
Australian woman found guilty of triple murder with toxic mushrooms
Keen home cook Erin Patterson hosted an intimate meal in July 2023 that started with good-natured banter and earnest prayer -- but ended with three guests dead.
Throughout a trial lasting more than two months, Patterson maintained the beef-and-pastry dish was accidentally poisoned with death cap mushrooms, the world's most-lethal fungus.
But a 12-person jury on Monday found the 50-year-old guilty of triple murder.
She was also found guilty of attempting to murder a fourth guest who survived.
The trial has drawn podcasters, film crews and true crime fans to the rural town of Morwell, a sedate hamlet in the state of Victoria better known for prize-winning roses.
Newspapers from New York to New Delhi have followed every twist of what many now simply call the "mushroom murders".
On July 29, 2023, Patterson set the table for an intimate family meal at her tree-shaded country property. This photo taken on June 17, 2025 shows people in a Melbourne laneway walking past a mural by street artist Jarrod Grech of Erin Patterson, an Australian woman accused of murdering three members of her husband's family with a toxic mushroom-laced beef Wellington lunch. - (Photo by WILLIAM WEST / AFP)
Her lunch guests that afternoon were Don and Gail Patterson, the elderly parents of her long-estranged husband Simon.
Places were also set for Simon's maternal aunt Heather and her husband Ian, a well-known pastor at the local Baptist church.
Husband Simon was urged to come but he declined because he felt "uncomfortable".
In the background, Patterson's relationship with Simon was starting to turn sour.
The pair -- still legally married -- had been fighting over Simon's child support contributions.
Patterson forked out for expensive cuts of beef, which she slathered in a duxelles of minced mushrooms and wrapped in pastry to make individual parcels of beef Wellington.
Guests said grace before tucking in -- and prayed once more after eating -- with Heather later gushing about the "delicious and beautiful" meal.
Death cap mushrooms are easily mistaken for other edible varieties, and reportedly possess a sweet taste that belies their potent toxicity.
- 'Not survivable' -
The guests' blood was soon coursing with deadly amatoxin, a poison produced by the death cap mushrooms known to sprout under the oak trees of Victoria.
Don, Gail and Heather died of organ failure within a week.
"It was very apparent that this was not survivable," intensive care specialist Stephen Warrillow told the trial.
Detectives soon found signs that Patterson -- herself a true crime buff -- had dished up the meal with murderous intent.
Patterson told guests she had received a cancer diagnosis and needed advice on breaking the news to her children, prosecutors alleged.
But medical records showed Patterson received no such diagnosis.
The prosecution said this was a lie cooked up to lure the diners to her table.
She also lied about owning a food dehydrator which police later found dumped in a rubbish tip.
Forensic tests found the appliance contained traces of the fatal fungi.
"I agree that I lied because I was afraid I would be held responsible," Patterson told the trial.
A computer seized from her house had browsed a website pinpointing death cap mushrooms spotted a short drive from her house a year before the lunch, police said.
- 'Super sleuth' - Death caps are the most lethal mushrooms on the planet, responsible for some 90 per cent of all fatalities due to consuming toxic fungi.
Baptist preacher Ian Wilkinson was the only guest to survive, pulling through after weeks in hospital.
He told the court how guests' meals were served on four gray plates, while Patterson ate from a smaller orange dish.
But he could not explain why Patterson wanted him dead.
Patterson was a devoted mother-of-two with an active interest in her tight-knit community, volunteering to edit the village newsletter and film church services.
She was also a well-known true crime buff, joining a Facebook group to chew over details from infamous Australian murders.
Friend Christine Hunt told the jury Patterson had a reputation as "a bit of a super sleuth".
Patterson said the meal was accidentally contaminated with death cap mushrooms, but maintained through her lawyers it was nothing more than a "terrible accident".
"She didn't do it deliberately. She didn't do it intentionally," defence lawyer Colin Mandy told the trial.
"She denies that she ever deliberately sought out death cap mushrooms."
The trial heard from doctors, detectives, computer experts and mushroom specialists as it picked apart the beef Wellington lunch in forensic detail.
Confronted with countless hours of intricate expert testimony, it took the jury a week to judge Patterson guilty.
