ICMAP proposes four-pillar crypto adoption framework and CBDC launch plan
This timely initiative introduces a Four-Pillar Framework for the responsible adoption of crypto currencies in Pakistan and outlines a strategic Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) Development and Regulatory Launch Plan. The proposal is intended for consideration by the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC) and relevant policymakers, aiming to facilitate a secure and well-regulated digital financial ecosystem in the country.
In view of the rapidly evolving global landscape of digital finance and crypto investments, ICMAP's proposal serves as a much-needed foundation for Pakistan's policy direction. The Four-Pillar Framework focuses on key dimensions necessary for crypto integration, each supported by international case studies to guide implementation.
The first pillar emphasizes the creation of a clear regulatory framework. It highlights the need for robust, transparent, and internationally aligned regulations to support the development of a safe crypto environment. This includes full compliance with Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Counter-Terrorism Financing (CFT) measures, as well as lessons from other jurisdictions that have effectively implemented such frameworks.
The second pillar advocates for alignment with global crypto and blockchain standards. ICMAP stresses that Pakistan must actively engage with international standard-setting bodies and adopt best practices to ensure credibility and innovation. This involves the appropriate classification of digital assets, setting up effective controls for digital asset transactions, and encouraging blockchain innovation. The case study provided shows how a country successfully built a compliant yet dynamic crypto ecosystem by closely working with global organizations.
The third pillar calls for active industry-government collaboration to encourage responsible innovation while maintaining financial stability. ICMAP highlights that close coordination between regulators and industry stakeholders is essential to strike a balance between enabling innovation and safeguarding the economy. The included case study illustrates how a country effectively fostered such cooperation, promoting growth while ensuring regulatory oversight.
The fourth and final pillar underlines the importance of consumer protection and financial stability. ICMAP recommends clear and enforceable measures to ensure that consumers are protected from abuse and that markets operate with integrity. A case study demonstrates how another country implemented robust consumer safeguards in the crypto sector, ensuring both user confidence and market stability.
Complementing the crypto framework, ICMAP has proposed a structured Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) Development and Regulatory Launch Plan. Recognizing the need for a state-backed digital alternative to crypto currencies, this plan recommends that the State Bank of Pakistan introduce a CBDC to enhance regulatory control, reduce volatility, and expand financial inclusion. A government-issued CBDC would provide a stable digital option that supports innovation without compromising monetary sovereignty.
The proposal also reflects on global investment trends, noting that crypto currencies have attracted investors due to their higher returns compared to traditional stock markets and real interest rates. As more countries increase their exposure to digital assets, ICMAP believes Pakistan must take strategic steps to prepare for the financial future. The document also provides valuable insights into global developments in CBDC implementation, drawing lessons from countries at the forefront of digital currency adoption.
Through this initiative, ICMAP reaffirms its role as a leading policy advisor and thought leader in Pakistan's financial landscape. The Institute remains committed to supporting policymakers in developing forward-looking, well-regulated frameworks that enable innovation, protect consumers, and preserve economic stability.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
18-07-2025
- Business Recorder
Digital rupee set to transform Pakistan's financial landscape
Pakistan is undergoing a profound digital transformation towards digital finance in the financial system with the pilot initiation of a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) by State Bank of Pakistan (SBP). RAAST is a real-time payment system in the country and the officials of SBP have stated that since its inception in 2021, it has handled more than Rs 8 trillion worth of transactions. The CBDC is not just a channel to transfer money like RAAST – it represents the money itself, issued by the central bank. Pakistan has a mobile phone penetration rate of over 82 percent and the expected remittance inflow of an estimated 38.3 million during the fiscal year 2024-25. It stands ready to use CBDC to enhance financial inclusion by cutting transaction fees, digitalisation of welfare payments, and including millions of unbanked citizens into the formal economy. The economic consequences of embracing CBDC are the trade-offs between