
Sinful. Poisonous. Stinky? How tomatoes overcame their wicked reputation
While Salem, Massachusetts gets all the hype for its infamous 1692 witch trials, there's another city called Salem—this time in New Jersey—that's tied to a rather legendary tale where tomatoes were the enemy.
(Witch hunts were common in the 17th century. Here's what made Salem infamous.)
There are many myths and legends about how the tomato was once seen as the so-called 'poison apple,' but how it lost its evil reputation and became a beloved piece of produce is a complicated story. According to historian Andrew F. Smith, author of The Tomato in America: Early History, Culture, and Cookery, the tale involves a farmer and horticulturist who went to brazen lengths to prove the tomato was safe to eat. Aristocrats would fall ill or die when they consumed tomatoes—but it was the plates they were eating on that posed the problem. Photograph by O. F. Cook, Nat Geo Image Collection
In 1544, Italian herbalist Pietro Andrea Mattioli classified the tomato as both a nightshade and a mandrake—a category of food known as an aphrodisiac. The tomato was often referred to as a 'love apple' and kept at arm's length.
Later in 1597, prominent English herbalist and botanist John Gerard called tomatoes 'corrupt' and 'of rank and stinking savor' in his book, Herbal. This statement essentially sealed the tomato's fate in Great Britain and later the American colonies.
By the 18th century, the tomato was nicknamed the 'poison apple' because aristocrats would fall ill or die after consuming them. But it wasn't the consumption of the tomato that triggered their illness or death. Instead, it was the plates the wealthy used to dine on—specifically the pewter plate. These plates contained high levels of lead that, when mixed with the natural acidity of the tomato, caused lead poisoning.
(How the simple fork almost tore apart the fabric of society.)
In his book, Smith notes that some of the earliest references of tomatoes in American colonies were in the late 18th century, but people were growing the fruit out of curiosity, not eating them. 'For those who came to America in the colonial period, it just wasn't on their agenda,' says Smith. The rise in tomatoes with myth and folklore
According to Smith, large-scale immigration to America in the late 19th and early 20th centuries—particularly from Italians, who brought with them the invention of pizza—contributed to the eventual consumption of tomatoes.
(Think you know who invented pizza? These foods have surprising global origins.)
But it was Robert Gibbon Johnson, a farmer and horticulturist from Salem, New Jersey, who had a lasting impression on the general public's opinion of tomatoes. According to legend, Johnson stood on the Salem's courthouse steps in 1820, eating a basket full of tomatoes for all the public to see. When he didn't die of poison, word spread that tomatoes were safe to eat. Despite there being no record of Johnson's actions on the courthouse steps in Salem, that didn't stop this New Jersey town from playing along with the tale. Photograph by Justin Locke, Nat Geo Image Collection
Smith did find evidence that Johnson actually grew tomatoes, so 'it's certainly possible that his work encouraged others to consume,' he says. But Smith notes that a lot of other folks were growing tomatoes at the time, so this isn't the sole reason the fruit became popular. By the 1830s, an array of tomato cookbooks and recipes were being published in America.
Rich Guido, executive director and librarian of the Salem County Historical Society, believes this tall tale is typical of a small rural town that's passionate about their local history, even if the story may have a lot of half-truths.
'We've always had a connection with history and being a rural agricultural community—that's why the tomato story really comes into play,' says Guido. How the tomato lives on in Salem
Although there is no physical evidence or documentation of Johnson's tomato trial, that hasn't stopped people from embracing this tale. Sickler eventually recounted the story to Harry Emerson Wildes, an American sociologist and historian, who wrote about it in his 1940 book, The Delaware. Stewart Holbrook added further embellishment to the event in his 1946 book, Lost Men of American History.
On January 30, 1949, CBS radio gave the narrative even more notoriety when it broadcast a reenactment of Johnson famously eating a tomato on the show, You Are There; Sickler acted as a historical consultant for the show.
In New Jersey's Salem, from 1989 till 2022, the town held the Salem Tomato Festival, where locals and visitors would watch reenactments of Johnson's event, wear costumes, and, of course, eat tomatoes. However, according to Guido, the festival was put on hold when it was revealed that Johnson was a slaveholder to Amy Hester Reckless.
