Dire flaw in Labor's student fee cut plan
The research, released by not-for-profit research body e61 Institute on Thursday found the policy as is, doesn't meaningfully speed up debt repayment, and unfairly benefits students who graduated in 2024.
Instead of a 20 per cent cut to balances, e61 said the relief would be better targeted if Australia's with student debt were given a flat $5500 cut.
The figure also represents the average amount set to be wiped across all HELP accounts.
e61 said that a $5500 reduction would help 35 per cent of account holders make their final repayment in an earlier year, or 15 per cent more debt holders than a 20 per cent discount. New analysis from e61 urged Labor to consider a flat $5500 cut to student debts, instead of a 20 per cent cut. NewsWire/ Nicholas Eagar Credit: NewsWire
e61 Research Economist Matthew Maltman said the benefits of a straight cut was important factor due to the policy's $16bn price tag, which equals the annual cost of Jobseeker.
'Most HELP debt is held by university graduates, who have much higher lifetime incomes than the average taxpayer. And even if you look within graduates, those with more costly degrees tend to go on to earn higher incomes in the future,' he said.
'You could make the argument that we need to provide debt relief to humanities students in a
targeted way because of Job Ready Graduates.
'But the current policy isn't at all targeted and that means it's going to give a very large amount of debt relief to future lawyers, dentists and doctors who are going to go on to enjoy very high lifetime incomes.' Labor says its 20 per cent cut to student debt will be the first piece of legislation it will pass once parliament resumes on July 22. NewsWire/ Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia
University students who finished their degrees in 2024 will also receive twice as much relief as people who left in 2020, and two and a half times more than students who are currently in their first year of a three year degree.
e61 Senior Research Economist Jack Buckley said this would create a debt relief lottery.
'If you cut 20 per cent of each individual's balance, it means two very similar people will receive very different amounts of debt relief simply because one finished their degree in 2024 and the other finished a few years earlier or later,' said Mr Buckley.
Anthony Albanese has repeatedly said the 20 per cent cut to HELP debts will be the first piece of legislation passed when parliament returns on July 22, with the changes backdated to account balances as of June 1.
Labor is also set to increase the debt repayment threshold from $56,156 to $67,000, repayments of payment will also be lowered.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
an hour ago
- The Advertiser
Used car prices are 'ridiculous', says MG boss
Australians are paying 'ridiculous' prices for used cars, says MG Motor Australia CEO, Peter Ciao. And he has a plan to correct the market, while encouraging more new-car buyers, with a three-pronged powertrain strategy that's designed to challenge the status quo. "For me, the used car price in Australia is ridiculous. It's too high," Ciao told CarExpert in an exclusive interview. Hundreds of new car deals are available through CarExpert right now. Get the experts on your side and score a great deal. Browse now. "There are more than one million used car buyers each year, and lots of people will purchase a used car because they trust this brand and [will] pay 70 per cent of the price for a car that has already driven 50,000km, 80,000km or more, and maybe only has one year left on the warranty. Why would you do that? "At MG, we need to challenge this." The Chinese automaker has firmly established itself as a top-10 selling brand in Australia, on the strength of its budget-focused range of small passenger vehicles, family-friendly SUVs and, to a certain degree, the affordable MG 4 electric hatchback. But it is in the midst expanding its model portfolio with new fuel-efficient powertrains across its core product lineup, with models such as the MG 3 city hatch and the ZS small SUV now offered with the choice of conventional petrol engines or hybrid options. And, in the case of the HS mid-size SUV and the upcoming QS seven-seat SUV, also with 'Super Hybrid' plug-in alternatives. This, claims Mr Ciao, provides MG with the ability to challenge the used car market with entry-level models powered by internal combustion engines, while tackling the lower end of mainstream brands with hybrid vehicles, and also conventional hybrid rivals with the added benefit of plug-in technology at similar prices. "With a population of 27 million people, everyone's budget is different. And, at MG, we look after everyone, and we challenge the other OEMs [automakers]. "With MG, I will provide a new car with a 10-year warranty that is priced similarly to a used car. For MG 3, ZS, HS and QS with ICE powertrains, I will focus on why you shouldn't buy a used car. "For hybrid, I'll use this to benchmark against other OEMs offering entry-level models with stronger Hybrid+ value. "[And] with Super Hybrid, I will compete with the top hybrids. The benefit will be to provide more for the same price, as the MG Super Hybrid is much, much better than a normal hybrid. "This is my strategy: I will use ICE to target used car buyers, hybrid to target OEM petrol, and Super Hybrid to target other hybrids." Watch this space for our full Expert Insights interview with Mr Ciao this weekend. MORE: Everything MG Content originally sourced from: Australians are paying 