high short-term expenditure and efficiency, inclusion, and transparency in the long run. According to the SBP annual report of 2022-23, Pakistan spends over Rs 28 billion annually in cash-management-related activities annually in Pakistan, including storage and maintenance of cash, printing, banknotes processing, distribution, and ATM-related maintenance, despite cash accounting being approximately 62 per cent of transaction volume at the mid of 2023. These expenses may be significantly lower as the use of programmable digital rupees that can be stored on a secure mobile wallet can substantially replace physical money in the system that the central bank can issue as digital form of legal tender. The cost of using traditional payment channels of paying via ATM withdrawals, or clearing a cheque is still expensive and time consuming. As of 2022, the fees for using ATM vary between Rs 20- 23 service fee per transaction, and a cheque clearing process may require two days of business, with challenges to control over liquidity and maintaining cash flow. In addition, the latest Global Findex report published by the World Bank in 2021 revealed that the number of Pakistani adults who are not using any financial service is more than 100 million, clarifying the drawbacks of the traditional financial system of Pakistan. According to State Banks data of 2024, RAAST has facilitated transactions of over 160 million, across bank accounts and electronic wallets, which has made instant and free financial transfers. It has been doing this since its introduction in the year 2021. With that being said, experts share that RAAST is unlikely to make money even though it serves as a payment rail. Contrary to these, CBDC represents sovereign digital currency, fully supported and actually issued by the SBP, and is not dependent on the balance sheets of commercial banks. The trend follows the general pattern abroad, with such nations as China and the Bahamas developing their virtual currencies to supplement or minimize the use of the conventional banking system. According to a report published by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in March 2022, China Digital Yuan pilot was commended, stating that CBDCs can enhance financial inclusion with access to safe, convenient digital payment instruments, many of which Citizens, who lack bank accounts, or maintain them at under-staffed or under-equipped institutions, receive limited benefit. Relatively, the Sand Dollar project has been introduced in the Bahamas back in 2020 and has helped in scaling up financial services to previously inaccessible areas in the islands. The legal foundation of CBDC in Pakistan was put in place by the Digital Currency Regulatory Framework (DCRF) act of 2024 that authorized the issuance of digital legal tender by the SBP, cyber security and data privacy requirements, and digital banking licensing. According to the 2023 report published by Bank for International Settlements, unless there is a robust regulatory framework in place, CBDCs can subject users to privacy violation and financial fraud, and therefore it is quite important that Pakistan is already making steps towards setting a regulatory framework. To complement this scenario, the government of Pakistan enacted the Act of Virtual Assets, 2025, which was a historic bill that formed the Pakistan Virtual Asset Regulatory Authority (PVARA). The mission of PVARA is to control and oversee the ecosystem of virtual assets that entail, but are not limited to crypto currencies, tokenized assets, and other digital financial products. The mission of such body of authority is to furnish an orderly legal framework that facilitates innovation without jeopardizing investors and alleviating the risk of money laundering, financing of terrorists, and fraud. The Virtual Assets Act has given the PVARA power to license the providers of services involving virtual assets, strict observance of anti-money laundering (AML), and the knowledge-your-customer (KYC) requirements, and established transparency and accountability in the digital asset market. With the formation of PVARA, Pakistan joins an increasingly long list of nations implementing serious sets of rules to handle digital assets such as Singapore Monetary Authority of Singapore and the UK Financial Conduct Authority. This is a step that is also compliant with international requirements as spelt out by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) who requires countries to ensure that they oversee the safety of the virtual assets and the service providers. Among pilot projects it is considering are direct payment of social safety net programs like BISP and Ehsaas via CBDC wallets, programmable utility payments, and cross-border remittance corridors that could help to push the estimated $8 billion of annual informal remittance outflow in Pakistan, the World Bank reported in 2023. There are success stories like eNaira that is being launched in Nigeria, where the Central Bank of Nigeria (2023) notes that eNaira has ended up solving the government-to-person payments, and lowered leakages. The rollout of CBDC also supports Pakistan's project URAAN, specifically its