WA's youth justice system in crisis before 16-year-old's death: coroner
Loading
He found staff failed to wear radios as per department policy, Cleveland was confined to his cell for excessive amounts of time and the teen's cell was in a condition that enabled him to self-harm.
The department had accepted many failings, including staff not following policies and procedures and Cleveland's lack of access to running water in his cell, Urquhart said.
He pointed to extensive evidence Cleveland was not receiving adequate mental health and therapeutic support, education, recreation and 'access to fresh air'.
'There is much evidence to suggest that these needs of Cleveland were not adequately met,' he said.
Staff described the 'appalling conditions in which the young people were being detained' and the 'chaotic operating environment' at Unit 18, with some saying it was a 'war zone', Urquhart said as he recapped some of the evidence.
'They described the soul-destroying daily confinement orders which kept detainees in their cells, sometimes for 24 hours a day,' he said.
'They described the lack of support and training given to them to do their jobs and they described the chronic shortage of staff.'
The coroner revisited evidence heard about the establishment of Unit 18, as he made a case for a special inquiry after the department and some other counsel made submissions it was beyond the jurisdiction of the court.
He said further adverse findings against the department and individuals would be confined to actions taken or not taken in Unit 18 and matters connected to Cleveland's death.
He said examples of these would be what staff did after Cleveland covered his in-cell observation camera and the damage in his unit that enabled him to harm himself.
The inquest previously heard Cleveland self-harmed about 1.35am.
At 1.51am, an officer opened his cell door and at 1.54am a red alert was issued as staff tried to revive the teen.
Paramedics arrived at 2.06am but did not get access to Cleveland, who was found to be in cardiac arrest, for nine minutes.
The teen was partially revived and taken to hospital but suffered a brain injury becauise of a lack of oxygen.
Cleveland died, surrounded by his family, on October 19, 2023.
AAP
Crisis support is available from Lifeline 13 11 14. For 24/7 crisis support run by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, contact 13YARN (13 92 76).
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
7 hours ago
- Perth Now
Misleading 'ghost stores' haunting Australian consumers
Australians have been warned to stay alert for "ghost stores" as shoppers who fall victim have few avenues for recourse. At least four such stores have been noted by the Australian consumer watchdog for misleading shoppers into buying low-quality items. They often claim to be local Australian businesses that are closing down and selling off high-quality goods, when they are actually based overseas and sell poor-quality, drop-shipped clothes and footwear. "This conduct preys on the empathy of consumers who have a genuine desire to support local businesses," Australian Competition and Consumer Commission deputy chair Catriona Lowe said. The commission specifically issued public warning notices about and However, the issue appears to be more widespread with the watchdog receiving at least 360 reports about 60 online retailers since the start of 2025. Many complaints alleged ghost stores were refusing to provide refunds, were offering only partial refunds or were not responding to complaints at all. Normally, Australians could pursue their consumer rights and go to a local store. But because so many of the shops operate overseas, the usual consumer guarantees would not apply, Consumer Action Law Centre legal director Stephen Nowicki said. "There's very little you can do," he told AAP. The commission has urged consumers to contact their bank to see if they can reverse the charge or stop the transaction. While this can be done when Australians fall victim to scams, the situation with ghost stores is less clear because shoppers still receive a product. "It becomes harder in these kinds of situations, compared to an outright scam, to know what is a genuine discount versus what someone is presenting as a discount but is actually something not worth what they are promoting it as," Mr Nowicki said. But there are some potential areas for reform. Though governments could not pass laws that would give consumers jurisdiction against an overseas business, they could try to block and prevent advertising in the first place. Operators generally target Australians through social media ads on platforms like Facebook and Instagram. They make themselves appear local by closing and then rebranding under new names that use different Australian suburbs, towns or cities. The competition and consumer commission has written to Meta, which owns both platforms, and e-commerce giant Shopify, which can be used to host and operate ghost web stores. It has also tried to educate shoppers. Ghost store domains often end with ".com" and not ". and many use AI-generated images. They also generally do not provide a physical address or a means of contact beyond an email address, while their Privacy Policy or Terms of Service sometimes refers to international regulations rather than Australian laws.
