OAP who slashed neighbour's neck with Stanley knife in row over dogs avoids jail
A 69-year-old man who slashed at his neighbour with a Stanley knife after a dispute over trespassing dogs has had his four-month custodial sentence replaced with a peace bond on appeal.
Gary Healy, with an address at Palmerstown Woods, Clondalkin, Dublin, left his neighbour with cuts to his neck and arms after the assault.
Healy had pleaded guilty in the District Court to assault causing harm contrary to section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act, 1997.
Stock image
Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 5th
The District Court Appeals Court yesterday heard that on June 28, 2023, the victim went to the home of Mr Healy in order to speak to him following an earlier argument between Healy and the injured party's wife.
Garda Shay Leonard, giving the facts on behalf of a colleague, told the court that there had been a disagreement between the neighbours concerning dogs trespassing in gardens.
At the front doorstep of the house, Healy produced a Stanley knife and slashed at the injured party, the court heard.
The injured party received minor injuries including a 7cm cut to his neck, two 5cm cuts to his forearms and a 2cm cut to his hand.
Defence counsel for Healy, David Staunton BL, said that his client was reacting to the presence of the injured party at his doorstep and that he felt threatened when he heard someone come to the house.
He said that Healy had lived a 'blameless existence' until this incident, where he had the 'momentary thought process' to pick up the blade, which he lived to regret.
Mr Staunton said that Healy, who worked for 40 years as a porter in Temple Street Hospital, made the 'incredibly foolish and stupid decision' to arm himself in a panic.
He presented letters and testimonials in support of Healy from members of his community and said that Healy has sought to avoid the injured party since the incident.
Judge Jonathan Dunphy noted that something more serious could have happened and said the injured party has every right to be aggrieved and upset by the attack.
He said he accepted Healy's actions were an overreaction and that 'he let himself, his family and his neighbours down on this occasion'.
Judge Dunphy decided to replace Healy's four-month custodial sentence with a peace bond lasting 12 months.
He also ordered that €3,000 in compensation be paid to the injured party, or to the injured party's chosen charity if he does not choose to accept it.
Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
a day ago
- The Journal
Boy (14) accused of firebomb attack which ‘gutted' family home and killed pet husky in Dublin
A 14-YEAR-OLD BOY showed no remorse for taking part in a firebomb attack that destroyed an innocent family's home in Dublin and killed their pet husky trapped in the blaze, a court heard. The teenager, charged with arson of the house on Landen Road, Ballyfermot, which was left gutted on May 21, was denied bail today. The teen was remanded to the Oberstown Children Detention Campus after appearing before Judge Maire Conneely at Dublin District Court. The boy cannot be named because he is a juvenile with the right to anonymity. He made no reply when charged ahead of his court appearance after he was deemed unsuitable for inclusion in the Garda Youth Diversion Programme. Objecting to bail due to the seriousness of the case, Garda Alan McGinty recounted that at 2:28 am, gardaí responded to a report of a domestic fire at the home. They learned that one resident was asleep in the living room, but he woke to the sound of glass smashing and found the room was on fire. The man's wife, son and their dog were in the property at the time. He alerted his wife and son, and they got out, but the pet husky 'was still trapped inside and died in the fire'. The court heard the innocent family's home was 'totally' destroyed in the attack, after which a witness overheard a male yell 'wrong house'. Evidence was given that two males in balaclavas arrived at the house on an electric bicycle, and the defendant was allegedly the driver, while his passenger carried and threw the burning petrol can. Images of the scene were handed over to the court, which also heard there was CCTV footage, but the judge held it was unnecessary to view the video. She noted allegations that a jerrycan of petrol was bought at a service station three hours before the incident and brought to and hidden in bushes at a building in the Dolphin's Barn area. It was alleged that shortly before 2:30 am, two males arrived in a taxi, put on balaclavas, and travelled to Landen Road on an electric bicycle. Garda McGinty alleged that they could be tracked on CCTV, and after the arson, they returned to the Dolphin's Barn area and handed the electric bicycle back to another person. It was alleged that the boy and another male went away in a taxi, and the vehicle's dashcam footage has been retrieved, leading to his identification. Advertisement The jacket he allegedly wore in the taxi was found during a search of his home. Garda McGinty stated that during the interview, the teenager, who has no prior criminal convictions, showed no remorse. The boy, supported in court by his mother and other family members, sat silently at the side of the courtroom and has not yet indicated a plea. The judge noted that no bail terms would alleviate the concerns of the investigation team. A decision has yet to be made on his trial venue, but defence barrister Kevin McCrave submitted it was likely the case would go to the Circuit Court, which has greater sentencing powers. He submitted that refusal of bail would mean he could be held for a year before his trial and disrupt his education. He urged the judge to note that the teenager would abide by a myriad of strict conditions available to the court. Referencing the Children's Act, he cited the law, which sets out that detention should be a last resort. He stressed the teen had the presumption of innocence, no prior convictions, or history of drug abuse or failing to appear in court, and there was no witness intimidation evidence. However, Judge Conneely held that the garda had established a case for refusing bail and remanded the boy in custody to appear at the Children's Court on Wednesday. On Friday, a 15-year-old boy, also accused of arson, was denied bail too after a judge heard a description of the video evidence. 'This male passenger walks into the driveway, sets the jerrycan alight, throws a stone through the window, and throws the jerrycan full of petrol into the sitting room where the occupant of the house is sleeping, and the house is set alight,' Detective Garda Michael McNulty had told the Children's Court. That boy, who also has the right to anonymity due to his age, will appear again on Friday. Adult co-defendant Curtis Stafford, 23, of Rutland Grove, Crumlin, appeared before Judge Paula Murphy at Dublin District Court on Friday, also facing a connected arson charge. Garda Kevin Coller alleged Mr Stafford, who has still to enter a plea, purchased the jerrycan of petrol used in the incident. The unemployed man was refused bail and was remanded in custody to appear again on July 11. All three have been granted legal aid.