'ridiculous' prices for used cars, says MG Motor Australia CEO, Peter Ciao. And he has a plan to correct the market, while encouraging more new-car buyers, with a three-pronged powertrain strategy that's designed to challenge the status quo. "For me, the used car price in Australia is ridiculous. It's too high," Ciao told CarExpert in an exclusive interview. Hundreds of new car deals are available through CarExpert right now. Get the experts on your side and score a great deal. Browse now. "There are more than one million used car buyers each year, and lots of people will purchase a used car because they trust this brand and [will] pay 70 per cent of the price for a car that has already driven 50,000km, 80,000km or more, and maybe only has one year left on the warranty. Why would you do that? "At MG, we need to challenge this." The Chinese automaker has firmly established itself as a top-10 selling brand in Australia, on the strength of its budget-focused range of small passenger vehicles, family-friendly SUVs and, to a certain degree, the affordable MG 4 electric hatchback. But it is in the midst expanding its model portfolio with new fuel-efficient powertrains across its core product lineup, with models such as the MG 3 city hatch and the ZS small SUV now offered with the choice of conventional petrol engines or hybrid options. And, in the case of the HS mid-size SUV and the upcoming QS seven-seat SUV, also with 'Super Hybrid' plug-in alternatives. This, claims Mr Ciao, provides MG with the ability to challenge the used car market with entry-level models powered by internal combustion engines, while tackling the lower end of mainstream brands with hybrid vehicles, and also conventional hybrid rivals with the added benefit of plug-in technology at similar prices. "With a population of 27 million people, everyone's budget is different. And, at MG, we look after everyone, and we challenge the other OEMs [automakers]. "With MG, I will provide a new car with a 10-year warranty that is priced similarly to a used car. For MG 3, ZS, HS and QS with ICE powertrains, I will focus on why you shouldn't buy a used car. "For hybrid, I'll use this to benchmark against other OEMs offering entry-level models with stronger Hybrid+ value. "[And] with Super Hybrid, I will compete with the top hybrids. The benefit will be to provide more for the same price, as the MG Super Hybrid is much, much better than a normal hybrid. "This is my strategy: I will use ICE to target used car buyers, hybrid to target OEM petrol, and Super Hybrid to target other hybrids." Watch this space for our full Expert Insights interview with Mr Ciao this weekend. MORE: Everything MG Content originally sourced from: Australians are paying 'ridiculous' prices for used cars, says MG Motor Australia CEO, Peter Ciao. And he has a plan to correct the market, while encouraging more new-car buyers, with a three-pronged powertrain strategy that's designed to challenge the status quo. "For me, the used car price in Australia is ridiculous. It's too high," Ciao told CarExpert in an exclusive interview. Hundreds of new car deals are available through CarExpert right now. Get the experts on your side and score a great deal. Browse now. "There are more than one million used car buyers each year, and lots of people will purchase a used car because they trust this brand and [will] pay 70 per cent of the price for a car that has already driven 50,000km, 80,000km or more, and maybe only has one year left on the warranty. Why would you do that? "At MG, we need to challenge this." The Chinese automaker has firmly established itself as a top-10 selling brand in Australia, on the strength of its budget-focused range of small passenger vehicles, family-friendly SUVs and, to a certain degree, the affordable MG 4 electric hatchback. But it is in the midst expanding its model portfolio with new fuel-efficient powertrains across its core product lineup, with models such as the MG 3 city hatch and the ZS small SUV now offered with the choice of conventional petrol engines or hybrid options. And, in the case of the HS mid-size SUV and the upcoming QS seven-seat SUV, also with 'Super Hybrid' plug-in alternatives. This, claims Mr Ciao, provides MG with the ability to challenge the used car market with entry-level models powered by internal combustion engines, while tackling the lower end of mainstream brands with hybrid vehicles, and also conventional hybrid rivals with the added benefit of plug-in technology at similar prices. "With a population of 27 million people, everyone's budget is different. And, at MG, we look after everyone, and we challenge the other OEMs [automakers]. "With MG, I will provide a new car with a 10-year warranty that is priced similarly to a used car. For MG 3, ZS, HS and QS with ICE powertrains, I will focus on why you shouldn't buy a used car. "For hybrid, I'll use this to benchmark against other OEMs offering entry-level models with stronger Hybrid+ value. "[And] with Super Hybrid, I will compete with the top hybrids. The benefit will be to provide more for the same price, as the MG Super Hybrid is much, much better than a normal hybrid. "This is my strategy: I will use ICE to target used car buyers, hybrid to target OEM petrol, and Super Hybrid to target other hybrids." Watch this space for our full Expert Insights interview with Mr Ciao this weekend. MORE: Everything MG Content originally sourced from: Australians are paying 'ridiculous' prices for used cars, says MG Motor Australia CEO, Peter Ciao. And he has a plan to correct the market, while encouraging