As to why Salem and New Jersey embraced this legendary tale as the obscure history of the Garden State, Curtis Harker, records manager at the County of Salem, thinks it's the love of the Salem tomato—which also involved a certain ketchup company at one point.
(How Henry Heinz used ketchup to improve food safety.)
'It's a combination of the love of the huge flavorful Salem tomato plopped on a hamburger, Heinz Company's citywide aroma making ketchup in Salem City for 100 years until 1977, and the amusing story of Johnson bravely eating a tomato on the courthouse steps,' he says.
Although the lore around Johnson has been tarnished by his slaveholding, the tomato continues to maintain its grip on this small New Jersey town.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time Business News
an hour ago
- Time Business News
English as an Additional Language
The EAL Academy is one of the leading providers in the UK and internationally of courses, training, and consultancy for teachers' working with English as an additional language (EAL) learners. They are also often to referred to as multilingual learners (MLLs). In an educational context, the term 'EAL learner' can be broadly defined as a student or pupil for whom English is an additional language to their native language, and for whom support is required to assist them in becoming proficient in English and enabling them to thrive in an English-speaking environment. As the needs of these EAL learners can be very diverse, the EAL Academy offers a range of approaches to assist teachers and schools in meeting the needs of their EAL learners. Perhaps the most popular of the EAL Academy's offerings are the short 12-15 hour online EAL courses for teachers working with EAL learners. These interactive and tutored courses are suitable for subject and class teachers as well as those taking the lead in EAL in their school. They are based on the needs and experiences of teachers working with EAL learners and relate directly to the everyday situations teachers encounter. EAL beginners in the mainstream classroom addr esses the full range of beginners in English from those with no prior schooling to those with strong literacy skills in their mother tongue and offers teachers a blueprint for integrating these EAL learners into the classroom. The course – EAL and SEND: cracking the conundrum –assists teachers in distinguishing between those learners with language needs from those with special educational needs, offering teachers appropriate assessment procedures and guidance on provision for those where there may be an overlap. The course, Early years and diversity, focusses on how teachers can best develop the English of multilingual learners in the early years of schooling to reflect the diversity of the communities from which they come. There are courses which focus more on the teacher and the role played within the school. Perhaps one of the most popular courses is aimed at teaching assistants who are often tasked with more responsibility for the EAL learners in a classroom. The course aims to give them the skills and knowledge needed to support those new to is a course specifically for primary teachers, one for secondary teachers, and for science teachers. The EAL Academy also offers a 6-month extended online course – Supporting the learning of pupils with EAL in multicultural settings. This course is aimed at teachers who want a more in-depth approach or wish to take the lead in EAL within their school. This course gives teachers access to a breadth of resources not easily available elsewhere. The course is tutored and interactive, giving the participants the chance to learn from a real-life peer group, sharing knowledge and experiences collaboratively. In some situations, it may be more appropriate for the EAL Academy to offer in-house support or consultancy, or in-house training for the school as a whole. This approach has worked particularly well for international schools with a diverse and multicultural student population. The training is planned in collaboration with the EAL lead, the headteacher, or the school as a whole, and will concentrate on the specific areas of need within the school. In some cases, with direct support from the EAL Academy, the school will adapt the EAL Academy's online courses, tailoring them to for their teachers, and targeting the content to the specific needs of their learners and situation. The EAL Academy has some case studies and examples of where this has been superbly successful. The jewel in the EAL Academy's crown is its Quality Mark award. Many schools are already effective in meeting the needs of their EAL learners but know that there is also room for improvement. The Academy works with such schools to assess the work they are currently doing for their EAL learners and advise on areas where there is room for improvement. The schools undergoing this EAL award always report that it has been highly beneficial for the pupils and the school as a whole. In fact, many of the schools undergoing the Quality Mark are very happy and proud to share their experience with others. The EAL Academy runs termly webinars, bringing these teachers into the webinar to talk about their experiences in front of an audience of classroom teachers, EAL leads, headteachers, and more. These webinars are hugely incentivising and very popular. Such a programme as the EAL Academy delivers can only be achieved with a team of truly highflyers! These consultants, trainers,and serving teachers have collectively trained and worked in classrooms with thousands of teachers in hundreds of schools in over 30 countries across four continents. Individually, each team member draws on extensive experience, works with academic rigour, and is driven by compassion. Underpinning all of the EAL Academy's training and consultancy is the belief – tried and tested – that EAL learners do best when they are included in the mainstream classroom rather than set aside to work on separate activities. Best practice is at the root of the EAL Academy's approach and what is good for an EAL learner is good for all learners and the whole school benefits. TIME BUSINESS NEWS