The Advertiser
14 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Parent's anguish over handing child to alleged abuser
A horrified father who unknowingly handed his daughter over to an alleged sex offender at a local childcare centre is pleading for answers as hundreds of families have their infants tested for infectious diseases. Father of three, Satbir, who asked that his surname not be used, went to the Creative Garden Early Learning Centre at Point Cook in Melbourne's southwest on Wednesday after recognising the alleged offender on the news. The troubled father said he was seeking information about Joshua Dale Brown's supervision of his children in 2023. More than 1200 families with infants and toddlers at the 20 centres where Brown worked since 2017 have been told to get them screened for potential diseases. Satbir wanted advice on whether two of his children needed to be tested. "I dropped off my child into his hands a couple of times," Satbir told AAP. "I'm a bit worried, I (need) to find out everything. I've seen him in the classroom where I dropped my children." The more than 70 charges against Brown, 26, include sexual penetration of a child under 12, attempted sexual penetration of a child under 12 and producing child abuse material. He's also been charged with recklessly contaminate goods to cause alarm or anxiety, which is understood to refer to the alleged contamination of food with bodily fluids. The charges relate to eight alleged victims aged between five months and two years who were enrolled at the Point Cook childcare centre between April 2022 and January 2023. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare has pushed back against a call to ban men from working as early childhood educators, pointing to separate reports of misconduct allegations involving female workers. "I don't think that's going to be the solution here," Mr Clare told Nine's Today show on Thursday. When parliament resumes this month, the federal government will introduce legislation to cut funding to childcare centres that breach safety rules. Opposition shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser on Thursday backed any changes to protect children. "We have to go to issues of principle here and we won't be playing politics with this issue," he told ABC Radio. National Children's Commissioner Anne Hollonds has also called for child safety and wellbeing to be a priority for Labor's national cabinet. Families with children at the 20 centres in Brown's employment history have reported long wait times to access support and health information from a government hotline. Another parent of a child who attended the Point Cook centre from 2021 to 2023, who declined to give their name, received a generic response from authorities and later found the same information in the news. "There's a lot of stress, it's very distressing so I needed to come and get some details," he said. Brown was not known to Victoria Police until the start of the investigation, and there were no formal complaints against him. He had a valid working with children check. The Victorian government has ordered an urgent child safety review, a register of all early childhood educators and moved forward a mobile phone ban in facilities to late September with $50,000 fines for breaches. But the "band-aid measures" don't tackle the root causes of issues in a sector where half of all educators had been working for less than three years, early education advocate Lisa Bryant said. On Wednesday, parents demanded answers and questioned why "red flags", such as Brown's extensive work history, had not been identified by authorities. Victoria will consider introducing mandatory CCTV in centres, while there are also calls for a national overhaul of background checks. On Wednesday, it also emerged that a second man, Michael Simon Wilson, 36, from Hoppers Crossing, had appeared in court on the same day as Brown, charged with child abuse material, sex offences and bestiality. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028 A horrified father who unknowingly handed his daughter over to an alleged sex offender at a local childcare centre is pleading for answers as hundreds of families have their infants tested for infectious diseases. Father of three, Satbir, who asked that his surname not be used, went to the Creative Garden Early Learning Centre at Point Cook in Melbourne's southwest on Wednesday after recognising the alleged offender on the news. The troubled father said he was seeking information about Joshua Dale Brown's supervision of his children in 2023. More than 1200 families with infants and toddlers at the 20 centres where Brown worked since 2017 have been told to get them screened for potential diseases. Satbir wanted advice on whether two of his children needed to be tested. "I dropped off my child into his hands a couple of times," Satbir told AAP. "I'm a bit worried, I (need) to find out everything. I've seen him in the classroom where I dropped my children." The more than 70 charges against Brown, 26, include sexual penetration of a child under 12, attempted sexual penetration of a child under 12 and producing child abuse material. He's also been charged with recklessly contaminate goods to cause alarm or anxiety, which is understood to refer to the alleged contamination of food with bodily fluids. The charges relate to eight alleged victims aged between five months and two years who were enrolled at the Point Cook childcare centre between April 2022 and January 2023. