Nigel Owens says Springboks should have been penalised for illegal scrum tactic
Image: Anne-Christine Poujoulat/AFP
The Springboks broke the law with their scrum tactic in the second Test against Italy and should have been penalised, said former referee Nigel Owens.
Rassie Erasmus and the Springboks created a stir with a number of contentious tactics in the second Test against the Italians in Gqeberha, which they won 45-0.
Right off the bat, the Boks manufactured a scrum off the kick-off when André Esterhuizen went ahead of kicker Manie Libbok, resulting in a scrum being awarded for having a player in front of the kicker.
Later in the match, the Boks came up with another tactic that saw Ruan Nortjé being lifted to secure a ball in the middle of the park.
Get your news on the go, click
here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
According to Owens, a penalty should have been given to Italy, while the lifting incident is open for interpretation.
'The key word is 'deliberate'. Normally, in this kind of situation, if a player is in front of the kick-off, it's deemed to be offside and a scrum is awarded. What we saw in this instance is that it looks deliberate. It's a ploy, an action to get a scrum.
'In this instance, if I was refereeing this game, that would have been a pretty straightforward, clear penalty because it's not the normal action of being slightly in front,' said the Welshman when talking to England great Ugo Monye on Whistle Watch on YouTube.
On Nortjé being lifted in the middle of the field, again, Owens felt it was a grey issue that was open for interpretation.
'A player being lifted in the air to catch the ball from a kick-off is perfectly legal. We see it every game and nothing's wrong with it at all. Within the laws, this is not an illegal action.
'Is it against the sportsmanship of the game or is it an unfair advantage? If a guy is in the air, the defenders cannot do anything to compete for that ball. You can't touch the player or bind around those who are supporting him. The opposition pretty much have to wait for him to come down, then they can do something.
'It's a very clever ploy. Some like it, some think it's not right, but it all comes down to whether you think it's fair.'
Owens went on to discuss Jasper Wiese's red card, which was shown to him after a supposed headbutt on an opponent.
While many commentators in South Africa have felt it was a headbutt and the red card was a harsh sanction, Owens felt it was appropriate given the coming together of heads. Wiese has since been suspended for four matches following a World Rugby disciplinary hearing and will be available for selection again on September 13 when the Boks play the All Blacks in Wellington.
IOL Sport
Get your news on the go, click
here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
6 minutes ago
- The South African
When will Springboks name Rugby Championship squad?
The Springboks have already used an extended squad so far this season, with Rassie Erasmus expanding the group to 46 players for the first three Tests of the year, but this will be trimmed down for the Rugby Championship. After this weekend's encounter, the Springbok players will be given a few days off before a reduced squad of 35 will be named for the start of the build up to the Rugby Championship. The first Rugby Championship clash for the Springboks takes place on 16 August, but some senior players may well be rested for the first two home games against Australia. So it's worth keeping in mind that there could be some surprise omissions in the reduced squad, although there should be a number of leading players who then return for the blockbuster away games against New Zealand. 'We are fairly happy,' Erasmus commented after the 45-0 victory over Italy on Saturday. 'The Barbarians game we didn't concede a lot of points in a tough rainy game there – we got a 50 there, we got 42 last week and 45 here, and only conceded 24 points against Italy and, overall, a lot of the guys got caps. 'So, hopefully after the Georgia game a lot of the guys will have had two caps, and we will have won all four matches, and we can pick a nice settled, balanced team for the Rugby Championship.' Whatever the case may be, the first Rugby Championship is likely to be named in the final week of July. SPRINGBOKS' REMAINING 2025 TEST SCHEDULE AS THE RUGBY CHAMPIONSHIP APPROACHES: 19 July: vs Georgia, Mbombela Stadium, Nelspruit. Kick off: 17:10. 16 August: vs Australia, Ellis Park, Johannesburg. Kick off: 17:10. 23 August: vs Australia, DHL Stadium, Cape Town. Kick off: 17:10. 6 September: vs New Zealand, Auckland. Kick off: 09:05. 13 September: vs New Zealand, Wellington. Kick off: 09:05. 27 September: vs Argentina, Kings Park, Durban. Kick off: 17:10. 4 October: vs Argentina, London. Kick off: 15:00. 8 November: vs France, Paris. Kick off: TBD. 15 November: vs Italy, Turin. Kick off: TBD. 22 November: vs Ireland, Dublin. Kick off: 19:40. 29 November: vs Wales, Cardiff. Kick off: 17:10. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 0211. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The Citizen
36 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Kwagga: No drop in breakdown intensity against Georgia
Loose forward Kwagga Smith said the Springboks had rectified mistakes in the breakdown battle against Italy but needed to maintain that standard. After a much-improved performance in the breakdown battle during the Springboks' second Test against Italy in Gqeberha on the weekend, loose forward Kwagga Smith said the South Africans need to maintain that standard as they head into their final match before the Rugby Championship. The Springboks take on Georgia in Mbombela on Saturday (kick-off 5.10pm), with the 11th-ranked nation losing both of the teams' previous two matches (2003 and 2021). The game follows South Africa's commanding 45–0 win against Italy at Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium despite having 14 men for an hour. The Springboks showed a turnaround in the breakdown battle, after Italy were far superior in that regard, winning turnovers or at least slowing down play, during their 42–24 defeat at Loftus the week before. Breakdown needed more prep 'I think the mindset against Italy at Loftus maybe wasn't up there as it should have been,' Smith said. 'After you get a beating in some departments, you go and rectify it. So obviously it was better the next weekend.' He said Georgians were a 'hard people' known for their strength, and would offer a similar challenge to the Italians. 'They grew up in a rural country and are strong people. They have a lot of passion. Everyone wants to measure themselves against the Springboks, so it will be a tough battle this weekend. 'They are going to be physical. They are one team that never steps back. It doesn't matter what the scoreboard is, those guys will keep fighting, keep on playing.' Georgian players have personal motivation against Boks He said the game has special significance for Georgian players who wish to impress on the international stage and earn contracts in France, for instance, where several top Georgians already play. 'They want to measure themselves against us, the Springboks because that might give them an opportunity to get a contract in France or wherever in the world. It's a huge opportunity for them to prove themselves against the best and that might open their career forward.' Smith said it was up to the South Africans to improve whatever they could ahead of the Rugby Championship, which kicks off against Australia at Ellis Park on 16 August. 'For us, it is to make sure we get better every game and it speaks for itself the game went better after the Pretoria–Italy game. For us playing this weekend, we have a responsibility to keep that standard up and keep getting better.'
SowetanLIVE
an hour ago
- SowetanLIVE
Wales locked out of Lions as Curry named to start first Test
Tom Curry was named at openside flanker in the British & Irish Lions team for the first Test against Australia on Saturday, ensuring the tourists would field a Test team without a Welshman for the first time since the late 19th century. Welsh hopes of a presence in the side had rested on poacher Jac Morgan but coach Andy Farrell preferred England's Curry in the starting side with Ben Earl and Ollie Chessum covering the loose forwards on the bench. Farrell has gone for a conventional number eight in Jack Conan at the back of the scrum with his Ireland teammate Tadhg Beirne completing the back row at blindside flanker.
