Regional revitalization faces Tokyo-countryside divide
Tokyo officials are pushing back against arguments that blame the dwindling national population partly on the concentration of people and businesses in the capital.
Overcoming the "Tokyo versus local areas" divide appears to be a key factor in advancing regional revitalization.
The National Governors' Association set up a population strategy headquarters last year to strengthen collaboration with the central government on addressing depopulation, particularly the outflow of young people from rural areas, which makes sustaining local communities increasingly difficult.
At the association's meeting last summer, in which the decision to establish the headquarters was made, differences quickly surfaced over how to address population declines.
The debate centered on the wording of a draft emergency declaration calling for urgent action to tackle the issue.
Referring to a section that connected the heavy concentration in Tokyo with the overall population decline in Japan, Tokyo Gov. Yuriko Koike said the causal relationship remained unclear.
In response, Fukui Gov. Tatsuji Sugimoto argued, "The outflow of young people from rural areas to urban centers where low birthrates are low, when they enter universities or take jobs, is a key factor accelerating the overall decline in childbirths across Japan."
Prioritizing the unity of the association, the meeting adopted the emergency declaration as drafted, adding the Tokyo Metropolitan Government's opinion in a supplementary note.
Still, Okayama Gov. Ryuta Ibaragi said after the meeting, "I don't think any governor was convinced by Gov. Koike's claim that the heavy concentration in Tokyo and the declining birthrate are unrelated."
A source close to the association noted, "It left lingering resentment."
The choice of an indicator for addressing the decline in childbirths has also become a point of contention. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba is focusing on raising the marriage rate, defined as the number of marriages per 1,000 people annually, in which Tokyo has consistently led all prefectures.
At a forum for consultations between the central and local governments in December last year, Yoshihiro Murai, chairman of the governors' group and governor of Miyagi Prefecture, proposed using a different metric: The proportion of married individuals among women in their 20s to 40s. In 2020, Fukui Prefecture had the highest share at 59.5%, while Tokyo had the lowest at 48.1%.
Since the marriage rate covers all age groups, the association argues that it would be more effective to focus on the proportion of married women in the main childbearing age group.
"We need to determine the most appropriate indicator to guide effective measures against the declining birthrate," another official close to the association said.
Meanwhile, discussions aimed at correcting the imbalance in tax revenues between major cities such as Tokyo and rural areas have stalled, largely due to opposition from the Tokyo Metropolitan Government, which fears a decline in its own revenue under a revised taxation system.
In December last year, six local organizations and the central government held a meeting in Tokyo to exchange views on regional revitalization.
According to sources familiar with the discussion, several local government leaders called for addressing the heavy concentration of people in Tokyo, while Murai urged the central government to consider the issue, including the imbalance in tax revenues.
Yoshitaka Ito, minister for regional revitalization, described this as the most challenging topic, according to the sources.
A decade after the launch of full-scale related efforts, Regional Revitalization 2.0, a cornerstone policy of the Ishiba government, aims to create a society in which residents of large cities and rural areas are mutually connected, moving beyond the binary divide between urban and rural.
Still, despite agreeing on the general policy framework, the governor's association still faces challenges over specific issues that affect the interests of individual prefectures.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Mainichi
13 minutes ago
- The Mainichi
Tokyo stocks flat on post-election political uncertainty, US tariff
TOKYO (Kyodo) -- Tokyo stocks ended flat Tuesday, with the Japanese ruling coalition's major setback in a national election weighing on the outlook for the stability of Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba's government and tariff talks with the United States. The 225-issue Nikkei Stock Average fell 44.19 points, or 0.11 percent, from Friday to 39,774.92. The broader Topix index finished 1.71 points, or 0.06 percent, higher at 2,836.19. Japanese financial markets were closed Monday for a national holiday. On the top-tier Prime Market, decliners were led by pharmaceuticals, precision instrument, and warehousing and harbor transportation service issues, while iron and steel, nonferrous and machinery sectors gained. The U.S. dollar rose to the upper 147 yen level in Tokyo on selling of the yen due to political uncertainties in Japan after the ruling coalition failed to retain its majority in Sunday's House of Councillors election, dealers said. Stocks were initially higher as investors were relieved after the election outcome was largely within expectations and Ishiba said Monday he will remain in office, averting a political upheaval at least for the time being, market analysts said. But stocks later erased gains, as investors turned cautious with the election result leaving the ruling bloc without control of both chambers of parliament and concerns growing over prospects for the Japan-U.S. tariff negotiations. "The election result itself drew buying as the ruling coalition won more seats than expected. But questions remain over the outlook for tariffs negotiations with the United States," said Seiichi Suzuki, chief equity market analyst at the Tokai Tokyo Research Institute. Japan's chief negotiator Ryosei Akazawa is in Washington for the eighth round of ministerial-level talks as the deadline for imposition of U.S. President Donald Trump's so-called reciprocal tariffs looms on Aug. 1. If there is no deal by that date, Japan is set to face a country-specific tariff of 25 percent on its goods, which would be a further drag on its economy. "With the deadline nearing and difficulties of reaching an agreement becoming apparent, investors are not in the mood to proactively buy stocks," Suzuki said.
