‘Terrorism has no religion ... ': What NIA court judge said in 2008 Malegaon bomb blast case
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
'The court of law is not supposed to proceed on popular or predominant public perceptions… the more serious the offence, the higher the degree of proof needed for conviction,' special judge A K Lahoti said.
'Though there was strong suspicion of the accused, it cannot take place of legal proof.'
What the judge said
Prosecution has failed to provide cogent and reliable evidence
Failed to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt
Terrorism has no religion
No religion in the world preaches violence.
Court of law is not supposed to proceed on popular or predominant public perceptions.
The testimony of prosecution witnesses is riddled
With material inconsistencies and contradictions (39 witnesses turned hostile)
— A K Lahoti | Special judge
Six of the seven had spent nine years in jail as undertrials till 2017 before getting bail in a case purportedly linked to a plot by right-wing extremists to terrorise the local Muslim population of Malegaon.
Six people died in the 2008 blast and 101 were injured.
The judgment, delivered after a legal process lasting 17 years, highlighted lapses in the probe conducted by the state's anti-terrorism squad before it was handed over to the National Investigation Agency. The judge pointed to retractions by numerous witnesses and shortcomings such as mishandling of the crime scene and planting of evidence.
After the verdict, Thakur took a seat in the witness box. Addressing the judge, she said the verdict was a 'victory for Hindutva'. Breaking down, she said her life was destroyed by the humiliation and stigma of being labelled a terrorist for 17 years. ' Jinhone bhi humaare saath galat kiya, prabhu unko kabhi kshama nahi karega (God will punish those who wronged us).'
Purohit, who arrived with military security, said the agencies are not wrong, but the people running them were.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
6 minutes ago
- Indian Express
BJP MLC's ‘father of Sena' remark draws ire of Shinde's party: ‘Apologise within 12 hours'
In a fresh instance of trouble between the ruling Mahayuti allies, the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena demanded an apology 'within twelve hours' from BJP MLC Parinay Phuke who mentioned that he was the 'father' of Sena. Phuke made the remarks at a party function held in Bhandara district Monday, where he was speaking about Bhandara District Central Cooperative Bank elections. The Shiv Sena had blamed the BJP leader for its election loss. ' Whenever every student does well the credit goes to his mother or him. But then things don't blame it pushed on the father… I have come to understand that I am the father of Shiv Sena,' Phuke said in Marathi, referring to the Sena's accusations against him. Responding to the remarks, the Shinde Sena has demanded an apology from Phuke. 'We will not tolerate such irresponsible statements from BJP's Parnay Phuke and he should apologise within twelve hours. Or else we will be forced to respond in Shiv Sena style,' Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Kumbhalkar said. Earlier, a senior Shinde Sena minister said, ' The Shiv Sena has only one father Bal Thackeray. Nobody can take his place. And certainly not Phuke. Therefore, BJP leadership should reprimand their members who make such irresponsible statements and hurt the sentiments of Sena.' Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis said that Phuke's remark was being distorted and misunderstood. 'Phuke's remark should be seen in the right context. He did not mean it,' Fadnavis told mediapersons in Mumbai. This is the second instance of a BJP legislator landing in controversy in a span of few days. On Sunday, a video surfaced in which Minister of State Meghana Bordikar from BJP was seen threatening to slap a gram sevak. Explaining her action, Bordikar, the two-time MLA from Jintur, said, 'I expressed my anger at a function where zilla parishad officials were present. One particular gram sevak was not taking the welfare schemes being implemented by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis to the poor people. He was creating hurdles.' 'I lost my cool because the women labourers had complained to me about the harassment from the gram sevak,' she had said.
The Hindu
6 minutes ago
- The Hindu
PM Modi to address NDA parliamentary meeting on August 5
Prime Minister Narendra Modi will address the BJP-led NDA parliamentary party meeting on Tuesday (August 5, 2025), a get-together of the ruling alliance's MPs which is being held after a considerable gap. The NDA meeting comes a couple of days before the filing of nomination for Vice-President's election begins from August 7. The NDA will have to announce its candidate, whose election will be a certainty due to the alliance's majority in the electoral college, by August 21, the last date of nomination-filing and the Monsoon Session of Parliament. The meeting comes in the middle of a session which has been all but a washout so far, except for a two-day discussion on the Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor, due to a united Opposition's ceaseless protest against the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar by the Election Commission of India. Mr. Modi is expected to speak on a host of current issues as the Opposition has been raising the heat over the poll body's alleged partisan conduct favouring the government, and the Pahalgam terror attack and Operation Sindoor. The Prime Minister is also likely to be felicitated by the parliamentary party over his government's military response to the terror strike. The electoral college for the vice president poll includes MPs of the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha, and its current strength is 782. If the Opposition also names a candidate, a distinct possibility, then the poll is scheduled to be held on September 9. Sources said Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju and a few BJP national general secretaries are likely to be coordinating with allies for the vice presidential poll. Since the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, when the BJP lost its majority but comfortably crossed the halfway mark with allies, the sessional meeting of the party's MPs was expanded to include its allies. PM Modi had addressed the first such meeting on July 2. However, no meeting has been held in the last few sessions. Before the last national elections, he used to address the weekly meetings of BJP parliamentary party, now expanded to include party's allies such as the TDP, JD(U), and LJP (Ram Vilas). The meeting is attended by MPs of the ruling alliance, and Mr. Modi often covers a sweep of political and governance issues, and at times touches on the government's agenda in Parliament. He often offers to the MPs talking points to be raised in public, especially their constituencies.
The Hindu
6 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Demonstration against arrest of Christian nuns in Chhattisgarh
Condemning the recent arrest of two Roman Catholic nuns in Chhattisgarh, the Tamil Nadu Minorities Welfare Committee staged a demonstration here on Monday. The protestors said the nuns, while taking three children to Agra with their parents' consent, were assaulted by Bajrand Dal members, who also filed a complaint with Narayanpur police that the children were being kidnapped for religious conversion. Without verifying the fact, the police remanded them in judicial custody. On its part, the judiciary, while hearing their bail pleas, rejected it and directed the NIA to take up investigation even though the children were going along with the nuns with the knowledge of their parents. After steps taken by MPs of various political parties other than the BJP, they were enlarged on bail. 'Since the BJP and the Hindu outfits across the country are spreading religious hatred, the minorities are living in fear after frequent attacks on them and their properties and, hence, those who believe in communal harmony should join hands against these evil forces,' the protestors said.
