The villagers who waded across a river to tell us their story
Zach Hope and Kate Geraghty travel to the borderlands near Myanmar, where efforts are under way to rescue thousands of trafficking victims from scam factories. See all 7 stories.
Ayoung woman crouches by a gap in the bamboo fence of Thailand's biggest refugee camp, her head askew, eyes peering through barbed-wire strands at the sparse oncoming traffic.
She is anticipating a taxi – a family member has a doctor's appointment in the nearest Thai town. When the car pulls up, they will need to move fast, as they do not want the attention of the guards.
Almost 40,000 people live in the Mae La camp, a crowded jumble of tin and timber homes and rambling tracks, close to the border with Myanmar. The occupants are mostly Karen, an ethnic group from south-eastern Myanmar.
No one is allowed to leave without special short-term permission, unless to return to the homelands they have fled over decades of civil war.
Even trips to the doctor must be discreet.
Mae La is the largest of nine camps on the Thai side of the border. Many residents, longing for third-country resettlement and peace, have known no other life.
The latest iteration of Myanmar's civil war, brought on by the 2021 military coup that removed the democratically elected government of Aung San Suu Kyi, has added 20,000 people to the camps, pushing the combined population above 100,000.
Loading
'But there is no more space, so we cannot build new houses,' Karen Refugee Committee secretary Saw Bweh Say says. The committee has been operating along the Thai-Myanmar border for more than 40 years.
In addition to increased population pressure, US President Donald Trump's order to freeze foreign aid has crippled the capacity of at least one major non-government organisation to deliver healthcare, water and sanitation.
Another major non-government organisation, The Border Consortium, said on Friday (World Refugee Day) it had been forced to reduce rations to 'well below international standards', though it did not cite the Trump administration as the cause.
While some people get help from relatives overseas and a small number slip out to work illegally, about 80 per cent depend on NGOs for their everyday needs, the secretary says.
Thailand is not a party to the 1951 Refugee Convention, meaning the camp populations are not recognised as such, and are restricted in their movements and activities.
'Life in a refugee camp is you cannot work and you cannot do anything with your daily life,' 70-year-old Mae La resident Naw Mu says.
'When USAID was suspended, we faced a food shortage – they reduced the monthly food ration – and we don't get enough water.
'On the other hand, when you look at the Burma [Myanmar] situation, there is no peace. People face difficulties every day. They cannot live in their villages.'
Naw Shee Eh Plo, the eldest daughter of Karen revolutionaries, came to Mae La in 1997 because it was unsafe at home.
'If we cannot go back to Burma or another country, then I prefer to stay here,' she says. 'I don't have hope for peace in Burma.'
Saw Bweh Say, the Karen committee secretary, hopes Thailand will change its position on recognising refugees, allowing adults to work and children to attend formal education.
Still, he is grateful. For 50 years, the Thai government and people have allowed the Karen refugees a safe haven.
For those still in the Karen lands of Myanmar, life can be upended – and ended – at any moment by military air raids and drone attacks.
This masthead met a group of internally displaced people in the Thai town of Noh Bo, about 50 kilometres north of the Mae La camp.
Loading
The men had crossed the shallow Moei River border that morning – not because of an immediate threat, but because they wanted Australians to be aware of what is happening to them and their country.
The Myanmar civil war, though unfolding in Australia's region, is overshadowed by the conflicts in Gaza and Ukraine, and now Iran. But it is no less barbarous, claiming about 50,000 lives, including 6000 civilians, since February 2021.
About 20 million people – more than a third of Myanmar's population – need humanitarian assistance and 3.5 million people are internally displaced. These young men are among these numbers.
On February 27, the State Administration Council, as the military regime is called, bombed positions of the Karen National Liberation Army, one of Myanmar's many ethnic resistance forces.
The fighting was almost at the village of Pu Lu Palaw, forcing the civilians to wade over the river to the safety of Noh Bo, aided by Thai military border patrol teams.
'We could not even bring anything with us,' Saw Hser Khu, a weathered 39-year-old former fisherman, says.
Hundreds crammed inside the Noh Bo church. Hundreds more slept where they could outside.
When things calmed down, they crossed back to Myanmar, but Pu Lu Palaw was still not safe.
'Mostly, people now sleep by riverbank, but those who are quick, they stay in their homes,' Saw Hser Khu says with a grin, only half-joking.
