Philippine senator's plea to colleagues misrepresented as 'vow to defy constitution'
It was shared after the Senate voted to send back to the House of Representatives the impeachment case against Vice President Sara Duterte (archived link).
The vice president was impeached by the lower house in February on charges of graft, corruption and an alleged assassination plot against one-time ally and former running mate President Ferdinand Marcos.
A conviction in the Senate would require the support of two-thirds of its 24 members, and would see Duterte removed as vice president and permanently banned from public office.
Before the case can return to the Senate, the House must certify that it did not violate the constitution in its handling of impeachment proceedings and that it remained willing to prosecute the case after its new members take their seats.
Hontiveros opposed the motion to send the case to the lower body, calling the decision a "functional dismissal'.
Image
Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured on July 1, 2025, with a red X added by AFP
The clip also spread in similar Facebook and TikTok posts.
"Wow, defy the constitution? You think you're more powerful than the country's laws?" read a comment on one of the posts.
Another wrote: "She really wants to remove the vice president!"
But the clip has been misleadingly edited to omit Hontiveros's full remarks. It was also earlier fact-checked by Philippine media organisation Vera Files (archived link).
A reverse image search on Google using a keyframe from the falsely shared clip found it was taken from a news conference held by Hontiveros on June 9 (archived link).
At the 9:15 mark, Hontiveros was asked if she thinks convening as an impeachment court is optional for the Senate.
"Oh, definitely not. Definitely not," she says before responding further in Tagalog.
"If we look at it and act as if convening as an impeachment court is optional, we will be defying the constitution, we, the senators.
"And that's why I've been saying that will not allow this. As a senator, I will not agree to that."
Her answer is also shown in the transcript of the press conference published on the Senate's website (archived link).
Duterte's impeachment has spawned a wave of misinformation debunked by AFP here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
an hour ago
- France 24
Gaza civil defence says Israeli forces kill 69 people
Israel has recently expanded its military operations in the Gaza Strip, where its war on Hamas militants has created dire humanitarian conditions and displaced nearly all of the territory's population of more than two million. Many have sought shelter in school buildings, but these have repeatedly come under Israeli attacks that the military often says target Hamas militants hiding among civilians. In an updated toll on Thursday afternoon, civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal told AFP that 69 people were killed by Israeli strikes, artillery or gunfire across the territory. They included 38 people waiting for humanitarian aid at three separate locations in central and southern Gaza and a child killed by a drone in Jabalia in the north. Bassal said 15 people, "the majority of them children and women", were killed and several others wounded in an Israeli air strike on a school-turned-shelter in Gaza City. Ceasefire pressure Contacted by AFP, the Israeli military (IDF) said regarding that incident that it "struck a key Hamas terrorist who was operating in a Hamas command and control center in Gaza City". "Prior to the strike, numerous steps were taken to mitigate the risk of harming civilians, including the use of precise munitions, aerial surveillance, and additional intelligence," it added. Regarding numerous other strikes across the territory on Thursday, it said it could not comment in detail without precise coordinates and times. "In response to Hamas' barbaric attacks, the IDF is operating to dismantle Hamas military capabilities," it told AFP. It said it "follows international law and takes feasible precautions to mitigate civilian harm". Pressure has risen for a ceasefire to allow sorely needed humanitarian aid into Gaza at scale and permit the release of hostages seized by Palestinian militants during Hamas's October 2023 attack that sparked the war. US President Donald Trump earlier this week declared a new ceasefire push, aiming for an initial 60-day truce, which he said had Israel's backing. But Israel's leaders held firm to their aim of crushing Hamas, even as the group said Tuesday it was discussing new proposals for a ceasefire from mediators. Strike hits school At the Gaza City school compound hit on Thursday, AFP footage showed young children wandering through the charred, bombed out building, as piles of burnt debris smouldered. Groups of Palestinians picked through the rubble and damaged furniture that littered the floor. Umm Yassin Abu Awda, who was among mourners who gathered at the city's Al-Shifa hospital after the strike, said: "This isn't a life. We've suffered enough." "For two years, we've been fighting just to get a piece of bread," she told AFP. "Either you (Israel) strike us with a nuclear bomb and end it all, or people's conscience needs to finally wake up." Bassal of the civil defence agency reported 25 people killed while seeking aid near the Netzarim area in central Gaza, six others at another location nearby and seven in Rafah, southern Gaza, with scores of people injured. They were the latest in a string of deadly incidents that have hit people trying to receive scarce supplies. Across Gaza on Thursday, Bassal said artillery shelling in the northern town of Beit Lahia killed three people. Further south, he said three people were killed in a strike that hit tents housing displaced people in the coastal Al-Mawasi area. Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties in accessing many areas mean AFP is unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by the civil defence agency. 'Finish the job' Despite mounting calls at home and globally for a ceasefire, Israel's hardline National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir called on Wednesday to push the offensive harder. "Let's finish the job in Gaza. We must bring down Hamas, occupy the Gaza Strip, encourage the transfer" of Palestinians out of the territory, Ben Gvir said in a television interview. To the minister, Israel was now "in a position to achieve" victory over Hamas, which he said would help free the remaining hostages still held in Gaza from the 2023 attacks. "We must bring them back, but the way to bring them back is to bring down Hamas," he said. Hamas's October 7, 2023 attack that prompted the Israeli offensive resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on Israeli official figures. Israel's retaliatory military campaign has killed at least 57,130 people in Gaza, also mostly civilians, according to the Hamas-run territory's health ministry. The United Nations considers its figures reliable.
