
Scholars explain how humans can hold the line against AI hype, and why it's necessary
Strategic refusal is one of the ways to counter AI hype. (Bigstock Illustration / Digitalista)
Don't call ChatGPT a chatbot. Call it a conversation simulator. Don't think of DALL-E as a creator of artistic imagery. Instead, think of it as a synthetic media extruding machine. In fact, avoid thinking that what generative AI does is actually artificial intelligence.
That's part of the prescription for countering the hype over artificial intelligence, from the authors of a new book titled 'The AI Con.'
''Artificial intelligence' is an inherently anthropomorphizing term,' Emily M. Bender, a linguistics professor at the University of Washington, explains in the latest episode of the Fiction Science podcast. 'It sells the tech as more than it is — because instead of this being a system for, for example, automatically transcribing or automatically adjusting the sound levels in a recording, it's 'artificial intelligence,' and so it might be able to do so much more.'
In their book and in the podcast, Bender and her co-author, Alex Hanna, point out the bugaboos of AI marketing. They argue that the benefits produced by AI are being played up, while the costs are being played down. And they say the biggest benefits go to the ventures that sell the software — or use AI as a justification for downgrading the status of human workers.
'AI is not going to take your job, but it will likely make your job shittier,' says Hanna, a sociologist who's the director of research for the Distributed AI Research Institute. 'That's because there's not many instances in which these tools are whole-cloth replacing work, but what they are ending up doing is … being imagined to replace a whole host of tasks that human workers are doing.'
Such claims are often used to justify laying off workers, and then to 'rehire them back as gig workers or to find someone else in the supply chain who is doing that work instead,' Hanna says.
Tech executives typically insist that AI tools will lead to quantum leaps in productivity, but Hanna points to less optimistic projections from economists including MIT's Daron Acemoglu, who won a share of last year's Nobel Prize in economics. Acemoglu estimates the annual productivity gain due to AI at roughly 0.05% for the next 10 years.
What's more, Acemoglu says AI may bring 'negative social effects,' including a widening gap between capital and labor income. In 'The AI Con,' Bender and Hanna lay out a litany of AI's negative social and environmental effects — ranging from a drain on energy and water resources to the exploitation of workers who train AI models in countries like Kenya and the Philippines.
The authors of 'The AI Con': Emily Bender (left) is a linguistic professor at the University of Washington. Alex Hanna (right) is director of research at the Distributed AI Research Institute. (Bender Photo by Susan Doupé; Hanna Photo by Will Toft)
Another concern has to do with how literary and artistic works are pirated to train AI models. (Full disclosure: My own book, 'The Case for Pluto,' is among the works that were used to train Meta's Llama 3 AI model.) Also, there's a well-known problem with large language models outputting information that may sound plausible but happens to be totally false. (Bender and Hanna avoid calling that 'hallucination,' because that term implies the presence of perception.)
Then there are the issues surrounding algorithmic biases based on race or gender. Such issues raise red flags when AI models are used to decide who gets hired, who gets a jail sentence, or which areas should get more policing. This all gets covered in 'The AI Con.'
It's hard to find anything complimentary about AI in the book.
'You're never going to hear me say there are things that are good about AI, and that's not that I disagree with all of this automation,' Bender says. 'It's just that I don't think AI is a thing. Certainly there are use cases for automation, including automating pattern recognition or pattern matching. … That is case by case, right?'
Among the questions to ask are: What's being automated? How was the automation tool built? Whose labor went into building that tool, and were the laborers fairly compensated? How was the tool evaluated, and does that evaluation truly model the task that's being automated?
Bender says generative AI applications fail her test.
'One of the close ones that I got to is, well, dialogue with non-player characters in video games,' Bender says. 'You could have more vibrant dialogue if it could run the synthetic text extruding machine. And it's fiction, so we're not looking for facts. But we are looking for a certain kind of truth in fictional experiences. And that's where the biases can really become a problem — because if you've got the NPCs being just total bigots, subtly or overtly, that's a bad thing.'