Some have family on the Thailand side, and this masthead witnessed several family groups crossing the river with sacks of rice and whatever else they could carry above the waist-high waterline.
Military planes are a regular sight and sound above the hazy mountains.
'If the [regime] see a lot of people in the village, they will bomb,' Saw Hser Khu says. 'We were lucky that we were already in hiding.'
Almost all the group living in Pu Lu Palaw has fled there from elsewhere in Myanmar because of the fighting. Now, they are displaced again.
As there is almost no work, the villagers on the riverbank rely on charity and NGOs for most of their needs.
Those with a little bit of money sometimes cross into Noh Bo to buy rice and supplies. Those without often go hungry, the men say.
At the end of the day, it is time for the villagers to leave Noh Bo and return to the Myanmar riverbank.
This masthead follows them down the steep track, past the Thai military observation post. They pause on the way to point out an abandoned regime military base, shrouded by trees at the tip of a Myanmar mountain.
At the river, we exchange thank yous and farewells. Then, they pull up their shorts and pants legs, and wade back to broken Myanmar.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Advertiser
a day ago
- The Advertiser
Australian agencies count cost of US foreign aid axing
In the Papua New Guinea highlands, tribal violence is an unfortunate way of life and, increasingly, death. In February 2024, bystanders were among 49 people killed in a gun battle between clans in Wabag, the capital of the Enga province. That clash was the destructive climax of a spate of fierce inter-tribal battles in Enga, where hundreds have been killed and thousands displaced, fearing for their lives. The reasons behind the violence are complex, including land ownership, with displacement of tribes causing cascading issues around custodianship of country. The arrival of industry, including forestry and mining, can upset traditional community authority structures, and challenge chiefly systems. The single greatest impact behind the swollen death tolls is perhaps the arrival of modern weaponry which replaces traditional weapons with lethal firearms. The UN estimates there are 112 inter-group conflicts in Papua New Guinea, and recent massacres extend beyond Enga. In 2019, more than 20 died in Hela province after an initial attack, which killed six, led to a retaliation including the murder of pregnant women and children. It was in Hela and Morobe provinces that agency Conciliation Resources began a peace-building project, drawing from years of expertise and a scoping assessment of the likelihood of success. "It was to enhance the skills and capacities of the people working on these conflict challenges," Ciaran O'Toole, Melbourne-based regional director, tells AAP. "Working to enable specific communities, in particular those affected by violence, to design and develop their own peace-building work (and) provide ... small grants for them to conduct dialogue or provide livelihood for some of the young men engaged in violence. "It was very targeted on what we would call the drivers of the violence." That was, until a stop-work letter arrived early this year. "It was quite blunt. It was very quick. There wasn't any lead time to wind down. It was just 'stop work'," Mr O'Toole said. The peace-building project was one of thousands axed by the US President Donald Trump's executive order to pause and re-evaluate foreign aid in January. Alongside peace-building programs, multi-billion dollar health initiatives to treat HIV and malaria, food provision, and climate-mitigation projects funded by USAID were ended. Months later, it is estimated that roughly 90 per cent of USAID's $A53 billion annual spend has been cancelled, representing roughly a third of all foreign aid. Australian development agencies are among those counting the cost. In a survey of members, peak body Australian Council for International Development (ACFID) has revealed at least $A400 million worth of projects have been defunded by the United States. ACFID believes that is a lowball figure, given many NGOs are yet to see the full picture of cuts, and others were not able to complete the survey during the upheaval. "This means communities losing access to healthcare, girls losing access to education and families losing access to food programs," ACFID chief executive Matthew Maury said. The hardest-hit region for Australian agencies is the Pacific, with the loss of $A113 million worth of support, predominantly climate change resilience and disaster preparedness, health and gender projects. Other axed projects include education and nutrition projects in Timor-Leste, drought recovery in Fiji, climate-resilient food systems in Nauru, and sexual and reproductive health services right across the Pacific. Given the challenges and sensitivity that comes with securing funding from donor governments, not every agency is keen to speak on the record about their loss. Caritas Australia programs director Dan Skehan said Caritas partners in Fiji and Samoa were also hit by USAID cuts. "They were receiving USAID funding specifically for WASH, which is