
Foreign transfers are now flowing mostly North to South via remittances — World Inequality Lab report
The World Inequality Lab, a think-tank fronted by the economic historian Thomas Piketty, has produced a new study that looks at the unequal North-South wealth exchange through the prism of global trade flows and balance of payments over the longue durée from 1800 to 2025.
Piketty is a prolific author and public intellectual whose work is focused broadly in readable and insightful ways on the history of inequality.
Piketty's latest effort is typically trailblazing and is erected from the foundations of a vast new database on global trade flows and the world balance of payments from 1800 to the present.
The study, co-authored by Gastón Nievas, covers a lot of ground but one of the many things that stands out is how financial transfers are now moving in a North-South direction – largely because of remittances. This is a striking contrast to the colonial era that defined the 19th century.
'No country or world region has ever received foreign income inflows approaching the magnitude of Europe's in the 19th century,' the study says.
This accumulation of foreign wealth to the European colonial powers – an extractive process – had many taps: France imposed a large debt in Haiti in 1825 to compensate former French slave owners for the loss of their property(!), Britain saddled China with a debt from the Opium War, and there were also massive transfers of tax revenues from colonies to the metropolis.
'Today, financial transfers mostly flow from North to South, particularly through private remittances, rather than from South to North, via colonial transfers. For instance, sub-Saharan Africa received very large cumulated net transfer inflows between 1970 and 2025 (the equivalent of +64% of its 2025 GDP), approximately as much as the cumulated foreign income outflows (-55%),' the authors write.
So one of the many trends the study has unearthed is that Africa's inflow of financial transfers since 1970 has exceeded its outflows, and this is mostly explained by wage and salary earners from the continent working abroad and sending part of their income home – and in a big way.
These findings come against the backdrop of a rising tide of xenophobia and racism in Europe and North America, fuelled on the far right by the 'Great Replacement' conspiracy theory which holds that white folks up North are being 'replaced' by a tsunami of dark-skinned migrants from the South.
Of course, there has been significant migration in recent decades from South to North, not least because of the labour market needs in advanced economies with ageing populations. Far-right shrills in the US and France who want to shut down such migration will shut down their own economies in the process.
The findings also underscore the importance of remittances to regions such as Africa. For families these can be literal lifelines of income support, and multiplied many, many times they amount to vast inflows of capital which are at odds with perceptions of capital flight.
Remittances, of course, can also create a dangerous economic dependency for the countries on the receiving end that can evaporate if the needs of the labour market change or an isolationist regime builds a wall.
Lesotho offers an arresting example on this front.
As this correspondent has previously reported, during the peak of South Africa's gold production under apartheid – which relied on a ruthlessly exploited pool of migrant, rural labour – remittances from the wages of Basotho working underground here amounted in 1987 to an astonishing 236% of the mountain kingdom's GDP.
They now equal 21% of GDP, according to World Bank data – a 'remittance shock' without parallel in modern global economic history.
South Africa's mines once employed almost 500,000 foreign workers. That number, according to the last available data, stood at 35,000 in 2022.
This explains why so many Basotho are now 'zama zamas' at the bottom of the exploitative and transnational criminal pyramid of illicit gold mining.
Lesotho's economy has not developed or industrialised in meaningful ways to provide jobs and domestic economic opportunities for its labour force. Exploited by the legal gold industry in the past, many of its young men are now exploited by the illicit sector in the precious metal.
Does that stand as a warning for Africa more widely?
Certainly there is a lot of talk these days about industrialisation and the 'beneficiation' of minerals and stuff like that. And remittance inflows to Africa are clearly important and at a scale larger than many have perhaps assumed.
Africa notably between 1970 and 2025 had a cumulated trade surplus from primary commodities that equalled close to 200% of its GDP, but a trade deficit in manufactured goods equal to 169% of its GDP.
It is surely no bad thing to develop your economy and raise the living standards for most of your population through processes such as industrialisation, and not just as a precaution if the remittance flows are suddenly staunched.
