Universities threatened with funding cuts under proposed plan to tackle antisemitism in Australia
Jillian Segal was appointed to the role a year ago in response to a surge in reports of attacks against Jewish sites and property in Australia, following Israel's invasion of Gaza, and was tasked with combating antisemitism in the country.
Standing alongside Prime Minister Anthony Albanese Thursday, Segal released a report nine months in the making proposing strong measures, including the university funding threats and the screening of visa applicants for extremist views.
'The plan is not about special treatment for one community; it is about restoring equal treatment,' Segal said. 'It's about ensuring that every Australian, regardless of their background or belief, can live, work, learn and prosper in this country.'
Like in the United States, Australian campuses were once the hub of pro-Palestinian protests led by students who pitched tents demanding action to stop Israel's assault on Gaza.
The campus protests dwindled after restrictions were tightened and some protesters were threatened with expulsion, a move condemned by the activists as an infringement on free speech.
Segal's report said antisemitism had become 'ingrained and normalised' within academia and university courses, as well as on campuses, and recommended universities be made subject to annual report cards assessing their effectiveness in combating antisemitism.
Universities Australia chief executive Luke Sheehy said the organization had been working 'constructively' with the special envoy and its members would 'consider the recommendations.'
'Academic freedom and freedom of expression are core to the university mission, but they must be exercised with responsibility and never as a cover for hate or harassment,' he said in a statement.
Antisemitic attacks in Australia surged 300% in the year following Israel's invasion of Gaza in October 2023.
In the past week alone, the door of a synagogue was set on fire in Melbourne, forcing 20 occupants to flee by a rear exit, as nearby protesters shouting 'Death to the IDF' – using the initials of the Israeli military – stormed an Israeli-owned restaurant.
A man is facing arson charges over the synagogue attack, and three people were charged Tuesday with assault, affray, riotous behavior and criminal damage over the restaurant raid.
The Executive Council of Australian Jewry, which Segal once led and is the umbrella organization for hundreds of Jewish community groups, said the report's release 'could not be more timely given the recent appalling events in Melbourne.'
However, the Jewish Council of Australia, which opposes Israel's war in Gaza, voiced concerns about Segal's plan, saying it carried the overtones of US President Donald Trump's attempts to use funding as a means of control over institutions.
In a statement, the council criticized the plan's 'emphasis on surveillance, censorship, and punitive control over the funding of cultural and educational institutions,' adding that they were 'measures straight out of Trump's authoritarian playbook.'
Max Kaiser, the group's executive officer, said: 'Any response that treats antisemitism as exceptional, while ignoring Islamophobia, anti-Palestinian racism, and other forms of hate, is doomed to fail.'
The envoy's 20-page plan includes sweeping recommendations covering schools, immigration, media, policing and public awareness campaigns.
Segal wants Holocaust and antisemitism education baked into the national curriculum 'as a major case study of where unchecked antisemitism can lead,' according to the report.
Arts organizations could be subject to the same restrictions as universities, with threats to pull public funding if they're found to have engaged in, or facilitated, antisemitism.
'While freedom of expression, particularly artistic expression, is vital to cultural richness and should be protected, funding provided by Australian taxpayers should not be used to promote division or spread false/ distorted narratives,' the report said.
Under the recommendations, tougher immigration screening would weed out people with antisemitic views, and the Migration Act would enable authorities to cancel visas for antisemitic conduct.
Media would be monitored to 'encourage accurate, fair and responsible reporting' and to 'avoid accepting false or distorted narratives,' the report added.
During Thursday's press conference, Albanese pointed to an interview on the country's national broadcaster with a protester, saying the interviewee tried to justify the Melbourne restaurant attack.
'There is no justification for that whatsoever,' he said. 'The idea that somehow the cause of justice for Palestinians is advanced by behavior like that is not only delusional, it is destructive, and it is not consistent with how you are able to put forward your views respectfully in a democracy,' he said.
Asked if the country had become less tolerant of different views and had, perhaps, lost the ability to have a debate, Albanese pointed to social media.
'I think there is an impact of social media, where algorithms work to reinforce people's views,' he said. 'They reinforce views, and they push people towards extremes, whether it be extreme left, extreme right. Australians want a country that is in the center.'
His comments came as Grok, X's AI chatbot, was called out for spreading antisemitic tropes that the company said it was 'actively working to remove.'
Albanese said, regarding antisemitic views, 'social media has a social responsibility, and they need to be held to account.'
Asked whether anti-Israel protests were fueling the antisemitic attacks, the prime minister said people should be able to express their views without resorting to hate.