E-Pakistan pillar focused on digital governance and inclusion. By offering digital cash accessible via mobile phones, CBDC could help bridge gaps in financial access, reduce the size of the informal economy, and enhance tax transparency, as detailed in the Planning Commission of Pakistan's 2024 documentation. Globally, United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) experts view CBDCs as tools to advance Sustainable Development Goals by promoting financial inclusion and reducing poverty. In its 2022 report, the UNDP emphasized that 'digital currencies can accelerate economic development by integrating marginalized populations into the formal financial system.' To ordinary Pakistanis, living in remote locations or low-income families, CBDC wallets may be their entry point into the formal finance realm. A daily-wage earner or a small-business owner or shopkeeper who may only have a simple mobile phone could access welfare, pay utilities, start savings-all without having to open a traditional bank account. In conclusion, while Pakistan faces significant costs in developing CBDC infrastructure, including cyber security safeguards and institutional reforms, the potential benefits are transformative. These include drastically reduced cash handling costs, faster and cheaper payments, greater inclusion of unbanked populations, and improved government accountability. The CBDC is not intended to replace existing payment systems immediately but to complement platforms like RAAST. Together, these tools can form a resilient digital financial architecture essential for Pakistan's economic modernization. (The writer is an Assistant Professor of Finance at the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE). He can be reached at [email protected].) Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
14-07-2025
- Business Recorder
ADB-funded CAREC project: NHA rejects irregularity claims
ISLAMABAD: The National Highway Authority (NHA) has formally submitted a comprehensive status report to the Prime Minister's Office, rejecting allegations of irregularities and award of the ADB-funded Central Asia Regional Economic Cooperation (CAREC) Tranche 3 project to any black listed firm. The NHA's report stated that the CAREC Tranche 3 project, which involves the construction of an additional two-lane carriageway along a 330 km stretch of National Highway N-55 from Rajanpur to Dera Ismail Khan, is being financed under ADB Loan No. 4416-PAK. The procurement process is subject to strict ADB guidelines and was carried out under the ADB Prior Review Mechanism, meaning that every single step—technical and financial—required prior approval from ADB before proceeding. NHA denies CAREC project being given to blacklisted Chinese co The NHA categorically denied awarding the contract to a blacklisted firm, stating that the successful consortium—M/s Ningxia Communications Construc-tion Co. Ltd (NXCC) of China with local partners M/s Rustam Associates (RA) and M/s Dynamic Constructors (DC)—was never blacklisted by any Pakistani agency including NHA, FBR or PEC and PPRA or the donor agency. 'These firms are in good standing with the Pakistan Engineering Council and the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA),' the report affirms, adding that both local partners are registered in the 'No Limit' category with PEC and have completed multiple projects in the country. The NHA also clarified that allegations regarding NXCC's performance on the Lodhran–Multan project were resolved through ADB-sanctioned processes. NXCC responded to the concerns, and the ADB, after reviewing all documentation and clarifications, issued a No Objection Certificate (NOC) on January 17, 2025, for the technical evaluation and again on April 30, 2025, for the financial bid evaluation. The report highlights that the lowest evaluated bids across the four project lots totalled Rs146 billion, which is about 20% below the NHA's own engineer's estimate and not Rs172 billion as falsely claimed in the news reports. The difference between the lowest and second-lowest bids alone resulted in a cost saving of Rs13.19 billion, the NHA stressed. According to the NHA report to PM office, the project bidding followed the Single Stage – Two Envelope Procedure in accordance with ADB's standard documents. A pre-bid meeting was held in August 2024, attended by 12 interested firms. Technical bids were submitted by 12 bidders and underwent a thorough ADB-approved evaluation process. Concerns raised by a competing bidder about NXCC's track record were evaluated under Appendix 7 of ADB's procurement regulations and addressed within the Technical Bid Evaluation Report (TBER), which ADB fully endorsed. After receiving ADB's concurrence at every step—including the final Price Bid Evaluation Report (PBER)—the NHA awaits only a revision in the PC-I approval from ECNEC before formally awarding the contracts. The report also refers to Rule 5 of Pakistan's Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) Rules, which states that international obligations under treaties or agreements—including those with financial institutions like ADB—take precedence over domestic procurement rules in case of conflict. The report concluded that the entire procurement process was conducted in a 'transparent and accountable manner' and with the full oversight and approval of ADB at all stages. All complaints were addressed and shared with the ADB, and none of the bidding firms were unfairly disqualified. 'The issuance of No Objection Letters by ADB for both technical and financial stages is the strongest evidence that no procurement violations occurred,' the report added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