more new-car buyers, with a three-pronged powertrain strategy that's designed to challenge the status quo. "For me, the used car price in Australia is ridiculous. It's too high," Ciao told CarExpert in an exclusive interview. Hundreds of new car deals are available through CarExpert right now. Get the experts on your side and score a great deal. Browse now. "There are more than one million used car buyers each year, and lots of people will purchase a used car because they trust this brand and [will] pay 70 per cent of the price for a car that has already driven 50,000km, 80,000km or more, and maybe only has one year left on the warranty. Why would you do that? "At MG, we need to challenge this." The Chinese automaker has firmly established itself as a top-10 selling brand in Australia, on the strength of its budget-focused range of small passenger vehicles, family-friendly SUVs and, to a certain degree, the affordable MG 4 electric hatchback. But it is in the midst expanding its model portfolio with new fuel-efficient powertrains across its core product lineup, with models such as the MG 3 city hatch and the ZS small SUV now offered with the choice of conventional petrol engines or hybrid options. And, in the case of the HS mid-size SUV and the upcoming QS seven-seat SUV, also with 'Super Hybrid' plug-in alternatives. This, claims Mr Ciao, provides MG with the ability to challenge the used car market with entry-level models powered by internal combustion engines, while tackling the lower end of mainstream brands with hybrid vehicles, and also conventional hybrid rivals with the added benefit of plug-in technology at similar prices. "With a population of 27 million people, everyone's budget is different. And, at MG, we look after everyone, and we challenge the other OEMs [automakers]. "With MG, I will provide a new car with a 10-year warranty that is priced similarly to a used car. For MG 3, ZS, HS and QS with ICE powertrains, I will focus on why you shouldn't buy a used car. "For hybrid, I'll use this to benchmark against other OEMs offering entry-level models with stronger Hybrid+ value. "[And] with Super Hybrid, I will compete with the top hybrids. The benefit will be to provide more for the same price, as the MG Super Hybrid is much, much better than a normal hybrid. "This is my strategy: I will use ICE to target used car buyers, hybrid to target OEM petrol, and Super Hybrid to target other hybrids." Watch this space for our full Expert Insights interview with Mr Ciao this weekend. MORE: Everything MG Content originally sourced from:
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Hakeem Jeffries trying to ‘go for the record' of longest speech in US Congress
On tonight's episode of Paul Murray Live, Sky News host Paul Murray discusses a lengthy Democrats' speech in Congress, Labor's growing bureaucracy, Liverpool soccer star's shock death, and more. Mr Murray said Hakeem Jeffries is trying to 'go for the record' of the longest speech in US Congress. 'The story right now is a bloke who is seemingly trying to take every moment he can to speak for as long as possible, to get as many eyeballs on his opposition and his party's opposition to the 'Big Beautiful Bill'.'
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
One Nation leader Pauline Hanson laments exploding public sector reaching record levels under Albanese government
One Nation leader Pauline Hanson has lamented the Albanese government's bloated public sector and claimed the huge growth in workers was 'making our life worse'. The federal public service has expanded to record levels under Labor, despite Prime Minister Anthony Albanese pledging to bolster lagging productivity growth. New Australian Public Service (APS) data has revealed the federal bureaucracy is set to balloon to a record-breaking 213,000 staff, up from a 14-year low of 144,704 workers at the end of 2019. A considerable number of the growing workforce is made of up compliance, regulation, administrative, and human resources officers tasked with supervising the mammoth public service. The compliance category, which makes up HR, policy and regulation employees experienced the steepest bump, surging by more than 41,000 workers over five years to December 2024. 'They're actually making our life worse,' Senator Hanson told Sky News on Thursday. 'You put in more public servants, that means more taxpayers' money has to pay the wages and then on top of that you've got all superannuation on top and then all your benefits and everything.' Senator Hanson said the expanded public service was a 'drain' of taxpayers' dollars. 'Albanese has also increased (the public service) because public servants will vote for Labor because they've got a job for life and they're just going to not sack them,' she added. Mr Albanese made the topic of the federal bureaucracy a central talking point in the recent election and defended his government's hiring spree while criticising former opposition leader Peter Dutton's plan to cull over 41,000 civil servants in the nation's capital. Senator Hanson said the Liberal Party backing away from the policy to crack down on working from home was a 'big mistake'. 'They should have followed through on that,' she said. Despite Mr Albanese vowing to lift lagging productivity and reduce the workforce's dependency on government support, Australian Bureau of Statistics data released last week showed that the almost one million workers were employed in federal, state, territory, and local government positions. This makes up 6.8 per cent of the Australian workforce.
