‘Save 188-year-old banyan tree or scrap the building': HC slams NMC
2
Nagpur: The Nagpur bench of Bombay high court on Wednesday orally censured the Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) for insisting on transplanting a 188-year-old banyan tree reportedly obstructing an e-library project at Pachpaoli's Thakkargram locality.
In strong remarks, the court asked whether NMC was determined to cut the tree at any cost and warned that it may pass orders halting the construction if alternatives to preserve the tree weren't considered.
"If your intent is just to remove the tree for open space, parking, and a canteen, we will be compelled to pass appropriate directives. Either change the plan or don't build the structure," the bench verbally clarified while examining the layout of the project.
The court emphasised that the tree stands in a corner, not at the centre of the plot, making design adjustments feasible.
The directions came during the hearing of a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by environmentalist Preeti Patel and three others, who objected to the proposed felling or relocation of 1,374 trees for development projects across Nagpur, citing violations of the Tree Protection Act. One of their key objections concerned the banyan tree, which the NMC decided to transplant to the Nagpur University campus.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Say Goodbye to Itchy Scalp? Here's What Some People Are Doing
Lintmit.com
Read More
Undo
Lawyer Mrunall Chakravarty represented the petitioners, while NMC was represented by advocate Gemini Kasat.
The petitioners questioned the viability of that plan. "There is no guarantee the tree will survive if shifted," they argued, suggesting that the civic body was ignoring feasible alternatives.
Earlier, the HC directed both the petitioners and NMC to consult with environmental experts to explore alternatives. Following the suggestions from the petitioners' side, NMC submitted its response, stating that 50% of the construction of the proposed three-storey e-library was already completed, and the tree now obstructed further development.
Unimpressed, the court reiterated its position, pointing out that infrastructure cannot come at the cost of long-standing ecological assets. It then scheduled the next hearing for Friday granting NMC time to reconsider.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Why red light is essential for flowering plants and indoor gardening: Benefits and how to use
Indoor gardening has surged in popularity, with plant enthusiasts increasingly using grow lights to support healthy growth. Among the various light colours available, red light is gaining attention for its unique role in plant development. Red light plays a crucial part in photosynthesis and is especially effective during the flowering and fruiting stages. It helps regulate plant hormones and encourages stem elongation, bud formation, and energy production. Many growers use red LED lights as part of a full-spectrum setup to enhance both indoor gardening success and plant health. This targeted lighting approach supports vibrant, thriving plants year-round, especially in low-light environments. What is red light and why does it matter for plants Red light is part of the visible light spectrum and plays a crucial role in photosynthesis, the process by which plants convert light energy into food. It is distinct from infrared light, which is invisible and can cause heat stress if overused. Red light influences key growth phases like flowering and fruiting. According to gardening experts red and blue light are the primary wavelengths plants need. Blue light supports leaf and stem growth, while red light triggers flowering and fruit production, making it essential in later stages of plant development. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villas For Sale in Dubai Might Surprise You Villas In Dubai | Search Ads Get Rates Undo Why gardeners prefer red LED grow lights Modern growers favour LED grow lights, including red LEDs, for several reasons. LED lights provide strong, energy-efficient illumination without generating excessive heat, unlike incandescent or fluorescent bulbs. This makes LEDs safer and more cost-effective for indoor use. Garden designers prefer full-spectrum LED lights, which include red light, for starting seedlings indoors, especially in early spring. The ability to customise light wavelengths and intensity allows growers to optimise plant growth for specific species and growth stages. Types of red light: Visible, infrared, and far-red Red light comes in three forms: visible red light, infrared light, and far-red light. Visible red light is the classic red glow seen in grow lights, directly influencing plant photosynthesis. Infrared light is invisible and mainly involved in plant signaling; however, excessive infrared can cause overheating and damage. Far-red light , situated between visible red and infrared wavelengths, is believed by some growers to be the most effective at promoting growth, though scientific evidence is still emerging. Anecdotal reports from gardeners highlight its benefits, but more research is needed. How to use red lights effectively for your plants The effectiveness of red light depends heavily on timing and duration. Seedlings typically require 16-18 hours of light per day, while flowering plants need around 12-16 hours. Overexposure to red light can stress plants, so balancing with blue and full-spectrum light is ideal. For best results: Use full-spectrum LEDs with a strong red light component to mimic natural sunlight. Adjust light duration based on plant species and growth stage. Position lights to provide even coverage without overheating plants. Research specific plant needs, as some may benefit more from combined blue and red light. Also read | 10 best small plants for your office desk
