logo
Gerry Thornley: Talk of a breakaway rugby competition odd at such a perilous time for the sport

Gerry Thornley: Talk of a breakaway rugby competition odd at such a perilous time for the sport

Irish Times06-06-2025
Rarely a season or two seems to go by without some talk, or not so idle threat, of a breakaway rugby club competition to lure the best players with vastly increased riches. But while the odds remain against the latest grandiose concept, namely the R360, well-placed sources do give it some chance where previously they would have given it none whatsoever.
The founders and people behind R360 are former England international Mike Tindall, Stuart Hooper, who spent seven years as the director of rugby at Bath, player agent Mark Spoors and John Loffhagen, who was the chief legal adviser for LIV golf for a year.
Their proposal is to create two superclub competitions based on franchises, one between eight men's sides and one between four women's sides, which would compete initially in a seven-match season rising to 14 matches, to be run on consecutive weekends in two windows from April to June and then August to September.
Rounds would take place in a different city each week, with São Paulo, Barcelona, New York and Los Angeles all mentioned as potential venues to weeklong events, involving concerts. They want to hire the best 360 players in the world by doubling their salaries and claim to have interested backers from Formula 1 and the NFL, with eight franchises already agreed in principle at €55 million apiece.
READ MORE
They have conducted several meetings with player agents and representatives, and also the game's governing body, World Rugby. Players from countries, including Ireland, have signed non-binding heads of agreement and, potentially in some cases, contracts which are predicated on the premise that the R360 starts up by next September. For players in their late 20s or more, promises of doubling salaries would be an attractive end-of-career segue.
While the R360 has been in the planning for a while, and is reasonably well advanced, next September is a tight timeline and must count against the project taking off. It seems unlikely the unions and federations will give the R360 the green light, in which case World Rugby won't do either. In that scenario, it's harder to envisage players sacrificing their international careers.
It's also puzzling to see how the project could even begin to make a profit any time soon. Comparisons with the hugely lucrative, franchise-based Indian Premier League in cricket and LIV golf hardly seem remotely apt.
The IPL had a ready-made fan base in a country of one billion people, which dwarfs cricket's global popularity. It's hard to conceive of a major sport where its popularity is so concentrated in one country.
The Indian Premier League has been a massive success, but it takes place in a country where cricket dominates the sporting interests among the population of over a billion people. Photograph: Arun Sankar/AFP via Getty Images
LIV golf is backed by a trillion‑dollar petrochemical fund. Furthermore, when golfers on the LIV circuit pitch up at golf's Majors, they've tended to be less competitive and this would inevitably be the same were players to take a detour into a franchise-based mini league.
Imagine, say, franchises with amalgamated squads rolling into Dublin for a week, even ones with some leading Irish players, complete with new names and new strips, and tens of thousands of supporters buying into these teams as the R360 claims is the potential for this venture?
Rugby has tried something like this. They're called the Barbarians. They've held their place or worked, to a degree, thanks in large part to their longevity but they're not the attraction of yore for spectators.
That's just not the way rugby works. Supporters' loyalties have been generated over time, through family heritage and a strong sense of identity, be that local, provincial or national. It's hard to see R360 filling out Energia Park, much less the Aviva or Croke Park, and is even less likely to do so in the aforementioned cities in non-rugby territory.
Television money would also seem critical, but since the pandemic that has been a shrinking market, which is partly why rugby is facing such a perilous time. There is talk of the R360 initially being televised by Premier Sports, but they are not big spenders.
At best, this latest concept will not be a breakaway per se, but will be World Rugby-approved and somehow be squeezed into an already overcrowded calendar. At worst, it will cause a huge schism in the game which will do untold damage. Most likely, it won't happen and will serve as a working template for the next breakaway-type concept.
Because the drivers behind R360 are right about one thing, namely that the rugby keeps drawing from the same well, the international game, to fund pretty much everything else, including the club/provincial game, which save for the French Championship, is unsustainable.
There are too many self-serving, competing parts in rugby which are pulling in different directions. It seems ridiculous that every competition does its own deals, with no leverage from the World Cup down. The sport is ripe for the plucking, perhaps even by this R360, which is not entirely out of the question. And if not this one ...
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Farrell names eight Irishmen in starting side to face ACT Brumbies
Farrell names eight Irishmen in starting side to face ACT Brumbies

