‘They got it all wrong': Teenager's action against HSE over eye-squint surgeries settled for €120,000
The girl, now a teenager, settled an action against the HSE on Thursday for €120,000 over her treatment at University Hospital Waterford.
The settlement was reached without an admission of liability.
In the girl's case it was claimed the surgery she had for a downward-looking eye allegedly caused an overcorrection and her eye then looked upward.
READ MORE
It was claimed that after the six surgeries the girl was left in a worse condition than she was in 2012 when she first had surgery as a toddler.
Alan Keating SC, for the girl, told the court she was six-months-old when she was taken to the hospital as she had a congenital squint in her left eye.
Counsel said that between the ages of two and seven years the girl had six surgeries involving the eye muscles, which their side would say 'were either wrong or should not have taken place at all'.
Mr Keating said the first surgery resulted in an overcorrection where the child's eye then deviated upwards. Her right eye, which did not have a squint, was also operated on.
'Really, they got it all wrong,' he said at one stage.
Mr Keating said the surgeries did not affect the girl's eyesight, but there is 'a profound cosmetic issue'.
He said experts on their side would say that if nothing was done then it was likely the girl would now have a normal appearance.
Experts on their side would also say that further squint surgery would be challenging, hazardous and unpredictable.
In the proceedings against the HSE, it was claimed there was an alleged failure to discuss fully the risks and benefits of operating before the first surgery, including the risk of not improving the condition and needing further surgical procedures.
There was also, it was claimed, an alleged failure to have such a conversation with the girl's parents in advance of the procedures.
All the claims were denied.
Approving the settlement, Mr Justice Paul Coffey said it was fair and reasonable and he conveyed his best wishes to the teenager.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
34 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Three companies paid €71m to reduce hospital waiting lists – one of which received more than €54m, HSE figures reveal
One of the companies was paid in the region €54.6m, according to the figures provided to the Oireachtas health committee. The other two were each paid €10m and over €5m. The figures supplied to the committee come after HSE chief Bernard Gloster said earlier this week it was planned to phase out of the use of these companies over the next year. They are hired by hospitals and the wider health service to help reduce waiting list backlogs. He told the health committee that a trawl carried out by the HSE covering 27 months found around €100m in total was paid out to these companies during that time employing the external companies to carry out waiting list work using public facilities in the evenings and weekends. The HSE review – which followed recent controversies – also shows that 83 directors of these companies are current or previous employees of the HSE. Some 23 are current employees – working in the HSE while also serving as directors of companies hired by hospitals to reduce backlogs of waiting list patients. He told the committee earlier this week he planned to phase out this form of insourcing in public hospitals by the end of June this year and it was not possible to do it immediately. These companies have grown in 'level and scale. We took our eye off the ball. We need to unwind it,' he told the committee. He add that the 'only way to change it is to stop it.' The winding down must be done 'sensibly', he added. He pointed out there is nothing unlawful about being a company director and there are obligations under the Standards in Public Office or employment contract terms. The review had found an over-reliance on these external companies – several of which had links to hospitals. He said the plan is to introduce more safeguards around them and he is to work with Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill on strengthening these. The review examined 148 companies which had 365 directors in total and found 93 matches with current or previous HSE employees. The implications for removing these companies from carrying out the work is that there is potential for having to use more private hospitals to treat public patients. The aim is to increase productivity through routine work.