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare has pushed back against a call to ban men from working as early childhood educators, pointing to separate reports of misconduct allegations involving female workers. "I don't think that's going to be the solution here," Mr Clare told Nine's Today show on Thursday. When parliament resumes this month, the federal government will introduce legislation to cut funding to childcare centres that breach safety rules. Opposition shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser on Thursday backed any changes to protect children. "We have to go to issues of principle here and we won't be playing politics with this issue," he told ABC Radio. National Children's Commissioner Anne Hollonds has also called for child safety and wellbeing to be a priority for Labor's national cabinet. Families with children at the 20 centres in Brown's employment history have reported long wait times to access support and health information from a government hotline. Another parent of a child who attended the Point Cook centre from 2021 to 2023, who declined to give their name, received a generic response from authorities and later found the same information in the news. "There's a lot of stress, it's very distressing so I needed to come and get some details," he said. Brown was not known to Victoria Police until the start of the investigation, and there were no formal complaints against him. He had a valid working with children check. The Victorian government has ordered an urgent child safety review, a register of all early childhood educators and moved forward a mobile phone ban in facilities to late September with $50,000 fines for breaches. But the "band-aid measures" don't tackle the root causes of issues in a sector where half of all educators had been working for less than three years, early education advocate Lisa Bryant said. On Wednesday, parents demanded answers and questioned why "red flags", such as Brown's extensive work history, had not been identified by authorities. Victoria will consider introducing mandatory CCTV in centres, while there are also calls for a national overhaul of background checks. On Wednesday, it also emerged that a second man, Michael Simon Wilson, 36, from Hoppers Crossing, had appeared in court on the same day as Brown, charged with child abuse material, sex offences and bestiality. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028 A horrified father who unknowingly handed his daughter over to an alleged sex offender at a local childcare centre is pleading for answers as hundreds of families have their infants tested for infectious diseases. Father of three, Satbir, who asked that his surname not be used, went to the Creative Garden Early Learning Centre at Point Cook in Melbourne's southwest on Wednesday after recognising the alleged offender on the news. The troubled father said he was seeking information about Joshua Dale Brown's supervision of his children in 2023. More than 1200 families with infants and toddlers at the 20 centres where Brown worked since 2017 have been told to get them screened for potential diseases. Satbir wanted advice on whether two of his children needed to be tested. "I dropped off my child into his hands a couple of times," Satbir told AAP. "I'm a bit worried, I (need) to find out everything. I've seen him in the classroom where I dropped my children." The more than 70 charges against Brown, 26, include sexual penetration of a child under 12, attempted sexual penetration of a child under 12 and producing child abuse material. He's also been charged with recklessly contaminate goods to cause alarm or anxiety, which is understood to refer to the alleged contamination of food with bodily fluids. The charges relate to eight alleged victims aged between five months and two years who were enrolled at the Point Cook childcare centre between April 2022 and January 2023. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare has pushed back against a call to ban men from working as early childhood educators, pointing to separate reports of misconduct allegations involving female workers. "I don't think that's going to be the solution here," Mr Clare told Nine's Today show on Thursday. When parliament resumes this month, the federal government will introduce legislation to cut funding to childcare centres that breach safety rules. Opposition shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser on Thursday backed any changes to protect children. "We have to go to issues of principle here and we won't be playing politics with this issue," he told ABC Radio. National Children's Commissioner Anne Hollonds has also called for child safety and wellbeing to be a priority for Labor's national cabinet. Families with children at the 20 centres in Brown's employment history have reported long wait times to access support and health information from a government hotline. Another parent of a child who attended the Point Cook centre from 2021 to 2023, who declined to give their name, received a generic response from authorities and later found the same information in the news. "There's a lot of stress, it's very distressing so I needed to come and get some details," he said. Brown was not known to Victoria Police until the start of the investigation, and there were no formal complaints against him. He had a valid working with children check. The Victorian government has ordered an urgent child safety review, a register of all early childhood educators and moved forward a mobile phone ban in facilities to late September with $50,000 fines for breaches. But the "band-aid measures" don't tackle the root causes of issues in a sector where half of all educators had been working for less than three years, early education advocate Lisa Bryant said. On Wednesday, parents demanded answers and questioned why "red flags", such as Brown's extensive work history, had not been identified by authorities. Victoria will consider introducing mandatory CCTV in centres, while there are also calls for a national overhaul of background checks. On Wednesday, it also emerged that a second man, Michael Simon Wilson, 36, from Hoppers Crossing, had appeared in court on the same day as Brown, charged with child abuse material, sex offences and bestiality. