Israel's actions offend us more than Bob Vylan
During last year's riots, people were actually attacking and attempting to burn alive asylum seekers in hotels. No one is in a position to attack the Israel Defense Forces, who are the ones allegedly committing war crimes – eg burning and blasting people to death in cafes populated by students on the shores of the Mediterranean – and a military force that our own government is still giving arms and intelligence assistance to.
But I do take her point about how the criminalisation of these incidents sets 50% of the population against the other 50% – and I've probably just proved her point.Desmond HewittMarlborough, Wiltshire
Marina Hyde is right. If this is still supposed to be a liberal democracy we must be very reluctant to lock people up for what they say, however hateful and offensive we find it. It is tragic that progressives have conceded the cause of free speech to their reactionary rivals, whose insincerity is breathtaking.
Jonathan Allum
Amersham, Buckinghamshire
Ephraim Mirvis, the UK's chief rabbi, said Bob Vylan's appearance at Glastonbury was a 'national shame' (Allies of BBC chief Tim Davie fear latest controversy may damage his leadership, 1 July). I think that the Israeli government's treatment of the people of Gaza is a national shame for Israel. To echo Owen Jones (1 July), all the people getting aerated over Bob Vylan and not over the senseless, barbaric killing of civilians in Gaza have become detached from reality. Let's call it what it is – genocide. My mother, a Holocaust survivor, would be turning in her grave.Monica GripaiosHovingham, North Yorkshire
There is much ado about 'appalling hate speech', as Keir Starmer put it. What troubles me more is the appalling hate silence.Bob SimpsonDurham
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
40 minutes ago
- The Sun
Judges grant two out of three people taxpayer-funded benefits after their claims are refused by the Government
JUDGES grant two out of three people taxpayer-funded benefits after their claims are refused by the Government, The Sun on Sunday can reveal. In astonishing figures seen by this paper, 69 per cent of cases win the award on appeal after taking their case to a tribunal panel. Last night a Government source said: 'This is a staggering success rate because in many of the cases the judges see the same evidence the original Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) officer saw when they refused the application. 'It clearly shows that the whole system is becoming a joke.' More than one half of all applicants applying for state benefits are successful. Out of 721,100 Personal Independence Payments (PIP) claims processed during the period of 2023/24, 332,800 were declined - making the rejection rate 46 per cent. Claimants are able to appeal in two stages. One in five people win an award by simply asking the DWP to change its mind by way of a 'mandatory reconsideration' of their application. If this fails they are then allowed to appeal to a tribunal where two out of three people are successful at overturning the DWP's decision. The tribunals are headed up by lawyers and consist usually of a legally qualified judge who chairs the panel, a medical member and a disability member who has experience with related issues. The latest full financial year data published by the DWP shows that in 2023/24 there were 46,803 PIP appeals cleared at tribunal hearings. Of these, 32,222 - 69 per cent - were decided in favour of the applicant. Moment Starmer TRIPS as he leaves Downing Street amid welfare fiasco In 2007 Sir Ernest Ryder, former senior president of tribunals, said that the quality of evidence provided by the DWP is so poor it would be 'wholly inadmissible' in any other court. In an extraordinary outburst he called the department 'incompetent'. And said he and his fellow judges were so incensed by the volume of cases where there was 'no justifiable defence to the appeal' that they were considering sending them back – or charging the DWP for the cases it loses. It comes after Sir Keir Starmer's attempts to win over welfare bill rebels fell flat this week after Labour MPs opposed any attempt to bring it under control. Under the Government's original proposals, daily living assessments were to be tightened for millions with physical or mental health conditions who claim PIP. But ministers were forced to dilute the proposals - applying stricter PIP eligibility rules only to new claimants rather than those receiving the benefit - after 126 Labour MPs threatened to vote them down. Originally, the measures were due to save £4.8billion, then that figure dwindled to £2.5billion. But now any changes will affect only new claimants and only kick in after welfare minister Sir Stephen Timms has concluded a review with disability groups. Sir Keir had promised to stand firm over PIP changes, but caved in after days of protests. Rebel ringleader Rachael Maskell - whose bid to reject the entire package was defeated by 328 votes to 149 - said: "The whole bill is now unravelling and is a complete farce." Jon Sparkes, chief executive of learning disability charity Mencap, insisted: "Disabled people should not have to pay to fix black holes in the public finances." Proposals to cut the health element of Universal Credit by almost 50 per cent for most new claimants from April next year remain in place. Plans for an above inflation increase in the benefit's standard allowance also stand. 1
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Boy, 17, planned Southport-style knife-attack at dance school after praising Axel Rudakubana and suggested targeting Oasis comeback concert
