Earth's First Crust May Have Looked Surprisingly Like The One We Have Today
It may mean a complete rethink of how Earth's coat transitioned from a skin of boiling magma to the shifting armor of tectonic plates we now live on, according to the international team of researchers behind the study.
"Scientists have long thought that tectonic plates needed to dive beneath each other to create the chemical fingerprint we see in continents," says geochemist Simon Turner, from Macquarie University in Australia.
"Our research shows this fingerprint existed in Earth's very first crust, the protocrust – meaning those theories need to be reconsidered."
The chemical fingerprint Turner and his colleagues were looking for was a lack of the element niobium. This is one way of identifying rocks at subduction zones, where one plate slides under another – it's thought that the magma forming these rocks loses niobium as the element gets trapped further down.
Find the first evidence of low levels of niobium in the geological record, it was thought, and you find the point when continental plates first appeared and started slamming into each other. However, this hypothesis of a differing early crust composition has been called into question before.
Here the researchers took a fresh approach. They used mathematical models to figure out the composition of Earth's earliest covering of hard rock, some 4 to 4.5 billion years ago (the Hadean eon). The modeling showed that niobium would be attracted to Earth's core, with no plate tectonics required.
It means continental crust formation may have been a part of the original process of layer formation on Earth, not something that came after. The idea is backed up by the behavior of other siderophile elements in the model – elements attracted to iron, such as the iron in Earth's core as it took shape.
"I realized there might be a connection between early core formation, high siderophile element patterns, and the infamous negative niobium anomaly observed in continental crust," says Turner.
In the many millennia since, it seems continental crust has retained that original chemical signature, less affected by the heavy bombardment of meteorites that changed the composition of Earth's mantle, and ended around 3.8 billion years ago.
All of this needs further investigation, of course, but it's an intriguing alternative take on how Earth first became the planet we recognize today, and how that might apply to other planets. It also answers some of the most baffling questions in geological history.
"This discovery completely changes our understanding of Earth's earliest geological processes," says Turner.
"It also gives us a new way to think about how continents might form on other rocky planets across the Universe."
The research has been published in Nature.
Did Dire Wolves Just Come Back From Extinction? Here's The Truth.
How Do Dogs Perceive The World? It All Starts With The Nose
One Brain Receptor Explains Why 'Virgin' Male Worms Take More Risks
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scientific American
2 hours ago
- Scientific American
Allergens May Make Us Cough and Sneeze by Poking Holes in Airway Cells
The sneezing, itchy eyes and coughing elicited by some allergens are caused by proteins creating holes in airway cells, reports a study published this week in Nature. The findings challenge scientists' understanding of how allergies are triggered, says Feargal Ryan, who studies host–microbe interactions at Flinders University in Adelaide, Australia. Before this, the mechanism that triggers immune responses to allergens was not really understood. Researchers focused mostly on how a single allergen elicits a reaction, rather than looking for a generalizable mechanism. The results could also change allergy-treatment strategies, which typically target the allergen directly or downstream immune responses. Now, researchers can start looking for ways to target the hole-creating proteins that are initiating the immune response, Ryan says. On supporting science journalism If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today. Pore-forming proteins Researchers based in Beijing, China, identified two proteins in the mould Alternaria alternata, which causes allergic reactions in about 5% of people, that trigger the airway inflammation seen during allergic reactions. Together, the proteins, called Aeg-S and Aeg-L, create a pore in the membranes of cells lining the nose, throat and lungs. This allows calcium ions to enter the cells and release molecules that alert the immune system to danger. The damage to cell membranes from these pore-forming proteins could be a 'common signal that our body uses to recognize something as an allergen', says co-author Mo Xu, who studies immune responses at Tsinghua University. To test how the proteins stimulated the immune system, the team treated lung cells with the proteins. Administering the proteins at the same time triggered a similar response as administering an extract of A. alternata, but this response was not seen when the proteins were given one at a time. The researchers also tested whether the proteins could cause an allergic airway inflammation in mice. Six hours after mice were given the proteins intranasally, the rodents showed immune responses similar to those triggered by exposure to A. alternata. The team also observed signs that the mice had developed a respiratory allergy, such as increased levels of serum immunoglobulin E (IgE) — an antibody produced in response to allergens — after the mice were given the proteins every three days for two weeks. This response wasn't seen when the proteins were administered separately, or when mice were exposed to genetically modified mould lacking either protein. Common trigger The team suspected that other allergens with pore-forming proteins would also induce an immune response. When the researchers exposed mice to pore-forming proteins from the airborne mould Aspergillus niger — an allergen — and the venom of the sea anemone Actinia equina, they observed an immune response similar to that induced by Aeg-S and Aeg-L. They also found that allergic airway inflammation was triggered by pore-forming proteins from the earthworm Eisenia fetida, the king oyster mushroom Pleurotus eryngii, the bacterium Clostridium perfringens and the fungus Laetiporus sulphureus. The findings suggest that allergens that are unrelated to each other can trigger allergic reactions in the same way, because they have pore-forming proteins that have been conserved by evolution, says Ryan. 'This is a new way of thinking about allergens,' he says. Future treatments could look at whether there's a way to block or inactivate those proteins and stop the reactions, he adds. Xu says his team are investigating which immune-response pathways are activated after pore-forming proteins damage cell membranes, and whether allergens with proteins that don't form pores, such as those in dust mites or pollens, use the same pathway.