water, sanitation and hygiene work ... delivering water to much needed communities, be that schools, communities or in some instances health facilities," he tells AAP. In this instance, Caritas Australia - part of the world's second largest humanitarian grouping, second only to the Red Cross - was able to redirect support to these programs at a reduced scale. "(Where) something like vital water to community hasn't been delivered, we've made decisions to at least finalise the project activities," he said. The aid sector has also been plunged into chaos, and in many cases, retrenchment by the USAID cuts. Caritas has shed hundreds of jobs in places like Bangladesh, and a smaller number in the Pacific. "This is an enormous funding cut ... there's been an enormous amount of disruption in the sector," Mr Skehan said. "There would be large number of staff who have been serving communities of very skilled workers who no longer, unfortunately, have a job. "What's most important, and we've always got to hold at the centre, is it's the communities and the vulnerable people that we serve that are most impacted." It's not just the US which is cutting development assistance. In April, the UK cut foreign aid by 40 per cent - a move which shocked many given it came from a centre-left Labour government - while last month, New Zealand axed $A91m in climate-related assistance. Mr O'Toole said the huge US retreat on aid had "given permission to other governments to cut back on their aid budgets as well". "We're all feeling the hurt across all of this change and I think all aid organisations are feeling this pain," he said. The sector hopes Australia, which has made incremental increases under Anthony Albanese, will step up to fill the gap. There are some positive signs from Canberra, including a flexibility afforded to agencies to move funds earmarked for one purpose onto others in light of cuts. Mr Maury hopes future budgets will see aid rise not just in real terms but as a percentage of the budget. "Australia has a proud history of supporting development, particularly in the Pacific," Mr Maury said. "Yet as global needs rise, our aid budget has fallen to just 0.65 per cent of the Federal Budget ... restoring aid to one per cent would reaffirm our commitment and secure Australia's place at the forefront of development." In the Papua New Guinea highlands, tribal violence is an unfortunate way of life and, increasingly, death. In February 2024, bystanders were among 49 people killed in a gun battle between clans in Wabag, the capital of the Enga province. That clash was the destructive climax of a spate of fierce inter-tribal battles in Enga, where hundreds have been killed and thousands displaced, fearing for their lives. The reasons behind the violence are complex, including land ownership, with displacement of tribes causing cascading issues around custodianship of country. The arrival of industry, including forestry and mining, can upset traditional community authority structures, and challenge chiefly systems. The single greatest impact behind the swollen death tolls is perhaps the arrival of modern weaponry which replaces traditional weapons with lethal firearms. The UN estimates there are 112 inter-group conflicts in Papua New Guinea, and recent massacres extend beyond Enga. In 2019, more than 20 died in Hela province after an initial attack, which killed six, led to a retaliation including the murder of pregnant women and children. It was in Hela and Morobe provinces that agency Conciliation Resources began a peace-building project, drawing from years of expertise and a scoping assessment of the likelihood of success. "It was to enhance the skills and capacities of the people working on these conflict challenges," Ciaran O'Toole, Melbourne-based regional director, tells AAP. "Working to enable specific communities, in particular those affected by violence, to design and develop their own peace-building work (and) provide ... small grants for them to conduct dialogue or provide livelihood for some of the young men engaged in violence. "It was very targeted on what we would call the drivers of the violence." That was, until a stop-work letter arrived early this year. "It was quite blunt. It was very quick. There wasn't any lead time to wind down. It was just 'stop work'," Mr O'Toole said. The peace-building project was one of thousands axed by the US President Donald Trump's executive order to pause and re-evaluate foreign aid in January. Alongside peace-building programs, multi-billion dollar health initiatives to treat HIV and malaria, food provision, and climate-mitigation projects funded by USAID were ended. Months later, it is estimated that roughly 90 per cent of USAID's $A53 billion annual spend has been cancelled, representing roughly a third of all foreign aid. Australian development agencies are among those counting the cost. In a survey of members, peak body Australian Council for International Development (ACFID) has revealed at least $A400 million worth of projects have been defunded by the United States. ACFID believes that is a lowball figure, given many NGOs are yet to see the full picture of cuts, and others were not able to complete the