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Only 10% of people with ADHD have been assessed or treated, says charity
As little as 10% of people with ADHD in Ireland are prescribed with medication, despite a surge in demand. Ken Kilbride, the chief executive of ADHD Ireland, acknowledged an increase in prescribing but cautioned that it is from a very low base. A total of 25,715 patients were prescribed medication for ADHD on the medical card, or other public health schemes last year, compared to 10,327 in 2020, information released under the Freedom of Information Act showed. However, this needs to be compared with an estimated 5% prevalence rate for ADHD in Ireland, Mr Kilbride cautioned. 'There's probably about 250,000 people in Ireland that do have ADHD, so 25,000 taking medication is only 10%,' he said. 'We've gone from few thousand people up to 10% but there's still 90% that haven't been assessed or treated. Good start, more to do.' Non-medical management is usually the first step, he explained, and then medication in parallel with this, if necessary. There are private psychiatrists also supporting ADHD patients, but he said: 'There's only a handful to be honest.' Dublin South East had the most patients receiving reimbursements for ADHD medicines under the drug payment scheme at 1,261. 'They would have opened up a clinic there in the last couple of years, and the clinic got overwhelmed in terms of the number of people coming through it,' he said. 'They're not taking new referrals, and that clinic might be part of the Local Health Offices in Dublin South East.' In contrast, the data showed just 79 prescriptions on medical cards last year in West Cork, the lowest nationally. While there is a clinic in Cork City, he said: 'People living in West Cork are that little bit further out, so they're likely not getting into see them.' He added the figure of 79 is 'absolutely not' reflective of the likely true number there. Camhs He also raised concerns about waiting times for Child & Adolescent Mental Health Services (Camhs) in Cork and Kerry, also released under the Freedom of Information Act. It is accepted many of these children are waiting for ADHD assessment. 'At the top of the list children waiting 15 to 18 months make up about 70% to 80%, so people aren't getting seen quickly,' he warned. 'Why are people waiting this long? It is an indication of the lack of staffing in the service. The HSE will say we have moved this up the priority list.' He added: 'They have reduced the waiting lists but there's still more people on it now than two years ago because there's more people coming into the system.' Read More Cork and Kerry mental health services have fewer staff now than during staffing crisis two years ago
The Irish Sun
5 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Third of Brits are ‘obsessed' with tracking their health… from diet to sleep, survey shows
ONE in three Brits admit they're obsessed with tracking their health - including diet, heart rate, and sleep quality. A poll of 2,000 adults found 23 per cent of trackers can't go a day without logging updates. 2 A survey of 2,000 Brits found that 1 in 3 are obsessed with health tracking Credit: Getty 2 The survey found 22% said it helps ensure they eat a balanced diet Credit: Getty Among the apps used were But while 18 per cent keep tabs on their health to ensure they don't forget things, 31 per cent said it makes them feel better about their overall health. And 22 per cent claim it ensures they eat a balanced diet. While 24 per cent believe being so stringent can help them prevent illnesses in the future. Annika Bizon from Samsung UK & Ireland, which commissioned the research following the launch of its One UI 8 watch, which includes bedtime guidance and an antioxidant measuring feature, said: 'As we look to the future of health tech, it's clear that wellbeing won't just shape the big moments, but it will also guide the everyday ones too. 'From what time we go to bed, to how we 'It's no longer about extremes, but consistency.' The study also found trackers are also keeping an eye on their heart rate (28 per cent), sleep quality (25 per cent) and Most read in Health But one in four adults would like to be able to monitor how their body responds to different foods, and 18 per cent would love to know how their 'mental clarity' was at any given moment. Just under half (46 per cent) believe Back pain exercises Half (51 per cent) appeared to be keen on smarter support, rather than purely data, liking the idea of using a watch that could indicate a suitable And 41 per cent said wearable tech often helps keep them motivated due to being able to track their progress. With 83 per cent believing it's important to see the long-term effects of their health habits. However, nearly a third (32 per cent) confessed they sometimes feel overwhelmed by how much health data they're trying to keep on top of. Although 55 per cent 'always or often' feel motivated to exercise, move, or do other healthy things, because of their wearable tech. Leaving 31 per cent of those who keep an eye on these things feeling more in control, with 25 per cent reporting increased fitness, according to the figures. With the top micro habits being drinking more water (51 per cent), spending time outdoors (41 per cent) or taking vitamins or supplements (40 per cent). Read more on the Irish Sun Of all respondents, 80 per cent believe small daily changes can lead to major health benefits over time. The research was commissioned by Samsung in the lead up to the Samsung Unpacked 2025 on 9th July, when the next generation of Galaxy mobile devices will be unveiled, which include a new artificial intelligence-powered interface. TOP 20 THINGS BRITS TRACK: Steps walked Weight Blood pressure Heart rate Sleep quality Sleep duration Workout or exercise routines Calories burned Fitness goals (e.g. running time) Water intake Calories eaten Blood sugar Stress levels Menstrual cycle Screen time Medications taken Energy levels Cholesterol Alcohol intake Breathing exercises