Scientific American
2 hours ago
- Scientific American
Miniature Neutrino Detector Promises to Test the Laws of Physics
Physicists have caught neutrinos from a nuclear reactor using a device weighing just a few kilograms, orders of magnitude less massive than standard neutrino detectors. The technique opens new ways to stress-test the known laws of physics and to detect the copious neutrinos produced in the hearts of collapsing stars. 'They finally did it,' says Kate Scholberg, a physicist at Duke University in Durham, North Carolina. 'And they have very beautiful result.' The experiment, called CONUS+, is described on 30 July in Nature. Challenging quarry On supporting science journalism If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today. Neutrinos are elementary particles that have no electrical charge and generally don't interact with other matter, making them extraordinarily difficult to detect. Most neutrino experiments catch these elusive particles by observing flashes of light that are generated when a neutrino collides with an electron, proton or neutron. These collisions occur extremely infrequently, so such detectors typically have masses of tonnes or thousands of tonnes to provide enough target material to gather neutrinos in relevant numbers. Scholberg and her collaborators first demonstrated the mini-detector technique in 2017, using it to catch neutrinos produced by an accelerator at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee. The Oak Ridge particles have slightly higher energies than those made in reactors. As a result, detecting reactor neutrinos was even more challenging, she says. But lower-energy neutrinos also allow for a more precise test of the standard model of physics. Scholberg's COHERENT detector was the first to exploit a phenomenon called coherent scattering, in which a neutrino 'scatters' off an entire atomic nucleus rather than the atom's constituent particles. Coherent scattering uses the fact that particles of matter can act as waves — and the lower the particles' energy, the longer their wavelength, says Christian Buck, a leader of the CONUS collaboration. If the wavelength of a neutrino is similar to the nucleus's diameter, 'then the neutrino sees the nucleus as one thing. It doesn't see the internal structure', says Buck, who is a physicist at the Max Planck Institute for Nuclear Physics in Heidelberg, Germany. The neutrino doesn't interact with any subatomic particles, but does cause the nucleus to recoil — depositing a tiny amount of energy into the detector. Catching sight of a nucleus Coherent scattering occurs more than 100 times as frequently as the interactions used in other detectors, where the neutrino 'sees' a nucleus as a collection of smaller particles with empty space in between. This higher efficiency means that detectors can be smaller and still spot a similar number of particles in the same time frame. 'Now you can afford to build detectors on the kilogram scale,' Buck says. The downside is that the neutrinos deposit much less energy at the nucleus. The recoil induced on a nucleus by a neutrino is comparable to that produced on a ship by a ping-pong ball, Buck says — and has until recent years has been extremely challenging to measure. The CONUS detector is made of four modules of pure germanium, each weighing 1 kilogram. It operated at a nuclear reactor in Germany from 2018 until that reactor was shut down in 2022. The team then moved the detector, upgraded to CONUS+, to the Leibstadt nuclear power plant in Switzerland. From the new location, the team now reports having seen around 395 collision events in 119 days of operation — consistent with the predictions of the standard model of particle physics. After COHERENT's landmark 2017 result, which was obtained with detectors made of caesium iodide, Scholberg's team repeated the feat with detectors made of argon and of germanium. Separately, last year, two experiments originally designed to hunt for dark matter reported seeing hints of low-energy coherent scattering of neutrinos produced by the Sun. Scholberg says that the standard model makes very clean predictions of the rate of coherent scattering and how it changes with different types of atomic nucleus, making it crucial to compare results from as many detecting materials as possible. And if the technique's sensitivity improves further, coherent scattering could help to push forward the state of the art of solar science. Researchers say that coherent scattering will probably not completely replace any existing technologies for detecting neutrinos. But it can spot all three known types of neutrino (and their corresponding antiparticles) down to low energies, whereas some other techniques can capture only one type. This ability means it could complement massive detectors that aim to pick up neutrinos at higher energies, such as the Hyper-Kamiokande observatory now under construction in Japan.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Deep-Sea Discovery: Submersible Finds Creatures Thriving At The Bottom Of The Ocean
An underwater voyage has revealed a network of creatures thriving at the bottom of deep-sea ocean trenches. In these extreme environments, the crushing pressure, scant food and lack of sunlight can make it hard to survive. Scientists know that tiny microbes prosper there, but less is known about evidence of larger marine life. Researchers traveling along the Kuril–Kamchatka and Aleutian trenches in the northwest Pacific Ocean used a submersible to find tubeworms and mollusks flourishing at over 31,000 feet deep. The deepest part of the ocean goes down to about 36,000 feet. (MORE: Watch Sea Lions Evacuate During Earthquake) Scientists had surveyed this area before and had hints that larger creatures might live at such depths. The new discovery confirms those suspicions and shows just how extensive the communities are, said Julie Huber, a deep sea microbiologist with Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. 'Look how many there are, look how deep they are," said Huber, who was not involved with the research. 'They don't all look the same and they're in a place that we haven't had good access to before.' The findings were published Wednesday in the journal Nature. (MORE: Changing Tides Reveal Hawaiian Petroglyphs) In the absence of light to make their own food, many trench-dwellers big and small survive on key elements like carbon that trickle down from higher in the ocean. Scientists think microbes in this new network may instead be capitalizing on carbon that's accumulated in the trench over time, processing it to create chemicals that seep through cracks in the ocean floor. The tubeworms and mollusks may survive by eating those tiny creatures or living with them and snacking on the products of their labor, scientists said. With this discovery, future studies will focus on how these deep-sea creatures adapted to survive in such extreme conditions and how exactly they harness chemical reactions for food, study authors Mengran Du with the Chinese Academy of Sciences and Vladimir Mordukhovich with the Russian Academy of Sciences said in a statement. Their existence challenges 'long-standing assumptions about life's potential at extreme depths,' the authors said. Solve the daily Crossword
