Musk faces a daunting path in challenging US two-party system
3D printed miniature depicting Elon Musk and words \"The America Party\" are seen in this illustration taken July 7, 2025. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration
WASHINGTON - Building a new U.S. political party from scratch is a daunting task, even for the world's richest man.
But that is what Elon Musk, the billionaire behind Tesla and SpaceX, said he plans to do in the wake of his falling out with President Donald Trump. Musk this weekend announced the birth of the 'America Party' – dedicated, he said, to defeating Republicans who backed Trump's massive tax-cut and spending bill.
Musk described his new party on his platform X as tech-centric, budget-conscious, pro-energy and centrist, with the goal of drawing both disaffected Democrats and Republicans. Musk has criticized the tax-cut bill, which is forecast to add about $3.4 trillion to the United States' debt.
Breaking the two-party system's grip on U.S. federal elections would take tremendous resources and a long-term commitment, political experts say. Similar attempts have failed, underscoring how difficult it is to gain a foothold in a country where elections are organized on a state-by-state level.
"There are just very, very significant barriers to the creation of a viable third party," said David A. Hopkins, a Boston College political science professor. He said challenges include building party infrastructure, organizing volunteers and qualifying for the ballot.
David Jolly, a former Republican congressman from Florida who left the party over Trump, said Musk can provide what has long been required for such a push: money.
"What the independent space has been lacking has been resources," Jolly said. "It's more than filing with the Federal Election Commission. It's really starting 50 state parties. You're talking about $100 million just to enter the space with real serious intent."
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore NDP celebrations to be held at 5 heartland sites, including Bishan and Punggol, on Aug 10
Singapore NDP 2025: Tank that bumped into traffic light lost steering and braking power due to faulty part
Singapore SIA flight from Brisbane to Singapore diverted to Perth due to technical issue
Singapore New Draft Master Plan could reignite developers' interest to buy land
Singapore AI cannot supplant learning, it must enable it: Desmond Lee
Business ShopBack to scale up its payments business as it gets major payment institution licence
Asia China warns Trump on tariffs, threatens retaliation on supply chain deals
Multimedia 'I suspect he's cheating': She finds proof when spouses stray
Jolly considered returning to politics as an independent, but he concluded that staying within the two-party system would be a more effective way to reach unhappy voters. He is now running for governor of Florida as a Democrat.
In 2016, former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, another billionaire, made a similar conclusion, rejecting the idea of running for president as an independent, saying that such a candidate would have "no chance of winning."
Jolly estimated it would take Musk 10 years and perhaps $1 billion to build a viable national party – and said Musk's recent history with his Department of Government Efficiency suggests the billionaire may not be in it for the long haul.
Musk left DOGE after just a few months in Trump's administration, having delivered little of the savings he promised.
"What we have seen is an Elon Musk who is not disciplined ... enough to change American politics," Jolly said.
Musk's office did not respond to a request for comment. Tesla shares closed nearly 7% lower on Monday as Musk reignited investors' worries about his focus on the company.
PLAYING SPOILER
Musk could have chosen a more traditional path, using his political action committee to back Republican challengers to incumbents in the party primaries ahead of next year's midterm elections, which will determine control of Congress.
He was the largest donor in the 2024 U.S. campaign cycle, making nearly $300 million in contributions, mostly focused on helping Trump return to the White House.
Not all his political efforts have paid off. He poured millions of dollars into a Wisconsin Supreme Court election in April, only to see his preferred candidate fail.
His efforts to convince Republicans in the U.S. Congress not to pass Trump's tax bill also fell flat.
It is unclear how effective he would be in backing independents in a handful of competitive U.S. House of Representatives races.
As it is, the roughly three-dozen races deemed competitive by nonpartisan analysts are often already swamped with cash from political parties and outside fundraisers, and the candidates themselves typically are ideologically more moderate - which would make it harder for Musk's candidates to differentiate themselves.
Historically, congressional candidates outside the two parties have struggled to overcome disadvantages in local efforts to organize and get out the vote. More often, independents have served as spoilers – siphoning away votes from either the Democrat or Republican.
In the 2024 election for a House seat in Ohio, independent candidate Dennis Kucinich, a former Democratic congressman, captured more than 12% of the general election vote. The Republican, Max Miller, won by 15 percentage points.
Trump mocked Musk's efforts on Sunday. "Third parties have never worked, so he can have fun with it, but I think it's ridiculous," he told reporters.
Complicating Musk's plans is that many voters dislike him. Any role he plays in an election is sure to become part of the debate.
Musk is viewed less favorably than Trump by the American public at large - just 36% of respondents to a June Reuters/Ipsos poll had a favorable view of Musk compared with 42% who viewed Trump favorably, while 59% of respondents have an unfavorable view of him compared with 55% who viewed Trump unfavorably.