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028 A horrified father who unknowingly handed his daughter over to an alleged sex offender at a local childcare centre is pleading for answers as hundreds of families have their infants tested for infectious diseases. Father of three, Satbir, who asked that his surname not be used, went to the Creative Garden Early Learning Centre at Point Cook in Melbourne's southwest on Wednesday after recognising the alleged offender on the news. The troubled father said he was seeking information about Joshua Dale Brown's supervision of his children in 2023. More than 1200 families with infants and toddlers at the 20 centres where Brown worked since 2017 have been told to get them screened for potential diseases. Satbir wanted advice on whether two of his children needed to be tested. "I dropped off my child into his hands a couple of times," Satbir told AAP. "I'm a bit worried, I (need) to find out everything. I've seen him in the classroom where I dropped my children." The more than 70 charges against Brown, 26, include sexual penetration of a child under 12, attempted sexual penetration of a child under 12 and producing child abuse material. He's also been charged with recklessly contaminate goods to cause alarm or anxiety, which is understood to refer to the alleged contamination of food with bodily fluids. The charges relate to eight alleged victims aged between five months and two years who were enrolled at the Point Cook childcare centre between April 2022 and January 2023. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare has pushed back against a call to ban men from working as early childhood educators, pointing to separate reports of misconduct allegations involving female workers. "I don't think that's going to be the solution here," Mr Clare told Nine's Today show on Thursday. When parliament resumes this month, the federal government will introduce legislation to cut funding to childcare centres that breach safety rules. Opposition shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser on Thursday backed any changes to protect children. "We have to go to issues of principle here and we won't be playing politics with this issue," he told ABC Radio. National Children's Commissioner Anne Hollonds has also called for child safety and wellbeing to be a priority for Labor's national cabinet. Families with children at the 20 centres in Brown's employment history have reported long wait times to access support and health information from a government hotline. Another parent of a child who attended the Point Cook centre from 2021 to 2023, who declined to give their name, received a generic response from authorities and later found the same information in the news. "There's a lot of stress, it's very distressing so I needed to come and get some details," he said. Brown was not known to Victoria Police until the start of the investigation, and there were no formal complaints against him. He had a valid working with children check. The Victorian government has ordered an urgent child safety review, a register of all early childhood educators and moved forward a mobile phone ban in facilities to late September with $50,000 fines for breaches. But the "band-aid measures" don't tackle the root causes of issues in a sector where half of all educators had been working for less than three years, early education advocate Lisa Bryant said. On Wednesday, parents demanded answers and questioned why "red flags", such as Brown's extensive work history, had not been identified by authorities. Victoria will consider introducing mandatory CCTV in centres, while there are also calls for a national overhaul of background checks. On Wednesday, it also emerged that a second man, Michael Simon Wilson, 36, from Hoppers Crossing, had appeared in court on the same day as Brown, charged with child abuse material, sex offences and bestiality. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
7NEWS
16 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Father's harrowing reaction to alleged childcare crimes as children screened for diseases
A father of three has recalled the harrowing moment he unknowingly handed his daughter over to an alleged sex offender working at a local childcare centre. Satbir, who asked to be identified only by his first name, visited the Creative Garden Early Learning Centre in Point Cook, in Melbourne's southwest, on Wednesday after recognising the alleged offender on the news. The troubled father said he was seeking information about Joshua Dale Brown's supervision of his children in 2023. He also wanted advice on whether two of his children needed to be tested after more than 1000 families were told to screen infants for potential diseases. 'I dropped off my child into his hands a couple of times,' Satbir told AAP. 'I'm a bit worried, I (need) to find out everything. I've seen him in the classroom where I dropped my children.' The charges against Brown, 26, include sexual penetration of a child under 12, attempted sexual penetration of a child under 12 and producing child abuse material. They relate to eight victims aged between five months and two years who were enrolled at the childcare centre between April 2022 and January 2023. He worked at about 20 facilities since 2017 and health authorities have urged the parents of 1200 children to get them tested for unspecified infectious diseases as a precaution. Families with children at the centres have reported long wait times to access support and health information from a government hotline. Another parent who visited the Point Cook centre on Wednesday, who declined to give their name, received a generic response from authorities and later found the same information in the news. His daughter attended the centre from 2021 to 2023. 'There's a lot of stress, it's very distressing so I needed to come and get some details,' he said. Brown was not known to Victoria Police until the start of the investigation, and there were no formal complaints against him. He had a valid working with children check. The Victorian government has ordered an urgent child safety review, a register of all early childhood educators and moved forward a mobile phone ban in facilities to late September with $50,000 fines for breaches. But the 'band-aid measures' didn't tackle the root causes of issues in a sector where half of all educators had been working for less than three years, early education advocate Lisa Bryant said. Parents demanded answers on Wednesday, questioning why clear 'red flags' such as Brown's extensive work history had not been identified by authorities. Victoria will consider introducing mandatory CCTV in centres, while there are also calls for a national overhaul of background checks. In an emergency, call 000.
