Warren Mundine responds to Pat Dodson's call for reconciliation and WA scheme offering Stolen Generation survivors $85k
Mr Dodson spoke at a Reconciliation Week event in Western Australia on Tuesday where he raised hopes of reconciliation between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Aussies, describing it as "unfinished business" that must not be neglected.
'If we are to have meaningful reconciliation in this country, the nation must come to grips with our inherent collective rights as First Peoples," he said in Fremantle.
"An approach to reconciliation in which the focus is only on the practical business of Closing the Gap suggests that all (that) the First Peoples are entitled to is equality in the standards of life enjoyed by other citizens and little more.
'To reframe reconciliation as solely practical risks displacing from the national conscience the historical root causes of the structural inequality.
'It reinforces a form of psychological terra nullius that has been likened to a collective amnesia about the past which becomes manifest in an ideological inability to come to grips with and accommodate the inherent sovereign rights of Indigenous people in a modern nation state. The consequences of this have been devastating for First Peoples."
Mr Mundine on Sky News argued "we get treated all the same, we're all citizens".
He pointed to the 1967 referendum which asked Australia to vote on the recognising of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the Constitution.
More than 90 per cent supported it which saw First Peoples included in the census and gave the government power to make laws for the the Indigenous community.
"In regard to the sovereignty issue, we have sovereignty already. We're citizens of this country. We enjoy all the sovereignty rights of this county," Mr Mundine said.
"In fact, we've gotten benefits from the sovereignty rights of this country. And that is in regard to Native title, the High Court decision in regard to the native title saying that we had rights. And that terra nullius is now doesn't exist anymore."
The prominent anti-Voice campaigner referred to a recent High Court decision on property rights for Aboriginals, First Nations programs, heritage legislation and mining and energy industries giving royalties to Aboriginals as examples of sovereignty.
Sky News host Danica Di Giorgio then asked about a Western Australian government redress scheme where Stolen Generation survivors will be each given $85,000.
Those in the community who were forcibly removed from their families in the state before 1972 will be eligible to receive the taxpayer-funded payout.
WA Attorney General Tony Buti estimated between 2,500 to 3,000 people in the state are eligible, meaning the cost of the scheme could reach $250 million.
Mr Mundine stressed "there has to be burden of proof".
Mr Dodson this week also urged Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to forge ahead with a national truth telling commission, also known as Makarrata, and a treaty process, which are the two other requests in the 2017 Uluru Statement from the Heart.
"They can do that because it doesn't require constitutional referendum, it can be done by way of legislation," he said on ABC's 7.30 this week.
If it went ahead it could be met with mixed feelings given the Voice, also one of the requests, was voted against in almost all jurisdictions in a 2023 referendum.
Mr Dodson - also known as "the father of reconciliation" due to his advocacy work - retired from federal politics in 2024 due to treatment on cancer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
PM to set sights on closing the gap in festival speech
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese will unveil an economic partnership with Indigenous organisations at the Garma Festival aimed at "a new way of doing business". Mr Albanese is expected to use his speech at the festival in Arnhem Land to announce the economic partnership with the Coalition of the Peaks, following the release of Closing the Gap data Indigenous organisations have labelled "unacceptable". "This builds on our commitment to the Closing the Gap Agreement, to its call for a new way of doing business and to the principle of shared decision-making," Mr Albanese will say on Saturday. The approach would allow Traditional Owners to advocate for infrastructure, housing and energy projects on their land and to build equity beyond the land itself. It would empower Indigenous groups to engage with business and the private sector, encouraging partnerships with private capital and institutional investors from the outset. "So companies and communities can come to government as partners, putting forward projects that are ready to go," Mr Albanese will say. Closing the Gap has been a topic of discussion at the Garma Festival, which has become a ground for political conversations and policy announcements while also focusing on culture and empowerment of the local Yolngu people. The data, released on Thursday, revealed just four of 19 targets are on track to be met, with another four goals going backwards - adult incarceration, children in out-of-home care, suicide rates and child development. When he delivers his keynote address on Saturday, Mr Albanese will say Closing the Gap data has underlined that a different, dedicated approach is required to address these issues. "Reports and reviews have their place, but they are not a substitute for results," he will say. "Creating a process matters but it is not the same thing as making progress." Federal Opposition Leader Sussan Ley will not attend the four-day festival and will instead be in Western Australia's Kimberley region. Ms Ley will visit Indigenous and community organisations in Wyndham and Kununurra on Saturday. She said Mr Albanese's speech should be used to outline his plan for First Nations people. "Anthony Albanese's speech to Garma is an opportunity for him to provide some clarity," she said. "He has a personal obligation to explain to Indigenous Australians what his plan is to turn around the widening gap." 13YARN 13 92 76 Lifeline 13 11 14
