Supreme Court ruling has ‘changed landscape' of Peggie tribunal
The nurse, who has worked at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy for 30 years, was suspended by NHS Fife after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton.
She took the health board and Dr Upton to an employment tribunal, lodging a complaint of sexual harassment or harassment related to a protected belief under Section 26 of the Equality Act 2010.
The visit to Holyrood also came shortly after a letter from Sex Matters to the Scottish Government threatening legal action if they did not implement April's Supreme Court judgement on biological sex in equalities law.
The ruling stated said the words 'woman' and 'sex' in the Equality Act 2010 refer to a biological woman and biological sex, which has implications for access to single-sex spaces.
Asked how the judgment had affected the ongoing tribunal, Ms Forstater said: 'I think it's really changed the landscape. You can't ignore it.
'But in practical terms, it was only about people with Gender Recognition Certificates (GRCs), and the doctor in this case didn't have a GRC.
'So, what NHS Fife was doing was unlawful before the Supreme Court judgment (and) it's definitely unlawful now. And I think everyone can see that.'
She said of Wednesday's meetings that it had been 'important' for politicians to hear what Ms Peggie had been through as as result of 'bad policies that NHS Fife, NHS Scotland and the Scottish Government (are) still sticking with'.
She went on: 'All the politicians we met really understand the human impact of this on women.
'That Sandie's rights at work were abused because of bad policies, bad decisions, right from the top.
'And what they heard was the real human impact on her.'
She added that there was 'really no excuse' for delaying the implementation of the Supreme Court judgment.
'The law is clear from the moment that the Supreme Court gave their judgment, the Scottish Government, all public bodies, all private employers, were obliged to act,' she said.
Ms Peggie's solicitor Margaret Gribbon also took part in the visit.
Afterwards she said: 'Politicians needed to hear directly from Sandie to understand how the sheer depth of the discrimination and harassment she and women like her have endured in workplaces – in her case, as a nurse with 30 years' unblemished service, simply because she objected to having to undress in front of a man.
'We were grateful for the politicians' time and welcomed the opportunity to share insights into how misguided actions by public bodies such as NHS Fife have devastating real-life consequences and come at great expense to the Scottish taxpayer.
'We had productive meetings, and the door is always open for any politicians who were unable to meet Sandie today.'
Tribunal hearings took place in February and it will resume in July.
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay was one of the politicians that Sandie Peggie met during her visit.
Commenting afterwards, he said: 'It was a privilege to meet Sandie Peggie and to hear a first-hand account of her appalling ordeal.
'It is outrageous that a dedicated NHS nurse's career has been destroyed and her life consumed by a suffocating legal process simply because she stood up for women's rights.
'Sandie has paid a massive price for her brave and principled stand against the SNP Government's promotion of gender politics which now infects Scotland's entire public sector.
'NHS Fife should stop squandering vast sums of taxpayers' cash on this nonsense and every state agency in Scotland must now respect the law and women's rights.'
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government has been clear that we accept the Supreme Court judgment.
'We are reviewing policies, guidance and legislation potentially impacted by the judgment.
'This will prepare us to take all necessary steps when the regulator of the Equality Act 2010, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, publishes its revised Statutory Code of Practice and associated guidance for services, public functions and associations.
'The EHRC is currently consulting on this revised Code of Practice.
'The Scottish Government's approach is aligned with that of the UK Government and Welsh Government in awaiting the EHRC's revised Statutory Code of Practice.
'We will respond to the letter in due course.'
The spokesperson added that it would be inappropriate to comment on Ms Peggie's case while judicial proceedings in an employment tribunal are ongoing.