survey during the upheaval. "This means communities losing access to healthcare, girls losing access to education and families losing access to food programs," ACFID chief executive Matthew Maury said. The hardest-hit region for Australian agencies is the Pacific, with the loss of $A113 million worth of support, predominantly climate change resilience and disaster preparedness, health and gender projects. Other axed projects include education and nutrition projects in Timor-Leste, drought recovery in Fiji, climate-resilient food systems in Nauru, and sexual and reproductive health services right across the Pacific. Given the challenges and sensitivity that comes with securing funding from donor governments, not every agency is keen to speak on the record about their loss. Caritas Australia programs director Dan Skehan said Caritas partners in Fiji and Samoa were also hit by USAID cuts. "They were receiving USAID funding specifically for WASH, which is water, sanitation and hygiene work ... delivering water to much needed communities, be that schools, communities or in some instances health facilities," he tells AAP. In this instance, Caritas Australia - part of the world's second largest humanitarian grouping, second only to the Red Cross - was able to redirect support to these programs at a reduced scale. "(Where) something like vital water to community hasn't been delivered, we've made decisions to at least finalise the project activities," he said. The aid sector has also been plunged into chaos, and in many cases, retrenchment by the USAID cuts. Caritas has shed hundreds of jobs in places like Bangladesh, and a smaller number in the Pacific. "This is an enormous funding cut ... there's been an enormous amount of disruption in the sector," Mr Skehan said. "There would be large number of staff who have been serving communities of very skilled workers who no longer, unfortunately, have a job. "What's most important, and we've always got to hold at the centre, is it's the communities and the vulnerable people that we serve that are most impacted." It's not just the US which is cutting development assistance. In April, the UK cut foreign aid by 40 per cent - a move which shocked many given it came from a centre-left Labour government - while last month, New Zealand axed $A91m in climate-related assistance. Mr O'Toole said the huge US retreat on aid had "given permission to other governments to cut back on their aid budgets as well". "We're all feeling the hurt across all of this change and I think all aid organisations are feeling this pain," he said. The sector hopes Australia, which has made incremental increases under Anthony Albanese, will step up to fill the gap. There are some positive signs from Canberra, including a flexibility afforded to agencies to move funds earmarked for one purpose onto others in light of cuts. Mr Maury hopes future budgets will see aid rise not just in real terms but as a percentage of the budget. "Australia has a proud history of supporting development, particularly in the Pacific," Mr Maury said. "Yet as global needs rise, our aid budget has fallen to just 0.65 per cent of the Federal Budget ... restoring aid to one per cent would reaffirm our commitment and secure Australia's place at the forefront of development." In the Papua New Guinea highlands, tribal violence is an unfortunate way of life and, increasingly, death. In February 2024, bystanders were among 49 people killed in a gun battle between clans in Wabag, the capital of the Enga province. That clash was the destructive climax of a spate of fierce inter-tribal battles in Enga, where hundreds have been killed and thousands displaced, fearing for their lives. The reasons behind the violence are complex, including land ownership, with displacement of tribes causing cascading issues around custodianship of country. The arrival of industry, including forestry and mining, can upset traditional community authority structures, and challenge chiefly systems. The single greatest impact behind the swollen death tolls is perhaps the arrival of modern weaponry which replaces traditional weapons with lethal firearms. The UN estimates there are 112 inter-group conflicts in Papua New Guinea, and recent massacres extend beyond Enga. In 2019, more than 20 died in Hela province after an initial attack, which killed six, led to a retaliation including the murder of pregnant women and children. It was in Hela and Morobe provinces that agency Conciliation Resources began a peace-building project, drawing from years of expertise and a scoping assessment of the likelihood of success. "It was to enhance the skills and capacities of the people working on these conflict challenges," Ciaran O'Toole, Melbourne-based regional director, tells AAP. "Working to enable specific communities, in particular those affected by violence, to design and develop their own peace-building work (and) provide ... small grants for them to conduct dialogue or provide livelihood for some of the young men engaged in violence. "It was very targeted on what we would call the drivers of the violence." That was, until a stop-work letter arrived early this year. "It was quite blunt. It was very quick. There