Why Pakistan's middle class backs terror while poor suffer from it
Team TOI Plus
TIMESOFINDIA.COM
Updated: May 18, 2025, 18:41 IST IST
A 2012 study, which has acquired new relevance after Pahalgam and Operation Sindoor, reveals that Pakistan's urban middle class — shielded from violence and ideologically invested — sustains extremist groups
For years, the dominant explanation for terrorism in Pakistan has rested on a simple idea: that poverty breeds radicalism. It is a narrative among global policy experts that has shaped the direction of billions of dollars in international aid and development programmes.
Now, with Pahalgam and India's Operation Sindoor reigniting the debate over cross-border militancy, a 2012 Princeton-led study has acquired fresh relevance, revealing that the true drivers of extremism may lie closer to comfort than crisis.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
41 minutes ago
- Hans India
Does it burn that BJP did what Cong couldn't in 60 years: Ashoka slams K'taka CM on Sigandur bridge row
Karnataka BJP on Monday slammed Chief Minister Siddaramaiah's decision to remain absent from the Sigandur Bridge inauguration event as 'pettiness'. The party further asked, "Does it burn that BJP achieved what Congress couldn't in 60 years?" The inauguration of the 2.12-kilometre-long Sigandur Bridge, built at a cost of Rs 473 crore, has run into controversy after Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah alleged that protocol was not followed and announced that no local Ministers or MLAs from the state government would attend the event. Speaking to reporters in Bengaluru on Monday, CM Siddaramaiah stated that it was the Centre that had initiated the conflict. Responding to the criticism, the Leader of the Opposition R. Ashoka stated on Monday that, "The people of the Sharavathi backwater region are celebrating today as a 60-year-old dream is finally coming true. They are decorating their homes with festoons and flowers, celebrating this joyous day like a festival." "But like a man who doesn't want the marriage yet goes looking for a stone in the wedding meal, you, as the Chief Minister of the state, chose not to join in the celebrations of this historic day. Instead, you stirred up unnecessary controversy. What can we even say about such pettiness?" Ashoka slammed. Ashoka further charged, "Is it making you jealous that what couldn't be achieved in 60 years of Congress rule has now been accomplished by the BJP-led Central government under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi?" "Or is it that the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, instructed you not to attend the bridge inauguration ceremony?" Ashoka asked. "When high command leaders call, you leave all state matters and rush to Delhi in a special flight just to save your chair. But you don't have the will to attend the Sigandur Bridge inauguration?" Ashoka questioned. Union Minister for Road Transport and Highways Nitin Gadkari is visiting Karnataka to dedicate the Sigandur bridge project to the people of the state. Construction work began on December 12, 2019. The bridge, a long-standing demand for over 60 years, is expected to benefit more than 40 villages. Previously, people and vehicles had to use a ferry to cross the Sharavathi River. The Chief Minister had written a letter to Union Minister Nitin Gadkari objecting to the timing of the inauguration and had requested that the event be postponed. Responding to a question on Monday about the inauguration, CM Siddaramaiah said he had spoken to Union Minister Gadkari over the phone and also written to him, requesting a change in schedule for the programme in Sagara taluk. Although Gadkari had agreed to reschedule the event, the programme was schedule for Monday under pressure from local BJP leaders, without informing him, CM Siddaramaiah stated.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
an hour ago
- First Post
How S Jaishankar's visit to China points to a continued thawing of ties
External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar is in China to attend the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting of the foreign ministers. He is on his first such visit to the neighbouring country since the Galvan Valley clash in 2020. The trip is yet another indication of the ties between the countries continuing to thaw. Let's take a closer look read more External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar is making his first trip to China since the Galwan Valley clash in 2020. Image/X/@DrSJaishankar External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar is in China. Jaishankar is in China to attend the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting of the foreign ministers. In the backdrop of Jaishankar's visit to China, let's take a closer look at how India-China ties are improving. A brief look at Jaishankar's visit First, let's take a brief look at Jaishankar's visit to China. The external affairs minister is in the city of Tianjin. He is making his first such visit to the neighbouring country since the Galvan Valley clash in 2020. India and China share a 3,800-kilometre border in the Himalayas. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Jaishankar's trip taken in concert with Rajnath's visit last month, indicates that the thaw between the two countries seems to be lasting Jaishankar met Chinese Vice President Han Zheng on Monday. Jaishankar during the meeting reiterated New Delhi's support for Beijing's presidency of the SCO. The SCO is a China-led multilateral group comprising nine permanent members including India, Pakistan, Russia and Iran. China is the current chair of the SCO. It is hosting the meetings of the grouping in that capacity. In the first leg of his China visit, S Jaishankar held talks with Chinese Vice President Han Zheng on Monday. At the meeting, Jaishankar expressed confidence that the ongoing discussions will maintain a positive trajectory when it comes to ties between the two nations. X / @DrSJaishankar 'Pleased to meet Vice President Han Zheng soon after my arrival in Beijing today, and conveyed India's support for China's SCO Presidency. Noted the improvement in our bilateral ties. And expressed confidence that discussions during my visit will maintain that positive trajectory,' Jaishankar wrote on X. 'The international situation, as we meet today, is very complex. As neighbouring nations and major economies, an open exchange of views and perspectives between India and China is very important. I look forward to such discussions during this visit,' Jaishankar said. The external affair ministers' meeting will be held tomorrow (July 15). Jaishankar is set to hold a bilateral meet with his counterpart Wang Yi before the summit. The two men previously met on the sidelines of the G20 Summit in Johannesburg, South Africa. They will hold wide-ranging talks on a number of issues including the Dalai Lama, rare earth materials, resuming flights between the two countries and the recent conflict between India and Pakistan. