‘Fungi fatale' and ‘death cap stare': how the world's media reported Erin Patterson's guilty verdict
After a week of deliberation, a supreme court jury found Victorian woman Erin Patterson guilty of three counts of murder and one of attempted murder after three guests died and one almost died after eating her homemade beef wellington lunch.
Here's how newspapers in Australia and around the world responded to Monday's verdict.
In London, the case made the Guardian's front page as well as two inside pages, where the verdict was reported, alongside details around how Patterson covered up – and repeatedly lied about – the death cap mushroom poisoning of her relatives.
The Sydney Morning Herald's front page was dominated by a photo taken of Patterson recoiling from camera flashes through the window of a police vehicle in May – an image only allowed to be published after a verdict was reached. The paper reported the mother-of-two 'did not react, staring at the jury as the verdict was read out: guilty'.
The Age ran with Patterson's 'death cap stare' and, as with many media outlets, a photo from the same series taken in May. A newly public image of the beef wellington leftovers, a key exhibit in the investigation, also ran on the paper's front page, along with images of the murder victims, Don and Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson.
The Australian opted for 'killer in the kitchen'. Much of the national broadsheet's front page was given to its reporting from Morwell, including that Patterson 'could die in jail as the nation's most notorious female prisoner'.
'Fungi fatale' led the West Australian's coverage, alongside an image of Patterson inside the same police vehicle. 'Death cap cook found guilty of three murders', the paper said.
To the Courier Mail, the killer is cooked. 'Finally revealed: how evil Erin first gave herself up', stated the Queensland tabloid.
The Herald Sun maintained the 'cooked' theme as it stated justice was 'served for cold-blooded killer'. Inside, alongside its main story, the paper reported on revelations Patterson 'was crazy' and why the 'quiet country mum turned wicked'.
The UK's Daily Mail featured a six-page special focusing on the 'definitive inside story' of the 'mushroom murderer' – and nudged readers towards its YouTube video and podcast coverage of the trial.
'The verdict ends one of Australia's most intriguing homicide cases', the paper's Melbourne correspondent reported.
Over at the BBC, a raft of online stories around the verdict was led by the headline 'Australian woman guilty of murdering relatives with toxic mushroom meal'. A newly released video of Patterson discharging herself from Leongatha hospital – another key piece of evidence seen in court – featured prominently in the report.
In the US, the 'mushroom poisoning case' also made headlines at the New York Times, which reported Patterson's conviction came after a trial that had 'gripped' Australia.
'The contrast between the banality of the lunch – a quaint small town in dairy country, the familiar menu item, the seemingly typical mother of two – and its lethal outcome seemed to foment more public fascination with the case than with any other murder trial in recent memory', reported the Times.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
27 minutes ago
- The Guardian
News live: Australia reportedly in talks over Ukraine defence pact; childcare provider to install CCTV
Update: Date: 2025-07-08T20:36:47.000Z Title: G8 Education to install CCTV in its childcare centres Content: Australia's largest childcare provider, G8 Education, will install CCTV in all of its centres and allow parents to provide preferences on who conducts nappy changes and toileting after child abuse charges were laid against a former employee, Joshua Dale Brown. Dale, 26, was charged with more than 70 offences relating to eight alleged victims aged between five months and two years old. In an announcement to investors on Tuesday evening, managing director and chief executive of G8 Education Limited, Pejman Okhovat, said the team was 'horrified and appalled' by the allegations. 