France 24
2 hours ago
- France 24
Mali junta chief granted renewable presidential mandate
The move clears the way for General Assimi Goita to lead the west African country until at least 2030, despite the military government's initial pledge to return to civilian rule in March 2024. The bill, adopted by the legislative body, now only needs approval by the junta leader himself who rose to power following back-to-back coups in 2020 and 2021. It is the latest in a series of restrictions on freedoms by Mali's military leadership to consolidate its power in the jihadist-hit Sahelian nation. The bill was unanimously backed by the 131 members present in the National Transitional Council, an AFP journalist said. The cabinet, the Council of Ministers, had already adopted the measure last month. The transition is fixed at five years, renewable "as many times as necessary, until the pacification of the country, from the promulgation of this charter", the bill, seen by AFP, states. The transitional president, government and legislative members are eligible to stand in presidential and general elections, the text says. "This is a major step forward in the rebuilding of Mali," Malick Diaw, president of the National Transitional Council, told AFP after Thursday's vote. "The adoption of this text is in accordance with the popular will," he said. When Goita took power, he insisted on Mali's commitment to the fight against jihadist violence and initially pledged a return to civilian rule. But the military ultimately reneged on its promise to cede power to elected civilians by their own deadline. - Repression of dissent - Earlier this year, a junta-led national consultation recommended the move proclaiming Goita president without a vote for the five-year renewable term. The same assembly -- boycotted by most political groups -- also recommended the dissolution of political parties and tougher rules for their creation. Subsequently, the junta announced in May the dissolution of all political parties and organisations, as well as a ban on meetings. The ongoing squeeze on Mali's civic space comes against a backdrop of clamour by authorities for the country to unite behind the military. Since 2012, Mali has been mired in violence carried out by jihadist groups affiliated with Al-Qaeda and the Islamic State group, as well as other criminal organisations. Those attacks have only intensified in recent weeks. The Malian army and its Russian mercenary allies from Africa Corps, tasked in particular with tracking down jihadists, are regularly accused of rights violations against civilians. Mali and its junta-led neighbours Burkina Faso and Niger have teamed up to create their own confederation, the Alliance of Sahel States (AES), and have announced the creation of a joint 5,000-strong force for joint military operations. In Niger and Burkina, political parties have also been dissolved and suspended. Burkina's junta leader Capitain Ibrahim Traore, who seized power in a September 2022 coup, extended his transition at the helm of the country for an additional five years in May last year. In Niger, General Abdourahamane Tiani overthrew democratically elected president Mohamed Bazoum in July 2023. A national conference held in February strengthened the ruling junta by authorising Tiani to remain in power in Niger for the next five years. All three Sahelian countries have turned their backs on their shared former colonial master France in favour of stronger ties with Russia and other partners.
France 24
4 hours ago
- France 24
Europe court says France allowed to fine president portrait snatchers
Eleven protesters had filed an appeal with the European Court of Human Rights, arguing France had impeded their right to freedom of expression. But the ECHR found that France had not interfered with the activists expressing themselves, and that the judicial proceedings could in fact be considered "part of their communication strategy". The suspended fines of 200 to 500 euros ($230 to $590) had been among the "most lenient sanctions possible" and therefore not disproportionate, the court based in the French city of Strasbourg added. All town halls in France display the president's portrait, with Emmanuel Macron's showing him perched on the edge of his desk with two mobile phones and the memoirs of French resistance hero and post-war president Charles de Gaulle behind him. The group behind the 2019 portrait thefts, Non-Violent Action COP21 (ANV-COP21), claimed some 130 pictures had been stolen across France that year. They said it was their "moral duty" to act in the face of what they called the inaction of Macron's government on climate change. The 11 plaintiffs in the ECHR case had exhausted all legal avenues in France, from lower courts to the supreme court, in three separate cases after stealing portraits in Paris and two other locations in eastern France. France's highest court has since the 2019 incident however changed its position. In 2023, it approved the acquittal of another group of activists over stealing the president's picture, arguing it had not been an attack on his dignity and that climate change was a subject of "general interest". It added that the official images of Macron were only worth 8.90 euros ($10), frame not included. Other defendants have since been acquitted in similar cases. Critics had targeted Macron's portrait before 2019. In October 2017, mayors in the central Creuse region turned his picture around so that Macron faced the wall, to protest cuts to local government budgets and job losses. © 2025 AFP