'The AI Con: How to Fight Big Tech's Hype and Create the Future We Want,' by Emily M. Bender and Alex Hanna. (Jacket design by Kris Potter for Harper)
Besides watching your words and asking questions about the systems that are being promoted, what should be done to hold the line on AI hype? Bender and Hanna say there's room for new regulations aimed at ensuring transparency, disclosure, accountability — and the ability to set things straight, without delay, in the face of automated decisions. They say a strong regulatory framework for protecting personal data, such as the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation, could help curb the excesses of data collection practices.
Hanna says collective bargaining provides another avenue to keep AI at bay in the workplace. 'We've seen a number of organizations do this to great success, like the Writers Guild of America after their strike in 2023,' she says. 'We've also seen this from National Nurses United. A lot of different organizations are having provisions in their contracts, which say that they have to be informed and can refuse to work with any synthetic media, and can decide where and when it is deployed in the writers' room, if at all, and where it exists in their workplace.'
The authors advise internet users to rely on trusted sources rather than text extruding machines. And they say users should be willing to resort to 'strategic refusal' — that is, to say 'absolutely not' when tech companies ask them to provide data for, or make use of data from, AI blenderizers.
Bender says it also helps to make fun of the over-the-top claims made about AI — a strategy she and Hanna call 'ridicule as praxis.'
'It helps you sort of get in the habit of being like, 'No, I don't have to accept your ridiculous claims,'' Bender says. 'And it feels, I think, empowering to laugh at them.'
Links to further reading
During the podcast, and in my intro to the podcast, we referred to lots of news developments and supporting documents. Here's a selection of web links relating to subjects that were mentioned.
Bender and Hanna will be talking about 'The AI Con' at 7 p.m. PT today at Elliott Bay Book Company in Seattle, and at 7 p.m. PT May 20 at Third Place Books in Lake Forest Park. During the Seattle event, they'll share the stage with Anna Lauren Hoffmann, an associate professor at the University of Washington who studies the ethics of information technologies. At Third Place Books, Bender and Hanna will be joined by Margaret Mitchell, a computer scientist at Hugging Face who focuses on machine learning and ethics-informed AI development.
My co-host for the Fiction Science podcast is Dominica Phetteplace, an award-winning writer who is a graduate of the Clarion West Writers Workshop and lives in San Francisco. To learn more about Phetteplace, visit her website, DominicaPhetteplace.com.
Fiction Science is included in FeedSpot's 100 Best Sci-Fi Podcasts. Check out the original version of this report on Cosmic Log to get sci-fi reading recommendations from Bender and Hanna, and stay tuned for future episodes of the Fiction Science podcast via Apple, Spotify, Player.fm, Pocket Casts and Podchaser. If you like Fiction Science, please rate the podcast and subscribe to get alerts for future episodes.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
23 Parents Are Revealing The Biggest (and Funniest) Lies They Tell Their Kids, And If You Need Me, I'll Be On The Floor Laughing
Sometimes a parent's got to do what a parent's got to do. Whether their kiddo is throwing a seemingly endless temper tantrum or refusing to eat their veggies, parents have to occasionally get a little creative with their version of the "truth..." That's why when TikTok user (and former NFL quarterback) @mattleinartqb said, "I'm bored. Tell me the biggest lies you tell your kids. I'm not talking about Santa or the Easter Bunny. I want the ones that you're taking to the grave," thousands of parents took to the comment section to share the weirdly useful and wildly creative "mistruths" they tell their children. Without further ado, here are 23 of their best stories: If you've ever told your kids a creative or hilarious lie, feel free to tell us about it in the comments or using this anonymous form! 1."When my daughters were six and three, they both slept with my partner and me, so I had them start sleeping on the floor instead. A couple of days in, they got the flu, so I told them they were allergic to carpet and they started sleeping in their own beds!" "I forgot all about it until my oldest was 21 and called to let me know she was not allergic to the kind of carpet in her boyfriend's house. I finally told her the