'In Israel itself, as a democracy, there is protest against actions of the government, and in a democracy, you should be able to express your view here in Australia about events overseas,' he said. 'Where the line has been crossed is in blaming and identifying people because they happen to be Jewish.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
59 Palestinians in Gaza killed by Israeli airstrikes or shot dead while seeking aid
At least 31 Palestinians were fatally shot on their way to an aid distribution site in the Gaza Strip on Saturday, Palestinian hospital officials and witnesses said. The Israeli military said it had fired warning shots toward people it said were behaving suspiciously to prevent them from approaching.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
‘Stop the excuses' and recognise state of Palestine, SNP tells UK government
The SNP has called on the UK Government to 'stop the excuses' and follow other European countries in recognising the state of Palestine. The party's comments follow a speech by French President Emmanuel Macron during his recent state visit to the UK, in which he said recognising the state of Palestine was 'the only path to peace'. The SNP also called on the UK Government to stop the sale of arms to Israel, saying that failure by the Government to 'use the power it has' to end the conflict in Gaza would make it 'totally complicit' in what it called a 'slaughter'. SNP Middle East spokesman Brendan O'Hara MP said that if the UK Government 'could muster just a shred of conviction and courage they would have the power to act'. He went on: 'After witnessing another week of slaughter, the Labour Party could, and should, begin this new week by taking two concrete steps,' he said. 'They should start this new week by finally stopping all arms sales to Israel and finally recognising the state of Palestine. 'President Macron was crystal clear that he is preparing to join other European nations in recognising the state of Palestine and that he is pressing the UK to join this 'political momentum' towards a ceasefire and a permanent peace. 'Keir Starmer should stop the excuses and join him in recognising the state of Palestine without any more damaging delays. 'That would send the clearest of signals that we are prepared to protect and guarantee the right of the Palestinian people to their own homeland – and that all diplomatic levers will be used to prevent any plan that effectively proposes ethnic cleansing in Gaza. 'It is also blindingly obvious that anyone claiming to support a two-state solution must back immediate recognition of Palestine, otherwise their words ring hollow. 'If after this week Westminster stays sitting on its hands and fails to use the power it has to act, then they will be totally complicit in giving the (Benjamin) Netanyahu government impunity to commit week upon week of slaughter, even deadlier than the one Palestinians have just suffered.' The party pointed out that 144 members of the UN, including Ireland, Spain and Norway, have already moved to recognise Palestine. Foreign Secretary David Lammy said earlier this week that the UK Government remained 'completely committed' to recognition, but refused to set a time frame for it, saying it was a 'moving, live situation'. A FCDO spokesperson said: 'From day one we have taken decisive action – suspending relevant export licences, suspending trade negotiations, restarting UNRWA funding, sanctioning Israeli Ministers, providing aid to hundreds of thousands of civilians, and using our position on the UN Security Council to demand the end of this war and the full resumption of aid into Gaza. 'We continue working with international partners to end Palestinian suffering, free the hostages and secure lasting Middle East peace.'
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Anti-Semitism ‘normalised in middle-class Britain'
Anti-Semitism has been normalised in middle-class Britain, a Government-backed report has found. The review warned that Jewish people in the UK were suffering increasing prejudice 'in our professions, cultural life [and] public services' and felt they were 'tolerated rather than being respected'. The report, commissioned by the Board of Deputies of British Jews, the country's largest Jewish community organisation, found anti-Semitism to be pervasive in the NHS, at universities and in the arts. The inconsistent policing of hate crimes against Jews, including at pro-Palestine protests, was also highlighted. The review was co-authored by Lord Mann, the Government's anti-Semitism adviser, and Dame Penny Mordaunt, the former defence secretary. Writing in The Telegraph, they said they had been 'stunned into silence' by the evidence gathered during six months of research for the Commission on Anti-Semitism. They wrote: 'We heard about the noisy demonstrations and how intimidating people find the current environment, but as we dug deeper, what really scared us was the increasing normalisation of far more extreme, personalised and sometimes life-changing impact directed at individuals purely and simply because they are Jewish.' The pair added: 'We are two non-Jews from opposite sides of the political spectrum and we have both come to realise that if our Jewish community is facing discrimination, this is a failure of our society.' Among 10 recommendations made in their report, which will be published on Tuesday and considered by the Government, are recognising Judaism as an ethnicity, an overhaul of the policing of anti-Semitic crimes and the launch of an 'Anti-Semitism Training Qualification' for employers. After the Oct 7 attacks in 2023, anti-Semitic incidents hit record highs, according to the Community Security Trust, which monitors reports of anti-Jewish hate in Britain. The co-authors said that British Jews were often 'held responsible for the actions of the Israeli government', which are frequently the subject of pro-Palestine protests. The report also raised concerns that police forces had struggled to effectively tackle anti-Jewish hate, arguing 'improvements can be made to ensure that there is a consistent standard and understanding of anti-Semitism across all police forces throughout the country'. The war in Gaza following the Oct 7 attacks triggered mass protests that were branded 'hate marches' by Suella Braverman, the then home secretary, in October 2023. Police forces have repeatedly been accused of a 'two-tier' approach for allowing what critics have described as 'intimidating' pro-Palestine protests outside Jewish places of worship. Earlier this year, The Telegraph revealed that a Jewish counter-protester was arrested by the Metropolitan Police after he briefly held a sign satirising a Hezbollah terrorist leader at a pro-Palestine march. Turning to the health service, researchers found 'many Jewish employees within NHS organisations' felt that issues in their workplace were not being addressed and that it had been 'swept under the carpet'. 