Insurance Companies Not Obliged To Pay For Deaths Caused By Rash Driving, Rules SC
The apex court rejected a plea filed by the kin of a victim who died due to rash and negligent driving.
Insurance companies are not obligated to pay compensation to victims who die due to rash driving, said the Supreme Court on Wednesday.
A bench of Justices PS Narasimha and R Mahadevan denied compensation to the wife, son, and parents of a man who died in a car accident. The man was reportedly driving the car at high speed and in a rash manner, making it an act of negligence, reported the Times of India.
The court dismissed a plea by the kin of the victim, seeking Rs 80 lakh compensation from the insurance company, United India Insurance Company, and said that the family cannot demand compensation as the death was caused by the man's own negligence and did not involve any extraneous factors.
The top court upheld the Karnataka High Court's decision on November 23 last year, dismissing the compensation claim.
What's The Case?
The case dates back to June 18, 2018, when N.S. Ravisha was on his way from Mallasandra village to Arasikere town. He was travelling with his father, sister, and children when the accident took place. Notably, Ravisha was not only driving at high speed, but he also broke traffic rules before his car toppled over and rolled on the road near Mylanahalli Gate, Arasikere. The man died in the accident, said the report.
After his demise, his wife and son claimed compensation of Rs 80 lakh, citing that the deceased was a busy contractor who earned Rs 3 lakh per month.
However, the chargesheet filed by the police cites Ravisha's rash and negligent driving as the reason behind his death, and the claim was rejected by the Motor Accident Tribunal.
First Published:
July 03, 2025, 08:58 IST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
22 minutes ago
- Indian Express
ED arrests Bobby Patel, gets 4-day remand in money laundering, human trafficking case
The Ahmedabad Zonal Office of Enforcement Directorate (ED) has arrested human trafficker Bharatkumar Rambhai Patel alias Bobby Patel, said a statement on Thursday. Bobby Patel, who has cases against him in Gujarat, West Bengal and Delhi for illegally sending Indian nationals abroad, was arrested by the ED under the provisions of Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). Patel was produced before the Special Judge (PMLA), Mirzapura Court, Ahmedabad, which remanded him to ED custody for four days custody, the agency said in the statement. The ED said that it had initiated its investigation against Patel and others based on an FIR registered for illegally sending Indian citizens abroad since 2015 by Sola High Court Police Station in Ahmedabad City. The ED said that its probe allegedly revealed that Patel has been involved in sending 'desirous Indian nationals abroad illegally for exorbitant consideration on the basis of bogus or fabricated documents for getting visas of different countries with duplicate or bogus passports used as genuine by impersonating the passengers wrongly'. For this purpose, Patel and others, 'used to collect Rs 60 to Rs 75 lakh for one passenger, Rs 1 to 1.25 crore for a couple (husband and wife) and Rs 1.25 to 1.75 crore if children were also accompanying the passengers abroad'. In India, the ED said, multiple FIRs have been registered against Patel in Gujarat, Delhi and West Bengal. The 'Proceeds of Crime (POC) generated in this case are valued at Rs 7 crore (approx)', said the ED. Further investigation into the matter is under progress.
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Married woman can't level ‘false promise of marriage' allegation: Kerala HC
Kochi: High court has stated that a married woman cannot claim that she was induced into sexual relations on the false promise of marriage. The bench of Justice Bechu Kurian Thomas made the observation while granting bail to an accused in a case where he allegedly sexually assaulted a married woman on the pretext of marriage, threatened to publish her photos and videos, and borrowed a total sum of Rs 2.5 lakh. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Counsel for the petitioner/accused contended that the victim is a married woman and, therefore, there cannot be sexual intercourse based on a promise to marry. He further submitted that a reading of the FIR indicates that the case is primarily based on a financial claim and the allegation of rape on the promise of marriage has been raised only to compel the petitioner to yield to her unlawful demands. The petitioner was arrested on June 13 and has been in custody since. Upon perusal of the records and previous decisions of the court, the bench observed that it is prima facie doubtful whether the offence under Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) is attracted, as a promise to marry cannot arise when one of the parties is already in a subsisting marriage. Additionally, the offence under Section 84 BNS, pertaining to enticing, taking away, or detaining a married woman with the intent to have illicit intercourse, is bailable, and therefore, the continued detention of the petitioner is not warranted, the court noted. Further, the court granted him bail on execution of a bond for Rs 50,000 with two solvent sureties each for the like amount, to the satisfaction of the court having jurisdiction.
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Flesh trade racket busted, five held
Patna: In a late-night crackdown, police arrested five people — both men and women — in compromising situations during a raid on a residential premises near Energy Park in Patna's Board Colony. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Among those arrested was a woman, alleged to be the mastermind, who ran the operation by maintaining a selective clientele and conducting transactions via an instant messaging platform. According to police, she shared photographs through her profile to attract clients and fixed each deal for approximately Rs 4,000. "The operation was conducted following a tip-off received by the Patna SSP's cell team about illegal activities in the house," said Shastrinagar SHO Amar Kumar. He added that police also recovered a scooter from the premises, bearing a 'press' sticker, which was allegedly used to transport clients or people involved in the operation. Meanwhile, ADG (weaker sections) Amit Kumar, during a press conference at police headquarters, identified Kishanganj and Araria as major hotspots for and illegal sex trade in Bihar. He also flagged Arwal, Nalanda and Begusarai districts as emerging centres for such illicit activities. The ADG added that districts including Saran, Siwan, Gopalganj, Motihari, Bettiah and Rohtas have become prominent for orchestra-linked operations, which have led to multiple rescue missions. "We are continuing investigations to trace any links to larger trafficking networks operating across the region," he said.