NHS Fife has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Scottish Government warned over single-sex toilet policy
In a formal legal letter sent on Wednesday, the organisation said ministers must urgently rewrite internal guidance on single-sex facilities to bring it into line with a recent Supreme Court judgment on biological sex. READ MORE The warning centres on the Scottish Government estate — made up of 66 sites and 1,016 toilet facilities — where existing policy allows staff to use facilities based on self-identified gender rather than biological sex. Around 18% of the facilities are gender-neutral single-user 'superloos', while the rest are designated as either male or female. There are also numerous smaller sites — including fisheries and field-monitoring offices — where facilities may be shared or gender-neutral. In April, the UK's highest court ruled unanimously that a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) does not alter a person's sex for the purposes of the Equality Act. The judgment clarified that the terms 'man' and 'woman' in the legislation refer to biological sex, not acquired gender. That ruling meant every organisation in the country needed to review their equality policies. The Supreme Court ruled that sex in the Equality Act means biological sexWhile First Minister John Swinney initially welcomed the 'clarity' provided by the ruling, the Scottish Government has said it is waiting for further guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission before issuing new advice to Scotland's public sector — including prisons, schools and the NHS. However, earlier this week, Dr Lesley Sawers, Deputy Chair and Scotland Commissioner for the EHRC, told The Herald that Scottish ministers had 'a responsibility to ensure their adherence to the Public Sector Equality Duty' — the legal requirement for public authorities in Scotland to consider protected characteristics, including biological sex, when carrying out their functions. In response, a spokesperson said work was 'proceeding at pace to implement the ruling across Government'. The Scottish Government's trans inclusion policy, signed off in January, states that 'staff should choose to use the facilities they feel most comfortable with' and that a GRC is not required to access single-sex spaces. In a letter to John Somers, Director of Equality, Inclusion and Human Rights, Maya Forstater, Chief Executive of Sex Matters, said the policy was 'clearly unlawful'. She added: 'The problem is not lack of infrastructure, but that the Scottish Government continues to operate an unlawful policy. 'As far as we can see, there is nothing to stop the Scottish Government immediately bringing the policy on toilets into line with the law, by making a statement that all facilities designated as male or female within the Scottish Government estate are to be interpreted as meaning biological sex, and that gender-neutral options are widely available. This would be in line with the Supreme Court judgment and the action taken by the Scottish Parliament. 'It is clearly a reasonably practical step in order to address the risk of individuals using opposite-sex toilets and other facilities. 'Please confirm, therefore, that you will take this step within seven days of the date of this letter. 'To the extent that the Scottish Government does not immediately stop the unlawful practices set out in this letter we may decide to commence proceedings without further warning.' The Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 require separate changing and toilet facilities for men and women 'where necessary for reasons of propriety'. Failure to provide such facilities, or to protect staff from discomfort or distress in those spaces, may also amount to unlawful harassment under the Equality Act. The Scottish Government has been approached for comment.
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Minister ‘worried' about rise in crime reports near consumption room
Asked if she is concerned about some residents reporting a rise in crime and discarded needles since its opening, she told the PA news agency: 'Of course it worries us. 'The safe consumption drug facility was sited here because it was already an area where these challenges occurred. 'So there was lots of street usage and lots of littering challenges. 'In time, I would expect that the challenges faced by the community will reduce as the confidence in this facility increases.' Asked if she accepts locals who believe crime and needle sightings have gone up, she added: 'I'm not sure the statistics bear that out. 'I think it's really important that we're not cloth-eared to the concerns that the local community are raising. 'It is causing them concern. They think there has been an increase in crime, and they think there has been an increase in littering. 'We need to pay attention to that, and we need to reassure them on that front. Whether that is actually what has happened, or whether the increased focus is what is making people worried about that, I'm not sure.' Maree Todd (Image: PA) She added it is 'important' that 'appropriate treatment' is not 'stigmatised'. By the end of June, 348 people had registered with The Thistle, with staff overseeing 3,008 injections in six months. Ms Todd said it is 'very difficult' to say whether the facility has been a success – but she believes it will be. She said: 'We do hear first-hand, anecdotally, from the staff working here about some of the incidents that they are facing. 