Labor's 20 per cent student debt cut delivers only 7.9 per cent real reduction, parliamentary analysis finds
The research, released by the Australian Greens on Monday, showed the $16 billion student debt relief package has been eroded by three years of indexation.
High inflation over the first term of the Albanese government caused student debts to balloon as they were indexed each financial year.
According to the analysis, students owing $30,000 in loans when Labor came to power will see their debt cut to $27,619 after indexation and the 20 per cent cut are applied.
That is just $2,381 in relief, or a 7.9 per cent reduction on their original balance.
Despite the government's changes to indexation, the compounding impact of annual increases has significantly diluted the long-term benefit of the one-off policy.
The policy drew widespread criticism when it was announced for its high cost and perceived unfairness, particularly for taxpayers without student debt.
The total cost of the policy was earmarked at $16 billion, providing assistance to just three million people, while 24 million Australians without HELP debt receive nothing.
Concerns over fairness also intensified after Sky News revealed that nearly 40,000 overseas-based debtors will receive close to $50 million in taxpayer-funded relief.
The students that were most reckless with their loans also stand to benefit the most, with some individuals racking up hundreds of thousands in debt.
Not-for-profit research body e61 Institute recently exposed the way the policy will unfairly benefit students who graduated in 2024.
University students who finished their degrees in 2024 will receive twice as much relief as people who left in 2020, according to e61.
'Most HELP debt is held by university graduates, who have much higher lifetime incomes than the average taxpayer,' e61 Research Economist Matthew Maltman said.
'And even if you look within graduates, those with more costly degrees tend to go on to earn higher incomes in the future.
'The current policy isn't at all targeted and that means it's going to give a very large amount of debt relief to future lawyers, dentists and doctors.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
a few seconds ago
- Sky News AU
Chris Minns under scrutiny for his stance on pro-Palestinian protest on Harbour Bridge
Some members of the NSW government are accusing NSW Premier Chris Minns of overstepping his authority by ruling against a pro-Palestinian protest on the Sydney Harbour Bridge this weekend. Two state Labor MPs have criticized Mr Minns, claiming he is more concerned about traffic flow than the starving children in Gaza. Sydney Mayor Clover Moore is in favour of the protest, believing the march will be a powerful symbol.
Perth Now
a few seconds ago
- Perth Now
'Show about nothing': PM taunted over US tariffs
Anthony Albanese has been accused of being a "Seinfeld prime minister" as the opposition ramps up its rhetoric over the US tariffs issue. The prime minister has been compared the famous 1990s "show about nothing", amid dwindling hopes Australia can secure a total tariff exemption. US President Donald Trump's deals with other nations have laid bare the limits of trade negotiations, with no countries receiving a better deal than Australia's 10 per cent baseline tariff. And now Australian exporters could see the impost set on goods sent to the US doubled, after Mr Trump delivered an ominous warning on Tuesday. He implied the base rate, which applies to the goods of many countries including Australia, could rise to 15-20 per cent. Mr Trump said his administration would soon notify about 200 countries of their new "world tariff" rate. "I would say it'll be somewhere in the 15-to-20 per cent range," he said. "Probably one of those two numbers." Senior Labor government minister Clare O'Neil said Australia was continuing to argue to the US that it deserves beneficial treatment, given the two countries' long running alliance. "We want to get the best deal for our citizens - that's what our government is working towards every day," she told Seven's Sunrise program on Wednesday. But opposition foreign affairs spokeswoman Michaelia Cash said the government's approach had been a failure so far, given Mr Albanese was yet to secure a face-to-face meeting with Mr Trump. "The prime minister of Australia, Mr Albanese, is becoming the Seinfeld prime minister - he's a show about nothing," she told Seven. "Other countries ... they are successfully negotiating trade deals that benefit their countries. "We now hear it could go 15 per cent, it could go 20 per cent. "I just remind the Australian people that when the coalition was last in government, we successfully negotiated a zero per cent tariff." Senator Cash was referencing the Seinfeld episode The Pitch, when characters Jerry and George pitched an idea for a "show about nothing" to TV executives - recreating how creators Jerry Seinfeld and Larry David came up with the show's concept. During Mr Trump's first stint in office, Australia under former prime minister Malcolm Turnbull and several other countries secured tariff exemptions from the White House. No countries have secured total exemptions this time. The government resolved one of Mr Trump's grievances with Australia last week by lifting an effective ban on US beef imports. Canada on Wednesday morning, AEST, announced Australia also reopened market access for Canadian beef, ending a 22-year-old ban imposed following the discovery of mad cow disease.
Sky News AU
31 minutes ago
- Sky News AU
'Facts can no longer be concealed': Labor's renewables push undermined by CSIRO report proving coal is 'king', energy expert claims
Labor's claims about renewable energy appear to have been undermined in a new CSIRO report, with the Centre for Independent Studies' energy expert Aidan Morrison confident coal was still the "king" of cheap power. Speaking to Sky News, Mr Morrison refuted Labor's claims renewable energy was the best path forward and said the CSIRO's 'own numbers' in its recent GenCost report showed coal was cheaper than firmed integrated renewables. In the report, black coal cost $111 per megawatt hour at the lowest end of annual forecasts while backed-up wind and solar was $116 MWh under the cheapest model. Last year's report had black coal in second place at $107 MWh compared to firmed renewables, which were in first place at $97 MWh. Energy Minister Chris Bowen, however, said the CSIRO report showed renewables, backed by batteries and transmission, was the cheapest form of energy. 'Much cheaper than nuclear and the Liberal Party remains committed to nuclear, the most expensive form of the energy, rejected by the Australian people,' he said. Mr Morrison said the headline from the GenCost report should be: 'Coal is the king of low cost energy'. 'CSIRO's own numbers in this report actually say that coal is now cheaper to build than firmed integrated renewables,' he said. Mr Morrison claimed the CSIRO demonstrated coal was now the cheapest form of electricity for consumers, but had 'bent over backwards' to conceal the truth. 'In particular, the estimation for the cost of firm renewables, that is providing all the gas and the transmission and the storage to make that intermittent feast and famine energy into reliable electricity,' he said. 'Last time they told us that that was between $42 and $48. This time they're saying it's between $48 and $64. There is literally no overlap between draft and final between those two different estimates for how much it costs to firm renewables." Mr Morrison said the CSIRO had 'moved the goalposts' by adding 'caveat words' to its website such as 'low-carbon electricity', referring to renewables. 'They are literally shifting the goal posts in front of our eyes when they are no longer able, in their own analysis, to sustain the argument… that renewables are not just environmentally virtuous but also economically virtuous,' he said. 'The facts can no longer be concealed.' Mr Morrison said the CSIRO's report could not be 'taken seriously'. Earlier on Tuesday, the CSIRO refused to reveal its modelling on the cost of the renewable energy transition, sparking transparency concerns over the Albanese government's push for net zero. Among those voicing their concerns was shadow energy minister Dan Tehan, who pointed to the final GenCost report released by the CSIRO in which it said the modelling on its renewable integration costs was 'not suitable for general release'. Mr Tehan said the government needed to release the information given its broken $275 power bill reduction promise. 'Why? This is our leading scientific organisation and it will not release the modelling on these costs they are putting forward,' Mr Tehan said. 'Nothing in this report goes to that fact. As a matter of fact, all we see now is our leading scientific organisations saying they cannot release that model. Well, I think the government needs to explain why. 'The cost is being hidden by this government.'
