One year after Trump rally shooting, witnesses say investigations leave more questions than answers
"I'm highly dissatisfied with the lack of preparation," said Rep. Dan Meuser, R-Pa., who was seated in the front row at the rally. "The failures were almost unbelievable," he told Fox News Digital, echoing a widespread view that the breach was the result of avoidable missteps by law enforcement.
Despite probes by multiple federal agencies and a formal congressional investigation, both local residents and lawmakers say they're still left wondering what went wrong.
"The task force was bipartisan. And frankly, I don't think to this day they've gotten all the answers," Meuser said.
Shooter Thomas Matthew Crooks was killed by law enforcement at the scene. Since then, the Secret Service has undergone a series of high-profile shakeups.
A congressional select committee found in its report a "lack of planning and coordination between the Secret Service and its law enforcement partners," adding that the agency had been alerted to Crooks' suspicious movements for over 10 minutes before he fired a shot.
But for those who were there, major questions remain:
What was Crooks' motive? Why weren't agents stationed on a nearby pitched roof? Why was Crooks' presence on top of the AGR building not acted on sooner? How was he able to fire eight rounds before being neutralized by a Secret Service countersniper?
In the absence of concrete answers, some attendees have drawn their own speculative conclusions.
"There were certain stock transactions that transpired right beforehand," one rally-goer said.
"CNN never airs Trump's rallies. Why did they air this one?" another asked. (CNN has said it aired the Butler rally in anticipation of Trump announcing his vice presidential pick.)
"I don't think it was [Crooks]," another witness claimed. "Nobody that went to school with him believes he could have engineered that kind of event."
Zach Scherer, a Butler local who has worked on all three of Trump's presidential campaigns, voiced ongoing skepticism.
"We don't know anything about this kid from Bethel Park," he said. "The Comperatore family needs answers. The rest of the community does too. It affected every single person who was here."
Corey Comperatore, a local firefighter, was killed during the shooting.
"Investigations that were already done are very inconclusive," said Erin Autenreith, a GOP activist and rally attendee from Glenshaw, Pennsylvania. "There's just so much technology now – these videos have such high resolution they can actually see the bullets."
"The American people, they don't trust the investigations," she added. "Nobody believes it. So I don't think it's good."
Jim Hulings, chairman of the Butler County GOP, criticized Pennsylvania officials for what he called apathy toward the case. He singled out both the Republican district attorney and state attorney general.
"Murder was never investigated," Hulings said. "We asked for the district attorney to call for a grand jury. He wouldn't do it. We gave him a letter and 8,000 signatures on a petition. He still wouldn't do it."
"The AG doesn't really care either," Hulings added. "We got Dave Sunday elected, and he went persona non grata."
Some argue the investigation should be elevated to the federal level, given its national implications.
But longtime rally-goers agreed on one thing: a scant security presence was noticeable from the start of the day in Butler last year.
"All the other rallies I'd been to, there was Secret Service everywhere, so I just assumed they were going to be there. And they weren't," said Lucie Roth.
"There was no counter sniper teams visible. There was no drones. There was no helicopters," said Hulings. "Very few police."
A number of factors have been blamed: technical issues with drones, high temperatures prompting Secret Service to seek refuge in the air conditioning, a force that was spread thin by long hours and unexpected overtime.
A Senate report found that key resource requests were denied, and some were not even made: Secret Service did not request a surveillance team to help patrol the rally of 15,000 attendees, while an event for first lady Jill Biden had one assigned for her event of 400 individuals roughly an hour away.
Until a fuller picture emerges, those who lived through that harrowing day say they won't stop pushing for accountability – not just for Trump, but for Comperatore and a shaken community still seeking closure.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
22 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Unreleased Beyoncé music reported stolen from vehicle in Atlanta
Unreleased music by Beyoncé was stolen from a rental vehicle in Atlanta last week, her longtime choreographer Chris Grant and Diandre Blue, a dancer, told the Atlanta Police Department. Five digital storage devices containing watermarked and unreleased music, set lists and tour plans were stolen from the vehicle, the police report said. Several other items, including Grant and Blue's laptops, two suitcases, AirPod headphones and clothing worth $2,000 were also listed as stolen in the report.
