Councillors vote to cut more than 160 planned homes in south county Dublin
This includes a new residential community of new homes, parks, neighbourhood centres and the potential extension of the Luas to the area.
However, during the six-hour meeting, two motions raised by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael councillors were agreed on which cut the overall number of homes planned from 2,515 units to 2,350.
Fianna Fáil Councillor Justin Moylan raised the motion to reduce residential density from 60 dwellings per hectare (dph) to 'ensure economic viability'.
He said the higher density of homes would mean people not having self-contained or 'own door' houses.
'We've a finance model that doesn't satisfy market demands. It results in built-to-rent developments that nobody can buy,' he said.
'We're in a situation where builders don't build because financiers don't finance, and homeowners don't get anywhere to live in.
'This motion addresses that dilemma. Builders are fearful of taking on compact developments due to increased economic risk,' he added.
Fine Gael councillor Barry Saul agreed that the current LAP would be non-viable for developers.
'This is a more realistic, nuanced plan. These motions are about stimulating own door house building in our community,' he said.
'It will help the old Connaught area and we can prioritise delivery if we reduce the density.'
Green Party Councillor Tom Kivlehan, who did not support the motions, said Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil councillors were ignoring their own party guidelines around housing policy.
'It's giving two fingers to your own parties, ignoring your own government's guidelines as to what should be put beside high volume public transport,' he said.
'You're absolutely ignoring your own policies and reducing the number of houses we're going to build. We're not a county that's huge on the amount of land available, we have to use it efficiently.'
Independent councillor Hugh Lewis, who also voted against the motions, added: 'Why are we taking a developer-led approach because the plan is not 'economically viable' for them?
'That's not how we plan anything. Why are we taking breadcrumbs being thrown by developers.
'If we need own-door houses, the state should intervene and build those houses. There's no rationale to support this motion to support developers over people.'
Green Party councillor Lauren Tuite described the motions as 'political doublespeak at its worst – talking crisis while voting for less housing'.
'Housing is the single greatest challenge facing our country – yet councillors from government parties supposedly committed to increasing housing supply, voted to cut the number of homes in this LAP.
'Their reasoning – to increase the viability for developers to build – doesn't hold water. With fewer properties to bring to market, developers will have slim margins to work with, and buyers will be lumped with higher prices.
'The decision to decouple the delivery of the plan's housing from necessary neighbourhood infrastructure is also difficult to understand,' she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
5 hours ago
- The Journal
Dublin city councillors set to increase property tax for first time
DUBLIN CITY COUNCILLORS are set to vote next week to stop applying a 15% discount on property tax for the first time in more than 10 years. The change, for 2026, comes at the same time that the government is also applying increases to property tax to reflect the significant rise in house prices, although tax bands have been tweaked to moderate the impact. It's understood councillors' decision will cost less than €65 per year for homeowners whose houses are worth up to €525,000, with exact costs on a sliding scale based on the value of the property. For a €450,000 house, for example, the annual charge will be €428 in total. For the owners of the capital's most expensive houses, councillors' decision will cost more, with homes worth between €1m and €2m likely to pay €150-460 more than they would have with the discount. A house worth €1.2m must pay €1,094 in property tax in total each year from 2026 onwards. Property tax was introduced in 2013 at the behest of the Troika , with a view to broadening the tax base and funding local authorities without taxing employment. Dublin City Council management has long argued that the vast majority of Dublin homeowners would not be hit with substantial additional charges if councillors agreed to reduce the discount applied, while the city would benefit. The council's ruling group, comprising Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, Labour and the Green Party, agreed after last year's local elections to apply the baseline rate with no discount this year for the first time. The decision, which will be taken at a meeting on 18 July, is expected to bring in more than €15m in extra funding for the city. It's understood councillors are considering targeting the additional revenue at improving the council's housing stock, as well as improvements to footpaths, although no final decisions have been taken yet. Advertisement Labour and the Green Party, which pushed for the discount to be scrapped, argue that property tax is progressive and will provide crucial funding for improving the city. Councillors Feljin Jose of the Green Party and Darragh Moriarty of Labour characterised property tax as the closest thing Ireland has to a wealth tax, given most of the country's wealth is held in property. 'A lot of our [council] housing stock is very bad, and we need to maintain and repair and urgently increase the energy efficiency of those buildings,' said Jose of the Green Party. Darragh Moriarty of Labour said: 'In the vast majority of instances, these are very modest property taxes, by European comparisons. The 15% will be modest as well.' He noted that the decision would mean an extra €60m could be invested in improving the city over the lifetime of the council. Councillor Deirdre Heney of Fianna Fáil said she hoped additional funding would be allocated to footpath repairs and tree maintenance, issues that are raised with her frequently by residents, as well as to building more playgrounds. Property tax for 2026 is owed on 1 November. The government changed property tax bands earlier this year to moderate the increase in the amount of tax payable as a result of increasing house prices. A possible left-leaning ruling coalition on Dublin City council last year including Sinn Féin fell apart over the question of property tax . Sinn Féin wanted to continue to apply the 15% property tax discount. Separately, the government said last week that this year it will allow Dublin city, which takes in by far the most property tax of any council, to keep an additional €19m of the revenue it raises this year. The government wants this extra funding spent on implementing the recommendations of its Dublin city taskforce. Each year, a proportion of council tax from larger local authorities is redistributed to those with a lower property tax base. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Fianna Fáil MEPs still to pick a side ahead of no-confidence motion in European Commission president
