
Traders cry foul as Singapore-bound workers occupy public parking 15 hours daily
Traders claimed that by 5am on weekdays, hundreds of vehicles, mostly belonging to locals working in Singapore, were already occupying public parking bays in Medan Nusa Perintis 2, Gelang Patah, and Perling.
These vehicles remained parked until 8pm, effectively preventing others from using the spaces throughout the day.
The daily occupation of these lots and the resulting shortage of available parking have left customers unable to access shops and food stalls, forcing many to double park or abandon their visits altogether.
In some cases, vehicles were reportedly left parked for days, accumulating parking tickets.
A food vendor, who only wanted to be known as Emma and trades at a site allocated by the Iskandar Puteri City Council (MBIP) in Perling, said she arrived yesterday morning to find her designated business lot already occupied.
"The drivers only returned late in the evening, some even questioned our right to trade here, even though these spaces are legally allocated by MBIP," she said.
At the Iskandar Malaysia Food Court in Gelang Patah, stall owner Mar Muhammad, 33, claimed that nearly 20 vendors have seen their profits dwindle over the last two years.
"The cars come in as early as 5am and stay until 8pm. Some are left for weeks. We have filed complaints with MBIP, but the issue persists," he said.
"Customers circle the area multiple times, give up, and leave. It is affecting our livelihoods."
He added that traders had resorted to arriving early and placing traffic cones to reserve the bays, but some workers simply removed them or picked fights.
Amirul Arshad, 31, who works at a motorcycle shop in Perling, said long-term parking even spills over into reserved lots.
"Some of these car owners block our paid bays. We have had to call in enforcement tow trucks just to carry on with our business," he said.
Business owners along Jalan Lumba Kuda are also struggling, as motorists swamp the limited parking bays outside their ageing shop lots, drawn by the road's proximity to the CIQ complex and Johor Bahru city centre for easier access to Singapore.
Meanwhile, Kota Iskandar assemblyman Datuk Pandak Ahmad said the issue was raised at a recent district coordination meeting.
"A firmer mechanism is needed to prevent these spaces from being seized for such long durations," he said.
"There was a proposal to create a designated parking site on vacant land, but it has yet to be implemented."
For now, frustrated traders continue to fend for themselves, battling not just lost income but also territorial commuters who treat public parking like private storage.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
Malaysia's property bubble: A wake up call
For generations, Malaysians have lived by an unwavering belief: Buy property. It never depreciates. This axiom has been deeply ingrained, marketed as an infallible shield against inflation, a tangible emblem of success and a steadfast repository of wealth consistently outpacing market volatility.


The Star
13 hours ago
- The Star
MyDigital ID rollout must prioritise trust over compulsion, says think tank
PETALING JAYA: The government must prioritise public trust and voluntary participation over compulsion in implementing the MyDigital ID platform, says a policy think tank amid growing national debate on the digital identity system. Social and Economic Research Initiative (Seri) chairman Dr Helmy Haja Mydin said while MyDigital ID can be transformative for service delivery and governance, rushing into legislation to mandate adoption could backfire before gaining public confidence. "We must never lose sight of the fact that the rakyat's trust is earned, not assumed. Digital identity systems can bring enormous benefits, but only if people believe they are safe, effective, and in their interest. "Compulsion before confidence risks undermining the very system we are trying to build," he said in a statement on Saturday (July 26). Helmy Haja's comments came after the Dewan Rakyat was informed that the government is considering new legislation to accelerate MyDigital ID uptake. Currently, only 2.8 million Malaysians are registered, which is modest relative to the population. He added that other countries have achieved high adoption without legal mandates, largely by offering clear, everyday benefits through user-friendly platforms. Helmy Haja cited India's Aadhaar system, which gained traction because key government services and financial aid were channelled through it, not because it was mandatory. He added that Estonia and Singapore show that with thoughtful implementation, digital ID systems can flourish without mandates, by making them secure, convenient, and visibly beneficial. "Let the rakyat see how MyDigital ID simplifies life, whether it is for accessing subsidies, paying taxes, or interacting with banks. "When digital identity is seen as helpful, people will come on board without being forced," he said. Helmy Haja suggested that to build trust, the platform's purpose must be better communicated, as many Malaysians still do not fully understand how MyDigital ID works or what it offers. He noted that although MyDigital ID has begun integration with certain platforms like MyJPJ and MyBorderPass, broader usage across the digital government ecosystem remains patchy. "For real momentum, MyDigital ID must become a seamless key to unlocking public services, whether it is applying for university admission, accessing financial assistance, or filing taxes," he added. Helmy Haja also said that poor execution could severely damage public trust. He cited the Padu (Pangkalan Data Utama) platform as a cautionary tale, noting that issues with data accuracy, system usability, and inter-agency coordination had hurt its credibility despite high initial expectations. "Every failed or rushed rollout comes at a cost, not just in terms of wasted resources, but in eroding the very trust we need for future reforms to succeed," he said. Helmy Haja added the Home Ministry, which already issues MyKad, could be empowered to oversee MyDigital ID given its central role in identity governance that could help improve security, coordination, and user confidence. He said as Malaysia moves towards a digital-first government, Seri stressed that the goal should not be mass enrolment "at all costs" but rather the creation of a system that people choose to use. Helmy Haja outlined seven key recommendations; avoid premature legislation mandating registration, invest in public awareness and education on the benefits and safeguards of MyDigital ID, ensure system reliability and resilience, integrate meaningful services such as healthcare, education, taxes, and financial aid, enhance inter-ministerial system interoperability, provide opt-outs for non-essential services, and collaborate with civil society and grassroots networks to improve digital literacy and inclusion. He added Malaysia has the opportunity to become a leader in responsible digital governance but reminded that it must be done with care.

Barnama
16 hours ago
- Barnama
SERI Calls For Prioritising Public Trust And Awareness To Boost MyDigital ID Uptake
KUALA LUMPUR, July 26 (Bernama) -- The government should prioritise efforts to enhance public awareness and trust, while strengthening the reliability and resilience of the MyDigital ID system to encourage greater adoption among Malaysians. The Social and Economic Research Initiative (SERI), in a statement today, encouraged the government to avoid implementing mandatory registration for the digitalisation initiative at this stage. It emphasised the need to clearly communicate both the benefits and data protection measures of MyDigital ID to the public, while simultaneously integrating meaningful services such as financial aid, tax filing, university admissions and healthcare access to enhance the value of registration.