truth. I didn't mean for them to believe it that long — I just forgot. I then got a call from my other daughter telling me that she couldn't believe I lied to them like that!" —tori_jones_ Related: 2."I used to tell my son that oil or chewing gum spots in the parking lot were kids who didn't hold their mommy's hand when they were walking in traffic." — 3."Whenever I don't want to watch one of my daughters' shows, I tell her the characters are sleeping: 'Sorry, Paw Patrol are sleeping!'" "She's only two and a half, but I'll be sad the day it doesn't work..." —mls090493 4."My son was a picky eater and would never eat homemade pizza. When he was about three, I made a pizza and told him it was Batman's special recipe. He ate that sh*t up. He still asks me for Batman pizza today and he's SEVENTEEN." —eunice38350 5."I told my kids that the hazard button in the car was an ejection button for the passenger seat and that it would shoot them straight through the roof! They never touched anything around it and believed me until they were around 10." —raynacorrine 6."For every bite of vegetables they ate during dinner, they could stay up five minutes later. They didn't know how to tell time, so it worked." —11carla 7."I told my niece that if you break a pinky promise, your pinky will fall off. When she eventually lied, she went wild trying to hold her pinky on because she thought she was going to lose it." —cass_a_bration Related: 8."My parents told my sister the ice cream man was actually the music man. He plays music to make people happy, and he only has his music on when he's out of ice cream." —laura_rey1993 9."I told my daughter when new teeth grow in, they create new tastes. Now she tries to figure out which new foods she will like every time a new tooth comes in." —christopherwilso62 10."I told my kids that all mommies have eyes in the back of their heads. We were at a rest stop once, and I asked the woman ahead of us in line if it was true, and she said, 'Yes, it's true.' ALL of the moms around us agreed." "It was an unspoken support group and my daughter wholeheartedly believed it!" —npe2021 11."My husband used to tell our kids that if they picked their noses, the boogers would bite their fingers and make them crooked. Then he would show them his old broken finger and say, 'See!'" —micheleg8192 Related: 12."I made up a fictional character called Mr. Bugs, and when my son is behaving badly, I always tell him, 'I'm calling Mr. Bugs to deliver bugs to your bedroom, so when you wake up, you'll have them all over your room.' He shapes up real quick." —a_wachter 13."My son choked on bacon when he was six and refused to eat after that. When we were going on day four, I decided I had to do something to get him to eat, so I introduced him to anti-choking medication (watered-down syrup) in a medicine bottle with a legitimate-looking label that had his name on it." "He is 15 now and still reminisces about how that medicine saved him." —ffdh509 14."We live in a semi-rural area, so there are wild rabbits all around the house. I told my son they're all Easter Bunny spies who report back daily, all year." —mom2wil 15."I'm not a parent, but when I was learning the difference between left and right, my parents told me if I put my shoe on the wrong foot, I'd grow an extra toe." — 16."I told my daughter the only man she could trust was her daddy because he graduated from 'man school' and got a diploma (a homemade wallet-size 'man card'). Only certain men can get such a prestigious award, and he's legit because he has the card in his wallet to prove it." — 17."If we go somewhere that has a playground or a bounce house and we don't have time to play, I tell my kids that we didn't buy tickets like the other children, and they're definitely sold out by now." —jpgiddens 18."I text 'Santa' with pictures of toys my kids like; that way, we don't have to fight about toys at every single store. Closer to Christmas, we text Santa again with the top two or three toys they wanted all year. It helps with Christmas shopping too!" —circusofamerica Related: 19."Our family went to Disney parks often when we were kids. My dad told us that he knew Mickey Mouse personally and if we went to sleep early, he would take our autograph books to him before he went to bed and get them signed, so we never had to wait in long lines." "It took 25 years for us to realize that my dad just used his left hand to sign 'Mickey's' name." —carlymathes12 20."When you pee in a pool, you have to raise your hand to let others know what you are doing, so they know to stay away." —otoole732003 21."We have a family gnome. He lives in the kitchen or pantry. We even have a house just for