Perth Now
6 hours ago
- Perth Now
Albo's $31m pitch for remote Australians
Anthony Albanese will promise mobile TAFE centres to train Indigenous students in remote communities, with the Prime Minister set to make the announcement when he attends the Garma Festival in remote Arnhem Land this weekend. The $31m commitment, to be delivered alongside state and territory governments, will allow teachers to travel Australia using utes and trailers to train students in construction, mining, agriculture, carpentry, plumbing and community work, to ensure Indigenous people don't have to leave their communities to access that training. 'So that instead of communities relying on drive-in, drive-out workers to build and maintain the new homes we are delivering … locals get that training,' he is expected to say on Saturday. 'And instead of people having to move away from home to prepare for a career in mining or agriculture, construction or the care economy, we will bring skills and jobs to communities. 'Hands-on training, on country.' Anthony Albanese attending the Garma Festival in northeast Arnhem Land in 2024. Yothu Yindi Foundation/Nina Franova via NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia Labor will also promise $75m to help resource-strapped native title holders negotiate land use deals, to 'secure better deals, drive faster approvals and deliver a real and lasting economic legacy for communities. 'We must end the stalemate that arises when native title organisations with little in the way of back of house, or legal and commercial expertise, are expected to negotiate with multinational firms,' he will say. 'This is the tone and the standard we want this partnership to set, from the very start – pragmatic action that brings economic development, ownership and equity to communities. 'Not doubling-up on advice, or getting in the way of processes that are working.' In what will be his fourth time attending the large-scale event as Prime Minister, Mr Albanese will say that Labor's second term of government will be focused on 'delivery', with the government shifting focus to boosting economic empowerment among Indigenous Australians following the failure of the Voice referendum. It also coincides with this week's release of the Closing the Gap report which revealed Australia was only on track to meet four out of 19 targets, with efforts to reduce rates of Indigenous adult imprisonment, suicide rates and removing children in out-of-home care, and bring them in line with non-Indigenous peoples worsening. Australia was, however, expected to reach its targets to boost Indigenous preschool enrolments, employment and two land rights goals. Although Mr Albanese is expected to concede that there is 'more to do,' he will urge that 'closing the gap is a challenge all of us must meet' and took aim at the 'culture wars' instigated by the Coalition. This follows a successful motion at the WA Liberal Party state conference, which was supported by high-profile Liberal senator Michaelia Cash, and called for Welcome to Country ceremonies to be banned at official events. Mr Albanese will use his speech at Garma to call for an end to the culture wars saying they 'are a dry gully'. Yothu Yindi Foundation/Leicolhn McKellar via NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia Instead Mr Albanese will call on people to push back against people who 'choose the cheap politics of division over the patient work of lasting change or who seek to turn the grace and generosity of a welcome to country into a political weapon'. 'Culture wars are a dry gully. They offer us nothing, they lead us nowhere,' he will say. 'The way forward is to invest in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, trust in their aspirations and draw from their knowledge because when we lay these strong foundations together, there is no limit to what we can build.' New Liberal leader Sussan Ley will not attend the Garma Festival. Instead, shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser – who stood down from the front bench in 2023 because of his support of the Voice – will represent the Coalition. Ms Ley will, instead, travel to the Kimberley in Western Australia for a four-day listening tour with Indigenous communities and organisations. The Opposition Leader will also be joined by Coalition spokeswoman for Indigenous Australians Kerrynne Liddle and WA MP for Durack Melissa Price. Ms Ley said Mr Albanese had a 'personal obligation' to use his appearance at the Garma Festival to detail his government's plan to closing the gap. 'It is not good enough to just give speeches at festivals, we need to see his plan,' she said. 'Since the Voice Anthony Albanese has stepped back from Indigenous issues, that is not good enough. He led the referendum process, a process which was unsuccessful. So what is his path forward?' The four-day event, which started on Friday, will be the 25th anniversary of the Garma festival, which celebrates Yolngu culture – the name of Aboriginal peoples who inhabit northeastern Arnhem Land. The theme of this year's festival is 'rom ga waŋa wataŋu', or 'the law of the land, standing firm'.
Sky News AU
6 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Campbell Newman on what ‘needs to happen' to close the gap for Indigenous communities
Former Queensland premier Campbell Newman discusses the things that 'need to happen' to help the Indigenous community in Australia. In a joint statement, Uluru Statement co-architects Pat Anderson and Professor Megan Davis have claimed the upcoming appearances by Anthony Albanese at the Garma Festival in Arnhem Land will be a 'performative opportunity for the government to repeat their talking points'. 'The focus has to be on building communities that economically prosperous, that are viable, that have real jobs and real opportunity,' Mr Newman told Sky News host Steve Price. 'That means getting young kids to school and staying in school and it means bringing those opportunities instead of blocking them.'
