logo
Du Val property group heads to court to fight decision to put it into receivership

Du Val property group heads to court to fight decision to put it into receivership

RNZ News13-06-2025
Du Val director Kenyon Clarke.
Photo:
kenyonclarke.com
Some subbies still owed money in the Du Val collapse say their companies have barely survived and they doubt they will ever see a cent.
The Du Val property group is heading to court on Monday to try to fight the decision to put it into receivership and freeze the assets of founders Charlotte and Kenyon Clarke.
The
group of about 70 entities
and the Clarkes themselves were put into receivership by the Financial Markets Authority last year, with the companies eventually put into the more serious statutory management by the government in August. At last count
its debts were more than $300 million
.
Despite that, Kenyon Clarke maintained none of the current situation "was our making," suggesting it was Du Val that was the victim.
Deccan Property Services did painting, GIB stopping and fixing, and provided general labour at a Du Val development in Mount Wellington.
Its owner, Aniket Bapat, said the company was owed about $230,000 - a debt that nearly wiped his company out.
"We've... been just hanging by a thin strand of hair, not even thread," he said.
His was one of about 75 companies listed by statutory managers, PWC, as being owed money by Du Val Construction, otherwise known as Blue River Holdings, a residential building arm of the property group.
Many were family businesses.
Bapat said his company had to use profits from all their other jobs to pay their own staff and bills from the Du Val job, and they had to use a loan and overdraft to help, he said.
Most of the next year's profits had gone into paying off the loan and they were still struggling, he said.
"Even now if we don't see enough jobs coming, we are paranoid... we are literally just keeping the tip of our nose above water," he said.
As the company began to recover, it had put in more safeguards, and Bapat has had therapy to help with the mental health impact.
"It was bloody stressful," he said.
Like the other creditors, he will have to wait for the outcome of the statutory management process to see if he gets paid, but has had to move on.
Lisa Moroni owns Precision Cleaning Services and said she was owed about $80,000.
"It was very hard because... we are a small to medium business and we run pay cheque to pay cheque and that was a massive project for us," she said.
Most of the outstanding amount was from a big, final clean of one of the developments after construction was complete, she said.
"It's a lot of work done in two or three months and when you don't get paid it does affect the business a lot," she said.
They had to lay off staff and move out of their downtown office to cut costs," she said.
An owner of a large concrete cutting and drilling firm who did not want to be named said they were owed about $17,000.
Though it was not as big as some others' debts, it had still been stressful, she said.
She went to Du Val to try to get some money back to no avail.
"We drill a hole through a wall... so if we don't get paid there is nothing that we can go retrieve, like our consumables or materials," she said.
"We laugh that we should maybe go and fill the hole back up."
Bapat said he regretted giving Du Val the benefit of the doubt that money was coming - and had learned a hard lesson to be less trusting.
RNZ spoke to several more Du Val Construction creditors who did not want to be interviewed but expressed similar sentiments.
They said they did not expect to get any money back but they wanted more information from PWC about what was happening in the process.
A handful of other creditors said they had been paid in full and did not have a problem.
One felt if Du Val had been allowed to keep operating, it could have gone on to sell its developments and everyone would have been paid.
The Du Val founders remain defiant, suggesting it is the company and its investors who are the victims of heavy handedness by the Financial Markets Authority and the receivers.
In a lengthy statement to RNZ, Kenyon Clarke said prior to the FMA actions there were no financial concerns that were not capable of being managed and the group was on track to deliver a return to shareholders, investors and contractors.
"We can confidently say that none of this was of our making and was action taken without us being able to fight for those we have worked closely for and with," he said.
"It has been a horrible and frightening thing to witness, and we understand and feel for all those impacted."
It was telling that the FMA had not taken any further action in the 10 months since statutory management, he said.
Clarke also hits out at the PWC saying it lacked business acumen in the development sector and had made the group's financial position worse.
The company would seek compensation, he said.
At the time the government put Du Val into statutory management, it said it was an option of last resort used only where there was complex corporate failure.
It did so because of the complexity and scale, saying there were between 120 and 150 home buyers and commercial lenders "tangled up" in the situation, it said.
Du Val creditors spoken to by RNZ maintain there were sometimes months-long delays in getting paid in the lead up to the statutory management.
PWC and the FMA declined to comment on Clarke's statements.
PWC said creditors who wanted more information could find it on its website, or email the team.
"To most effectively and efficiently work with the large number of entities and stakeholders related to the Du Val Group, we prioritise providing updates when significant matters are resolved or analysis completed," a spokesperson said.
The legal action taking place on Monday is in the civil branch of the High Court in Auckland. There are no charges against Du Val or the Clarkes.
The Clarkes are challenging the Financial Market Authorities' decision to appoint receivers for both for them and Du Val last year, which culminated in the government putting Du Val into statutory management on the FMA's recommendation.
PWC has been both the statutory managers and the receivers for the Clarkes' personal financial situation since then.
Despite the legal challenge, the statutory management and receivership processes have been continuing.
At least part of the delay to allow the Clarkes to appoint a lawyer. They now have Ron Mansfield KC.
The Clarkes have also been given the right to appeal a High Court decision forcing them to be interviewed under oath by receivers, PWC.
PWC wants to interview the couple about the assets in their possession - including whether they were purchased by the Clarkes themselves or by Du Val companies.
So far the couple has refused and it will be up to the Court of Appeal to decide.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Calendar Girls strip clubs forced to take down posts about women involved in employment dispute
Calendar Girls strip clubs forced to take down posts about women involved in employment dispute

