Why don't you earn? Supreme Court on Rs 12 crore, Mumbai flat, BMW alimony demand
Highlighting the woman's qualifications, an MBA and experience as an IT expert, the Chief Justice remarked that she should not depend on alimony. 'If you are educated, you should not beg for yourself. You should earn and eat for yourself,' he said.The woman countered that her husband is very wealthy and has even sought an annulment of the marriage by alleging she suffers from schizophrenia. 'Do I look like a schizophrenic?' she asked the bench.Senior advocate Madhavi Divan, appearing for the husband, argued that alimony cannot be claimed in such an extravagant manner. She pointed out that the woman was already living in a Mumbai flat with two parking spots and could generate income from it. She said, "She has to work also. Everything cannot be demanded like this."'The BMW she is dreaming of is 10 years old and has been discontinued,' Divan added.CJI Gavai noted the husband's past income, Rs 2.5 crore salary and Rs 1 crore in bonuses during his employment, and directed both parties to submit complete financial documents. The bench also emphasised that the woman could not claim rights over property of her husband's father.The woman alleged that the husband's actions led to her job loss and that he had filed a false FIR against her. To this, CJI Gavai assured, 'You file the FIR, we will cancel that too. We will direct that no party will initiate any criminal proceedings against each other.'As the hearing concluded, the court offered the woman two options — either accept a burden-free flat or Rs 4 crore and seek employment in IT hubs like Pune, Hyderabad, or Bengaluru. 'There is demand in IT centers,' said the CJI.- Ends
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
NMC reinvites ‘Ram Kal Path' bids after lukewarm response
Nashik: The Nashik Municipal Corporation (NMC) on Thursday refloated the tender for the 'Ram Kal Path' project inviting tenders from private agencies for the second phase of the work amounting to Rs 74.8 crore, after receiving a lukewarm response to its initial bids. The Ram Kal Path project involves developing a 1.3km stretch from Ramkund to Kalaram Temple and Seetagumpha. After a poor initial response, the civic body has refloated the tender for the Rs 74.8-crore project, hoping for better participation this time. If a contractor is finalised soon, work is expected to begin promptly, given the project's deadline of Sept next year, civic official said. Prashant Pagar, a senior official from the public works department of NMC, said four contractors had filed their bids, but three were disqualified. "Hence, we took the second call for inviting the bids. This time, we are expecting good response from the contractors for the project," he said. The civic officials said various beautification works were to be undertaken under the project to make the entire stretch an attraction for tourists. "Deepstambh, sculptures, fountains, laser shows and wall paintings along the roads, and other beautification works are to be carried out there. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Indonesia: New Container Houses (Prices May Surprise You) Container House | Search Ads Search Now Undo The entire area is to be revamped from the tourism point of view," another official said. The total cost of the project is estimated at Rs 99.14 crore, which is to be funded by Centre. So far, NMC has received Rs 65 crore, while the remaining funds are to be disbursed as the work progresses. In the first phase of Rs 22.55 crore, conservation and renovation works will be undertaken of the ancient temples and structures' façade along the Ram Kal Path. NMC has already finalised the contractor for the first phase of the project through the tender process. Simhastha Kumbh Mela is held every 12 years in Nashik when lakhs of sadhus and devotees take a holy dip in the Ramkund during the religious conglomerate. The upcoming Kumbh Mela is slated to be held between 2026 and 2028. Hence, NMC wants to complete the Ram Kal Path project before the Kumbh Mela begins. The flag hoisting of the Kumbh Mela is to be held in Oct next year. In June, the civic body had decided to increase Ram Kal Path's width to 9 metres. In May, NMC had set aside Rs 23 crore on renovating structures' façade along the corridor. In April, NMC sought additional funding for project and also decided to demolish six wadas to pave.
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
No proposal for Bhubaneswar Metro to Centre: MoS
1 2 Bhubaneswar: The Bhubaneswar Metro rail project is notably absent from the list of metro rail proposals either received or sanctioned by the Centre, according to a reply by Union minister of state for housing and urban affairs, Tokhan Sahu, in the Lok Sabha on Friday. Over the past five years, the Centre received 17 proposals, including those submitted this year, but Bhubaneswar's project is not among them. In response to a query from Bharat Mathukumilli, Sahu informed the Lok Sabha that 24 metro projects are currently at various stages of implementation, in addition to the 17 approved by the Centre. Odisha's housing and urban development minister, Krushna Chandra Mahapatra, explained that the previous BJD govt did not submit a proposal for Bhubaneswar Metro because it intended to undertake the project independently, without central assistance. However, the current BJP govt plans to seek the central aid and will submit a proposal in due course. Mahapatra emphasised that the govt is earnestly planning a viable Metro project for the state capital, clarifying that the absence of a proposal submission to the Centre does not indicate lack of seriousness. "We have reimagined the Metro train project differently from the past govt's plan, which was not feasible. We aim to execute it as a joint venture with the Centre's help," Mahapatra said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like IQ Worldwide - Test your Intelligence, know your IQ Score Try Now Undo The previous govt had announced a fully state-funded project worth more than Rs 5,000 crore, intended to connect Biju Patnaik International Airport with Trisulia Square. However, Mahapatra questioned the viability of such a route. "Why would people travel from the airport to Trisulia Square?" he asked. An inter-ministerial committee meeting on the new plan has already taken place, with a second review scheduled. "Once the committee meets and finalises, the next steps will be determined. It cannot proceed without the Centre's assistance," Mahapatra added.
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
Consumer court pulls up realty firms, orders compensation in two cases
Hyderabad: The district consumer disputes redressal commission, Ranga Reddy, has ruled in favour of consumers in two separate real estate disputes — one involving delayed possession of a flat, and another over returns promised on land-linked investments. In both cases, refunds and compensation were awarded. In the first case, Rajitha Guduru from Bachupalli deposited Rs 25 lakh in instalments with a real estate firm dealing in land ventures in Warangal. The company issued her certificates promising monthly returns on "undivided land shares", but no payments were made. Rajitha was never told where the land was or given proper documentation. Despite repeated follow-ups, they neither refunded money nor responded clearly, she told the commission. The complainant also alleged that she helped the firm by enrolling others into chit fund schemes tied to the same group. You Can Also Check: Hyderabad AQI | Weather in Hyderabad | Bank Holidays in Hyderabad | Public Holidays in Hyderabad The firm argued that Rajitha hadn't completed the transaction or followed the exit terms, and claimed other companies mentioned were unrelated. However, the commission found that the certificates lacked essential details like location, land extent, and transaction terms. Holding the firm guilty of misleading the consumer and collecting money without delivering on promises, the commission directed it to refund the Rs 25 lakh with 9% annual interest, pay Rs 50,000 for mental agony, and Rs 10,000 in legal costs. Other firms named were let off. In the second case, N Gayathri and her husband N Rajasekhar Reddy filed a complaint after two developers failed to hand over a flat in a Narsingi project. The couple paid Rs 36.9 lakh of the agreed Rs 68 lakh after signing a sale agreement in January 2022. However, the developers neither completed the flat nor responded to legal notices. With no appearance from the developers during the hearing, the commission set them ex-parte and ordered them to hand over the flat within three months after collecting the remaining amount. They were also directed to pay Rs 50,000 in compensation and Rs 10,000 towards litigation costs. These orders highlight how consumer courts are increasingly holding builders and investment firms accountable for delays, false promises, and lack of transparency in real estate transactions.
