Man City sheikh was ‘shadow owner' of hospital tainted by fraud, claims EY
The Emirati royal had links to two Emirati businessmen accused of stealing billions from the former FTSE 100 company, the accountancy giant has alleged.
It was claimed his connections to NMC Health saw it shielded from proper scrutiny, meaning banks ignored 'red flags' to lend billions to the London-listed healthcare giant before its 2020 collapse.
EY made the claims in submissions to the High Court as it seeks to defend itself against a £2bn lawsuit brought forward by bankruptcy administrator Alvarez & Marsal.
The 'big four' firm claims Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan had close ties to two of NMC Health's top shareholders, Saeed and Khalifa bin Butti.
They are accused of stealing billions from the healthcare company alongside BR Shetty, its founder.
The three shareholders, who together owned two thirds of all shares in NMC Health, are accused of defrauding the company by borrowing more than $4bn (£3bn) worth of secret debt.
Dr Shetty has instead claimed he was the victim of a wider fraud. The High Court subsequently froze Dr Shetty's assets in 2022, including a luxury London penthouse.
EY claims fraudsters inside NMC Health used their links to Sheikh Mansour to secure loans from banks, who were willing to lend billions to the chain headquartered in Abu Dhabi because of the Emirati royal's 'name' and credibility.
The accounting firm's submissions to the High Court say: 'The evidence ... suggests that Sheikh Mansour stood behind the Bin Buttis in some informal way, making him effectively a shadow owner of NMC.'
Sheikh Mansour's links to NMC Health were 'well understood in the region,' EY's submissions add.
It claimed that banks conducted due diligence with the 'lightest of touches' due to the credibility given to the company by the Emirati royal.
NMC Health's lenders 'failed to take obvious steps to protect their own interests by conducting proper due diligence on the loans they were advancing to the NMC Group,' EY's submissions to the High Court say.
Sheikh Mansour is a member of Abu Dhabi's royal family, and is currently the United Arab Emirate's vice president. The Emirati billionaire is also the owner of Manchester City Football Club.
The accountancy giant says Alvarez & Marsal have also 'shied away' from pursuing the Bin Butti brothers, because of their links to Sheikh Mansour.
EY's submissions to the High Court say: 'No serious attempt seems to have been made to pursue the money stolen by the Bin Buttis.'
The claims come as EY is accused of 'extremely serious' failings in its audits of NMC Health that resulted in the accountancy giant allegedly missing one of the biggest frauds ever involving a London-listed company.
Alvarez & Marsal claims EY's accountants 'never even opened the books' at NMC Health. EY said it was a 'principal target and victim' of the alleged fraud.
Lawyers for the accountancy firm separately accused Abdul Rahman Basaddiq, the former head of EY's Abu Dhabi office, of having enabled the fraud. At a hearing on Wednesday, lawyers for EY told the High Court that Mr Basaddiq was 'plainly a fraudster'.
The Bin Butti brothers did not respond to Telegraph requests for comment. Khalifa bin Butti told The Times in 2020 that 'any suggestion that I have been involved in wrongdoing is categorically rejected'.
Abdul Rahman Basaddiq did not respond to requests for comment.
An EY spokesman said: 'This was a complex, pervasive and collusive fraud, and responsibility for it lies squarely with its perpetrators, including NMC's owners, directors and the treasury and finance team.