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Mumbai's love-hate relationship with pigeons: Why thousands are taking to the streets after ban on 'kabutarkhanas'
India's financial capital Mumbai has had a love-hate relationship with pigeons for decades. The avian species are synonymous with the city's landscape and are found fluttering around iconic railway stations, the Gateway of India and flocking in feeding areas known as 'kabutarkhanas'. These spots have now been covered with tarpaulin sheets following a July 31 Bombay High Court order banning public feeding of pigeons. This has led to a fresh controversy, protests and even an FIR, all within a week of the order being passed. Productivity Tool Zero to Hero in Microsoft Excel: Complete Excel guide By Metla Sudha Sekhar View Program Finance Introduction to Technical Analysis & Candlestick Theory By Dinesh Nagpal View Program Finance Financial Literacy i e Lets Crack the Billionaire Code By CA Rahul Gupta View Program Digital Marketing Digital Marketing Masterclass by Neil Patel By Neil Patel View Program Finance Technical Analysis Demystified- A Complete Guide to Trading By Kunal Patel View Program Productivity Tool Excel Essentials to Expert: Your Complete Guide By Study at home View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals Batch 2 By Ansh Mehra View Program The Bombay HC directed Mumbai's civic body, BMC to initiate a criminal proceeding on those found feeding pigeons and defying the order. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Orthopedic Knee Surgeon: Suffering From Pain After Age 50? Do This Every Morning Wellnee The court cited serious public health hazards, including respiratory infections, and damage to heritage sites due to their droppings, while passing its order. It has also come amid rising pigeon population in the city. However, the order has not pleased animal lover's and the city's powerful Gujarati and Jain communities as they consider feeding pigeons as auspicious, leading way to pigeon politics. Live Events Mumbai's love for pigeons The city's love for feeding pigeons is believed to have begun by Gujarati and Jain businessmen, which led to the setting up of kabutarkhanas across major hotspots in Mumbai. These communities considered it to be an act piety and believed it would bring blessings from ancestors. In Jainism, feeding the birds is one of the central tenets and for decades many Jain families have fed pigeons near temples or trust-run feeding spots. However, over 50 such spots have been closed in the last month, including the iconic Dadar kabutarkhana where the BMC installed a bamboo structure to prevent the feeding of pigeons. Massive protests This has started massive protest by the Jain community. On Sunday, over thousands of activists, animal lovers joined Jain spiritual leaders to march from Colaba Jain Mandir to Gateway of India. Jain monk Nareshchandra Ji Maharaj also announced fast-unto-death unless feeding pigeons becomes legal again. He told TOI that hundreds of pigeons have died of starvation in the last few days. A ban was always in place but it was never legally enforced as no political party wanted to upset the influential Gujarati community and the Jains, who form a large part of the city's population. However, on August 3,the first criminal case was registered by the Mumbai police for feeding the birds. The politics of pigeons The issue has now taken a political turn, with Maharashtra minister and BJP MLA Mangal Prabhat Lodha writing a letter to the commissioner of Mumbai, expressing concern over the demolition of kabutarkhanas. Lodha, in his letter, questioned if feeding pigeons were solely responsible for health issues and sought the formation of a court-monitored panel to suggest sustainable solutions. "Following the decision to restrict pigeon feeding, there have also been numerous instances of pigeons suffering from starvation. This has resulted in pigeons dying on the roads, thereby creating another public health hazard," Lodha pointed out. Health hazards and other concerns In a large urban setting like Mumbai, pigeons are dependent on the food given by people rather than natural sources. A PETA study revealed that more these birds feed, the more they reproduce. While feeding might seem to be harmless, what falls is its health concerns and ecological impact. Several studies have found that pigeon droppings and feathers carry harmful pathogens, including viruses, that can cause long-term respiratory issues, like hypersensitivity pneumonitis. This lung disease is caused by prolonged exposure to fungal spores found in dried pigeon droppings, which is seen in congested areas. Another disease linked with pigeons is cryptococcosis, an infection that can cause neurological issues. The effects are beyond health concerns. Mumbaikars have complained of the nuisance that pigeons amke create at bus stops and the stench their droppings leave in stretches near feeding spots. The highly acidic droppings have also caused damage to historical landmarks and public infrastructure like the Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj terminus. The excreta has also been found to corrode stone facades of protected monuments, leading to added maintenance costs. A BMC engineer died a few years after allegedly being struck by a pigeon while riding his bike.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Death of a delta: Pakistan's Indus sinks and shrinks
