Religious organisations cannot ‘play the poor mouth' to avoid redress
Simon Harris
has said.
Mr Harris said organisations that want to 'show their Christianity' must step up to the plate and bankroll what is likely to be the largest and most expensive redress scheme in the history of the State.
There are serious concerns within the Government about the costs of and demand for a redress scheme for survivors of sexual abuse in schools. Asked if the State could afford such a scheme, Mr Harris said the Government will return to the issue of redress 'at a future point'.
But, he said, 'should we arrive at a point of a redress scheme', the people who should be paying for it 'are the people who allowed the abuse to be carried out'.
READ MORE
'The religious institutions that stood idly by as children were sexually abused in schools, including special schools, utterly despicable acts that happened over a sustained period of time with the knowledge of many,' he said.
Mr Harris said he was 'with the survivors,' who 'rightly want to see the perpetrators pay'.
'I'll endeavour to be diplomatic, but I think it's highly questionable some of these organisations who play the poor mouth when many of these are very, very well resourced organisations. Very well resourced,' Mr Harris.
The Tánaiste declined to say if he felt such religious organisations should have to contribute even if it made them insolvent, saying: 'I don't want to get into that language.'
'But I think they have to make a very significant, a very, very significant contribution. In fact, to be honest, I think the word 'contribution' is wrong. The buck stops with them,' he said.
'I think if people accept accountability, if people want to show their Christianity, I think they have to really step up to the plate here.'
Analysis by officials from the departments of Education, Justice, Children, an Taoiseach and Public Expenditure and Reform found that a redress scheme for survivors of sexual abuse in schools would be at a 'far greater scale' than any other scheme in the history of the State, and could have 'far-reaching implications.'
Setting up such a redress scheme was a recommendation of a Scoping Inquiry into historic abuse in schools. The same inquiry also recommended setting up a Commission of Investigation.
While the Government
last week agreed to set up such a commission
, it has not yet committed to a redress scheme. It is understood that more information about how many people would be likely to apply for such a scheme and how much it would ultimately cost is needed.
The Government is also understood to be examining international examples of redress schemes where liable third parties were responsible for payments. This includes a scheme in Australia which succeeded in getting religious organisations to pay for redress by threatening to withdraw charitable status or state funding.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
31 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Tariffs may kill EU-US trade and hunt for auction house treasure
US president Donald Trump's threatened tariffs of 30 per cent would realistically cut off the European Union's ability to keep trading with the United States as it has done for years, the union's top negotiator has said. Jack Power reports. The State is 'well positioned against the backdrop of uncertain markets' even though the Ireland still has debt of more than €200 billion and there is no place for complacency, National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) chief executive Frank O'Connor said as the agency published its latest annual report. Martin Wall has the story. UK bank NatWest is to exit its stake in PTSB, just over three years after it invested in the Irish bank as part of Ulster Bank's exit from the Republic. Joe Brennan reports. Business lobbying group Ibec has called on the Government to reduce the growth of public expenditure in an effort to reduce the State's reliance on 'volatile' corporate profit tax receipts. Hugh Dooley reports. READ MORE Cantillon looks at the woes Rachel Reeves is enduring as UK chancellor, while also asking why markets are so calm this time in the face of Trump's latest salvos. Many of us have seen someone turn up on the Antiques Roadshow or Cash in the Attic with something they bought for buttons that turns out to worth thousands if not more, but does could it happen to you? Fiona Reddan shows how to find out if that cheap copy you have is actually the real thing. In Your Money, Dominic Coyle answers reader questions on how to treat retirement funds, and whether a widow should hold on to her late husband's broker account. The average wholesale price of electricity per megawatt hour fell for the fifth month in a row in June to drop to its lowest level since April 2024. Colin has the details. The High Court has granted social media giant TikTok permission to pursue a legal challenge against what it argues is the 'penal' €530 million fine imposed upon it by the Data Protection Commissioner (DPC) over the alleged transfer of site-users' personal data to China. Paul Neilan reports. A construction firm is suing a glazing company over alleged defects in glass installed at the Exo Building in Dublin's Point village which it says cost some €6.8 million to repair, the Commercial Court heard. A Milanese court placed exclusive clothing label Loro Piana under judicial administration for subcontracting production to suppliers that allegedly exploited workers, making the LVMH-owned cashmere brand the latest fashion house to be caught up in a series of investigations into labour rights violations. European Commission vice-president Teresa Ribera has warned China that the EU will not tolerate ' dumping ' of low-cost Chinese electric vehicles in Europe. And she rejected the idea that the EU should accept 'cheap equipment' to help member-states to reach their decarbonisation goals. Denis Staunton reports. Shortlists for the annual Business to Arts Awards, which take place at the National Concert Hall September, have been announced . The awards, which recognise businesses that have partnerships with artists and arts organisations, will be judged by representatives from CBRE, ESB, Community Foundation Ireland, Irish Life, The Irish Times, and TileStyle. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Rein in spending to cut reliance on ‘volatile' corporation tax, Ibec says