Irish Times

time3 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Farrell names eight Irishmen in starting side to face ACT Brumbies

It may not yet prove to be the Lions side for the first Test, but this sure looks the closest line-up to it yet, and by some distance. Although he has again heavily rotated his side for Wednesday's meeting with the ACT Brumbies, Andy Farrell has evidently given the biggest pointer yet toward the composition of the side for the first Test against the Wallabies in Brisbane a week and a half later. Even Joe Schmidt had speculated that this Lions selection would be the clearest indication yet of Farrell's thinking for the series opener. Whether or not the team that faces the Brumbies will be retained en bloc against the Wallabies remains to be seen, but this looks like being the core of the side for the opening Test. Putting Jamison Gibson-Park and Finn Russell together again, having done so in the 52-12 win over the Reds a week ago, is something of a signature selection given it is the likeliest half-back partnership to start against the Wallabies. READ MORE It doesn't necessarily follow that the rest of the team will follow suit, but strong performances against the Brumbies – the pick of the Australian Super Rugby teams if missing eight of Schmidt's Wallabies squad – could go some way toward nailing down Test starting places. An apparent case in point is the Irish midfield pairing of Bundee Aki and Garry Ringrose, which has been chosen as the Lions midfield for the first time on tour. This comes four days after an impressive first outing in red for the Sione Tuipulotu-Huw Jones combination in what looks like a straight shoot-out between the two settled international pairings. Perhaps significantly too, Blair Kinghorn has been chosen ahead of Hugo Keenan at full-back. Although Keenan has the better body of work over the last four years, injury and illness delayed his Lions debut until a slightly off-colour performance in last Saturday's laboured win over the Waratahs. Opportunity clearly knocks for Kinghorn who is the only player retained after starting that game on the left wing. James Lowe's selection in the 11 jersey against the Brumbies reinforces his status as strong favourite for that position against the Wallabies. Up front, it also looks highly significant that last Saturday's replacement front-row of Ellis Genge, Dan Sheehan and Tadhg Furlong has been chosen to start, having been introduced en bloc for the final half-hour against the Waratahs. No less than those before them, the Lions head coach and scrum coach, ie Farrell and John Fogarty, like their front-rows to generate cohesion before the first Test. The selection of this trio means that Andrew Porter is on the bench with Ronan Kelleher and Will Stuart, in what would be an impactful front row. Joe McCarthy's barnstorming display against the Force laid down a marker and made him the likeliest partner for captain Maro Itoje in the Test opener, and so this secondrow partnership has come to pass for the first time in this game. The competitive backrow permutations could yet prove fluid, but the combination of Ollie Chessum, in his first start at blindside, and Tom Curry, in his first start at 7, either side of Jack Conan, looks interesting. On the basis that Chessum covers lock, both Josh van der Flier and Henry Pollock are accommodated on the bench, and given the latter has played across the backrow in his three appearances on tour, it does look as if he is being groomed for a well-suited role as impact replacement. Alex Mitchell and Marcus Smith are named on the bench, as is Mack Hansen who, no doubt to his delight, could thus play on his old stomping ground against his former team in his home city. Never has the Return of the Mack seemed so apt and while a bench split of 6-2 for the first Test cannot be ruled out, like all those named for this game, Hansen appears to have a real shot at a place in the matchday 23 for the first Test. While missing eight of the ten Brumbies players in Joe Schmidt's Wallabies squad, Stephen Larkham has been able to call upon backrower Tom Hooper and exciting winger Corey Toole, who scored 11 tries in 16 games in their run to the Super Rugby Pacific semi-finals. Hooper has been released despite playing the last 12 minutes of the Wallabies' 21-18 win over Fiji in what will be the 24-year-old's last game for the Brumbies before joining Exeter. As Larkham has picked Hooper's younger brother Lachie (21) for his debut off the bench, the Hoopers cold thus play together in Brumbies shirts for the first time. As well as the older Hooper and Toole, prop Lington Ieli, flanker Rory Scott, talented scrumhalf/captain Ryan Lonergan and centre David Feliuai all start after recently being involved in the Wallabies camp in both Sydney and Newcastle, before returning to the Brumbies. Lock Cadeyrn Neville starts against the Lions for the second time, having played against them for the Melbourne Rebels during the 2013 tour. The one-time Connacht winger Ben O'Donnell will play his first and last game for the Brumbies as a consequence of suffering a torn hamstring last February and ahead of his move to French D2 side Aurillac. Replacement outhalf Jack Debreczeni should also feature for the last time in a Brumbies shirt. The British & Irish Lions v ACT Brumbies Gio Stadium, Wednesday 9th July, 2025, KO: 11:00 BST/IST 15. Blair Kinghorn (Toulouse/Scotland) #882 14. Tommy Freeman (Northampton Saints/England) #858 13. Garry Ringrose (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #872 12. Bundee Aki (Connacht Rugby/Ireland) #837 11. James Lowe (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #870 10. Finn Russell (Bath Rugby/Scotland) #835 9. Jamison Gibson-Park (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #879 1. Ellis Genge (Bristol Bears/England) #859 2. Dan Sheehan (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #873 3. Tadhg Furlong (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #818 4. Maro Itoje (Saracens/England) (C) #825 5. Joe McCarthy (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #871 6. Ollie Chessum (Leicester Tigers/England) #875 7. Tom Curry (Sale Sharks/England) #853 8. Jack Conan (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #839 Replacements: 16. Ronan Kelleher (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #864 17. Andrew Porter (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #876 18. Will Stuart (Bath Rugby/England) #877 19. Josh van der Flier (Leinster Rugby/Ireland) #874 20. Henry Pollock (Northampton Saints/England) #865 21. Alex Mitchell (Northampton Saints/England) #860 22. Marcus Smith (Harlequins/ England) #855 23. Mack Hansen (Connacht Rugby/Ireland) #867 ACT Brumbies: Andy Muirhead; Ben O'Donnell, Ollie Sapsford, David Feliuai, Corey Toole; Declan Meredith, Ryan Lonergan (capt); Lington Ieli, Lachlan Lonergan, Rhys van Nek, Lachie Shaw, Cadeyrn Neville, Tom Hooper, Rory Scott, Tuaina Taii Tualima. Replacements: Liam Bowron, Cameron Orr, Feao Fotuaika, Lachie Hooper, Luke Reimer, Harrison Goddard, Jack Debreczeni, Hudson Creighton