Salt crusts crackle underfoot as Habibullah Khatti walks to his mother's grave to say a final goodbye before he abandons his parched island village on Pakistan's Indus delta. Seawater intrusion into the delta, where the Indus River meets the Arabian Sea in the south of the country, has triggered the collapse of farming and fishing communities. Productivity Tool Zero to Hero in Microsoft Excel: Complete Excel guide By Metla Sudha Sekhar View Program Finance Introduction to Technical Analysis & Candlestick Theory By Dinesh Nagpal View Program Finance Financial Literacy i e Lets Crack the Billionaire Code By CA Rahul Gupta View Program Digital Marketing Digital Marketing Masterclass by Neil Patel By Neil Patel View Program Finance Technical Analysis Demystified- A Complete Guide to Trading By Kunal Patel View Program Productivity Tool Excel Essentials to Expert: Your Complete Guide By Study at home View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals Batch 2 By Ansh Mehra View Program "The saline water has surrounded us from all four sides," Khatti told AFP from Abdullah Mirbahar village in the town of Kharo Chan , around 15 kilometres (9 miles) from where the river empties into the sea. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villas Prices In Dubai Might Be More Affordable Than You Think Villas In Dubai | Search Ads Get Quote Undo As fish stocks fell, the 54-year-old turned to tailoring until that too became impossible with only four of the 150 households remaining. "In the evening, an eerie silence takes over the area," he said, as stray dogs wandered through the deserted wooden and bamboo houses. Live Events Kharo Chan once comprised around 40 villages, but most have disappeared under rising seawater. The town's population fell from 26,000 in 1981 to 11,000 in 2023, according to census data. Khatti is preparing to move his family to nearby Karachi, Pakistan's largest city, and one swelling with economic migrants, including from the Indus delta. The Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum , which advocates for fishing communities, estimates that tens of thousands of people have been displaced from the delta's coastal districts. However, more than 1.2 million people have been displaced from the overall Indus delta region in the last two decades, according to a study published in March by the Jinnah Institute, a think tank led by a former climate change minister. The downstream flow of water into the delta has decreased by 80 percent since the 1950s as a result of irrigation canals, hydropower dams and the impacts of climate change on glacial and snow melt, according to a 2018 study by the US-Pakistan Center for Advanced Studies in Water. That has led to devastating seawater intrusion. The salinity of the water has risen by around 70 percent since 1990, making it impossible to grow crops and severely affecting the shrimp and crab populations. "The delta is both sinking and shrinking," said Muhammad Ali Anjum, a local WWF conservationist. 'No other choice' Beginning in Tibet, the Indus River flows through disputed Kashmir before traversing the entire length of Pakistan. The river and its tributaries irrigate about 80 percent of the country's farmland, supporting millions of livelihoods. The delta, formed by rich sediment deposited by the river as it meets the sea, was once ideal for farming, fishing, mangroves and wildlife. But more than 16 percent of fertile land has become unproductive due to encroaching seawater, a government water agency study in 2019 found. In the town of Keti Bandar, which spreads inland from the water's edge, a white layer of salt crystals covers the ground. Boats carry in drinkable water from miles away and villagers cart it home via donkeys. "Who leaves their homeland willingly?" said Haji Karam Jat, whose house was swallowed by the rising water level. He rebuilt farther inland, anticipating more families would join him. "A person only leaves their motherland when they have no other choice," he told AFP. Way of life British colonial rulers were the first to alter the course of the Indus River with canals and dams, followed more recently by dozens of hydropower projects. Earlier this year, several military-led canal projects on the Indus River were halted when farmers in the low-lying riverine areas of Sindh province protested. To combat the degradation of the Indus River Basin, the government and the United Nations launched the 'Living Indus Initiative' in 2021. One intervention focuses on restoring the delta by addressing soil salinity and protecting local agriculture and ecosystems. The Sindh government is currently running its own mangrove restoration project, aiming to revive forests that serve as a natural barrier against saltwater intrusion. Even as mangroves are restored in some parts of the coastline, land grabbing and residential development projects drive clearing in other areas. Neighbouring India meanwhile poses a looming threat to the river and its delta, after revoking a 1960 water treaty with Pakistan which divides control over the Indus basin rivers. It has threatened to never reinstate the treaty and build dams upstream, squeezing the flow of water to Pakistan, which has called it "an act of war". Alongside their homes, the communities have lost a way of life tightly bound up in the delta, said climate activist Fatima Majeed, who works with the Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum. Women, in particular, who for generations have stitched nets and packed the day's catches, struggle to find work when they migrate to cities, said Majeed, whose grandfather relocated the family from Kharo Chan to the outskirts of Karachi. "We haven't just lost our land, we've lost our culture."