Japan Times
an hour ago
- Japan Times
Japanese bonds remain vulnerable as unpopular Ishiba holds on
Japanese government bonds are vulnerable to further selling following a historic election defeat for Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, although the immediate reaction Tuesday has been damped by a rally in global debt markets. Benchmark 10-year bonds fell only slightly as trading resumed in Tokyo, pushing yields up by 1.5 basis points. Stocks opened higher on post-election relief, even as their outlook remains at the mercy of tariffs. The yen dipped and faces downside risks in the coming days and weeks from the prospect of more government spending. While Ishiba hanging on as leader for now provides a measure of continuity for markets, he will also need to find ways to placate opposition lawmakers seeking tax cuts and households wanting relief from inflation. Any concessions to these pressures can be expected to quickly translate into higher bond yields. With Japan's markets closed for a national holiday on Monday, investors expressing an initial view on the election did so largely through the yen, which advanced about 1% against the dollar after weakening for most of July. The currency weakened about 0.1% to trade around 147.51 as of Tuesday morning in Tokyo. "Concerns over fiscal expansion continue to simmer in the market, and in light of the election results, JGBs could come under selling pressure,' said Katsutoshi Inadome, a senior strategist at Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Asset Management. "I anticipate a bearish steepening of the yield curve, driven especially by super-long bonds.' Benchmark 10-year bond yields rose to 1.535%, while the 5-year bond yields rose a basis point to 1.05%. Yields on longer-maturity JGBs of 20 to 40 years dipped slightly on Friday but have been in an acute uptrend over recent months. The moves in Japanese yields, which have flowed through into global markets, reflect concerns among investors that the government is spending beyond its means. "Any sense of calm in JGBs is unlikely to linger. Japan's government will need to get on with expansionary policies to win over support from smaller political parties. Moreover, there is a 40-year auction on Wednesday which is unlikely to be smooth sailing ... Meanwhile, there is a global theme of yield curve steepening which isn't going away,' Bloomberg strategist Mark Cranfield said. A lack of clarity around fiscal and economic policies is likely to dim the global appeal of Japanese assets, at least in the short term, said Dilin Wu, a research strategist at Pepperstone Group. She added that political uncertainty may complicate Tokyo's trade negotiations with Washington, denting market sentiment. "A triple dip scenario is still on the table,' according to Wu, referring to the risk of the yen, bonds and stocks all falling. Despite Ishiba's insistence that he'll remain in charge, "investors are likely to question how much political capital he has left,' she said. Finance Minister Katsunobu Kato said on Tuesday that cutting the consumption tax as proposed by opposition parties would be inappropriate. While Japan's benchmark Topix stock gauge has bounced back from its sharp decline in the wake of U.S. President Donald Trump's tariffs salvo in April, it remains well off the record high set in mid-last year. "For Japanese equities, the picture is more complex,' said Hebe Chen, an analyst at Vantage Markets in Sydney. "A weaker yen may offer short-term support to exporters, but the deepening political noise threatens to erode broader investor confidence.' The yen could also be hit, particularly if long-term government bonds sell off, said Hiroshi Namioka, chief strategist and fund manager at T&D Asset Management. "There's a significant possibility of yen depreciation,' he said. "Although I expect super-long JGB yields to rise, it's for negative reasons. That could prompt yen selloffs.' Nick Twidale, chief analyst at ATFX Global Markets, said he expects selling in Japanese stocks and an overall weakening in the yen, despite its "initial haven move' higher on Monday. "There's plenty of volatility to come on both the domestic front and the trade front,' said Twidale. "I don't think policy uncertainty bodes well for Japanese equities, plus we still have the U.S. tariffs hanging over their heads and the new political setup could make things more tricky,' he added.
Asahi Shimbun
2 hours ago
- Asahi Shimbun
EDITORIAL: Established political parties must reconnect with the public
The ruling coalition of the Liberal Democratic Party and Komeito has lost its majority in the Upper House, just as it did in the Lower House last October. It goes without saying that this is an extremely harsh evaluation by voters of the administration of Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba. Meanwhile, the main opposition Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan only managed to maintain the number of seats it held before the election, while new parties, such as the Democratic Party for the People and Sanseito, made significant gains. The election outcome can be seen as a defeat for the established political parties. Voters appear to believe that they have not adequately addressed the public dissatisfaction and distrust that have been growing under more than 30 years of economic stagnation. At a news conference on July 21, Ishiba reiterated his intention to remain in office, saying, 'Political stagnation cannot be allowed even for a moment.' The prime minister may have judged that it would be inadvisable to announce an immediate resignation given the imminent deadline of the Japan-U.S. tariff negotiations on Aug. 1. Still, staying in power cannot be said to be in line with the will of voters. Ishiba clearly said he is not considering expanding the coalition framework at this point. He said he would discuss individual policy issues with opposition parties, as he has done so far. However, as he failed to gain public trust in both the Lower House and Upper House elections, it remains to be seen how much cooperation opposition parties will extend. It is nothing short of a 'thorny path,' as Ishiba himself put it. Komeito, which shares responsibility for the administration as a member of the ruling coalition, won a record-low eight seats, losing three seats each in electoral districts and the proportional representation portion. Among the opposition bloc, only the Japanese Communist Party lost seats. The party won only three seats, down from its seven seats up for re-election. Despite their long histories and established organizations, both parties have been in decline in recent years due to the aging of supporters, among other factors. They will continue to be challenged to develop new support bases using methods that adapt to the changing times. In contrast to the established parties, the DPP and Sanseito, both founded five years ago, have risen. The DPP, which appeals to the working generations with its slogan of increasing take-home pay, garnered 17 seats, up from its four seats up for re-election. Sanseito, which advocates 'Japanese First' policies, gained 14 seats, although it had only one seat up for grabs. The two parties share a common strategy of expanding their support base by taking advantage of social media to criticize the established parties. Sanseito's antiforeign rhetoric has often sparked intense debates on social media and become a source of conflict and division. Still, simply frowning upon the public discontent that sometimes erupts violently will not resolve the problem. It is the role of political parties to explore the background of such 'public sentiment,' bring it to the table for discussion and present effective solutions. If that channel has been blocked, it must be urgently reconnected. The established parties must start by confronting the reality of being shunned, reflecting on what is lacking and determining what needs to be done to regain the public's trust. --The Asahi Shimbun, July 22