But his biggest liability may be that he is trying to challenge Trump politically while relying on support from Trump's own voters. Musk enjoyed his strongest level of support - 78% favorability - among people who voted for Trump in November.
'Musk himself is not very popular, and his appeal has a huge overlap with the existing Republican coalition,' said Hans Noel, a political scientist at Georgetown University. 'There really isn't an unrepresented movement that he's speaking for ... he's unlikely to elect many America Party candidates." REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
9 minutes ago
- Business Times
EU reaches broad tariff deal with US to avert painful trade blow
[LONDON/WASHINGTON] The US and European Union agreed on a hard-fought deal that will see the bloc face 15 per cent tariffs on most of its exports, including automobiles, staving off a trade war that could have delivered a hammer blow to the global economy. The pact was concluded less than a week before a Friday (Aug 1) deadline for US President Donald Trump's higher tariffs to take effect and was quickly praised by several European leaders, including German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, who called it 'sustainable'. Trump and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen announced the deal on Sunday at his golf club in Turnberry, Scotland, although they did not disclose the full details of the pact or release any written materials. 'It's the biggest of all the deals,' Trump said, while von der Leyen added it would bring 'stability' and 'predictability'. The euro advanced over all Group of 10 peers in early Sydney trading, with the spot up 0.3 per cent to 1.1773 after closing up 1 per cent last week. The deal would leave EU exports facing much higher tariffs than the bloc would charge for imports from the US, with von der Leyen saying the aim is to rebalance a trade surplus with the US. But those kinds of tradeoffs in the agreement angered some European industry groups, with Germany's main lobby saying it 'sends a fatal signal to the closely intertwined economies on both sides of the Atlantic'. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Von der Leyen and Trump also differed on some of the key terms of the deal they announced. The US president said the tariff level would apply to 'automobiles and everything else,' but not pharmaceuticals and metals. Steel and aluminium 'stays the way it is', the US president added, and drugs are 'unrelated to this deal'. The chief of the EU's executive arm said later at a news conference that the 15 per cent rate would be all inclusive, would not stack on top of industry-specific tariffs and would cover drugs, chips and cars. Metals duties 'will be cut and a quota system will be put in place,' she said. 'We have 15 per cent for pharmaceuticals. Whatever the decisions later on is, of the president of the US, how to deal with pharmaceuticals in general globally, that's on a different sheet of paper,' von der Leyen said, adding that the overall rate 'is not to be underestimated but it was the best we could get.' The EU agreed to purchase US$750 billion in American energy products, invest US$600 billion in the US on top of existing expenditures, open up countries' markets to trade with the US at zero tariffs and purchase 'vast amounts' of military equipment, Trump said. Von der Leyen said no decisions have been made on European wine and spirits, but the matter would be sorted out soon. Key to getting the 15 per cent rate to apply to pharmaceuticals and semiconductors was the bloc's promise to make US investments, according to sources familiar with the matter. Ahead of the meeting, the EU was expecting a 15 per cent charge on its imports to also apply to most pharmaceuticals. The products had been one of the negotiation's main sticking points. Without a deal, Bloomberg Economics estimated that the total US average effective tariff rate would rise to nearly 18 per cent on Aug 1 from 13.5 per cent under current policies. The new deal brings that number down to 16 per cent. For months, Trump has threatened most of the world with high tariffs with the goal of shrinking the US trade deficits. But the prospect of those duties, and Trump's unpredictable nature, put world capitals on edge. In May, he threatened to impose a 50 per cent duty on nearly all EU goods, adding pressure that accelerated negotiations, before lowering that to 30 per cent. The transatlantic pact removes a major risk for markets and the global economy, a trade war involving US$1.7 trillion worth of cross-border commerce, even though it means European shipments to the US are getting hit with a higher tax at the border. The goals, Trump said, were more production in the US and wider access for American exporters to the European market. Von der Leyen acknowledged part of the drive behind the talks was a reordering of trade, but cast it as beneficial for both sides. 'The starting point was an imbalance,' von der Leyen said. 