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
OAP who slashed neighbour's neck with Stanley knife in row over dogs avoids jail
Gary Healy, with an address at Palmerstown Woods, Clondalkin, Dublin, left his neighbour with cuts to his neck and arms after the assault A 69-year-old man who slashed at his neighbour with a Stanley knife after a dispute over trespassing dogs has had his four-month custodial sentence replaced with a peace bond on appeal. Gary Healy, with an address at Palmerstown Woods, Clondalkin, Dublin, left his neighbour with cuts to his neck and arms after the assault. Healy had pleaded guilty in the District Court to assault causing harm contrary to section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act, 1997. Stock image Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 5th The District Court Appeals Court yesterday heard that on June 28, 2023, the victim went to the home of Mr Healy in order to speak to him following an earlier argument between Healy and the injured party's wife. Garda Shay Leonard, giving the facts on behalf of a colleague, told the court that there had been a disagreement between the neighbours concerning dogs trespassing in gardens. At the front doorstep of the house, Healy produced a Stanley knife and slashed at the injured party, the court heard. The injured party received minor injuries including a 7cm cut to his neck, two 5cm cuts to his forearms and a 2cm cut to his hand. Defence counsel for Healy, David Staunton BL, said that his client was reacting to the presence of the injured party at his doorstep and that he felt threatened when he heard someone come to the house. He said that Healy had lived a 'blameless existence' until this incident, where he had the 'momentary thought process' to pick up the blade, which he lived to regret. Mr Staunton said that Healy, who worked for 40 years as a porter in Temple Street Hospital, made the 'incredibly foolish and stupid decision' to arm himself in a panic. He presented letters and testimonials in support of Healy from members of his community and said that Healy has sought to avoid the injured party since the incident. Judge Jonathan Dunphy noted that something more serious could have happened and said the injured party has every right to be aggrieved and upset by the attack. He said he accepted Healy's actions were an overreaction and that 'he let himself, his family and his neighbours down on this occasion'. Judge Dunphy decided to replace Healy's four-month custodial sentence with a peace bond lasting 12 months. He also ordered that €3,000 in compensation be paid to the injured party, or to the injured party's chosen charity if he does not choose to accept it. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
Banned driver found asleep at wheel while almost five times over the limit
Sumod George Sam (45) was found slumped asleep in the seat, with the engine running and the keys in the ignition A banned driver, who was almost five times over the alcohol limit when he was found asleep at the wheel of his car in broad daylight with an empty vodka bottle in the passenger seat, has avoided a jail term and been disqualified from driving for five years. Garda Dylan O'Malley told Tallaght District Court that he was on mobile patrol on the Greenhills Road, Dublin 12 at around 4pm on August 9, 2023, when a man at a nearby bus stop flagged him down. The man alerted him to a white Honda Insight that was parked diagonally - half on the road and half on a hard shoulder - and appeared to be abandoned. When Garda O'Malley approached the vehicle he said he found the driver, Sumod George Sam (45), slumped asleep in the seat, with the engine running and the keys in the ignition. Stock image Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 5th An empty vodka bottle was visible in the passenger seat alongside recently purchased shopping, the court heard. The witness said the driver produced a learner permit and failed a roadside breath test. He was arrested and brought to a garda station, where the court heard that a subsequent breath analysis returned a reading of 99 micrograms of alcohol per 100ml of breath - nearly five times the legal limit of 20 micrograms for a driver on a learner permit. The court heard that Sam has a previous drink driving conviction from 2022 and was already serving a three-year disqualification, imposed in May 2024 and due to expire in February 2027. He was charged under Section 5(4)(b) and 5(5) of the Road Traffic Act 2010, for being in charge of a vehicle in a public place while exceeding the legal breath alcohol limit - namely, while having the intent to drive or attempt to drive the vehicle even though he was not actually driving at the time. Sam, with an address at Earlscourt, Terenure Road East, Dublin 6, pleaded guilty at the hearing. His defence counsel, Lauren Flanagan BL, told the court that Sam was deeply remorseful, had not come to garda attention since and had been 'partying with friends' at the time - describing the incident as an act of 'stupidity.' She said her client, a father-of-two who previously worked in IT but is currently unemployed, was willing to undertake a driver awareness course and she asked the court not to impose a custodial sentence. Judge Patricia McNamara described the level of alcohol involved as 'extremely dangerous' and said the offence warranted a significant response. She convicted Sam and imposed a five-year driving disqualification, effectively extending the existing ban by three years. She also imposed a four-month prison sentence, suspended for two years on Sam's own bond of €400, with conditions that he not drive or be in control of a vehicle and that he remain of sober habits. Sam had already surrendered his licence to Blanchardstown Garda Station. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.