A teenager has appeared in court after police were alerted that he was planning a Southport-style knife attack on a dance school near his home. The 17-year-old, who cannot be named because of his age, had talked of emulating Axel Rudakubana, who killed three girls aged six, seven and nine, during a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in July last year. The boy, who was living with his parents in a village near Cwmbran in South Wales, researched how to obtain large knives and, in a chat with a friend on April 19, sent an image of a large knife for sale online, saying: 'Would this work?' Police also found a note on his phone on April 28 headed 'places to attack'. It included images of a dance school near his home, along with directions on how to walk there. Location data suggested he had been close to the school just a few days earlier. The teenager had also researched other potential targets, including his own school, and told others on Snapchat of his plan to attack the first Oasis reunion concert in Cardiff. An earlier hearing was told the youth had participated in discussions on the social media app in which he praised Rudakubana. In one chat he said he had tried to make ricin poison – the same substance manufactured by the Southport killer – although he later told police this was not true. One of those he was talking to on Snapchat reported him to police. Following concerns by his family, the teenager met a counsellor on June 2 and revealed he planned to commit a 'Rudakubana-style attack', leading to a second report to police. At around 10.30am the same day, he transferred an al-Qaeda manual between phones. During police interviews, he admitted he had thoughts of launching attacks on a regular basis but said he did not intend to carry them through. The teenager appeared at Westminster Magistrates' Court on June 21, where he indicated a guilty plea to a single charge of possessing a document useful for terrorism. Sentencing was adjourned to a later date.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Kneecap vow to beat government in court ‘for second time' amid band member's terror charge
Next month will see 'the second time Kneecap have beat the British Government in court', the Irish rap trio said at their largest gig to date. The 45,000-strong crowd in Finsbury Park, London watched them walk on in front of a screen that said ' Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people'. They were supporting Irish band Fontaines DC, whose front man Grian Chatten joined to perform their collaboration Better Way To Live. People echoed the Belfast group's chants when they repeated the 'f*** Keir Starmer' and 'you're just a s*** Jeremy Corbyn' comments made at Glastonbury the previous weekend. Liam Og O hAnnaidh, who performs as Mo Chara, appeared at Westminster Magistrates' Court earlier this month charged with a terror offence and will return next month. Fellow member Naoise O Caireallain, who uses the stage name Moglai Bap, said 'if anyone's free on the 20th of August, you wanna go to the court and support Mo Chara' before shouting 'free Mo Chara, free, free Mo Chara'. Wearing a keffiyeh, O hAnnaidh responded: 'I appreciate it, the 20th of August is going to be the second time Kneecap have beat the British Government in court – in their own court, on their own terms, and we're going to beat them for the second time. 'I tell you what, there is nothing like embarrassing the British Government.' Last year Kneecap won a discrimination challenge over a decision by former business secretary Kemi Badenoch to refuse them a £14,250 funding award. The UK Government conceded it was 'unlawful' after the band launched legal action claiming the decision to refuse the grant discriminated against them on grounds of nationality and political opinion. It was agreed that the £14,250 sum would be paid by the Government to the group. During the performance the group intermittently broke off the mosh pits and raucous crowd by addressing the war in Gaza, which is a recurring theme of their shows. O hAnnaidh said: 'It's usually around this point of the gig that we decide to talk about what's happening in Palestine. 'I understand that it's almost inhumane that I'm thinking of new things to say on stage during a genocide, for sound bites. 'It's beyond words now, like, we always used to say obviously they're being bombed from the skies with nowhere to go, but it's beyond that now. 'They've been being starved for a few months on end, and not only that, the areas that they have set up, to collect aid and food, have turned into killing fields and they're killing hundreds a day trying to collect food.' He continued: 'It's beyond words, but again, we played in Plymouth last night to 750 people and we did the same thing, so it doesn't matter how big or small our audience is, Kneecap will always use the platform for talking about this.' O Caireallain had said earlier in the show: 'They can try and silence us, they can try and stop us, but we're not going to stop talking about Palestine – as long as there's a genocide happening in Palestine we're going to keep talking about it and yous are going to keep talking about it, and they can't stop us.' The UN human rights office has recorded 613 killings near humanitarian convoys and at aid distribution points in Gaza run by an Israeli-backed American organisation since it began operations in late May. On Friday its spokeswoman Ravina Shamdasani said the rights office was not able to attribute responsibility for the killings, but 'it is clear that the Israeli military has shelled and shot at Palestinians trying to reach the distribution points' operated by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). The GHF has denied any serious injuries or deaths on its sites and says shootings outside their immediate vicinity are under the purview of Israel's military. The Israeli military has said previously it fires warning shots to control crowds or at Palestinians who approach its troops.