wasn't any lead time to wind down. It was just 'stop work'," Mr O'Toole said. The peace-building project was one of thousands axed by the US President Donald Trump's executive order to pause and re-evaluate foreign aid in January. Alongside peace-building programs, multi-billion dollar health initiatives to treat HIV and malaria, food provision, and climate-mitigation projects funded by USAID were ended. Months later, it is estimated that roughly 90 per cent of USAID's $A53 billion annual spend has been cancelled, representing roughly a third of all foreign aid. Australian development agencies are among those counting the cost. In a survey of members, peak body Australian Council for International Development (ACFID) has revealed at least $A400 million worth of projects have been defunded by the United States. ACFID believes that is a lowball figure, given many NGOs are yet to see the full picture of cuts, and others were not able to complete the survey during the upheaval. "This means communities losing access to healthcare, girls losing access to education and families losing access to food programs," ACFID chief executive Matthew Maury said. The hardest-hit region for Australian agencies is the Pacific, with the loss of $A113 million worth of support, predominantly climate change resilience and disaster preparedness, health and gender projects. Other axed projects include education and nutrition projects in Timor-Leste, drought recovery in Fiji, climate-resilient food systems in Nauru, and sexual and reproductive health services right across the Pacific. Given the challenges and sensitivity that comes with securing funding from donor governments, not every agency is keen to speak on the record about their loss. Caritas Australia programs director Dan Skehan said Caritas partners in Fiji and Samoa were also hit by USAID cuts. "They were receiving USAID funding specifically for WASH, which is water, sanitation and hygiene work ... delivering water to much needed communities, be that schools, communities or in some instances health facilities," he tells AAP. In this instance, Caritas Australia - part of the world's second largest humanitarian grouping, second only to the Red Cross - was able to redirect support to these programs at a reduced scale. "(Where) something like vital water to community hasn't been delivered, we've made decisions to at least finalise the project activities," he said. The aid sector has also been plunged into chaos, and in many cases, retrenchment by the USAID cuts. Caritas has shed hundreds of jobs in places like Bangladesh, and a smaller number in the Pacific. "This is an enormous funding cut ... there's been an enormous amount of disruption in the sector," Mr Skehan said. "There would be large number of staff who have been serving communities of very skilled workers who no longer, unfortunately, have a job. "What's most important, and we've always got to hold at the centre, is it's the communities and the vulnerable people that we serve that are most impacted." It's not just the US which is cutting development assistance. In April, the UK cut foreign aid by 40 per cent - a move which shocked many given it came from a centre-left Labour government - while last month, New Zealand axed $A91m in climate-related assistance. Mr O'Toole said the huge US retreat on aid had "given permission to other governments to cut back on their aid budgets as well". "We're all feeling the hurt across all of this change and I think all aid organisations are feeling this pain," he said. The sector hopes Australia, which has made incremental increases under Anthony Albanese, will step up to fill the gap. There are some positive signs from Canberra, including a flexibility afforded to agencies to move funds earmarked for one purpose onto others in light of cuts. Mr Maury hopes future budgets will see aid rise not just in real terms but as a percentage of the budget. "Australia has a proud history of supporting development, particularly in the Pacific," Mr Maury said. "Yet as global needs rise, our aid budget has fallen to just 0.65 per cent of the Federal Budget ... restoring aid to one per cent would reaffirm our commitment and secure Australia's place at the forefront of development." In the Papua New Guinea highlands, tribal violence is an unfortunate way of life and, increasingly, death. In February 2024, bystanders were among 49 people killed in a gun battle between clans in Wabag, the capital of the Enga province. That clash was the destructive climax of a spate of fierce inter-tribal battles in Enga, where hundreds have been killed and thousands displaced, fearing for their lives. The reasons behind the violence are complex, including land ownership, with displacement of tribes causing cascading issues around custodianship of country. The arrival of industry, including forestry and mining, can upset traditional community authority structures, and challenge chiefly systems. The single greatest impact behind the swollen death tolls is perhaps the arrival of modern weaponry which replaces traditional weapons with lethal firearms. The UN estimates there are 112 inter-group conflicts in Papua New Guinea, and recent massacres extend