CNN
26 minutes ago
- CNN
What are Patriot missiles and why does Ukraine need them so badly?
US President Donald Trump's announcement that Ukraine will receive Patriot missile systems as part of a new package of US weaponry has been warmly welcomed in Kyiv as it reels under nightly Russian bombardments. President Volodymyr Zelensky has made repeated requests for Patriots in recent weeks as Moscow sends record numbers of drones and missiles to cause havoc and fear in Ukrainian cities and towns. But there were few specifics in Trump's announcement, and major questions remain over how many Ukraine will receive, when they will arrive, and who will provide them. Here's what we know about the vaunted US missile defense system: The Patriots, short for Phased Array Tracking Radar for Intercept on Target, are the US Army's key missile defense system. They most recently proved their worth last month, when they helped shoot down 13 out of 14 incoming Iranian missiles that were launched at the US Air Force's Al Udeid Air Base in Qatar. The latest versions of Patriot interceptors are capable of engaging incoming short-range ballistic missiles, cruise missiles and drones at altitudes up to 15 kilometers (9.3 miles) and distances of up to 35 kilometers. Analysts say that gives a single Patriot battery the ability to cover 100 to 200 square kilometers of area, depending on how many launchers are in the battery, local terrain and other conditions. That's not a large area in a country the size of Ukraine, at more than 603,000 kilometers in total area. Hence, Kyiv's need for multiple new Patriot batteries. A battery consists of six to eight missile launchers, each capable of carrying up to 16 interceptors, along with a phased-array radar, a control station, a power generation station – all mounted on trucks and trailers. About 90 people are assigned to a Patriot battery, but only three soldiers in the command and control center can operate it in a combat situation, according to US military reports. A Patriot battery is expensive, with the complete setup of launchers, radars and interceptor missiles costing more than a billion dollars, according to the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). A single interceptor costs up to $4 million, making their use against cheap Russian drones that can cost as little as $50,000 problematic, according to a CSIS report – especially when Russia is sending hundreds of drones a night in recent attacks on Ukraine. In regards to the latest transfer, US officials said Patriots could get to Ukraine quicker if they were moved from European NATO allies to Ukraine, with those then being replaced by systems bought from the US. Trump said some or all of 17 Patriot batteries ordered by other countries could get to Ukraine 'very quickly,' according to a Reuters report. According to the 'Military Balance 2025' from the International Institute for Strategic Studies, six NATO allies – Germany, Greece, the Netherlands, Poland, Romania and Spain – have Patriot batteries in their arsenals. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said Monday that several nations – including Germany, Finland, Denmark, Sweden and Norway – could be potential suppliers of the new equipment, but did not specifically mention the Patriots as coming from those countries. There has been concern inside and outside the military that US Patriot inventories may be stretched too thin. 'It is our most stressed force element,' Gen. James Mingus, vice chief of staff of the Army, told a dialogue at the CSIS earlier this month. He noted the Patriot unit in Qatar that helped defend the Al Udeid air base had been deployed to the Middle East for 500 days, Mingus said, a 'very stressed force element.' Ukraine has said it needs 10 new Patriot batteries to protect itself against Russia's increased onslaught of missiles and drones. Kyiv has already received six fully operational Patriot batteries – two from the US, two from Germany, one from Romania and one jointly given by Germany and the Netherlands, according to the UK-based arms monitoring group Action on Armed Violence. Analysts say Patriots alone can't end Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Wesley Clark, a retired US Army general and former NATO supreme commander, told CNN's Lynda Kinkade on Monday that the for the arms package to have real effect on the battlefield, it would have to include more than air defense systems. 'If you want to really stop this, you've got to strike Russia and you've got to strike deep,' Clark said. 'you have to shoot the archer and not the arrows coming in.' CNN's Kevin Liptak contributed to this report
CNN
26 minutes ago
- CNN
Jeffrey Epstein's former lawyer rejects idea of a ‘client list'
CNN's Laura Coates speaks with Jeffrey Epstein's former attorney David Schoen about questions over whether Epstein kept a "client list."
