Michael Vaughan Questions ICCs Double Standards As England Docked WTC Points For Over-rate But India Avoids Penalty
England Penalised Despite Lord's Victory
The ICC announced that England were two overs short after considering time allowances, triggering penalties under Article 16.11.2 of the WTC playing conditions. As a result, England lost two crucial WTC points and were fined 10% of their match fee under Article 2.22 of the ICC Code of Conduct.
The sanctions came as a significant blow, particularly as England had moved up to second in the WTC standings following their win. The deduction dropped their tally from 24 to 22 points, reducing their points percentage from 66.67% to 61.11% and pushing them down to third place.
Vaughan Calls Out ICC's Double Standards
Vaughan expressed his discontent on X (formerly Twitter), writing,
'Let's be honest both teams over rates at Lord's were very very poor… How only one team has been reprimanded is beyond me.'
Let's be honest both teams over rates at Lords were very very poor .. How only 1 team has been reprimanded is beyond me .. #ENGvsIND — Michael Vaughan (@MichaelVaughan) July 16, 2025
The former captain's remarks have sparked fresh debate about the transparency and fairness of the ICC's disciplinary procedures, especially given that no penalty was announced for India, who were also perceived to be lagging in over rates during the same Test.
India Escape Sanctions, Remain in Fourth
India, despite having a similar over-rate issue according to Vaughan and other observers, faced no official penalty from the ICC. The team currently sits in fourth place on the WTC standings with one win in three matches and a points percentage of 33.33%.
This discrepancy has added fuel to concerns among fans and former players over the consistency of over-rate rulings and their long-term impact on WTC standings.
Sri Lanka Benefit from England's Slip
England's points deduction helped Sri Lanka leapfrog into second place on the WTC table behind leaders Australia. With each point holding significant value in the tightly contested WTC race, especially with the final often determined by slim margins, the sanctions have already begun to influence the dynamics of the championship.
Calls for Greater Transparency in WTC Rules
Vaughan's criticism has reignited calls for the ICC to implement more consistent enforcement and clearer communication regarding over-rate penalties. With teams vying for a coveted spot in the WTC final, stakeholders are urging the governing body to ensure a level playing field in terms of disciplinary actions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
35 minutes ago
- India.com
Joe Root just 204 runs away from creating world record...set to achieve THIS feat in the 4th Test vs India
Joe Root Joe Root had a disappointing start to the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy, but in the 3rd Test at Lord's, he bounced back with an impressive century, his 37th in Test cricket. Root's hundred helped England post a total of 378 runs in the first innings. England were dismissed for 192 in their second innings, and if they had given away a lead, the 22-run victory might have slipped out of their hands. Root is one of the most consistent batters. Following his hundred, he will now be looking to score more runs in the remainder of the series. If Root plays his natural game, England's win percentage will automatically increase, as he is one of the most reliable batsmen in the England lineup. Meanwhile, Root is getting close to achieving a historic feat in the WTC. He will become the first player in the world to reach 6000 runs in the World Test Championship. Root is currently the leading run scorer in WTC, with 5796 runs, and also has the most no. of centuries in the league-19. The fact that Steve Smith, the next best, has scored 4,278 runs, more than 1,500 runs less than Root, shows how dominant Root is in the World Test Championship (WTC). Despite Joe Root's brilliance, England have failed to reach the WTC final in the first three editions. Currently leading 2-1 against India, a win in the final two Tests would give them a strong start to the new WTC cycle. While the upcoming Ashes series in Australia will be a tough challenge with few expecting an England win they have a promising path ahead. England has a good chance to push for WTC final qualification with home series against Pakistan and New Zealand, away trips to Bangladesh, and a weakened South Africa.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
EXCLUSIVE: Inspired by 2006 FIFA World Cup glory, Italy's cricket 'underdogs' take aim at T20 World Cup
Italy booked their maiden berth in a T20 World Cup, coming via the European Qualifiers. (Image: Instagram) NEW DELHI: Forza Italia! Forza Italia! The chants still reverberate in the ears of Thomas Draca after Italy secured a historic qualification for the 2026 ICC Men's T20 World Cup. Italy booked their place in the mega event, set to be held in India and Sri Lanka, by defeating hosts Netherlands in the ICC Men's T20 World Cup Europe Region Final. With the Italian flag draped over his shoulders and tears in his eyes, pacer Draca took a heartfelt victory lap around the Sportpark Westvliet in Voorburg, Netherlands. It was a deeply emotional moment — not just for Draca, but for all of Italy. Long celebrated as a football-mad nation that has produced legends like Alessandro Del Piero, Gianluigi Buffon, Andrea Pirlo, Franco Baresi, Paolo Maldini, Roberto Baggio and Francesco Totti, Italy is now scripting a new chapter — one