Minnesota's bill to ban transgender athletes fails
Debate on a bill to ban transgender athletes from Minnesota school sports started late Monday afternoon, and has now failed after not getting 68 votes to pass the bill.
GOP authors believe allowing it opens girls up to losing their spot on a team or even dangerous physical interactions, and it's just unfair.
DFL opponents say it's an unnecessary and cruel distraction that ignores established law and demonizes the small population of transgender people.
ST. PAUL, Minn. (FOX 9) - The Minnesota House spent Monday in the longest debate of the year over a GOP bill to block transgender athletes in girls' sports, which failed Monday evening.
What they're saying
The bill to ban transgender athletes from girls' sports in Minnesota failed in the Minnesota House. The House voted 67-66 in favor of the bill, but a 68-vote majority is needed to pass a bill in the House.
Speaker Emerita Melissa Hortman released the following statement:
"People of all ages deserve to be loved, accepted, and valued for who they are. At its core, this bill is about how we treat children, and it would allow children to be bullied by adults and other children for not meeting a particular definition of femininity. While Republicans push cruel, divisive bills like this, they ignore the real challenges Minnesotans are facing — like the rising costs of childcare, health care, and housing. Instead of solving problems, they're fueling division."
Author of the bill, Rep. Peggy Scott (R-Andover) released the following statement:
"There are fairness issues and there are safety issues involving girls' sports teams. When it comes to boys' and girls' athletics, how you identify shouldn't matter; how you were born should."
The celebrity case
It's a hot-button issue across the country and the vote drew a celebrity spokesperson to support the bill.
Riley Gaines took center stage in the debate before the debate.
A crowd at the Capitol heard from the former Kentucky swimmer who rose to fame after she tied for fifth place with transgender swimmer Lia Thomas.
A crowd also heard support for trans athletes from another 2022 college swimmer from here in Minnesota.
"I believe in preserving female sports teams," said Rep. Dawn Gillman, (R-Meeker).
For at least ten years, transgender kids in Minnesota have been allowed to participate in sports based on their gender identity.
Republicans want that to end, and they brought Gaines to the Capitol for a rally to boost their bill.
"Minnesotans and Americans alike reject this absurdity," said the former swimmer. "We embrace the America First agenda, and we reject this absurdity."
Challenging gender
The bill debated Monday on the House floor would have banned transgender girls from school sports.
If challenged, a female athlete would have to prove their gender. The House bill no longer describes how that would happen, leaving it up to the schools, but it originally matched a corresponding Senate bill requiring a doctor's note after an examination of the athlete's anatomy, hormone levels and chromosomes.
Authors told FOX 9 they're not aware of any transgender athletes competing now in Minnesota.
But they believe allowing it opens girls up to losing their spot on a team or even dangerous physical interactions, and it's just unfair.
Allowing access
Not all female athletes see it the same way.
"Athletics offers so many benefits, from physical to mental health," said Kara Cowell, another former NCAA championship swimmer. "To educational success and self-confidence. Trans women and girls deserve the same access to these benefits."
Transgender advocates point out that not even 10 of the 520,000 college athletes last year were transgender and none of them was a superstar.
They point to research showing hormone therapy seems to remove any physical advantages.
And they accuse Republicans of creating a distraction by making a boogeyman out of transgender athletes.
"This bill is not about protecting fairness in sports or upholding integrity," said transgender teacher and coach Maggie Dayvis. "Instead, it is a calculated effort to sow division, to amplify fear, and to distract from the larger issue of defunding education."