'This case is without merit and the full extent of this unprecedented fraud – of which EY was one of the targets – will be exposed during the course of the trial.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Watch: the moment a drug dealer police nicknamed 'Gangster Granny' is arrested
THIS footage shows the moment a drug dealer nicknamed 'Gangster Granny' was arrested following an investigation into her gang picking up shipments of cocaine at an Essex port. Deborah Mason, 65, the leader of the family-run group, was sentenced to 20 years in prison after being convicted of conspiracy to supply Class A drugs at Woolwich Crown Court on July 18. Mason and seven other people - six women and one man - were sentenced to a total of 106 years and six months in prison for their involvement in supplying nearly a tonne of cocaine over seven months. The group transported packages of imported cocaine and drove them around London, Bradford, Leicester, Birmingham, Bristol and Cardiff between April 2023 and November 2023. Footage shows Mason in disbelief that she was being arrested. Arrested - Deborah Mason last year (Image: Metropolitan Police/PA) Mug shot - Deborah Mason (Image: PA/Metropolitan Police) The Met Police's investigation saw officers receive information on April 20, 2023, that a hired car driven by Mason left her house in Crayford Road, Tufnell Park, London, at 4.30am and arrived at Harwich Port at 6.20am. Police said regular trips were made by Mason to the port alongside the couriers to collect the cocaine. The group used encrypted messaging site Signal to communicate. Officers trawled through thousands of messages following their arrests which helped prove their criminal movements. Officers discovered through the messages that Mason - known as Queen Bee - was living an extravagant lifestyle with her profits, purchasing a Gucci collar and lead worth £400 for her cat. During the crime group's operation, the drugs had an estimated wholesale value of between £23million to £35million and a street value of £80million. The Metropolitan Police arrested all members of the gang in May 2024 except a woman called Anita Slaughter who was arrested in November 2024 after being identified from the messages.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Everything you need to know about DLR extension to Thamesmead
Transport for London (TfL) wants to extend the DLR to Thamesmead – here is everything you need to know. London Mayor Sadiq Khan has backed an extension of the line from Gallions Reach, which if built would stop at both Beckton Riverside and Thamesmead. Although full funding for the project is yet to be secured, TfL has revealed details about the potential route as part of an ongoing consultation. Here is everything you need to know about what might soon be London's biggest new infrastructure project. READ MORE - Where would the extension go? The line would branch off from the existing DLR route to Beckton after Gallions Reach, with trains travelling over a viaduct to Armada Way, where a new station at Beckton Riverside would be built. Trains would then descend into a tunnel under the River Thames before rising onto another viaduct in south London at Thamesmead. A DLR station for the town will be built at the site of Cannon Retail Park. Although only two new stops are currently planned, TfL has said there is the potential for a further extension towards Bexley in the future. Why is the extension needed? TfL says that the project supports the creation of up to 30,000 new homes. Greenwich Council has also said that building the extension is the 'key in unlocking land' earmarked for redevelopment in Thamesmead. This would allow around 15,000 new homes to be built on a 100-hectare site to the west of the town's existing retail park on the southern bank of the Thames. When will trains start running? Transport bosses say that they hope that a funding plan for the project can be agreed with the Government by autumn this year. If funding is secured, work could start on building the extension in spring 2028, allowing trains to start operating from late 2031 or early 2032. The project is expected to cost at least £1.5 billion. How often would trains come? According to TfL, trains would run on the new branch every eight to ten minutes, with a similar service pattern on the spur to Beckton. This would mean a train would come every four to five minutes on the core section of the route between Canning Town and Gallions Reach. How can I have my say? A TfL consultation on the proposals is currently under way – although there are only three weeks until it closes. You can give feedback until Sunday August 17.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
The Lewisham pubs that are an asset of community value to locals
Lewisham is home to a number of pubs recognised as assets to the local community. The ACV designation, under the Localism Act 2011, allows communities to nominate buildings or land that further the social wellbeing or interests of the local population. Once registered, owners must inform the council if they intend to sell, giving community groups the opportunity to bid for the property. Alongside the three pubs currently open for business, The Baring Hall Hotel in Grove Park is also currently registered with an ACV, although it has been closed since 2020, as well as The White Hart and The Dirty South which also both closed that year. Here's a closer look at three Lewisham pubs that have earned this status. The Bell, Sydenham 59 Bell Green, SE26 5SJ Registered since 2019 by the Sydenham Society, The Bell has been a long-standing local pub that has served Sydenham for generations since it opened in the 19th century. The Bell has been a long-standing local pub that has served Sydenham for generations. (Image: Google) The pub was awarded an ACV after being nominated by The Sydenham Society, recognising it for its historical significance and as a community space and meeting point for locals. The Perry Hill, Catford 78-80 Perry Hill, SE6 4EY Another pub nominated by The Sydenham Society, formerly named The Two Brewers, this pub was added to the list on account of its community-focused program and role in revitalising the area. This pub was added to the list on account of its community-focused program and role in revitalising the area. (Image: Google) Today the pub offers an outdoor beer garden and space for events and is valued for supporting local creatives. The Birds Nest, Deptford 32 Deptford Church Street, SE8 4RZ Known for its eclectic music scene and artistic flair, The Birds Nest has been a part of the community for decades. (Image: Google) Known for its eclectic music scene and artistic flair, The Birds Nest has been a part of the community for decades, offering a creative space for artists and musicians. It was nominated as an asset by The Deptford Society in 2020, who highlighted its cultural significance as well as its accessibility to a wide cross-section of the local community.