beyond Enga. In 2019, more than 20 died in Hela province after an initial attack, which killed six, led to a retaliation including the murder of pregnant women and children. It was in Hela and Morobe provinces that agency Conciliation Resources began a peace-building project, drawing from years of expertise and a scoping assessment of the likelihood of success. "It was to enhance the skills and capacities of the people working on these conflict challenges," Ciaran O'Toole, Melbourne-based regional director, tells AAP. "Working to enable specific communities, in particular those affected by violence, to design and develop their own peace-building work (and) provide ... small grants for them to conduct dialogue or provide livelihood for some of the young men engaged in violence. "It was very targeted on what we would call the drivers of the violence." That was, until a stop-work letter arrived early this year. "It was quite blunt. It was very quick. There wasn't any lead time to wind down. It was just 'stop work'," Mr O'Toole said. The peace-building project was one of thousands axed by the US President Donald Trump's executive order to pause and re-evaluate foreign aid in January. Alongside peace-building programs, multi-billion dollar health initiatives to treat HIV and malaria, food provision, and climate-mitigation projects funded by USAID were ended. Months later, it is estimated that roughly 90 per cent of USAID's $A53 billion annual spend has been cancelled, representing roughly a third of all foreign aid. Australian development agencies are among those counting the cost. In a survey of members, peak body Australian Council for International Development (ACFID) has revealed at least $A400 million worth of projects have been defunded by the United States. ACFID believes that is a lowball figure, given many NGOs are yet to see the full picture of cuts, and others were not able to complete the survey during the upheaval. "This means communities losing access to healthcare, girls losing access to education and families losing access to food programs," ACFID chief executive Matthew Maury said. The hardest-hit region for Australian agencies is the Pacific, with the loss of $A113 million worth of support, predominantly climate change resilience and disaster preparedness, health and gender projects. Other axed projects include education and nutrition projects in Timor-Leste, drought recovery in Fiji, climate-resilient food systems in Nauru, and sexual and reproductive health services right across the Pacific. Given the challenges and sensitivity that comes with securing funding from donor governments, not every agency is keen to speak on the record about their loss. Caritas Australia programs director Dan Skehan said Caritas partners in Fiji and Samoa were also hit by USAID cuts. "They were receiving USAID funding specifically for WASH, which is water, sanitation and hygiene work ... delivering water to much needed communities, be that schools, communities or in some instances health facilities," he tells AAP. In this instance, Caritas Australia - part of the world's second largest humanitarian grouping, second only to the Red Cross - was able to redirect support to these programs at a reduced scale. "(Where) something like vital water to community hasn't been delivered, we've made decisions to at least finalise the project activities," he said. The aid sector has also been plunged into chaos, and in many cases, retrenchment by the USAID cuts. Caritas has shed hundreds of jobs in places like Bangladesh, and a smaller number in the Pacific. "This is an enormous funding cut ... there's been an enormous amount of disruption in the sector," Mr Skehan said. "There would be large number of staff who have been serving communities of very skilled workers who no longer, unfortunately, have a job. "What's most important, and we've always got to hold at the centre, is it's the communities and the vulnerable people that we serve that are most impacted." It's not just the US which is cutting development assistance. In April, the UK cut foreign aid by 40 per cent - a move which shocked many given it came from a centre-left Labour government - while last month, New Zealand axed $A91m in climate-related assistance. Mr O'Toole said the huge US retreat on aid had "given permission to other governments to cut back on their aid budgets as well". "We're all feeling the hurt across all of this change and I think all aid organisations are feeling this pain," he said. The sector hopes Australia, which has made incremental increases under Anthony Albanese, will step up to fill the gap. There are some positive signs from Canberra, including a flexibility afforded to agencies to move funds earmarked for one purpose onto others in light of cuts. Mr Maury hopes future budgets will see aid rise not just in real terms but as a percentage of the budget. "Australia has a proud history of supporting development, particularly in the Pacific," Mr Maury said. "Yet as global needs rise, our aid budget has fallen to just 0.65 per cent of the Federal Budget ... restoring aid to one per cent would reaffirm our commitment and secure Australia's place at the forefront of development."