A similar Senate will was also rejected by the DFL majority on Monday.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
17 minutes ago
- Yahoo
FCC chair pleased with Skydance vow to make changes at CBS
By David Shepardson (Reuters) -The chair of the Federal Communications Commission said on Thursday he is pleased with commitments that Skydance has made to make serious changes at CBS under a proposed merger with Paramount, but said the agency has not made a decision on the tie-up. CBS parent Paramount needs approval from the FCC for an $8.4-billion merger with Skydance Media. FCC Chair Brendan Carr said after a commission meeting the agency continues to review the deal and praised commitments to end diversity programs. Skydance has agreed to have an ombudsman in place for at least two years to evaluate complaints about bias in CBS News' programming if the deal is approved. "I was very pleased to see Skydance put in a filing that says if this deal goes through they are committing to serious changes at CBS. I think that would be a good thing," Carr said. "They have committed to addressing bias issues. They've committed to embracing fact-based journalism." Paramount declined to comment. Carr cited polls that Americans' trust in national programs has fallen to historic lows. This month, Paramount agreed to pay $16 million to settle a lawsuit filed by U.S. President Donald Trump, claiming the CBS News program "60 Minutes" deceptively edited an interview with former Vice President Kamala Harris that the network broadcast in October. Paramount did not admit to any wrongdoing. The FCC has required other companies like T-Mobile and Verizon to end diversity, equity and inclusion programs before approving deals. In January, Trump issued sweeping executive orders to dismantle U.S. government DEI programs, and pressured the private sector to join the initiative. The FCC did not make a decision by the 180-day informal deadline in mid-May and Carr previously denied Trump's lawsuit was a factor. Trump and CBS formally agreed on Tuesday to the dismissal of his lawsuit, according to a court filing. Skydance and its investors plan to acquire National Amusements, which holds the family's controlling stake in Paramount. Skydance will subsequently be merged into Paramount, with its CEO David Ellison becoming Paramount's next chief executive. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Yahoo
17 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Obama, sedition and Trump's urgent need to distract
To any American with an extremely short memory or perhaps a desire only to see the world through Donald Trump's eyes, the recent memo from Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard and the call from President Trump to investigate former President Barack Obama over the memo's claims of 'treasonous conspiracy' over claims of Russian interference in the 2016 election must be alarming. Talk of 'overwhelming evidence' and a 'yearslong coup,' 'seditious conspiracy' and 'treason' sure sound pretty serious. Well, they do until you quickly review your notes and recognize that A, President Trump has an urgent need for distraction given his ties to Jeffrey Epstein and the administration's failure to — despite big promises to the conspiracy-hungry during the presidential campaign — release details of the investigation into the late American financier and sex offender. And B, this is a subject that has been investigated to death with no fewer than four official inquiries, including a 2020 U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee report (written while the GOP had Senate control) and the special report authored by Trump-appointed special counsel John Durham that came out in 2023. And what did they find? There was ample reason to worry about Russian interference in the 2016 race, and it was clear the Kremlin didn't want Democrat Hillary Clinton in the Oval Office. Was then-candidate Trump complicit in these efforts? Nope, not in a manner those various investigators could prove. But Russian interference? There was ample evidence of computer hacking, of digging through emails and of using intermediaries to undermine Clinton (remember WikiLeaks?). Or how about simply remembering Robert S. Mueller III? The special counsel indicted a dozen Russians, none of whom has ever stood trial because they could not be extradited. Even then-U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio (now Trump's U.S. secretary of state) observed that interference signing off on that 2020 report, which concluded 'the Russian government inappropriately meddled in our 2016 general election in many ways but then-Candidate Trump was not complicit.' Hopefully, most people aren't taking these claims of treason seriously. They serve only to diminish Trump and Gabbard. Think those criminal referrals Gabbard has sent to the U.S. Department of Justice will result in a successful prosecution? Even Las Vegas will surely refuse wagers on that long shot. Those who still harbor doubts can go peruse those various reports (and their thousands of pages of findings). The rest of us will just have to be content to recognize that the current president and his cronies lie like rugs when it serves their purpose. Peter Jensen is an editorial writer at The Baltimore Sun; he can be reached at pejensen@


New York Post
18 minutes ago
- New York Post
Trump to sign executive order forcing homeless off America's streets
WASHINGTON — President Trump will sign an executive order Thursday calling on states and cities to 'remove vagrant individuals' from the streets — and rehouse homeless people, drug addicts, and those suffering from mental problems in 'treatment centers.' The order redirects federal funding to finance 'treatment centers, outpatient treatment and other facilities,' per a readout of the order viewed by The Post. States and municipalities that already crackdown on open illicit drug use and urban camping, loitering or squatting, and tracking sex offenders, will be prioritized for grants. The order redirects federal funding to finance 'treatment centers, outpatient treatment and other facilities.' Stephen Yang 'President Trump is delivering on his commitment to Make America Safe Again and end homelessness across America,' White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said in a statement. 'By removing vagrant criminals from our streets and redirecting resources toward substance abuse programs, the Trump Administration will ensure that Americans feel safe in their own communities and that individuals suffering from addiction or mental health struggles are able to get the help they need.'