Canada's first PM 'too controversial' for commemoration, federal board rules
According to reports published Thursday by Blacklock's Reporter, the board recommended that Sir John A. Macdonald — who served as Canada's first and third prime minister — garner no further plaques or commemoration.
'The Board recommended that Sir John A. Macdonald be commemorated by means of information to be made available on the Parks Canada website and that no plaque be erected,' read minutes of a Dec. 12, 2023 meeting of Parks Canada's Historic Sites and Monuments Board, obtained by Blacklock's via an access to information request.
The board reviewed and revised Macdonald's designation as a National Historic Person in 2024, which according to a statement on a Parks Canada website on Macdonald's legacy aligns with Call to Action no. 79 of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission — calling on the federal government to 'develop a reconciliation framework for Canadian heritage and commemoration.'
LILLEY: Sir John A's statue at Queen's Park is free at last
WARMINGTON: Sir John A. Macdonald's home reopens with rewritten history
Minutes from the meeting suggest members agreed Macdonald is now a 'polarizing and controversial figure in Canadian history' with 'complex' legacies.
'Given that Macdonald continues to be a polarizing figure, the Board noted the challenge of crafting a statement that views him from multiple perspectives and that there will continue to be public dialogue about Macdonald's legacy to present-day Canada,' the meeting's minutes stated.
'The Board then turned to consider whether or not it was appropriate to erect a plaque for Sir John A. Macdonald.'
The board concluded that existing statues and commemorations, including his gravesite at Cataraqui Cemetery in Kingston, were sufficient without introducing more.
Activism over Macdonald's legacy led to a widespread erasure across Canada, ranging from statues violently toppled to a rash of renamings, including schools and the Ottawa River Parkway — formerly known as the Sir John A. Macdonald Parkway as of 2023 is now known as 'Kichi Zibi Mikan.'
A statue of Sir John A. Macdonald at Queen's Park, unveiled in 1894, spent five years enclosed in a wooden box until the coverings were removed earlier this month.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
44 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Christian Singer Faces Anger Over MAGA Ties Ahead of Canada Concert
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Christian singer Sean Feucht is facing anger ahead of a concert in Canada, with its venue having been changed after people threatened to protest the original Parks Canada venue. Newsweek has reached out to Feucht via email for comment. Why It Matters Feucht is an Pro-Trump American Christian singer-songwriter and founder of the Let Us Worship movement. He unsuccessfully ran as a Republican candidate in California's 3rd congressional district in 2020. Born in Montana, he founded Hold The Line, which is described on Feucht's website as "A movement seeking to engage the church and young people to inform, educate, and inspire the next generation of leaders to stand for what is right in the governmental arena." Left, Israel supporters, including Christian evangelical Sean Feucht, holding guitar, participate in the United for Israel march outside of Columbia University in New York City on April 25, 2024 . Right, an LGBTQ+ flag is... Left, Israel supporters, including Christian evangelical Sean Feucht, holding guitar, participate in the United for Israel march outside of Columbia University in New York City on April 25, 2024 . Right, an LGBTQ+ flag is seen at the Madrid Pride Parade in Madrid, Spain, on July 5, 2025. More/David Benito/WireImage What To Know Feucht's concert was originally slated to take place at the York Redoubt National Historic Site near Halifax, but a permit was ultimately revoked because of safety concerns, following planned protests. In an email sent to Newsweek, the Parks Canada Media Relations Team shared a statement that read in part: "Parks Canada is aware that members of the public have expressed concern about an event scheduled to take place at York Redoubt National Historic Site on July 23, 2025." The statement detailed that this event was not a Parks Canada event but was instead to have been hosted by a permit holder. "After careful review, and due to heightened public safety concerns, Parks Canada has notified the organizer that the permit has been revoked," the statement read. A public event page on Facebook was titled "Protest MAGA dude in Halifaz at York Dedoubt Nat'l Park." The description for this event has been updated to read "THE PERMIT FOR THIS GROSS PERSON HAS BEEN REVOKED DUE TO SAFETY CONCERNS." It also read in part that "He [Feucht] spreads intolerance and hate under the name of religion." A post about the