Ireland's six debutants against Georgia: What they said and what song they sang
Ireland's six debutants against Georgia: What they said and what song they sang

Irish Times

time6 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Ireland's six debutants against Georgia: What they said and what song they sang

Ireland 's six debutants were presented with their caps in the dressingroom where Ireland's interim head coach Paul O'Connell did the honours before IRFU president Declan Madden repeated the gesture in the more formal setting of the post-match dinner with the Georgia team looked on as the players had to sing. Tommy O'Brien 'It was a crazy good start. I have to thank Sammy [Prendergast] for them [the two tries], he helped me out. Listen, when it comes like that you just grab it with both hands. I was actually okay. I played a good few big games recently for Leinster, so the nerves were okay. 'I was a bit emotional listening to the anthem now all right. I guess I was just thinking back to the people at home that were watching, probably seeing me up on the screen and stuff. I was just delighted to give them a great day out.' Song: Firework (Katie Perry) READ MORE Darragh Murray Ireland's Darragh Murray after the game with his first cap. Photograph: Ben Brady/Inpho 'It was unbelievable, the lads made it such a special week for us. We had full licence to go out there and be ourselves. Calling the lineout, it was a bit of added pressure, but all the lads got behind me. Paulie made it very easy for us on options, and it was such an enjoyable week. 'The highlight is just getting out and wearing a green jersey. It was so special. I tried to take it in and not get ahead of myself, which is something that can happen. A lineout steal is always an added plus, to disrupt them and their set piece. 'We knew that the Georgian team are a big, physical side. That's what we wanted to bring especially in our tackling, get off the line. The most nerve racking ... the singing, that's what I was most worried about, not the game.' Song: Country Roads (John Denver). Jack Aungier Ireland's Jack Aungier after the game with his first cap. Photograph: Ben Brady/Inpho 'That first scrum is something I won't forget, when I got up and saw that we had won a penalty. I think it was all Michael Milne, but we won't give him that credit. It was a frontrow effort. It was great. Set piece was solid, I was happy enough with the way it went. It was a proud day. 'I am very easy going and I tried to keep it as normal as possible until Friday night when Craig [Casey] sat down and said it's not normal to play for Ireland. It is an incredible privilege to wear an international jersey; not many people get to do it. My [nerves] kicked in when he said that, when you think about it in that way. 'I saw the lads [Michael Milne and Tom Stewart] go on at 56 or 57 minutes and I knew it would be soon after that. It's actually a bit nerve racking watching, when you get on it's the same as any other game to be honest, a bit more physical and faster. Song: Piano Man (Billy Joel) Michael Milne Ireland's Michael Milne after the game with his first cap. Photograph: Ben Brady/Inpho 'I think before the match the highlight when I got a bit of time to reflect a little was to be the first international from Birr rugby club. It means an awful lot to me and my family. It is a club that has done an awful lot for me, and I am proud to represent them. 'On the pitch it was the first scrum and winning the penalty. Me and Jack Aungier just got up and looked at each other. We smiled and gave each other a nod. It was a great moment. 