'These allegations are deeply disturbing, and our hearts go out to all the children and families involved. I am deeply sorry for the unimaginable pain caused to our families and what they are going through.' Okhovat said following the trial of CCTV in several centres, it would be rolled out to all operators in light of the allegations. In addition to greater parents' choice over their children's care, G8 would also commission an independent review into the incident following the police investigation and criminal proceedings. Update: Date: 2025-07-08T20:36:47.000Z Title: RecipeTin Eats cook upset her beef wellington recipe 'entangled in a tragic situation' Content: Nagi Maehashi, the Australian cook behind RecipeTin Eats, says it is 'upsetting' to have become 'entangled in a tragic situation' after it was revealed her beef wellington recipe was used by Erin Patterson to lace a meal with death cap mushrooms. During the trial, Patterson said she made multiple changes to the RecipeTin Eats recipe she was using to prepare the fatal beef wellington two years ago. It was a dish she had never made, but she wanted to try something special for her guests, she said. The recipe is described on Maehashi's website as 'incredibly juicy, edge-to-edge rose pink beef encased in pastry boasting a flawlessly crispy base'. It is only available in her debut cookbook, Dinner. In a post to Instagram on Tuesday, Maehashi requested journalists 'please stop calling and emailing and texting and DM'ing me about the Erin Patterson case'. It is of course upsetting to learn that one of my recipes – possibly the one I've spent more hours perfecting than any other – something I created to bring joy and happiness, is entangled in a tragic situation ... Thank you for respecting my privacy. On Monday, Patterson was found guilty of murdering three relatives and attempting to murder a fourth. Update: Date: 2025-07-08T20:36:47.000Z Title: Welcome Content: Good morning and welcome to our live news blog. I'm Martin Farrer with some of the top overnight stories and then it'll be Rafqa Touma to guide you through the day. Australia is in negotiations with Ukraine about a security pact that could see the two countries firm up cooperation on intelligence sharing, according to briefing documents prepared for the foreign affairs minister, Penny Wong. More coming up. One of the childcare operators at the centre of the abuse allegations in Victoria has told shareholders it plans to install CCTV in all of its sites and allow parents to provide preferences on who conducts nappy changes and toileting. More details shortly. The health regulator has recommended sunscreen manufacturers add safeguards to products containing two ingredients amid concern about their efficacy. We have more coming up.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Mother ‘murdered by former fiancé she took pity on'
'At times she thought it was easier to give in to his pestering than to challenge it,' Ms Oakley said, adding that Ms Mickleburgh told friends and family that she was going to follow through with a promise to spend his 60th birthday at the hotel in Bagshot in April. 'She didn't wish him any ill, but she no longer wanted to live with him and no longer wanted to be in a relationship with him,' Ms Oakley said. 'But part of her also felt bad for him, believing that he had no one else to spend that day with.' Mr Cartwright is said to have spent the morning of his birthday with his other girlfriend in Devon before Ms Mickleburgh picked him up from the station. The pair arrived at the hotel at about 5.30pm and had arranged to have dinner in the hotel restaurant. They are said to have had champagne and cake on the terrace before returning to the room. CCTV shows Samantha changed clothes, but the prosecutor alleged that Mr Cartwright had spent nearly the entire time in the room communicating with other women, including his other girlfriend. During the meal Ms Mickleburgh reportedly started to feel unwell with staff said to have noticed her 'falling asleep at the table'. The pair left, with staff describing Mr Cartwright as 'holding the lady up' as they returned to their bedroom. The prosecution believes Ms Mickleburgh was likely dead by about 1.30am, as at 1.22am Mr Cartwright started deleting images of her from his phone. Mr Cartwright, 61, is standing trial at Guildford Crown Court accused of raping and murdering Ms Mickleburgh between April 12 and 14 last year. He also denies one count of controlling and coercive behaviour between May 1 2022 and April 14 2024. Mr Cartwright called the emergency services to hotel on the morning of April 14 last year after he 'apparently discovered the cold, lifeless body of his partner, lying on her back next to him'. The prosecutor said a post mortem examination had revealed bruising to Ms Mickleburgh's forehead, scalp, right jaw, left neck and the bursting of blood vessels under the skin. A 'blunt impact' to the forehead is said to have been so severe that it fractured her skull. Tests revealed the presence of Mr Cartwright's semen inside her body, the prosecutor said. 'You will have to consider with great care whether…. she voluntarily engaged in intercourse with him,' the prosecutor said. Cartwright denies the rape and murder of Ms Mickleburgh and controlling and coercive behaviour. The trial continues.