him. If my kids don't clean up their things, he'll take them away and give them to kids who will take care of them." "He also magically fixes/replaces things when they get broken if you ask him really nicely and do good deeds. When you're extra good, he'll randomly leave trinkets, candy, etc." —sapphirecailleach 22."They think the car doesn't start unless their seatbelt is fastened. Facts." —aprilprest 23."My son has a scar on his arm, and I told him that is where I put a tracking device in him so I always know where he is." "He will be 15 this year, and I still tell him that — he still doesn't know if it's true or not. —lmt8310 Which one of these lies was your favorite? Parents, what's the biggest lie you've ever told your kid(s)? Tell us in the comments or answer anonymously using the form below! Note: Some responses have been edited for length and/or clarity. Also in Internet Finds: Also in Internet Finds: Also in Internet Finds: Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Gwyneth Paltrow is Astronomer's ‘temporary spokesperson' in new video
There's a lot of buzz around Astronomer, the data infrastructure company that skyrocketed into public attention after its executives - now former executives - gave us the viral Coldplay 'kiss cam' moment. With all this recent popularity, the business brought on some extra help, hiring a 'temporary spokesperson' with experience in Coldplay internet fame: Gwyneth Paltrow. Subscribe to The Post Most newsletter for the most important and interesting stories from The Washington Post. 'I've been hired on a very temporary basis to speak on behalf of the 300+ employees at Astronomer,' the actress said in the minute-long video posted to social media Friday. 'Astronomer has gotten a lot of questions over the last few days, and they wanted me to answer the most common ones.' The Goop chief executive happens to be the ex-wife of Coldplay lead singer Chris Martin and co-author of the original 'break-the-internet' breakup statement when the pair announced their 'conscious uncoupling' in 2014. If you're searching for answers to the company's real frequently-asked questions, you won't find them in the tongue-in-cheek clip. The questions 'OMG! What the actual f' and 'How is your social media team holding' get comically cut off by Paltrow as she explained the much less juicy details of Astronomer's business. 'We've been thrilled so many people have a newfound interest in data workflow automation,' Paltrow said. Astronomer's chief executive Andy Byron and human resources chief Kristin Cabot both resigned after they were filmed cuddling at a Coldplay concert in Boston earlier this month. They appeared on the arena video board in a 'kiss cam' segment before looking uncomfortable, with Cabot turning around and Byron ducking out of sight as Martin quipped from the stage that the two might be having an affair. Mark Borkowski, a British public relations and crisis consultant, described using Paltrow to front a video parodying the incident as 'utter genius' that shows the company has a sense of humor. 'It's a savvy use of media to create a viral moment,' he told The Washington Post in a phone interview Saturday. 'In a way you're laughing with everybody else.' Astronomer choosing Paltrow will not go unnoticed, Borkowski said. 'Astronomer is a meme now. Owning the ridiculous nature of how it became a meme is far better than apologizing for it.' A representative for Paltrow didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. As for how he advises clients caught in such situations, Borkowski said acting in a dignified way and 'using as few words as possible' is always the best approach. Paltrow's cameo is reminiscent of the scared Peloton wife discourse from 2019. After actress Monica Ruiz's worry-stricken expression in a Peloton holiday commercial became the butt of internet jokes, she laughed it off, later using her horrified face for an Aviation Gin ad. 'We will now be returning to what we do best: delivering game-changing results for our customers,' Paltrow closed out the ad. 'Thank you for your interest in Astronomer.' - - - Tatum Hunter contributed to this report. Related Content Hulk Hogan was a well-known Trump supporter. Their ties go back 40 years. Mendelson reaches deal with Commanders on RFK site amid growing pressure Amy Sherald cancels major Smithsonian show over 'censorship' Solve the daily Crossword

Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Dan Campbell references Metallica in interview with Tom Pelissero at Lions camp 'Back Together Weekend'
Detroit Lions head coach Dan Campbell references Metallica in interview with NFL Network Insider Tom Pelissero at Lions camp.