'We wanted to rebalance the trade we made, and we wanted to do it in a way that trade goes on between the two of us across the Atlantic, because the two biggest economies should have a good trade flow.' The announcement capped off months of often tense shuttle diplomacy between Brussels and Washington. The two sides appeared close to a deal earlier this month when Trump made his 30 per cent threat. The EU had prepared to put levies on about 100 billion euros (S$151 billion), about a third of American exports to the bloc, if a deal was not reached and Trump followed through on his warning. US and European negotiators had been zeroing in on an agreement this past week, and the decision for von der Leyen to meet Trump at his signature golf property brought the standoff to a dramatic conclusion. Officials had discussed terms for a quota system for steel and aluminium imports, which would face a lower import tax below a certain threshold and would be charged the regular 50 per cent rate above it. The EU had also been seeking quotas and a cap on future industry-specific tariffs. The EU for weeks, indicated a willingness to accept an unbalanced pact involving a reduced rate of around 15 per cent, while seeking relief from levies on industries critical to the European economy. The US president has also imposed 25 per cent duties on cars and double that rate on steel and aluminium, as well as copper. Several exporters in Asia, including Indonesia, the Philippines and Japan, have negotiated reciprocal rates between 15 to 20 per cent, and the EU saw Japan's deal for 15 per cent on autos as a breakthrough worth seeking as well. Washington's talks also continue with Switzerland, South Korea and Taiwan. Trump said he is 'looking at deals with three or four other countries', but 'for the most part', others with smaller economies or less significant trading relationships with the US would receive letters simply setting tariff rates. Trump announced a range of tariffs on almost all US trading partners in April, declaring his intent to revive domestic manufacturing, help pay for a massive tax cut and address economic imbalances he has said are detrimental to US workers. He put them on pause a week later when investors panicked. Trump's decades-old complaints about the global trading system heap particularly sharp scorn on the EU, which he has accused of being formed to 'screw' the US. The bloc was established in the years following World War II in order to establish economic stability on the continent. The president has lashed out at non-tariff barriers for American companies to do business across the 27-nation bloc. Those include the EU's value-added tax, levies on digital services, and safety and environmental regulations. Weeks of negotiations tested the EU's willingness to digest what is seen as an asymmetrical outcome, a senior EU diplomat said, but one that offers an opportunity to continue the talks without escalating further. BLOOMBERG
Straits Times
20 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Yemen's Houthis threaten to target ships linked to firms dealing with Israeli ports
Yemen's Houthis said on Sunday they would target any ships belonging to companies that do business with Israeli ports, regardless of their nationalities, as part of what they called the fourth phase of their military operations against Israel. In a televised statement, the Houthis' military spokesperson warned that ships would be attacked if companies ignored their warnings, regardless of their destination. "The Yemeni Armed Forces call on all countries, if they want to avoid this escalation, to pressure the enemy to halt its aggression and lift the blockade on the Gaza Strip," he added. Since Israel's war in Gaza began in October 2023, the Iran-aligned Houthis have been attacking ships they deem as bound or linked to Israel in what they say are acts of solidarity with Palestinians. In May, the U.S. announced a surprise deal with the Houthis where it agreed to stop a bombing campaign against them in return for an end to shipping attacks, though the Houthis said the deal did not include sparing Israel. REUTERS
Straits Times
39 minutes ago
- Straits Times
EU urges Ukraine to uphold independent anti-corruption bodies; Zelenskiy signals swift action
Find out what's new on ST website and app. FILE PHOTO: European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen speaks with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskiy prior to a bilateral meeting in Rome, Italy, April 26, 2025. Andrew Medichini/Pool via REUTERS/File Photo BRUSSELS - European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen called on Sunday for President Volodymyr Zelenskiy to uphold independent anti-corruption bodies, with the Ukrainian leader signaling that supporting legislation could be adopted within days. "Ukraine has already achieved a lot on its European path. It must build on these solid foundations and preserve independent anti-corruption bodies, which are cornerstones of Ukraine's rule of law," von der Leyen said in a post on X after a call with Zelenskiy. After a rare outburst of public criticism, Zelenskiy on Thursday submitted draft legislation to restore the independence of Ukraine's anti-corruption agencies - reversing course of an earlier bill aimed at stripping their autonomy. "I thanked the European Commission for the provided expertise," Zelenskiy said in a post on X after his Sunday call with von der Leyen. "We share the same vision: it is important that the bill is adopted without delay, as early as next week." Von der Leyen also promised continued support for Ukraine on its path to EU membership. "Ukraine can count on our support to deliver progress on its European path," she added. REUTERS Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Sewage shaft failure linked to sinkhole; PUB calling safety time-out on similar works islandwide Singapore Tanjong Katong Road sinkhole did not happen overnight: Experts Singapore Workers used nylon rope to rescue driver of car that fell into Tanjong Katong Road sinkhole Asia Singapore-only car washes will get business licences revoked, says Johor govt World Food airdropped into Gaza as Israel opens aid routes Sport Arsenal beat Newcastle in five-goal thriller to bring Singapore Festival of Football to a close Singapore Benchmark barrier: Six of her homeschooled kids had to retake the PSLE Asia S'porean trainee doctor in Melbourne arrested for allegedly filming colleagues in toilets since 2021