She will be sentenced at a later date. - William West
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Star
12 hours ago
- The Star
Philippines detains 15 police officers over alleged killings of cockfighting fans
FILE PHOTO: This photo taken on March 22, 2022 shows roosters squaring off during a cockfight at the World Slasher Cup 2022 in Manila. The Philippines justice secretary said on July 4, 2025 he has asked for Japan's technical assistance in searching for dozens of cockfighting participants allegedly killed by rogue police and dumped in a lake south of Manila. - AFP MANILA: Fifteen police officers have been taken into custody and are being investigated for their alleged role in the abductions and feared killings of at least 34 cockfighting fans, the Philippine police chief said Monday (July 7). The missing people were accused of cheating in the hugely popular sport, with their bodies reportedly dumped in a scenic lake with a restive volcano. The victims went missing around 2021 and 2022 mostly while on their way to or from cockfighting arenas dotting the main northern Philippine region of Luzon, including in the metropolitan Manila capital region. The unresolved disappearances again drew public attention after a key witness recently surfaced and accused his former employer, a gambling tycoon, of masterminding the killings, with bodies reportedly dumped in Taal Lake south of Manila or burned elsewhere. National police chief Gen. Nicolas Torre III said in a news conference that a key witness, who used the alias "Totoy,' provided crucial details. The cockfighting aficionados and workers were strangled and mutilated before being dumped. Police investigators have corroborated the details and evidence provided by the witness which will be used in criminal complaints to be filed by the Department of Justice against the suspects, he said. The witness has told local TV networks that he decided to speak out because his former employer was allegedly threatening to have him killed. He said he wanted to help ease the agony of families of the victims who had been demanding justice for their missing kin. "I was very shocked,' Torre said when asked how he felt over the disclosures made by the witness, who is under police guard. "It firmed up our resolve to really solve this because what happened was savage and not acceptable by any standard.' Criminal complaints will be filed against the influential businessman, who owns cockfighting arenas and other gambling businesses, and other suspects, Justice Secretary Jesus Crispin Remulla said. The businessman has denied the allegations. Remulla said he would ask Japan to help provide technology to help look for traces of the remains of the victims, which could still be retrieved from the bottom of Taal Lake about four years after the killings. While banned in the United States and other Western countries largely due to animal cruelty concerns, cockfighting has been a popular pastime and gambling sport in many parts of Southeast Asia, including the Philippines, Latin America and some parts of Europe. Cockfighting arenas are found prominently in far-flung rural towns and major cities across the Philippines and draw large numbers of aficionados in an industry that has become a vibrant part of the local culture and a regulated gambling business that generates state revenues and thousands of jobs. The game involves pitting two roosters - with razor-sharp gaffs or steel blades attached to their legs - in a battle often to the death amid the roar of the crowd. The missing cockfighting aficionados and workers were accused of cheating by discreetly taking steps to weaken one rooster or diminishing its chances of winning, including by slightly injuring it, then betting on the other rooster. - AP


The Star
12 hours ago
- The Star
Indian villagers beat five to death for 'witchcraft'
NEW DELHI: Indian villagers beat a family of five to death and dumped their corpses in a lake? accusing them of "practising witchcraft" after the death of a boy, police said Tuesday (July 8). Three people have been arrested and have confessed to the crime, police in the northern state of Bihar said in a statement. Three women -- including a 75-year-old -- were among those murdered. The main accused believed that his son's recent death was caused by one of those killed, and blamed "him and his family of practising witchcraft", the statement said. "After beating the victims to death, the perpetrators loaded the bodies onto a tractor and dumped them in a pond," police said. The murderers and victims all belonged to India's Oraon tribe in Bihar, India's poorest state and a mainly Hindu region of at least 130 million people. Despite campaigns against superstition, belief in witchcraft remains widespread in rural areas across India, especially in isolated tribal communities. Some states, including Bihar, have introduced laws to try to curb crimes against people accused of witchcraft and superstition. Women have often been branded witches and targeted, but the killing of the family of five stands out as a particularly heinous recent example. More than 1,500 people -- the overwhelming majority of them women -- were killed in India on suspicion of witchcraft between 2010 and 2021, according to the National Crime Records Bureau. Some believe in the occult, but attackers also sometimes have other motives including usurping their rights over land and property. - AFP


The Sun
14 hours ago
- The Sun
Indian villagers beat five to death for ‘witchcraft'
NEW DELHI: Indian villagers beat a family of five to death and dumped their corpses in a lake, accusing them of 'practising witchcraft' after the death of a boy, police said Tuesday. Three people have been arrested and have confessed to the crime, police in the northern state of Bihar said in a statement. Three women -- including a 75-year-old -- were among those murdered. The main accused believed that his son's recent death was caused by one of those killed, and blamed 'him and his family of practising witchcraft', the statement said. 'After beating the victims to death, the perpetrators loaded the bodies onto a tractor and dumped them in a pond,' police said. The murderers and victims all belonged to India's Oraon tribe in Bihar, India's poorest state and a mainly Hindu region of at least 130 million people. Despite campaigns against superstition, belief in witchcraft remains widespread in rural areas across India, especially in isolated tribal communities. Some states, including Bihar, have introduced laws to try to curb crimes against people accused of witchcraft and superstition. Women have often been branded witches and targeted, but the killing of the family of five stands out as a particularly heinous recent example. More than 1,500 people -- the overwhelming majority of them women -- were killed in India on suspicion of witchcraft between 2010 and 2021, according to the National Crime Records Bureau. Some believe in the occult, but attackers also sometimes have other motives including usurping their rights over land and property. – AFP