that puts cricket on the national sporting map. For Draca, it's just the beginning — marking the start of a fresh era for cricket in Italy. "Honestly, I can't believe it. It's just all surreal at the moment. It's been a work in progress. And I think, you know, you look at our squad now — when we get our main squad in — we're excited and thrilled to be a part of it. But we're also thrilled to be able to compete at the international level. And that's what we all believe. That's the whole goal," Draca told by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo "We know we'll be the underdogs, but it's more than just going to the World Cup. It's the start of something new. We've wanted to create a foundation for cricket - to inspire young kids to pick up a bat instead of just playing football at school. So for us, it's more than just qualifying for a World Cup. It's the start of something special," he said. Cricket may never reach football's level in Italy, but to do something even close would mean a lot. Thomas Darcy Draca was just six years old when Italy lifted the FIFA World Cup in 2006 — their fourth title — after a 5–3 victory over France in a dramatic penalty shootout. The memories of that iconic win remain fresh for the right-arm pacer, who once dreamed of becoming a footballer. Playing in a World Cup had always been his childhood dream, but destiny had other plans. Now, he's set to represent Italy on the global stage — not in football, but in cricket. "When we call Italy, the football stars come to mind. But this is the first time cricket is stepping up. There have been players who've been involved since the early 2000s. You look at Gareth Berg — he's devoted much of his career to cricket in Italy. So, it's not just the last year or two. Joe Burns made his debut in 2015. I actually met one of the early captains of Italy's qualifying days. He came to the ground and told me, 'You're one of my heroes. ' I was like, 'What do you mean?' And he said, 'I flew across to witness this special event.' He played back in 2016 when Italy was fighting to qualify for division cricket," he said. "Joe Burns keeps joking that I am the new Totti. And we've seen comments about how Italy couldn't qualify for the Football World Cup, but here we are qualifying in cricket! For me, the 2006 Italy football team that won the World Cup was inspirational. I remember when they knocked Australia out, and I was always a football fan. I only started taking cricket seriously at 16. I played football growing up, so the Serie A legends have always been heroes. Cricket may never reach football's level in Italy, but to do something even close would mean a lot." As the team continues to celebrate their qualification for the T20 World Cup, Draca remains confident that this squad has something special — a unique spark — and believes they are capable of creating their own piece of history. "We're representing a nation that's still new to cricket, but we want to inspire the next generation. 10-20 years ago, that idea wouldn't have existed. But now, it's becoming a reality. "The Federation has always supported us — people like Peter and Michael Di Venuto played in the early 2000s. Gareth Berg's been here since 2012–13. And now, we've got players in the peak of their careers, like Burns, the Manenti brothers (Ben Manenti and Harry Manenti), and Grant Stewart," the 24-year-old said. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
IND vs ENG: Karun Nair vs Sai Sudharsan? Former India player makes a blunt assessment
Karun Nair and Sai Sudharsan (Getty Images | BCCI X) Former Indian wicketkeeper-batter Deep Dasgupta has suggested replacing Karun Nair with B Sai Sudharsan for the final two Test matches against England, as Nair has struggled to establish himself at number three position in the ongoing Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy series. Nair, who returned to the Test team after an eight-year gap, has managed only 131 runs in three games and remains the sole top-four batter from either team without a half-century in the series. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! Sai Sudharsan, who made his Test debut at Leeds scoring zero and 30, was later benched to accommodate batting all-rounder Washington Sundar for the Edgbaston and Lord's matches. "In the Playing XI, you don't want more than one change. If there is only one, it would be replacing Karun Nair with Sai Sudharsan. Because Karun Nair hasn't made any runs. He's got starts, but hasn't converted them into big scores. I also believe he doesn't look that comfortable at the crease either," Dasgupta said on JioHotstar. Inside Lord's: Exclusive Stadium Tour & Must-Do Experiences "And secondly, Sai Sudharsan is a young player. If you want to invest in this England series, you'd rather invest in a younger player. Karun Nair has got starts in both Test matches, but he hasn't looked that convincing," he added. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo "So if you're looking to build ahead, you might as well invest in someone like Sai Sudharsan. Because after this, I don't know when you'll come back to a series in England. So when you have two Tests left, invest in Sai Sudharsan," Dasgupta concluded. India currently trails 1-2 in the five-match series. The Shubman Gill-led Indian team will aim to level the series in the fourth Test beginning July 23 at Old Trafford, Manchester. The fifth and final Test match will be played at The Oval in London from July 31 to August 4. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