But for now, remittances are flowing one way, and that in itself speaks to enduring global disparities in economic opportunity. DM
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


eNCA
29 minutes ago
- eNCA
Berlusconi family sell Monza football club to US investment fund
ROME - The Berlusconi family on Tuesday agreed the sale of Monza, who were relegated to the Italian second division last season, to the American investment fund Beckett Layne Ventures. "Fininvest (the Berlusconi family's holding company) and Beckett Layne Ventures (BLV) announce that they have signed an agreement today for the sale of 100 percent of AC Monza's share capital to BLV," a joint statement read. "The transaction provides for an initial transfer of 80 percent of the shares by this summer, with the remaining 20 percent to be transferred by June 2026." The cost of the transaction was not specified, but according to Italian media, Beckett Layne Ventures will pay 45 million euros ($52 million), including 15 million euros to cover the Lombardy club's debt. Flamboyant former Italian premier and businessman Silvio Berlusconi, who died in June 2023, took control of Monza in September 2018. Berlusconi had previously owned AC Milan from 1986 to 2017, using his immense wealth to turn the debt-ridden club into a European powerhouse. Under his leadership, Monza played its first season in Serie A in 2022-23. The club remained in the top flight for three seasons before being relegated in May after a disastrous campaign that ended with 18 points, 26 defeats, and only three wins. Beckett Layne Ventures are an investment fund specialising in sports and entertainment led by Brandon Berger, formerly in charge of marketing operations for English club Chelsea. The acquisition is a further illustration of the interest American investors have in Italian football. Eight of the 20 clubs that competed in the 2024-25 Serie A season -- Atalanta, Fiorentina, Inter Milan, AC Milan, Verona, Venezia, Parma and Roma -- have American owners.


The Citizen
8 hours ago
- The Citizen
24 hours in pictures, 1 July 2025
24 hours in pictures, 1 July 2025 Through the lens: The Citizen's Picture Editors select the best news photographs from South Africa and around the world. A robotic police dog and a K9 police dog work together in a crime-handling skill demonstration during the 79th anniversary celebration of the Indonesian National Police held at the National Monument (known as Monas) in Jakarta on July 1, 2025. (Photo by BAY ISMOYO / AFP) Water shoots into the air, up to 20 metres high, from a field alongside the N1 near the Diepkloof interchange, near Soweto, 1 July 2025, as Joburg residents experience water cuts due to maintenance. Picture: Michel Bega/The Citizen A young fan of Italy's Jannik Sinner dressed as a carrot poses for photographs as he stands on the stairs of Centre Court ahead of the men's singles first round tennis match between Italy's Jannik Sinner and Italy's Luca Nardi on the second day of the 2025 Wimbledon Championships at The All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club in Wimbledon, southwest London, on July 1, 2025. (Photo by HENRY NICHOLLS / AFP) DA Deputy Chief Whip, Baxolile Nodada and DA Federal Council Chairperson, Helen Zille speak to the media before laying criminal charges against Minister Nobuhle Nkabane for allegedly lying to Parliament at Cape Town Central Police Station on July 01, 2025 in Cape Town, South Africa. The move comes just days after President Cyril Ramaphosa fired DA Deputy Minister, Andrew Whitfield, for not following protocol and asking permission for an overseas trip. (Photo by Gallo Images/Brenton Geach) A dog walks in a sewage-flooded street at Snake Park in Soweto, 30 June 2025. Picture: Nigel Sibanda/The Citizen Workers install a new 'Point Zero' marker on the forecourt of Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris, France, 01 July 2025. Installed on April 22, 1786, by order of French King Louis XV, the Notre Dame de Paris cathedral serves as a reference for calculating distances to other French cities. Picture: EPA/TERESA SUAREZ Cllr Kenny Kunene during an inspection of dilapidated buildings and illegal water and electricity connections in the inner city on July 01, 2025 in Johannesburg, South Africa. The City is collaborating with various stakeholders to ensure the effective enforcement of by-laws, which is a critical component of the Mayor's High Impact Service Delivery Program. (Photo by Gallo Images/Sharon