Was Scotland's summer tour a success or failure?
Here's what some of you said:
Abigail: I don't think it can be classed as a success without the win in Fiji. However, I do believe the players on the tour will have learned a lot during their game time. The players built strong cohesion to end the tour and some players really stood out for Scotland selection, which is the ultimate aim. Especially Jamie Dobie, Andy Christie, Fergus Burke, Gregor Brown, Kyle Rowe, Ben Muncaster and Ollie Smith.
George: Yes, it was a success because of the amount of first-team players who were missing. They did great against Samoa.
Bernard: No, it's been a failure. We couldn't find our game against Fiji and got beat for it. Winning against Samoa isn't getting us into the top-six rankings, which means another group of death in the next World Cup. Gregor Townsend's time is up.
Jake: The Fiji game was billed as crucial to our World Cup seeding so the success of the tour can only be judged on this game. We once again showed a complete inability to perform when it really matters; characteristic of Townsend's tenure as head coach. The only way the tour could be judged a success is if the higher-ups at the SRU finally see sense off the back of this fresh failure and remove Townsend.
Kev: I'm counting the performance of the Dobie-Burke combination as a success. They looked class against Samoa, with the creative emphasis taken on by Dobie while Burke attacked the line with solid skill. Of course the Fiji result is not ideal, but the exposure of the wider squad to test match rugby is a plus. Christie and Fin Richardson also looked up to speed and offering something to be hopeful for in the future.
Stuart: The Scots did their job well against Samoa. Ewan Ashman had a good game, his first for a while. Arron Reed and Rowe connected well, as did Burke in the midfield. Fiji was a disaster but a good look at the talent coming through. Townsend has done well. The players let him down badly last week.
Tam: Scotland still lack the killer instinct when they are ahead of teams. It's something which has not been addressed. We are able to fight back great and hold out wins here or there, however there is a lack of cutting edge, especially in second-half performances. Townsend says we showed character. We know we have that within us but it's taking teams to the sword which we lack.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Take a Look at Nike's Incredible Pro-Family Tribute for British Open Champ Scottie Scheffler
Nike has just posted a new ad featuring golf superstar Scottie Scheffler, a beautifully crafted piece that resonates deeply with themes of family and success. The sneaker conglomerate posted the image following Scheffler's dominating performance at the British Open. The ad features a heart-warming image of Scheffler crouching on the green to meet his crawling child who is reaching for his putter. It is captioned, 'You've already won.' A second image shows Scheffler in mid-swing with the text, 'But another major never hurt.' Fans were pleased to see a message from Nike staying out of the political realm, or the glitzy and glamorous aspect of being thee best golfer in the world, instead focusing on family for a change – a rarity in sports. 'Refreshing to see uplifting content in sports ads from Nike,' one fan responded. Another wrote, 'This is the kind of athlete you should promote.' Take a look at the powerful image … His Son Stole the Show Scottie Scheffler secured a commanding four-stroke victory at the 2025 Open Championship at Royal Portrush, finishing at 17-under (267) to claim his fourth major title and the third leg of the career Grand Slam. As the world's top-ranked golfer for over 130 weeks, Scheffler has won four majors—the 2022 and 2024 Masters, the 2025 PGA Championship, and the 2025 Open Championship—solidifying his dominance in professional golf. Despite all that, his son Bennett stole the show during the post-match celebration. Following his major win, Scheffler celebrated with his wife, Meredith, and their 14-month-old son, Bennett, who charmed fans with an adorable attempt to join his father on the 18th green. Bennett stumbled while trying to climb the slope but was quickly scooped up by Scheffler, creating a heartwarming moment that went viral. RELATED: Scottie Scheffler Delivers All-Time Quote on the Importance of Family Scottie Scheffler, the world's No. 1 golfer, delivered a profound reflection at a press conference before the 2025 Open Championship, where he emphasized that his family, not golf, is his true priority. 'Is it great to be able to win tournaments and to accomplish the things I have in the game of golf? Yeah, it brings tears to my eyes just to think about because I've literally worked my entire life to be good at this sport,' Scheffler said. 'To have that kind of sense of accomplishment, I think, is a pretty cool feeling.' He expressed that the fleeting euphoria of winning tournaments doesn't fulfill him deeply, however, as life quickly moves on to mundane moments, such as deciding what to eat for dinner. 'This (golf) is not a fulfilling life. It's fulfilling from the sense of accomplishment, but it's not fulfilling from a sense of the deepest places of your heart,' Scheffler added. Scheffler stated he would retire from professional golf if it ever negatively impacted his relationship with his wife or son, underscoring that being a great father outweighs being a great golfer. 'I'm blessed to be able to come out here and play golf, but if my golf ever started affecting my home life or it ever affected the relationship I have with my wife or my son, that's going to be the last day that I play out here for a living,' he concluded. 'Because I'd much rather be a great father than I would be a great golfer. At the end of the day, that's what's more important to me.' Scheffler's candid and emotional comments on the importance of being a great husband and father compared to being a great golfer garnered nearly six million views. Also Read:: Open Championship 2025: 10 Winners and Losers, Including Scottie Scheffler Hoisting the Claret Jug Related Headlines Tennessee Titans QB Out For Season: 5 Early Replacement Options 5 NASCAR Drivers Having Breakout Seasons in 2025 Why Baltimore Orioles' Adley Rutschman May Face an Uncertain Future with Team Report: 2 'Strong Candidates' Revealed to Become Atlanta Braves Manager in 2026