'From evidence that we heard, we can identify that there is a specific unaddressed issue of anti-Semitism within the NHS,' they wrote. Jewish doctors in the NHS have reported a surge in anti-Semitic abuse from colleagues since Oct 7, according to the General Medical Council (GMC), the independent body which regulates the UK medical register. Several NHS staff have been reported for anti-Semitic activities, from workplace abuse to social media posts celebrating Oct 7. In 2024, the NHS suspended a family GP who described the attacks as 'a welcome punch on the nose' but later reinstated him, citing insufficient evidence that he was unfit to practice. The education sector was also criticised in the report for allowing the spread of anti-Semitism on university campuses and in primary school classrooms. Writing in The Telegraph, the co-authors noted one campus where 'staff members who Jewish students trust with their health records [were] shouting for an intifada', an Arabic word which can be used to describe violent Palestinian uprisings against Israel. Anti-Semitism on campuses has surged since Oct 7, with the 2023-24 academic year seeing record reports of verbal abuse, threats and assaults against Jewish students and staff. At Leeds University, for example, a chaplain received death threats and rape threats against his wife after returning from his Israel Defense Force (IDF) reservist duties in Israel. In another instance, a Jewish student society was targeted by a bomb hoax threat. The report also found 'evidence that some faith primary schools inadvertently use anti-Semitic tropes when teaching subjects like Religious Education'. In other professions, the co-authors found examples of professional bodies and trade unions passing motions about Israel that alienated Jewish members. Last month, Jewish members of the British Medical Association, the doctors' union, told The Telegraph they felt unsafe because of motions related to the Middle East conflict, which they deemed anti-Semitic. Earlier this year, in April, a Jewish teacher was loudly heckled for challenging an anti-Israel motion at the National Education Union's annual conference in Bournemouth. Researchers also 'received evidence about where an individual believes that their professional body is actively discriminating against them, but where they require membership in order to be able to work'. In the arts, the report found 'substantial evidence of more hidden barriers being put in front of Jewish involvement' and examples of cultural institutions 'cancelling artists because of their heritage or ethnicity, or pressure from anti-Semitic organisations'. Lord Mann and Dame Penny said they were moved by 'a young Jewish female performer who told us that following October 7th, venues and promoters who the artist had worked with for years, no longer wanted to engage with her'. The report found there was 'almost nowhere' that British Jews can turn 'where anti-Semitism does not seem present in some form' as well as 'a failure to effectively respond by institutions across the United Kingdom'. The co-authors concluded that anti-Semitism was 'not understood as a form of racism' in Britain and recommended that Judaism be nationally recognised as an ethnicity, as well as a religion, so that anti-Jewish prejudice can be more effectively tackled. Other recommendations included the drafting of a national policy on dealing with anti-Semitism consistently, to be followed by all police forces. The report also asked the Government to come up with a plan within a year to make professional bodies and trade unions safe for Jewish members, and recommended an 'Anti-Semitism Training Qualification' to be introduced by employers. Angela Rayner, the Deputy Prime Minister, previously said she supported the commission and would consider the recommendations of its report. When it was announced in November, Ms Rayner said: 'We welcome the launch of the Board of Deputies' Commission on anti-Semitism and will look closely at its recommendations as part of our work to keep communities safe.' The Government has been criticised by Jewish groups within the Labour Party for 'performative' anti-Israel policies such as suspending trade talks and embargoing arms sales. Labour Against Anti-Semitism, a campaign group, said the policies 'added to a climate of intolerance and hate' toward British Jews. Sir Keir Starmer is under pressure from Labour's Left and allies such as France to go further and recognise a Palestinian state. Israel has said any such recognition would be a 'reward' to Hamas. While the Prime Minister is theoretically in favour of recognising a Palestinian state as part of a Middle East peace process, he is understood to be 'reticent' about signing up to the French plans. However, the mooted emergence of a new Left-wing, pro-Palestinian party under Jeremy Corbyn, the former Labour leader, could also increase pressure on Sir Keir to act. In recent weeks, the Government was forced to intervene in a row over anti-Semitism after chants at Glastonbury music festival calling for the death of Israeli soldiers were broadcast live by the BBC. Bob Vylan, a rap duo, led calls for 'death to the IDF' while performing at the festival. The Prime Minister described the chants as 'appalling hate speech' and said the BBC had questions to answer over why they were broadcast live. The broadcaster's head of music stepped back from day-to-day duties over the row after Lisa Nandy, the Culture Secretary, demanded more 'accountability' from the corporation's leadership. Lord Mann previously told The Telegraph that 'heads should roll' at the BBC after it aired a documentary featuring the nephew of a Hamas official as a narrator. An NHS spokesman said: 'It is completely unacceptable for anyone to experience racism, discrimination or prejudice in the health service, whether staff or patient, and the NHS takes any instance of anti-Semitism or discrimination extremely seriously. 'The NHS provides care and treatment for everyone regardless of race, faith, or background, and all NHS healthcare providers should have policies in place to address issues like this in the workplace.'