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
‘Powerful' punches led to war veteran's death 10 months after attack, trial told
A man landed 'powerful and cowardly' punches on an Iraq War veteran in a street attack that caused him a severe brain injury he never recovered from, a murder trial has been told. British Army veteran Lee Woodward, 39, died in hospital 10 months after he was left brain damaged from an attack by 32-year-old Gregory Twigg in Trade Street, Stoke-on-Trent on the night of June 24 2022, Stafford Crown Court heard. The defendant, who was jailed in September 2022 after pleading guilty to grievous bodily harm with intent for the attack on Mr Woodward, is now on trial accused of murder after Mr Woodward died from complications arising from his injuries on April 26 2023. Twigg, who wore a black jumper and blue jeans for the start of the five-day trial on Tuesday, listened with the assistance of an intermediary in the dock as prosecution counsel David Mason KC outlined the case. He told the jury of five men and seven women that Twigg, previously of Blurton in Stoke-on-Trent, had punched Mr Woodward, who had been on a night out with his fiancee Kate Griffin in Stoke, 'really hard, not once, not twice, but three times'. He said: 'The first punch floored him. The second knocked him back into a car and the last completely knocked him out and he never recovered. 'When Gregory Twigg delivered this (final) punch, we say Lee Woodward was in no position to defend himself. 'He was increasingly vulnerable to a determined attack and as a direct result of this attack, he suffered a brain injury and arising medical complications that resulted in his death. 'There is no doubt that Gregory Twigg killed Lee Woodward, because it was his attack that caused him to die. 'We don't say he intended to kill Lee Woodward, but he intended to cause him really serious injury.' CCTV of the lead-up and the attack itself was played to the jury, showing Mr Woodward leaving The Liquor Vaults pub in Trade Street at around 11pm before his fiancee and walking down towards Hill Street with a man who has not been identified. As he reached Hill Street, he encountered a white Vauxhall Astra in which Twigg was a backseat passenger, before the car makes a sharp turn onto Trade Street and Mr Woodward appears to return to the road to meet them as the driver, Nathan Lockley, and some of the other four passengers get out. While Mr Woodward is focused on speaking to Mr Lockley, Twigg approaches from the side and delivers a 'powerful' punch to his face, knocking him to the ground and leaving him looking 'like a highly dazed boxer' as he tried to regain his balance, Mr Mason said. He told the jury: 'Gregory Twigg tracked his recovery to his feet and landed a second powerful and cowardly punch to his head. Lee Woodward would barely have seen it coming and was in no position to defend himself. It sent his head and body into the parked car this time.' While Mr Lockley and some of the other female passengers tried to get Twigg to move away, he instead 'honed in' on Mr Woodward, landing a third punch to his head. Mr Mason said: 'It was a devastating blow to his head with pinpoint precision, full power and that was it, lights out. He lay motionless on the road, out cold. It was immediately obvious he was very unwell.' While the occupants in the Vauxhall got back in the car and left the scene, an unconscious Mr Woodward was rushed to hospital with a laceration to the back of his head and a CT scan revealed a subdural haematoma on the left side of his brain. He was transferred to a high-dependency neurological ward by mid-July and he had developed a number of complications including an infection in his brain. Mr Woodward underwent eight surgeries by August 2022, could only occasionally open his eyes, could not speak and would likely be bed-bound and require full-time care in a nursing home had he survived. Mr Mason said: 'Moving into 2023 and Lee Woodward's injuries were sadly so serious he never recovered, he never left the hospital and he died in April 2023. 'He died from his injuries and the complications that arose from them. There is no doubt Gregory Twigg caused Lee Woodward's death.' Addressing the jury, Mr Mason said: 'Gregory Twigg has pleaded not guilty to murder. He does accept he caused Lee Woodward's death, but he is going to deny that he intended to cause those really serious injuries. 'We say this matter is crystal clear. Gregory Twigg did intend to cause Lee Woodward really serious injury. He admitted that at Stoke Crown Court in 2022 and was sentenced for that in 2022. 'The intention he admitted to having when he was charged with GBH means he is guilty. Lee Woodward's death is a consequence that Gregory Twigg must now face.' The trial continues.