21-06-2025
- Business Recorder
Potential fallout of Israel-Iran conflict: ICMAP for ensuring 90-day strategic oil reserves
KARACHI: To address the challenges arising from escalating regional tensions, the Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Pakistan (ICMAP) has proposed a set of strategic policy recommendations. These include the establishment of 90-day strategic oil reserves, formation of an economic task force, and adoption of oil price hedging mechanisms to help shield Pakistan from the potential fallout of the Israel-Iran conflict. In response to escalating regional tensions, the ICMAP has issued a timely and policy-focused assessment of the potential economic fallout from the ongoing Israel-Iran conflict. Developed by ICMAP's Research and Publications Department, the report complements the government's recent decision to establish a high-level committee, headed by the Finance Minister, to evaluate emerging economic risks. ICMAP's assessment underscores that while the conflict remains geographically limited, its indirect economic consequences are already rippling across global markets, particularly affecting energy, trade, and financial systems. For Pakistan, the exposure is significant due to its dependence on imported fuel, critical maritime trade routes through the Gulf, and the livelihoods of over four million expatriate workers based in the Middle East. Central to the analysis is a warning that any disruption in the Strait of Hormuz, through which nearly 20% of global oil and LNG transit, could drive oil prices to between $100 and $130 per barrel. This would substantially increase Pakistan's energy import bill, elevate power generation costs, and accelerate inflation. Domestic diesel prices could rise by more than 30%, with wide-ranging effects on food production, transportation, and household expenditures. The report further highlights rising risks to financial stability. Depreciation of the Pakistani Rupee, increased external debt servicing costs, and fiscal pressure from potential fuel subsidies could erode macroeconomic resilience. Exporters are already facing sharp increases in shipping insurance premiums, reportedly climbing from $400 to $2,000 per container, thereby undermining export competitiveness. In addition, supply chain disruptions and elevated freight charges are expected to impact industrial production - particularly in key sectors such as textiles, chemicals, and edible oils. To address these challenges, ICMAP has outlined a set of strategic policy recommendations. At the forefront is the proposal to establish a Strategic Economic Task Force comprising the Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Commerce, Ministry of Energy (Petroleum Division), Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Planning, Development and Special Initiatives, Ministry of Defence, and the State Bank of Pakistan. This high-level task force would be responsible for monitoring global developments and coordinating timely, cross-institutional policy responses to safeguard Pakistan's economic stability. The Institute also recommends expanding Pakistan's strategic petroleum reserves from the current 21 days to at least 90 days of national demand. This critical buffer could be financed through sovereign Sukuk, modelled after successful international practices, to enhance energy security and reduce vulnerability to global supply shocks. Additional recommendations include the adoption of Shariah-compliant oil price hedging instruments for up to 30% of imports to manage exposure to international price volatility. ICMAP also advocates diversifying oil procurement by pursuing local currency trade agreements with countries such as Russia, Iran, and China. Accelerating the modernization of local oil refineries is also advised, which could reduce reliance on imported refined fuels and potentially save up to $1 billion annually. ICMAP further recommends for reversing recent taxes on solar panel imports and fast-tracking the implementation of the 10,000 MW Solar Initiative to promote clean energy and enhance long-term energy resilience. On the external front, it emphasizes the need to safeguard overseas remittances by engaging Gulf countries, incentivizing formal remittance channels, and supporting returning workers to sustain household incomes and foreign exchange inflows. ICMAP further suggests applying for financing under the IMF's Resilience and Sustainability Trust (RST) and establishing an Energy Shock Stabilization Fund in collaboration with multilateral development partners to strengthen fiscal buffers. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