Business lobbying group Ibec has called on the Government to reduce the growth of public expenditure in an effort to reduce the State's reliance on 'volatile' corporate profit tax receipts. The lobbying group said the positive status of the State's headline economic markers are largely funded by corporate tax, which its chief economist Gerard Brady said could be 'volatile' over the coming years. Ibec suggested a maximum net spend on budget day of €3 billion, with increased exchequer spending offset by fiscal drag and €1.3 billion made up of commitments under the National Development Plan. [ Ireland's corporate tax receipts hit €156bn Opens in new window ] Ibec pointed to figures showing that, should Ireland collect a level of corporate profit tax comparable to similar economies, every worker in the country would have to pay an additional €4,000 in taxes to make up the State's current tax revenue. In light of the reliance of the State's balance sheet on corporation tax, Ibec called for the Government to rein in spending increases in the coming budgets to 'return to a balance of income over expenditure, were our corporate tax receipts to be realigned with other mid-sized globalised economies'. The lobbying group said the gap stands at around €5 billion, and Mr Brady noted that recent US policy is adding to the economy's exposure to volatility with the State at risk of being left 'very short' on tax receipts should that risk materialise. Mr Brady said the Government could 'correct, fairly painlessly, the underlying budget deficit' over a number of years and would avoid 'more painful' measures in the future. He said the business community's biggest concern is of a 'sharp correction' in Government policy should that 'volatility be materialised'. Asked whether it supported Government indications that cost-of-living measures would not be needed in the Budget, Fergal O'Brien, Ibec's head of lobbying and influence, said the group was against 'universal supports'. 'We shouldn't be doing across-the-board, universal supports – it is just really bad economic policy,' Mr O'Brien said, urging the State to target distressed households and reduce the cost of business. [ The EU/US tariff deal: The good, the bad and the potentially ugly for Ireland Opens in new window ] Ibec also called for 'targeted supports' for industries hardest hit by US import tariffs, such as the the spirits industry, where Ibec noted more than 90 per cent of distilleries had paused or cut back production. Mr Brady said that some sectors would be placed under 'existential pressure' should the level of tariffs rest at 20 or 30 per cent. The lobbying group noted that their members have been 'very vocal' in raising 'a lot of concerns' about the EU's countermeasures in response to US tariffs. One measure Ibec suggested to reduce costs to businesses and households is reducing the fixed cost component on Irish energy bills through a 'strategic annual subvention'. The group also suggested indexing the top tax band and income tax credits to wage growth at a cost of €440 million and €240 million respectively. Amid economic turmoil, Ibec called on the Government not to reduce infrastructural spending, and to introduce a set of spending targets in the upcoming 2026-2029 medium-term fiscal plan. These include a fiscal investment target of 5 per cent of gross national income (GNI), and working towards increasing public investment in research and innovation to 1 per cent of GNI by 2035. To encourage homebuilding, Ibec called for the reduction of VAT to 5 per cent and the removal of Government levies on new-build apartments – which it said would 'improve the viability of apartment building'.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Rural self-catering businesses didn't cause housing crisis': Property owners, local TDs push back on Government plans for short-term lets
Ministers have been facing pressure from property owners and politicians to ease the planned crackdown on short-term letting. Minister for Tourism Peter Burke and Minister for Housing James Browne are developing the new regime for short-term lets, such as those advertised on Airbnb and other platforms, which will include a new register underpinned by updated planning permission rules. The plans are part of efforts to tackle the housing crisis with some suggestions that as many as 10,000 homes could be freed up for long-term rental use. The Government proposals have prompted complaints from short-term let owners and representatives of the self-catering tourism industry. READ MORE Issues raised in correspondence released under the Freedom of Information Act, include the requirement for planning permission for short-term lets – which previously did not apply to many rural areas – and a population threshold bringing in restrictions on new short-term-lets in towns with more than 10,000 people. [ Does it make financial sense to buy a holiday home? Opens in new window ] Issues highlighted include fears for the rural tourism industry and the impact on retirement income. A number of people said they have no intention of putting their properties on the long-term rental market. In response to queries on the complaints, the Department of Enterprise and Tourism said: 'Minister Burke is aware of the genuine concerns regarding the impacts on rural tourism and local economies, of removing a significant cohort of properties from the [short-term let] market.' The department also highlighted the goal of the measures saying: 'meeting local housing need across Ireland is a critically important consideration and Government must use every lever available to assist in providing homes for our people, including returning properties to the long-term residential market.' Under the Government proposals there would effectively be a ban on new planning permissions for commercial short-term lets in urban centres with more than 10,000 people. There have been misgivings among Government TDs including Minister Norma Foley and Minister of State Michael Healy-Rae over the potential impact of this on tourist towns such as Killarney and Tralee. A Department of Housing statement said the 10,000 population threshold has been Government policy since April 15th and 'there is currently no review of this threshold under way.' Other correspondence released shows Kerry Fianna Fáil TD Michael Cahill wrote to the Taoiseach, Tánaiste and Minister Burke seeking consideration of 'a planning exemption for those involved in short-term lets in Killarney and Tralee for the past three years and longer.' [ Ireland could face anti-tourism protests without regulation of AirBnB-style lets, officials warn Opens in new window ] Another Kerry-based Fianna Fáil politician, Seanad Cathaoirleach Mark Daly, wrote to Mr Browne highlighting the concerns of the Irish Self Catering Federation (ISCF). He wrote: 'The ISCF asks that any changes to planning requirements apply solely to new businesses, with a degree of common sense to avoid deterring new entrants'. A Department of Housing statement said: 'An exemption for existing short-term lets is not being considered at this time.' It said a planning exemption for home-sharers that let their entire principle private residence on a short-term basis for a cumulative period of 90 days will continue to apply. In the correspondence to Mr Burke one self-catering owner in Wexford told the Minister: 'Yes there is a housing crisis' but 'rural self-catering businesses didn't cause this'. They argued the plans would 'ruin an already troubled Irish tourism industry'. Another owner wrote: 'the short-term accommodation we let here is an integral part of our income. Its absence would call into question whether or not we are able to stay in our family home in old age'. Another woman said her 'entire pension and inheritance went into this' and she has provided a 'valuable service' with her short-term let. She said: 'I have never had and will never have, any interest in being a landlady.'
