former ambassador to Singapore. 'It is hard to fully understand Trump's ultimate goals because at times he talks about the trade balance, at times he talks about reciprocity of tariff rates, at times he talks about re-shoring American manufacturing, and at times he talks about increasing tariff revenue to the US Government,' Lavin said. 'There are any number of contradictions among those four goals,' he said. For instance, if the goal of high tariffs is to boost US manufacturing by disincentivising imports, tariff revenues will fall in tandem with declining imports. It seems that his over-riding goal is a form of mercantilism, attaining greater market access for US firms, and reducing market access to foreign firms. 'It is not clear how this will help the US economy,' he said. Economists believe that maximising exports while minimising imports in an interconnected global marketplace does not augur well for any economy, regardless of its size. Such policies risk economic inefficiency, trade wars and shortchange consumers. - The Straits Times/ANN
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
Tariff deals with US lift Asian stocks; currencies upbeat
NEW YORK: Equities advanced across emerging Asia on Wednesday as investors cheered new US trade deals, with stocks in Indonesia resuming their rally as Southeast Asia's largest economy hammered out tariff arrangements with the United States. The MSCI index of emerging Asian equities jumped 1 per cent to its highest since mid-November 2021, largely driven by a gain of 1 per cent in Taiwan's benchmark index. Thai stocks jumped more than 2 per cent to a two-month high, while equity benchmarks in Indonesia and the Philippines gained as much as 0.7 per cent. US President Donald Trump announced a new tariff of 19 per cent for goods from the Philippines, a touch below the rate of 20 per cent he threatened earlier this month. Indonesia hashed out details of its pact with the United States to eliminate tariffs on more than 99 per cent of US goods and scrap barriers to American firms, while the US will drop its threatened tariff rate on Indonesian products to 19 per cent from 32 per cent. "Asian equities are rallying on a cocktail of positives," said Mohit Mirpuri, equity fund manager at SGMC Capital. "Tariff clarity with the United States across multiple fronts, including Japan and the Philippines, is lifting sentiment," he told Reuters in a text message. Signs of cooling inflation and policy support from China contributed to the risk-on approach across the region, he added. "Investors are rotating back into Asia, where valuations look compelling and policy risk is finally easing." Analysts saw the economic impact of the Philippines tariff rate of 19 per cent as relatively limited. A note of caution was struck by William Bratton, head of APAC cash equity research at BNP Paribas, warning that the rates, though less severe than feared, could prove disruptive for Asian exporters and punitive for earnings in the long term. Earlier, Japan and the United States struck a deal to lower to 15 per cent the tariff on all imported goods from the steep 25 per cent Trump had previously threatened, with Japan also pledging to invest US$550 billion in the US Elsewhere in Southeast Asia, stocks in Singapore gained for a 13th straight session in their longest streak on record. They had traded most of Tuesday in the red but ended slightly higher. Stocks in Kuala Lumpur added 0.3 per cent. Equities in Bangkok were set for their strongest day in almost a week. The appointment of rate-cut advocate Vitai Ratanakorn as governor of the Thai central bank, has boosted investor confidence, though concerns linger on its independence. "His (Vitai's) remarks and public statements suggest a decisive shift towards more aggressive monetary easing and closer coordination with government fiscal policies," analysts at Citi said in a note. Among currencies, South Korea's won and Taiwan's dollar appreciated up to 0.4 per cent, while Indonesia's rupiah , Thai baht, Singapore dollar, and Malaysia's ringgit traded largely unchanged. The MSCI index of global emerging market currencies rose to a two-week peak.