Hypebeast
6 hours ago
- Hypebeast
Visionary Painter Raymond Saunders Dies at 90
Summary Raymond Saunders, the radical American artist known for his radical approach to abstraction and assemblage, passed away at the page of 90. His death was confirmed in a joint statement co-published by his representing galleries — Casemore, Andrew Kreps and David Zwirner — earlier this week. Saunders' oeuvre is defined by his resistance to categorization. Through texture, symbolism and material he challenged the viewer to reconsider assumptions about Black identity and cultural expression. In his assemblage-style artworks gestural brushwork sits beside vibrant color fields, notational markings and found objects, and served as a means of interrogating the dense fabric of American history. News of his passing follows the recent close ofFlowers from a Black Gardenat the Carnegie Museum of Art, where he took art classes growing up. The exhibition marked the first major museum retrospective for the two-time National Endowment for the Arts Awards recipient. Born in Pittsburgh in 1934, Saunders received a BFA from Carnegie Institute of Technology, and later moved to Oakland to pursue an MFA the California College of Arts and Crafts, where he became a professor. Saunders leaves behind a legacy of fearless experimentation through bodies of work that bolsters the autonomy and expansivity of Black artisthood. In his 1967 essayBlack Is a Colorhe wrote: 'i'm not here to play to the gallery i am not responsible for anyone's entertainment. i am responsible for being as fully myself, as man and artist, as i possibly can be, while allowing myself to hope that in the effort some light, some love, some beauty may be shed upon the world, and perhaps some inequities put right.'


Newsweek
7 hours ago
- Newsweek
Dog Learns To Open Door, Owner Can't Believe Who's Also Sat on Front Porch
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A Labrador retriever from North Carolina recently went viral after his owners revealed his latest trick, opening the front door to let himself out; however, they had no idea who was hanging out in the porch with him. In a viral TikTok video shared on Friday under the username @uruguayanprincesss, the dog's owner can be seen walking outside their front door, to find the pup chilling in the porch with their black cat sat on the cushioned chair, keeping his canine sibling company. "My dog has learned to open the door, so now he lets himself and the cat out every morning and they do this," reads layover text in the clip. The caption says: "I aspire to be this level of unbothered." Many pet owners believe that they have to choose between a cat and a dog, but studies show that the two can actually live comfortably with each other, and may even become friends, like the pair in the clip. A 2020 study by Italian scientists, published in the journal PLOS ONE, surveyed 1,270 pet owners who own both a cat and a dog, and found that the two can easily cohabit without much conflict. Findings from the study showed that over 64 percent of the cats and dogs living together also played together; 58 percent chased each other; and 41 percent fought. Almost two-thirds of the pets sometimes playfully "ambushed" each other. While most dogs can be trained to live with cats, some dog breeds are more suited for life with a feline than others. Burns Court Veterinary Care says that, because of their friendly manners, dogs such as Labrador retrievers, golden retrievers, and beagles are the breeds that get along best with felines. Cat breeds that are most likely to accept dogs into their life include Maine coons, rag dolls, and Siamese. Stock image: A black Labrador retriever stands outside a house. Stock image: A black Labrador retriever stands outside a house. getty images The video quickly went viral on social media and has so far received over 1.6 million views and more than 460,000 likes on the platform. One user, Jussstcassie, commented: "I love that they have no desire to run away they just wanna sit on the porch in the sun." Rachel said: "When my black cat learned to open doors, he would go to neighbors houses and walk right in if their door wasn't locked." Erick Madrigal added: "I wish I could trust my dog to do this but he barks and straight lines anything that moves." Newsweek reached out to @uruguayanprincesss for comment via TikTok comments. We could not verify the details of the case. Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@ with some details about your best friend, and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.