Federal government appealing $28M award to North Dakota for pipeline protest costs
The U.S. Department of Justice is appealing a federal judge's decision to award North Dakota $28 million in damages for the executive branch's response to the Dakota Access Pipeline protests.
The case now heads to the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals for review.
Thousands traveled to south-central North Dakota to protest the construction of the oil pipeline underneath the Missouri River's Lake Oahe reservoir alongside the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe in 2016 and 2017. The tribe says the pipeline poses serious threats to the environment, intrudes upon Native territory and has desecrated sacred cultural sites.
Judge blasts Army Corps for pipeline protests, orders $28M in damages to North Dakota
The main demonstration camp was located on land managed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The state filed suit in 2019 against the federal government, arguing that the Corps unlawfully allowed, and at some times encouraged, protesters to use its land at the state's expense.
The case went to trial in February 2024. The trial lasted four weeks and included witness testimony from former North Dakota governors Doug Burgum and Jack Dalrymple, Indigenous activists, law enforcement officials and others.
In an April ruling, U.S. District Court Judge Dan Traynor sided with North Dakota's claims, finding the Army Corps at fault for negligence, public nuisance and civil trespass claims.
The executive branch has disputed North Dakota's accusations and maintains it did the best it could to manage an unpredictable situation.
The U.S. government must file its initial arguments for appeal by Aug. 15, the docket states.
North Dakota sought to recoup $38 million from the federal government, though Traynor lowered this amount to $28 million since the U.S. Department of Justice previously gave the state $10 million as compensation for the protests.
The state can't get any of the money until the appeals process wraps up, according to the North Dakota Office of Management and Budget. The award would also have to survive review by other judges.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
3 hours ago
- New York Times
Agriculture Dept. to Crack Down on Chinese Ownership of American Farmland
The Trump administration said on Tuesday that it would seek to limit Chinese and foreign purchases of American farmland, citing a threat to national security. In a seven-point national security plan, the Agriculture Department said it would enhance public disclosures of foreign ownership of farmland, enact steeper penalties for false filings and work with Congress and states to ban purchases from foreign adversaries. American agriculture is 'under threat from criminals, from political adversaries and from hostile regimes that understand our way of life as a profound and existential threat to themselves,' the agriculture secretary, Brooke Rollins, said in a news conference on Tuesday. The move underscores the increasing concern in recent years over foreign, particularly Chinese, ownership of American farmland. In 2023, the Senate voted 91 to 7 to block businesses based in China from purchasing American farmland, after a Chinese company's attempted purchase of cropland for a corn mill near a military base in North Dakota. And in 2024, the Biden administration proposed a rule to make it significantly harder for foreign businesses to buy land near locations deemed important to national security. Twenty-six states currently prohibit or limit non-Americans from purchasing or investing in agricultural land within their boundaries. While there is no federal law barring the practice, a 1978 law requires foreign owners to report their holdings — though the disclosure requirements have been criticized as lax and the government's data collection as slow and error-prone. In 2023, the year with the most recent data available, foreigners owned nearly 45 million acres of cropland and forests. That equated to about 3.5 percent of all agricultural land in the country, but represented a more than 70 percent increase from a decade earlier. Canadians owned the largest amount — 15.3 million acres, or about a third — while China held more than 270,000 acres. Ms. Rollins said in the news conference that the Trump administration was also exploring ways to 'claw back' existing foreign purchases of farmland. Other elements of the Agriculture Department's plan include identifying and refocusing domestic production of critical farming inputs like fertilizers; cracking down on fraud in nutrition assistance programs like food stamps; enhancing security in agricultural research; re-evaluating department programs that support foreign nations; defending against animal and plant diseases; and helping private food and agriculture companies protect their operations from cyberattacks. Ms. Rollins was joined by more than a dozen Trump administration officials and Republican lawmakers.
Washington Post
3 hours ago
- Washington Post
Death toll from Kenya's latest anti-government protest surges to 31
NAIROBI, Kenya — The death toll from Kenya's anti-government protests on Monday has surged to 31, marking the highest single-day toll since the demonstrations began earlier this year, the state-funded human rights commission said Tuesday. It said another 107 people were injured and more than 500 were arrested amid widespread destruction of property, including supermarkets. The arrest figure largely tracked with the one issued by police. The death toll did not say whether any security forces were included.
Associated Press
7 hours ago
- Associated Press
Armenian lawmakers brawl as the government cracks down on its political opponents
YEREVAN, Armenia (AP) — A brawl broke out Tuesday in Armenia's National Assembly involving an opposition lawmaker who later was stripped of his parliamentary immunity and faces prosecution for calling for ousting President Nikol Pashinyan as political tensions flared in the South Caucasus country. Artur Sargsyan, who represents the opposition bloc Armenia, had finished a speech in which he said the case against him had been decided ahead of time and tried to leave the chamber. Other lawmakers then moved to stop him, and security guards flooded in, according to video from news outlets. In his speech, Sargsyan said Armenia had become 'a bastion of dictatorship' where 'everything is decided in advance, written down, approved.' Lawmakers later voted to strip Sargsyan of his parliamentary immunity, opening him up to prosecution. He turned himself in to Armenia's Investigative Committee, which had accused him and 15 others of plotting to overthrow the government. Pashinyan's government has been cracking down on political opponents he has said are trying to engineer a coup. Various members of the opposition, including the influential Armenian Apostolic Church, have been leading demonstrations urging Pashinyan's ouster after he agreed to territorial concessions in the country's decades-long battle with neighboring Azerbaijan for control of disputed regions. Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan and Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, both senior church leaders, are in pre-trial detention after being accused of taking part in the alleged plot. On June 28, crowds of supporters gathered at church headquarters outside the capital of Yerevan to prevent Ajapahyan's arrest. He later turned himself in to the authorities. The Investigative Committee said conspirators planned to carry out bombings and arson to disrupt power supplies and stage accidents on major roads to paralyze traffic. Both men rejected the charges against them. Ajapahyan and Galstanyan are members of the opposition group Sacred Struggle, which took a central role in anti-Pashinyan demonstrations last year. Although the territorial concessions were the movement's core issue, it has expanded to a wide array of complaints about Pashinyan, who came to power in 2018. It has also sparked increasing friction between the president and the church in recent weeks. In a social media post Monday, Pashinyan said he would liberate the Armenian Apostolic Church from its 'anti-Christian, adulterous, anti-national, anti-state' leadership. Police on Monday raided one of the country's major energy providers, which is owned by another Pashinyan critic, Russian-Armenian billionaire Samvel Karapetyan. Parliament adopted a law allowing for nationalizing the company on July 3, days after Karapetyan was arrested for calling for the ouster of the government. The raid began in the morning and it was unclear which branch of the government or security services was carrying it out, said company spokesperson Natalya Sarjanyan. 'We do not know which department these people are from, but we are not allowed into the office,' she said. Armenia and Azerbaijan were locked in territorial disputes since the early 1990s, as various parts of the Soviet Union pressed for independence from Moscow. After the USSR collapsed in 1991, ethnic Armenian separatist forces backed by the Armenian military won control of Azerbaijan's region of Karabakh and nearby territories. In 2020, Azerbaijan recaptured broad swaths of territory that were held for nearly three decades by Armenian forces. A swift military campaign in September 2023 saw Azerbaijan gain full control of Karabakh, and Armenia later handed over the border villages.
