Green nod for sand mining in Mandovi challenged in NGT
The Goa River Sand Protectors Network has challenged the environmental clearance (EC) granted for sand mining by the Goa State Environment Impact Assessment Authority in the National Green Tribunal (NGT).
The group has currently challenged one EC granted on Feb 3, 2025, and informed the tribunal that it would be filing separate appeals against all the remaining 11 ECs as well.
The network has sought the quashing of the EC. The directorate of mines and geology was granted permission for the extraction of sand in Zone 4 (near Goa Shipbuilding, Khandola in Ponda) in the Mandovi in a proposed area of 4.5 hectares. The EC allows the extraction of 1,000 cubic metres per annum per permit by traditional (manual) methods.
The main ground on which the EC dated Feb 3 was assailed in the appeal is that it was granted in violation of the provisions given in paragraph 3, sub-clause (x) of the CRZ Notification, 2011, which prohibits the mining of sand in the complete CRZ area.
The appeal told the NGT that 'the area in question, where the sand mining is being done, lies in CRZ IV-B, which is evident from the field inspection report of the Mandovi, wherein this fact has been recorded very distinctly that the area falls in CRZ IV-B (water body) as per CZMP 2011.'
The NGT has admitted the appeal. The matter will be heard next on Aug 13.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
Expedite final ESA, ESZ notifications for Western Ghats, NGT tells Centre
Kochi: The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has directed the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) to expedite the process and publish the final notifications of ecologically sensitive areas (ESAs) and zones (ESZs) in the Western Ghats, particularly in states such as Kerala and Karnataka, where urgent action is warranted. The southern bench of NGT, while hearing a suo motu case on the 2024 Wayanad landslides, expressed concern that nearly a year had passed since the disaster, but little progress had been made on the notifications. Landslides in the Meppadi hills on July 30, 2024had buried entire villages — Mundakkai, Chooralmala, Attamala and Noolpuzha — under massive debris, claiming 298 lives and causing extensive damage to property. The counsel for the environment ministry submitted that the final ESZ notification would be issued before August. The case has been posted for further hearing on Aug 11. Kerala govt has demarcated 8,711.98 sq km as ESA across 98 villages and submitted the details to the Centre. Idukki district accounts for the highest number of such villages (28), followed by Palakkad (13), Wayanad (12) and Malappuram (10). During the hearing, the NGT observed that the Western Ghats is a significant geological formation along India's west coast. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Birla Evara 3 and 4 BHK from ₹ 1.75 Crore* Birla Estates Learn More Undo As the cradle of biological evolution, the Ghats support a population of around 50 million people, with high population density in some areas. It emphasised the need to conserve and protect the region's unique biodiversity, while allowing for sustainable and inclusive development, especially in areas prone to or highly susceptible to landslides. The NGT noted that comprehensive studies conducted by Madhav Gadgil and K Kasturirangan may be relied upon. It urged the MoEF&CC to prioritise states such as Kerala and Karnataka and to ensure the early publication of the final ESA and ESZ notifications. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Doctor's Day 2025 , messages and quotes!
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Extra funds spent to build flyover over village pond: NHAI
New Delhi: National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) told that it followed all rules while building Urban Extension Road (UER) over a village pond near southwest Delhi's Goyal Khurd. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The reply came after NGT took cognisance of a TOI report from last Sept, which highlighted that a natural pond, listed by Delhi govt for notification and legal protection, was impacted after NHAI constructed a flyover on it. NHAI stated that the land was acquired by Delhi Development Authority and handed over to it, after which all necessary environmental clearances were sought and received from the Union environment ministry. Thus there was no bar on the construction of the bridge under the applicable laws, it submitted. NHAI also clarified that it did not build the UER at grade by filling up the pond, which would have cost Rs 15 crore. Instead NHAI built a 1.2km-long flyover to go over the waterbody, spending around Rs 75 crore, five times more, to keep its environmental sanctity intact, the authority pointed out. "It is a well-established engineering practice that a bridge is proposed over a highway if it passes through any pond or waterbody so that it causes minimal disturbance to the waterbody. A similar practice was adopted in the case of the Goyla pond... Such a construction balances the interests of preserving the environment and the developmental interests of society," stated the NHAI report, adding that the steps were "proportionate, reasonable and remedial". "Extensive efforts" were also made to restore the pond as a consequence of the construction, NHAI claimed. No construction was undertaken that had caused permanent damage to the pond, it argued. According to the report, NHAI is also carrying out, through its contractor, routine maintenance and cleaning works of the pond, and any temporary structure built in the pond during the construction was removed. In March, Delhi State Wetland Authority submitted a report to NGT, stating that a pond in southwest Delhi was proposed to be listed, but was destroyed due to the construction of a highway.
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
Green nod for sand mining in Mandovi challenged in NGT
Panaji: The Goa River Sand Protectors Network has challenged the environmental clearance (EC) granted for sand mining by the Goa State Environment Impact Assessment Authority in the National Green Tribunal (NGT). The group has currently challenged one EC granted on Feb 3, 2025, and informed the tribunal that it would be filing separate appeals against all the remaining 11 ECs as well. The network has sought the quashing of the EC. The directorate of mines and geology was granted permission for the extraction of sand in Zone 4 (near Goa Shipbuilding, Khandola in Ponda) in the Mandovi in a proposed area of 4.5 hectares. The EC allows the extraction of 1,000 cubic metres per annum per permit by traditional (manual) methods. The main ground on which the EC dated Feb 3 was assailed in the appeal is that it was granted in violation of the provisions given in paragraph 3, sub-clause (x) of the CRZ Notification, 2011, which prohibits the mining of sand in the complete CRZ area. The appeal told the NGT that 'the area in question, where the sand mining is being done, lies in CRZ IV-B, which is evident from the field inspection report of the Mandovi, wherein this fact has been recorded very distinctly that the area falls in CRZ IV-B (water body) as per CZMP 2011.' The NGT has admitted the appeal. The matter will be heard next on Aug 13.