'For example, a few months ago there was a cluster of contaminated drugs being used in Scotland, which almost immediately resulted in very severe overdose and threat to life, and that was able to be reversed here. 'Not only that, they could identify that there was contamination in the drug supply in Scotland, feed that back into our radar systems in Scotland and make sure the message got out all over Scotland. 'In other parts of Scotland where those drugs were being used, death did occur. Here in this facility, death was avoided. 'That's a really powerful indicator that actually this can save lives, and that's really important for us in Scotland.' Glasgow's Safe Drug Consumption Facility (Image: Newsquest) Asked about her first month in the job since taking over from the late SNP minister Christina McKelvie, she said: 'It's quite a daunting task but it's one I feel really confident I can make a difference in.' While Scotland has the worst drug deaths rate in Europe, the minister said she is 'confident' she can make a difference, and she added the Scottish Government has been 'creative' in its response to the issue. Helen Clark, prime minister of New Zealand from 1999 to 2008 and one of the commissioners at the Global Commission on Drug Policy, toured the site with Ms Todd. Ms Clark said while the facility will have to be 'studied closely', it has already shown positive signs of success. She said: 'The fact that in the five months of operating, they've recorded 39 medical emergencies tells you they've avoided 39 deaths. If people had had those emergencies happen with the drugs they consumed out there, they'd be dead. 'That's 39 lives saved. It's hard to put a value on that. It's incalculable.' She added: 'You have to meet people where they are, and if where they are is on a street corner in central Glasgow, unsafely injecting or inhaling a substance which potentially could kill them, it's better they're here. 'So again, it's about humanity. It's about not marginalising people who make choices which the vast majority don't make, but we're human beings. 'People make choices. They may be very risky. The key thing is to keep them alive.' Scottish Conservative shadow minister for drugs Annie Wells MSP said: 'This is an astonishing display of arrogance from Maree Todd. 'In the same breath, she's claiming she isn't cloth eared to the concerns of local residents whilst simultaneously dismissing them out of hand. 'Her claim, too, that this facility has saved 39 lives is also debatable, given the latest drugs deaths statistics showed the number was up – a rise since The Thistle opened. 'While we must look at all ways to treat those who need support, arrogant SNP ministers can ill-afford to pin all their hopes on state-sponsored drug taking, especially when locals are bearing the brunt.'
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
'Further blow' over new Ayr National Treatment Centre
The plans were put on hold in February last year due to funding problems. The future of The National Treatment Centre at Carrick Glen Hospital, Ayr, won't be known until December. The plans were put on hold in February last year due to funding problems. However, the Scottish Government is now saying there won't be any update on its future until the end of the year. Ayrshire Live previously told how NHS Ayrshire & Arran were forced to 'pause' any new capital projects, including Carrick Glen, from the Scottish Government because of budget constraints. In April 2022, £1.8m of public money was used to purchase Carrick Glen Hospital in order to take it out of the private sector. At the time the overall plan was to build 10 National Treatment Centres across the country and thus reduce waiting times. It was supposedly part of £400m investment in 10 centres across the country from the Scottish Government. They were touted to play a 'pivotal role' in reducing waiting times. Carrick Glen was due to be operational in 2025 and help reduce waiting times in orthopaedics. However, with no fresh finance going towards its completion, the Carrick Glen Hospital plan, which passed all planning hurdles in the summer of 2023, remains in a state of paralysis. And news of this fresh delay has been greeted with dismay. South Scotland Labour List MSP, Colin Smyth, said: 'This is a further blow to plans for a treatment centre in Ayr. 'New National Treatment Centres were at the heart of the SNP's NHS Recovery Plan and these delays spell disaster for waiting lists in the south of Scotland.' Mr Smyth continued: 'This will be very worrying news for patients in south Scotland who are languishing on waiting lists, and show just what a serious situation our NHS is facing. 'Hospitals in Ayrshire, and across the whole of south Scotland, are under huge amounts of pressure and every month we see yet more record high waiting lists. 'Our amazing NHS staff are doing all they can, but they can't work miracles and need the improved facilities they were promised.' The Scottish Government did say they were spending more than £1bn on NHS capital investment this year. A spokesperson added: 'As part of our own Scottish Spending Review, we are undertaking a full review of our capital spending to prioritise the available funding towards projects that drive progress against our priorities. 'We will provide clarity over which projects and programmes will receive funding in the medium term when we publish our new infrastructure pipeline, alongside the 2026-27 Budget and Scottish Spending Review. 'The publication of the new pipeline will put our capital budget back on a sustainable trajectory.'