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD He and Wang will also lay the groundwork for Prime Minister Narendra Modi's likely China trip for the SCO summit. Wang may also visit India this month to hold a fresh round of talks with NSA Ajit Doval under the framework of Special Representatives (SR) dialogue on the boundary dispute. Jaishankar is set to hold several other bilateral meetings on the sidelines of the summit. Kailash Mansorvar resumes Jaishankar pointed to the resumption of the Kailash-Mansarovar Yatra as a positive development. The resumption of the Kailash Mansarovar Yatra is widely appreciated in India', Jaishankar said during the meeting. 'Continued normalisation of our ties can produce mutually beneficial outcomes', he added. The yatra was initially suspended during the Covid-19 pandemic. After the Galwan Valley clash caused the relationship between India and China to nosedive, the yatra remained suspended. The Kailash Mansarovar Yatra is resumed after a gap of five years. File Photo/ANI India and China had announced the resumption of the yatra to Mount Kailash and Mansarovar Lake in Tibet during Rajnath's visit last month. 'Expressed my happiness on restarting of the Kailash Mansarovar Yatra after a gap of nearly six years. It is incumbent on both the sides to maintain this positive momentum and avoid adding new complexities in the bilateral relationship,' Rajnath wrote on X after the announcement. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Rajnath visit Jaishankar's visit comes weeks after Rajnath visited Qingdao in June. The defence minister did so for an SCO meet of defence ministers. That was the first such visit by a senior Indian official to China since 2020 and the first visit by an Indian defence minister to China in over a decade. Rajnath during his trip met Chinese counterpart Admiral Dong Jun and presented him a four-pronged approach for better ties. This included following the 2024 Disengagement Agreement to the letter, continuing efforts at de-escalation, accelerating efforts to demarcate and delimit and bridging trust deficit. 'Held talks with Admiral Don Jun, the Defence Minister of China, on the sidelines of SCO Defence Ministers' Meeting in Qingdao. We had a constructive and forward looking exchange of views on issues pertaining to bilateral relations,' Rajnath wrote on social media. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh held bilateral talks with Chinese counterpart Dong Jun on the sidelines of the SCO Summit. X - @rajnathsingh Rajnath had also presented Dong with a Madhubani painting from Bihar. The painting, which comes from the Mithila region, is known for its line drawings filled in with bright colours and contrasts or patterns. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Such paintings are popular because of their tribal motifs and use of bright earthy colours. However, Rajnath had refused to sign the SCO statement as there was no mention of the Pahalgam terror attack. Border de-escalation Jaishankar is also likely to speak to Wang about de-escalation at the border. Rajnath during his trip had called for a 'structured roadmap of permanent engagement and de-escalation' as well as a 'permanent solution of border demarcation'. India and China previously met at a high-level to work on the disengagement process at Demchok and Depsang Plains in October 2024. Since the 2020 Galwan crisis, India has made incremental security improvements through diplomatic agreements and infrastructure development, yet significant challenges remain. Representational image: PTI/file photo Jaishankar also noted that the relationship between India and China has been on a firmer footing since the meeting between Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping in October. The two leaders had met on the sidelines of the summit in Kazan. The decision to resume talks under the Special Representatives (SR) mechanism was taken during this meeting. What do experts say? They say India thinks this is the right time to reach out to China given recent events in Washington. 'India thought it would be a very close strategic ally [of the US] but they were not getting the support they were expecting from Washington,' professor Christopher Clary of University of Albany in New York told BBC. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'In recent years, China has also significantly increased its influence in other multilateral organisations like the SCO and the Brics grouping of emerging economies,' Phunchok Stobdan, a former senior Indian diplomat, added. India sees this as the pragmatic approach, he added. 'At the same time, it does not want to be seen yielding too much to the Chinese demands for domestic reasons,' he adds. However, all isn't smooth sailing just yet. Jaishankar's visit also comes in the backdrop of China taking offence over some in India's remarks on the Dalai Lama, who celebrated his 90th birthday last week. 'They should be fully cognizant of the sensitivity of issues related to Xizang, and that the reincarnation and succession of the Dalai Lama is inherently an internal affair of China, brooking no interference of any external forces,' Yu said_._ With inputs from agencies
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Russia-Ukraine tensions: US Envoy in Kyiv for high-level talks; hours after Trump's clears defence upgrade
Keith Kellogg's visit to Kyiv (Image: AP) In a significant diplomatic move, US special representative Keith Kellogg arrived in Kyiv on Monday for key defence talks, shortly after president Donald Trump announced fresh supplies of Patriot air defence systems to Ukraine. According to the reports of AFP, The visit comes at a pivotal stage, with Russia intensifying aerial attacks on Ukraine—currently in its fourth year of war—firing swarms of drones almost daily. Earlier this month, Washington had signalled a pause in certain arms deliveries to Kyiv. Trump has since reversed course, taking a firm stand against Russian president Vladimir Putin over escalating attacks and stalled US-led peace efforts. 'We welcome US Special Representative Keith Kellogg to Ukraine,' wrote Andriy Yermak, chief of staff to President Volodymyr Zelensky, on Telegram. 'Peace through strength is the principle of US President Donald Trump, and we support this approach.' Trump, speaking on Sunday, said 'We will send them Patriots, which they desperately need.' But, he clarified that the US would not pay for them. Kellogg's visit coincides with President Trump's scheduled meeting with Nato Secretary General Mark Rutte in Washington later Monday, in what is expected to be a pivotal discussion on the alliance's future support to Ukraine.