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Scottish sports star dies after hotel balcony fall in Ibiza
Tributes have been paid to a Scottish sports star who died after falling from a hotel balcony in Ibiza. Gary Kelly, from Dundee, fell to his death at the Ibiza Rocks Hotel in San Antonio in the early hours of Monday morning. The 19-year-old ice hockey star played for both [[Dundee]] Stars and Aberdeen Lynx last season. A statement from Dundee Stars read: "The Dundee Stars are truly devastated to learn that Gary Kelly has tragically passed away. "We send our thoughts and condolences to Gary's family, partner, and all his friends at this extremely difficult time. "Everyone at the club including players, staff, management, and ownership are heartbroken to hear this tragic news. "Gary was hugely talented and charismatic individual who had a great future ahead of him. His loss will impact many in the ice hockey community and beyond. He will be sadly missed. "We respect and support the family's request for privacy at this extremely difficult time." READ MORE: Glasgow shop robbed at gunpoint as staff member threatened Investigation underway after teen sexually assaulted in Glasgow street Man due in court after 'disturbance' at Glasgow flat block Aberdeen Lynx also paid tribute, writing: "The Lynx family is heartbroken to share the devastating news of the sudden passing of one of our brightest young stars, Gary Kelly, while on holiday. "Gary was more than just a talented hockey player — he was a young man full of heart, passion, and dedication. On the ice, he gave everything he had. Off the ice, he brought energy, kindness, and an infectious love of life that lifted everyone around him. He wore his heart on his sleeve, and that spirit left a lasting mark on our team, our club, and everyone who had the privilege of knowing him. "Gary's potential was limitless, but even more than that, he was simply a brilliant person to be around. He was part of our family, and his absence leaves a hole that cannot be filled. "We send our deepest condolences to Gary's family and friends at this unimaginably difficult time. Our thoughts are with you, and we stand with you in grief and in love. "As a club, we are doing all we can to support our players and members as they come to terms with this tragic loss. "Rest easy, Gary — you will always be one of our brightest stars." Scottish Ice Hockey, the governing body for ice hockey in Scotland, added: "It is with deep sadness that Scottish Ice Hockey has learned of the sudden passing of Gary Kelly, a young athlete who represented both his clubs and his country with distinction. "Gary was a dedicated and talented player who proudly wore the Scotland jersey. He brought commitment, energy, and integrity to the sport both on and off the ice. His passion for hockey and the positive impact he had on teammates, coaches, and those around him will not be forgotten. "At just 19 years old, Gary had already demonstrated remarkable potential and was widely respected throughout the Scottish ice hockey community. His love for the game and the contribution he made to the clubs he played for have left a lasting legacy. "On behalf of everyone at Scottish Ice Hockey, we extend our deepest condolences to Gary's family, friends, and teammates at this incredibly difficult time. "We join them in mourning the loss of a young man who gave so much to the sport we all cherish. Gary will be remembered with admiration, respect, and great fondness." The death of the teenager comes weeks after another Scottish holidaymaker died at the same hotel in similar circumstances. Evan Thomson, 26, from Aberdeen, died after falling from a sixth-floor balcony at the Ibiza Rocks Hotel on July 7. On Monday afternoon, Ibiza Rocks issued a statement and confirmed that it had paused events following the deaths. The statement read: "We are deeply shocked and devastated by the recent incidents that have tragically occurred. 'Our priority is to support those affected and their loved ones during this incredibly difficult time, and to fully assist the authorities with their investigations. 'The safety and wellbeing of our guests has, and always will remain, our highest priority. "Given the seriousness of the situation and out of respect for those involved, we believe it is right to pause our advertised events programme at this time."
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
World Rugby unable to identify perpetrators of racism at Argentina-England match
LONDON (AP) — World Rugby couldn't identify perpetrators of racism after receiving a complaint from England regarding abuse aimed at its players during a match in Argentina this month. 'While it is clear that an incident took place, we regret that the individuals responsible could not be identified,' World Rugby said Monday, adding that the Argentine federation 'has developed an action plan to enhance their operations, educate fans and better prevent such unacceptable incidents from occurring again.' Jack van Poortvliet's last-gasp try earned England a 22-17 win over Argentina and another test series victory in Pumas country. 'We strongly condemn all acts of racism and stand in solidarity with the England Rugby players who felt aggrieved,' said Gabriel Travaglini, president of the Argentina Rugby Union. 'Upon learning of the incidents, intense efforts were made to identify the small group of five or seven individuals responsible within a crowd of over 20,000 spectators,' Travaglini added. 'Unfortunately, despite an exhaustive search, it was not possible to identify the perpetrators. We will continue to work collaboratively with World Rugby to educate the fans and eradicate any similar manifestations in the future, ensuring that our events are spaces of respect and inclusion for everyone.' __ AP rugby: The Associated Press