Seretlo) An artist dressed as Hindu deity Kali gestures during a religious procession on occasion of 'Bonalu' celebrations in New Delhi on July 1, 2025. (Photo by Arun SANKAR / AFP) Participants celebrate a Christian service during the National Day of Prayer and Thanksgiving at the Forecourt of the State House in Accra, Ghana, 01 July 2025. Ghana marked its first National Day of Prayer and Thanksgiving, an interfaith event featuring both Christian and Muslim services. The concept of a national prayer day was first proposed by President Mahama during his 2024 election campaign as a way to unify Ghanians. Picture: EPA/FRANK KPORFOR Britain's King Charles III inspects a Guard of Honour formed by Members of Royal Company of Archers during the traditional Ceremony of the Keys in the Gardens of the Palace of Holyroodhouse in Edinburgh, Scotland on July 1, 2025, on the first day of their Majesties The King and Queen's visit to Scotland. (Photo by ANDY BUCHANAN / AFP) An aerial picture shows a swimmers enjoying the water at the Faversham Pools complex in Faversham, southern England on July 1, 2025. Britain's Met Office weather service upped the number of amber heat alerts on Monday to seven regions, as temperatures hit 34C in London and southeast England. (Photo by Ben STANSALL / AFP) A man cools off at the water jets of a public fountain as outside temperatures reach 37 degrees celsius in Brussels on July 1, 2025. Withering conditions that have baked southern Europe for days crept northward, shutting some schools and daycare centres in France and the Netherlands, and sparking health warnings. (Photo by Nicolas TUCAT / AFP) MORE: 24 hours in pictures, 30 June 2025


The South African
15 hours ago
- The South African
How SA growers are making grapefruit cool again, starting in Europe
South African citrus growers have launched a joint campaign to shake up the grapefruit market in Europe, spotlighting the Star Ruby variety under a new brand: SummerStar Ruby Grapefruit. Led by members of the Citrus Growers' Association (CGA) of Southern Africa, the initiative aims to rebrand grapefruit as a sweet, refreshing summer fruit – not just a winter Vitamin-C boost. According to ITC Trade Map, grapefruit exports to the European Union (EU) only grew by 10% over the past decade. 'We recognised the urgent need to change how grapefruit is viewed,' Barry Landman, chairman of the CGA's Grapefruit Variety Focus Group (GVFG), told Fruitnet . 'They've historically been seen as bitter and old fashioned. But SummerStar Rubies are sweet, tangy and versatile and will help elevate food and cocktail menus if given the opportunity.' To uplift the entire grapefruit category, local citrus growers have pooled their resources. The CGA wants a collaborative marketing push rather than promoting individual brands. 'South Africa is one of the major suppliers of Star Ruby Grapefruits globally, which presents huge growth potential,' Landman noted. 'It made good business sense to rebrand and position it as a healthy and affordable summer fruit, capitalising on the warm European months when consumers are looking for fresh and easy foods.' By working together, the CGA believes it can grow exports, create jobs, and unlock long-term industry potential. Europe was chosen for the launch due to strong and established trade ties and its consistent demand for citrus. The campaign will highlight ruby grapefruit's summer appeal. In particular, how the fruit is a versatile addition to cocktails, salads and beach picnics. 'Many European consumers already know and appreciate SummerStar Ruby Grapefruits for their vibrant colour, sweetness, quality, and health benefits,' said Nicci Stewart, SummerStar Ruby's campaign manager. 'Our focus is on winning over consumers who only associate grapefruit with bitterness – or with something eaten when they're feeling sick or visiting their grandparents.' The GVFG has also highlighted SummerStar Rubies' seasonal advantage, since they are grown and exported during the South African winter. Germany will launch the campaign, thanks to the country's appetite for healthy, sustainable, and affordable fresh produce. 'SummerStar Rubies tick all of these boxes,' added Landman. 'They are produced in world-class growing conditions in South Africa, meet strict EU import standards, and thanks to advanced cold-chain technology, they arrive fresh and flavourful.' The campaign will expand to other European markets in 2026. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.