Perth Now
a day ago
- Perth Now
Australian agencies count cost of US foreign aid axing
In the Papua New Guinea highlands, tribal violence is an unfortunate way of life and, increasingly, death. In February 2024, bystanders were among 49 people killed in a gun battle between clans in Wabag, the capital of the Enga province. That clash was the destructive climax of a spate of fierce inter-tribal battles in Enga, where hundreds have been killed and thousands displaced, fearing for their lives. The reasons behind the violence are complex, including land ownership, with displacement of tribes causing cascading issues around custodianship of country. The arrival of industry, including forestry and mining, can upset traditional community authority structures, and challenge chiefly systems. The single greatest impact behind the swollen death tolls is perhaps the arrival of modern weaponry which replaces traditional weapons with lethal firearms. The UN estimates there are 112 inter-group conflicts in Papua New Guinea, and recent massacres extend beyond Enga. In 2019, more than 20 died in Hela province after an initial attack, which killed six, led to a retaliation including the murder of pregnant women and children. It was in Hela and Morobe provinces that agency Conciliation Resources began a peace-building project, drawing from years of expertise and a scoping assessment of the likelihood of success. "It was to enhance the skills and capacities of the people working on these conflict challenges," Ciaran O'Toole, Melbourne-based regional director, tells AAP. "Working to enable specific communities, in particular those affected by violence, to design and develop their own peace-building work (and) provide ... small grants for them to conduct dialogue or provide livelihood for some of the young men engaged in violence. "It was very targeted on what we would call the drivers of the violence." That was, until a stop-work letter arrived early this year. "It was quite blunt. It was very quick. There wasn't any lead time to wind down. It was just 'stop work'," Mr O'Toole said. The peace-building project was one of thousands axed by the US President Donald Trump's executive order to pause and re-evaluate foreign aid in January. Alongside peace-building programs, multi-billion dollar health initiatives to treat HIV and malaria, food provision, and climate-mitigation projects funded by USAID were ended. Months later, it is estimated that roughly 90 per cent of USAID's $A53 billion annual spend has been cancelled, representing roughly a third of all foreign aid. Australian development agencies are among those counting the cost. In a survey of members, peak body Australian Council for International Development (ACFID) has revealed at least $A400 million worth of projects have been defunded by the United States. ACFID believes that is a lowball figure, given many NGOs are yet to see the full picture of cuts, and others were not able to complete the survey during the upheaval. "This means communities losing access to healthcare, girls losing access to education and families losing access to food programs," ACFID chief executive Matthew Maury said. The hardest-hit region for Australian agencies is the Pacific, with the loss of $A113 million worth of support, predominantly climate change resilience and disaster preparedness, health and gender projects. Other axed projects include education and nutrition projects in Timor-Leste, drought recovery in Fiji, climate-resilient food systems in Nauru, and sexual and reproductive health services right across the Pacific. Given the challenges and sensitivity that comes with securing funding from donor governments, not every agency is keen to speak on the record about their loss. Caritas Australia programs director Dan Skehan said Caritas partners in Fiji and Samoa were also hit by USAID cuts. "They were receiving USAID funding specifically for WASH, which is water, sanitation and hygiene work ... delivering water to much needed communities, be that schools, communities or in some instances health facilities," he tells AAP. In this instance, Caritas Australia - part of the world's second largest humanitarian grouping, second only to the Red Cross - was able to redirect support to these programs at a reduced scale. "(Where) something like vital water to community hasn't been delivered, we've made decisions to at least finalise the project activities," he said. The aid sector has also been plunged into chaos, and in many cases, retrenchment by the USAID cuts. Caritas has shed hundreds of jobs in places like Bangladesh, and a smaller number in the Pacific. "This is an enormous funding cut ... there's been an enormous amount of disruption in the sector," Mr Skehan said. "There would be large number of staff who have been serving communities of very skilled workers who no longer, unfortunately, have a job. "What's most important, and we've always got to hold at the centre, is it's the communities and the vulnerable people that we serve that are most impacted." It's not just the US which is cutting development assistance. In April, the UK cut foreign aid by 40 per cent - a move which shocked many given it came from a centre-left Labour government - while last month, New Zealand axed $A91m in climate-related assistance. Mr O'Toole said the huge US retreat on aid had "given permission to other governments to cut back on their aid budgets as well". "We're all feeling the hurt across all of this change and I think all aid organisations are feeling this pain," he said. The sector hopes Australia, which has made incremental increases under Anthony Albanese, will step up to fill the gap. There are some positive signs from Canberra, including a flexibility afforded to agencies to move funds earmarked for one purpose onto others in light of cuts. Mr Maury hopes future budgets will see aid rise not just in real terms but as a percentage of the budget. "Australia has a proud history of supporting development, particularly in the Pacific," Mr Maury said. "Yet as global needs rise, our aid budget has fallen to just 0.65 per cent of the Federal Budget ... restoring aid to one per cent would reaffirm our commitment and secure Australia's place at the forefront of development."