concert was also shared on the public Facebook group Gay Nova Scotia (2SLGBTQIA+). It read in part that the person posting wanted to make the community aware of the concert, which it described as "concerning," and said that individuals could email Parks Canada to try to stop it from happening. Following confirmation that the permit for the event at the park had been revoked, a post was updated to read "WE WON WE WON WE WON!!!!!!!! LOVE WINS." Local residents described the concert as "upsetting" and "inappropriate" while speaking to the outlet, CBC. Feucht has previously been criticized over remarks he has made about the LGBTQ+ community and for his pro-life stance. The In the News section on his website lists appearances on NewsMax, Breitbart and Steve Bannon's War Room Podcast. Feucht first rose to prominence with his Let Us Worship tour in the latter half of 2020, which protested COVID-19 lockdowns. In April of 2022, he helped to lead a protest against The Walt Disney Company for their opposition to anti-LGBTQ legislation and in early 2023, he announced a "Kingdom to the Capitol" tour. This was co-sponsored by Turning Point USA, the nonprofit that advocates for conservative politics at high schools and university campuses. What People Are Saying Sean Feucht wrote in a post shared to X: "We will all get to witness if free speech and freedom of religion still exist in Canada." The Parks Canada Media Relations team said in a statement shared with Newsweek: "Due to evolving safety and security considerations based on confirmation of planned protests, input from law enforcement, and the security challenges with the configuration of York Redoubt, Parks Canada has reassessed the conditions of the permit and potential impacts to community members, visitors, concert attendees and event organizers. After careful review, and due to heightened public safety concerns, Parks Canada has notified the organizer that the permit has been revoked." What's Next CBC reported that Feucht's free concert will now be staged in a rural area about 60 kilometres north of Halifax.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
'Content' of trade talks with U.S. matters more than dates, Moe says
Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe says zero tariffs 'across the board' should be the goal for trade talks with the U.S. — but Canada needs to ensure 'we have lower tariffs than any other country' given the relationship with the U.S.
CBS News
2 hours ago
- CBS News
Russian aircraft spotted and tracked flying near Alaska again, NORAD says
Russian military planes were detected flying near the coast of Alaska on Tuesday, the North American Aerospace Defense Command said, marking the latest in a string of sightings in recent months. The planes were not considered a threat, as Russian activity in that airspace happens regularly, according to the military command. U.S. officials have not specified the type of aircraft spotted this week or how many of them were there. CBS News has reached out to NORAD for more information. The aircraft flew through a section of international airspace called the Alaskan Air Defense Identification Zone (ADIZ), which is a designated area just outside of U.S. and Canadian sovereign space that both countries surveil closely for national security reasons. Aircraft are also expected to identify themselves when entering this region. NORAD said it tracked the Russian planes after detecting them and confirmed that they remained in the international zone. "NORAD employs a layered defense network of satellites, ground-based and airborne radars and fighter aircraft to detect and track aircraft and inform appropriate actions," the command said in a news release, adding that it "remains ready to employ a number of response options in defense of North America." Military officials in the U.S. have reported the presence of Russian planes in the ADIZ a handful of times already since the beginning of the year. In April, NORAD said the command had detected Russian warplanes flying off the coast of Alaska, within the bounds of the defense identification zone. Less than three months earlier, the U.S. and Canada scrambled fighter jets to follow Russian warplanes seen over the Arctic, in an incident that drew some scrutiny as the region became a source of increasing geopolitical tension. The U.S. military said it later dispatched two F-16 fighter jets from Alaska to Greenland, to "forward posture NORAD presence in the Arctic." In September 2024, NORAD posted dramatic video of a Russian fighter jet flying "within just a few feet" of NORAD aircraft off the coast of Alaska. At the time, a U.S. general said "the conduct of one Russian Su-35 was unsafe, unprofessional, and endangered all." Two months before that incident, the U.S. military said it intercepted four Russian and Chinese bombers in international airspace off the Alaskan coast.