'I suppose it is something that you dream of as a kid but when you are playing Under-10s and 11s for Birr you never think that you are going to play for Ireland. When you get to represent your country at the highest level it's an unbelievable feeling. It's everything.' Song: Sweet Caroline (Neil Diamond). Tom Ahern Ireland's Tom Ahern after the game with his first cap. Photograph: Ben Brady/Inpho 'It feels amazing, a dream come true. It's something I have wanted for a long time, so it's a very special feeling. 'No, I wasn't too nervous. There was a lot of excitement to be honest. I was just absolutely buzzing to get an opportunity to play for this team. It's a special group of players and I'm delighted to get a chance to play with them. 'Yeah, my parents, Anthony and Jessie came over, so that made it a lot more special. They sacrificed a lot for me when I was younger, so to have them over here means the world to me. Obviously, there's not too much rugby played down in Waterford, so they were driving me all across the province for training sessions and matches. I owe a lot to them and to have them here is absolutely brilliant. 'Growing up, I was looking up to Jack O'Donoghue. He got the opportunity to do it as well, so it was always something that I saw and I strived for.' Song: The Gambler Ben Murphy Ireland's Ben Murphy after the game with his first cap. Photograph: Ben Brady/Inpho 'It was challenging playing in a game with so much emotion on it, trying to keep them in check and focus on the game. I was pretty calm this week, we had a nice presentation on Thursday, and it was good to let a couple of emotions out. 'I got a video from home from my parents, my brother and my dog, which was very nice and a video of highlights throughout the years from school all the way up. It was emotional seeing all the journey back, but it made me hungrier. 'We haven't been together very long, but we got around each other over the last few weeks. It was a big challenge set to us when we came into camp whether we could do this. We answered a lot of questions tonight. I think we can grow again next weekend. Song: Angels (Robbie Williams)

Hansen shoots Norway to brink of quarter-finals
Hansen shoots Norway to brink of quarter-finals

The 42

time13 hours ago

  • The 42

Hansen shoots Norway to brink of quarter-finals

CAROLINE GRAHAM HANSEN fired Norway to the brink of the Women's Euro 2025 quarter-finals with the decisive goal in Sunday's 2-1 over Finland. Barcelona star Hansen snatched the three points in Sion with a mis-hit cross six minutes before the end to keep Norway top of Group with a perfect six points. Gemma Grainger's side will become the first team to reach the last eight if Iceland fail to beat hosts Switzerland in Bern later on Sunday. Advertisement Norway looked set to dominate when Eva Nystrom diverted Hansen's low cross into her own net, and they were unlucky not be two ahead midway through the first half after striking the woodwork twice in the space of a minute. First, Ingrid Engen nodded Vilde Boe Risa's probing cross onto the post in the 24th minute. Then, Finland goalkeeper Anna Koivunen tipped an inswinging corner onto the upright. Koivunen pulled off two more superb stops four minutes later, tipping away Hansen's low drive before charging out to deny Ada Hegerberg just as it looked like the former Ballon d'Or winner was certain to net from close range. Koivunen's goalkeeping heroics were rewarded in the 32nd minute when Oona Sevenius kept her head on the edge of the penalty box to guide home a superb leveller. Finland suddenly looked far more likely to take the points, with Eveliina Summanen denied a brilliant goal when Norway goalkeeper Cecilie Fiskerstrand tipped a shot onto the post. Hansen seemed to have missed her chance to win the match for Norway in the 82nd minute when she blasted over from point-blank range. She made up moments later when she skipped past two Finnish defenders, burst into the box, evaded two more players and lofted the ball in off the post.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store