Fianna Fáil MEPs have come under pressure for suggesting they might support a motion of no-confidence in European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen . The no-confidence vote was tabled by a far-right Romanian MEP and 74 others, predominantly from right-wing populist and nationalist parties. On Thursday, Members of the European Parliament will vote on the proposed motion of no-confidence in Ms von der Leyen, the head of the EU 's executive arm that proposes laws. The effort is widely expected to fall far short of the required two-thirds majority needed to censure the commission. If the motion was successful, it would likely force Ms von der Leyen and her team of EU commissioners, including former Fianna Fáil minister Michael McGrath , to resign. READ MORE Fianna Fáil's four MEPs, Barry Andrews, Billy Kelleher, Cynthia Ní Mhurchú and Barry Cowen, have yet to declare what way they will vote. Fianna Fáil have been weighing up the possibility of supporting the motion or abstaining in the vote. The no-confidence vote centres on the 'Pfizergate' controversy, where the commission faced criticism for refusing to release text messages exchanged between Ms von der Leyen and the chief executive of Pfizer, during negotiations to secure supplies of Covid-19 vaccines at the height of the pandemic. Copies of the texts had been sought in access-to-information requests made by the New York Times, which later took the commission to court for blocking the release of the texts. Speaking in the European Parliament on Monday, Ms von der Leyen said the motion was supported by extreme political movements, 'from anti-vaxxers to Putin apologists'. Defending her role at the top of the EU executive during the pandemic, Ms von der Leyen said it was 'no secret' that she was in contact with senior figures in companies producing Covid-19 vaccines. 'Every single contract negotiated was examined in detail in the capitals before being signed by each of the 27 member states. There were no secrets, no hidden clauses,' she told a sitting of MEPs in Strasbourg. 'The implication that these contacts were somehow inappropriate or against the European interest is, by any measure, simply wrong.' The motion was an attempt to spin 'debunked conspiracies' and try to rewrite the history of how Europe 'successfully overcame a global pandemic together', she said. The EU executive needed to be in a strong position during ongoing tariff negotiations with the United States, the German politician said. Sinn Féin's two MEPs, Lynn Boylan and Kathleen Funchion, said they would vote against Ms von der Leyen, due to the failure of the EU to hold Israel to account for its conduct during its invasion of Gaza, among other things. Fine Gael's four MEPs will oppose the motion, which they said had been 'tabled by far-right members of the European Parliament in a bid to destabilise the EU for political gain'. Iratxe García, a senior Spanish MEP who leads the centre-left Socialist and Democrats (S&D), the second largest grouping in the parliament, said its members would not support the motion, as it refused to work with the far right. The motion has divided some right-wing populists, with hard right Italian prime minister Giorgia Meloni's party opposing the effort to bring down the commission leadership. Nicola Procaccini, an MEP from Ms Meloni's Brothers of Italy party, said the move was a mistake. 'This motion is doomed to fail and we know it, without even getting close to the level of votes needed,' he said. The proposal was one 'big political show' from the far-right to undermine democracy, according to Bas Eickhout, the co-leader of the European Greens.
The Journal
9 hours ago
- The Journal
Paschal Donohoe is keeping his big job in Europe because his competitors pulled out last minute
PASCHAL DONOHOE IS to remain as President of the Eurogroup for a third term after the two politicians contesting the role pulled out of the race at the last moment. Politicians from both Spain and Lithuania announced that they were throwing their hats into the ring last month , while Donohoe had expressed his interest in continuing his tenure as chair of the group earlier this year. Spain's finance minister Carlos Cuerpo promised a 'renewed impetus' for the Eurogroup when announcing his candidacy. Cuerpo was considered Donohoe's main competitor, although Lithuania's Rimantas Šadžius, who had also put himself forward. He said it must play a key role in the European political agenda and 'achieve tangible results in terms of growth, competitiveness, welfare state, and integration'. Any minister with responsibility for finance from a euro area member state may be elected President of the Eurogroup. The candidate must be a sitting member of the Eurogroup at the time of the election. The president's term is two and a half years. Advertisement The Eurogroup is an informal body created in 1997 in which the ministers from the euro area member states discuss matters relating to their countries' common responsibilities related to the euro. They coordinate economic policies and try to promote economic growth. They usually meet once a month, before the Economic and Financial Affairs Council meeting. Tánaiste Simon Harris congratulated Donohoe on 'a significant personal achievement' that reflects 'the confidence and trust of his European colleagues'. Harris, who is also the leader of Donohoe's party, said the appointment was 'a source of great pride for the Fine Gael party and for Ireland'. 'I'm so proud that one of our own will continue to play such a central role in shaping the economic direction of the Eurozone,' Harris said. With reporting from David Mac Redmond Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