RNZ News

time13 hours ago

  • RNZ News

Calendar Girls strip clubs forced to take down posts about women involved in employment dispute

By Ric Stevens, Open Justice reporter of The owners of the Calendar Girls strip clubs have been forced to take down posts identifying dancers suing the firm. Seven women are currently pursuing an application in the Employment Court for a declaration of their employment status. A non-publication order was issued in May, suppressing their identities, after they raised concerns about their safety and damage to their reputations, due to the stigma attached to the work they had been doing. One of the women has now returned to court, alleging breaches of the order by Calendar Girls NZ Ltd, the company named as the defendant in their case. Chief Employment Court Judge Christina Inglis hastily scheduled a hearing this week to hear the woman. "I accorded urgency to the application, given the nature of the alleged breaches and the concerns that had underpinned the making of the orders of non-publication in the first place," the judge said in a recent judgement. The urgent hearing was set down for Thursday, but was cancelled, after lawyers for both sides agreed non-publication orders should be respected. "The defendants confirm that they have removed all offending posts," Judge Inglis said. However, her judgement did not detail what was in the posts. The seven women are seeking a declaration that they were employees of Calendar Girls NZ Ltd under the Employment Relations Act 2000. Being an employee, rather than a contractor, gives entitlement to a wider range of legal protections, including minimum conditions, protection from discrimination, health and safety, and the ability to bargain collectively. In 2023, dancers from the Wellington Calendar Girls club attempted to bargain collectively, after being offered a contract that they said was "manipulative". Nineteen were told to clear out their lockers and not come back to work through a Facebook post, after asking for changes to the way they were paid. In seeking non-publication orders in the current case, filed in the Wellington Employment Court, the seven women raised several concerns about having their identities made public. Women in the clubs use a professional name while working there and are instructed not to give their real names to customers. Chief Employment Court Judge Christina Inglis. Photo: NZ Herald / George Heard However, their case in the Employment Court has been taken using their real names. The women involved in the case feared publication of their identities would "severely impact" their employment and housing prospects, and their ability to travel. They said the stigma attached to their work at Calendar Girls had already led to judgements about their morality and respectability. The women are all young, and fear damage to their reputations and the impact on their families. They also said they had safety concerns about former clients and members of the public. One of the women is a member of a church and worries about others in the congregation finding out. Others have had tenancy applications declined and another woman said she was dismissed from a government agency, when it became known she had worked in the sex industry. Judge Inglis has now ordered Calendar Girls not to disclose the names, identifying particulars or photographs of the seven women who have taken the case. She said this applied to "all forms of communication, including oral, written, electronic and any other medium". The substantive case has been scheduled for a five-day fixture in February 2026. Calendar Girls NZ Ltd is a Christchurch-based company that operates clubs in Christchurch, Auckland, Wellington and Queenstown. This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .

NZTA has not developed national tolling plan
NZTA has not developed national tolling plan

RNZ News

time15 hours ago

  • RNZ News

NZTA has not developed national tolling plan

State Highway 16 full of slow moving morning traffic as the sun rises. Photo: RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly The New Zealand Transport Agency / Waka Kotahi says it has not developed a national tolling plan but is working on a strategic network assessment. On government orders, the agency will be using tolls more to pay for roads. Internal documents in April said managers were going to develop a National Tolling Plan for the agency's board. But Waka Kotahi, in a response to a request under the Official Information Act, said no plan existed, and instead it briefed the board last month about being more strategic. "We are changing our tolling assessments to cater for a broader system network perspective... to provide decisionmakers with a more strategic, system-wide consideration of tolling the network," said the update in June. It was doing tolling assessments of all dozen or so roads of national significance in the works, including the Northland corridor to Whangārei, Mill Road in west Auckland and Tauriko West near Tauranga. "Due to data and modelling complexities associated with modelling tolling proposals for each section of the Northland Corridor, a proposal will be made to the board on the whole corridor" by the end of this year. An expensive overhaul of tolling technology had been going on for several years, however, the national manager of system design told RNZ an update on tolling tech has not been presented to the board.

Government looks to allow more overseas materials in bid to bring down building costs
Government looks to allow more overseas materials in bid to bring down building costs

RNZ News

time15 hours ago

  • RNZ News

Government looks to allow more overseas materials in bid to bring down building costs

Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone The government hopes opening up the ability for building companies to buy more overseas material will cut down the price of construction. On Monday it will release its building product specifications document, which will list international standards for products like plasterboard, cladding, windows and external doors. The aim of the change is to allow more overseas building materials into New Zealand's construction sector. Building and Construction Minister Chris Penk said the products had been given "the green light" to end "costly monopolies". He said there were are thousands of high performing products that had been tested against international standards, but faced uptake barriers in New Zealand because they had not been specifically tested against "our own standards". "This is just the beginning of our work to open the door to more building products, lower the cost of homes and turbo charge the construction sector and there will be more to come," he said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store