West Australian
a day ago
- West Australian
Australian agencies count cost of US foreign aid axing
In the Papua New Guinea highlands, tribal violence is an unfortunate way of life and, increasingly, death. In February 2024, bystanders were among 49 people killed in a gun battle between clans in Wabag, the capital of the Enga province. That clash was the destructive climax of a spate of fierce inter-tribal battles in Enga, where hundreds have been killed and thousands displaced, fearing for their lives. The reasons behind the violence are complex, including land ownership, with displacement of tribes causing cascading issues around custodianship of country. The arrival of industry, including forestry and mining, can upset traditional community authority structures, and challenge chiefly systems. The single greatest impact behind the swollen death tolls is perhaps the arrival of modern weaponry which replaces traditional weapons with lethal firearms. The UN estimates there are 112 inter-group conflicts in Papua New Guinea, and recent massacres extend beyond Enga. In 2019, more than 20 died in Hela province after an initial attack, which killed six, led to a retaliation including the murder of pregnant women and children. It was in Hela and Morobe provinces that agency Conciliation Resources began a peace-building project, drawing from years of expertise and a scoping assessment of the likelihood of success. "It was to enhance the skills and capacities of the people working on these conflict challenges," Ciaran O'Toole, Melbourne-based regional director, tells AAP. "Working to enable specific communities, in particular those affected by violence, to design and develop their own peace-building work (and) provide ... small grants for them to conduct dialogue or provide livelihood for some of the young men engaged in violence. "It was very targeted on what we would call the drivers of the violence." That was, until a stop-work letter arrived early this year. "It was quite blunt. It was very quick. There wasn't any lead time to wind down. It was just 'stop work'," Mr O'Toole said. The peace-building project was one of thousands axed by the US President Donald Trump's executive order to pause and re-evaluate foreign aid in January. Alongside peace-building programs, multi-billion dollar health initiatives to treat HIV and malaria, food provision, and climate-mitigation projects funded by USAID were ended. Months later, it is estimated that roughly 90 per cent of USAID's $A53 billion annual spend has been cancelled, representing roughly a third of all foreign aid. Australian development agencies are among those counting the cost. In a survey of members, peak body Australian Council for International Development (ACFID) has revealed at least $A400 million worth of projects have been defunded by the United States. ACFID believes that is a lowball figure, given many NGOs are yet to see the full picture of cuts, and others were not able to complete the survey during the upheaval. "This means communities losing access to healthcare, girls losing access to education and families losing access to food programs," ACFID chief executive Matthew Maury said. The hardest-hit region for Australian agencies is the Pacific, with the loss of $A113 million worth of support, predominantly climate change resilience and disaster preparedness, health and gender projects. Other axed projects include education and nutrition projects in Timor-Leste, drought recovery in Fiji, climate-resilient food systems in Nauru, and sexual and reproductive health services right across the Pacific. Given the challenges and sensitivity that comes with securing funding from donor governments, not every agency is keen to speak on the record about their loss. Caritas Australia programs director Dan Skehan said Caritas partners in Fiji and Samoa were also hit by USAID cuts. "They were receiving USAID funding specifically for WASH, which is water, sanitation and hygiene work ... delivering water to much needed communities, be that schools, communities or in some instances health facilities," he tells AAP. In this instance, Caritas Australia - part of the world's second largest humanitarian grouping, second only to the Red Cross - was able to redirect support to these programs at a reduced scale. "(Where) something like vital water to community hasn't been delivered, we've made decisions to at least finalise the project activities," he said. The aid sector has also been plunged into chaos, and in many cases, retrenchment by the USAID cuts. Caritas has shed hundreds of jobs in places like Bangladesh, and a smaller number in the Pacific. "This is an enormous funding cut ... there's been an enormous amount of disruption in the sector," Mr Skehan said. "There would be large number of staff who have been serving communities of very skilled workers who no longer, unfortunately, have a job. "What's most important, and we've always got to hold at the centre, is it's the communities and the vulnerable people that we serve that are most impacted." It's not just the US which is cutting development assistance. In April, the UK cut foreign aid by 40 per cent - a move which shocked many given it came from a centre-left Labour government - while last month, New Zealand axed $A91m in climate-related assistance. Mr O'Toole said the huge US retreat on aid had "given permission to other governments to cut back on their aid budgets as well". "We're all feeling the hurt across all of this change and I think all aid organisations are feeling this pain," he said. The sector hopes Australia, which has made incremental increases under Anthony Albanese, will step up to fill the gap. There are some positive signs from Canberra, including a flexibility afforded to agencies to move funds earmarked for one purpose onto others in light of cuts. Mr Maury hopes future budgets will see aid rise not just in real terms but as a percentage of the budget. "Australia has a proud history of supporting development, particularly in the Pacific," Mr Maury said. "Yet as global needs rise, our aid budget has fallen to just 0.65 per cent of the Federal Budget ... restoring aid to one per cent would reaffirm our commitment and secure Australia's place at the forefront of development."