French holiday camp accuses Vueling of discrimination against Jewish teens
The airline said it had asked the children to leave the Paris-bound plane in the Spanish city of Valencia due to their "disruptive behaviour", but parents condemned what some of them described as an "antisemitic act".
In a statement, Vueling said some passengers "engaged in highly disruptive behaviour and adopted a very confrontational attitude, putting at risk the safe conduct" the flight to Paris-Orly airport.
"We categorically deny any suggestion that our crew's decision related to the religion of the passengers involved. This decision was taken solely to ensure the safety of all passengers," it said.
"This group mishandled emergency equipment and actively disrupted the mandatory safety demonstration, repeatedly ignoring instructions from cabin crew," Vueling added.
The crew requested the intervention of the Civil Guard police force, which "decided to disembark the group to prioritise the safety of the rest of the passengers", Vueling said.
"Once at the terminal, the group's behaviour continued to be aggressive. Some individuals displayed a violent attitude," leading to the arrest of one person, Vueling said.
The Civil Guard corroborated Vueling's statement about a group of 47 minors and their four supervisors, saying the arrested person "refused to get off the plane and obey the officers" but was later released.
Parents said the teenagers were forced off the plane after one of them had sung a song in Hebrew.
A mother whose 17-year-old son was on the flight told AFP on condition of anonymity that the group was returning home from a two-week summer camp.
The mother said that after the 21-year-old leader of the travelling group tried to stop the Civil Guard from taking the youngsters' phones, "she was tackled to the ground and forcibly taken away in front of the kids, who started screaming".
She said she "could not see what could have justified" the incident, which affected children as young as 12 and 13. "They were disembarked like dogs," she said.
Karine Lamy, the mother of one of the children, told Israeli television channel i24NEWS that it was "an anti-Semitic act against young children who did nothing".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
2 hours ago
- France 24
French cities impose curfews for teens to curb crime
While some experts say that curfews for minors do not reduce crime, one French mayor begs to disagree. "It's become very quiet," said Cedric Aoun, the mayor of Triel-sur-Seine located 35 kilometres (21 miles) west of Paris. The 11 pm to 5 am curfew has been introduced in Triel-sur-Seine for under-18s after a series of incidents involving damage of public property and theft. Aoun said many families have started taking their parental responsibilities more seriously. "Parents are much more careful," he said. More towns in France are enforcing curfews for teenagers irrespective of their mayors' political leanings as authorities seek to respond to youth crime. In the southern city of Nimes, a temporary curfew has been introduced for children under 16 after a spate of urban violence linked to drug trafficking. The southern city of Beziers, Saint-Ouen-sur-Seine north of Paris and Villecresnes in the southeastern suburbs of the French capital have adopted similar bans. Last year, six percent of crimes were suspected to have been carried out by teens aged between 13 to 17, according to the interior ministry. More than a third of violent robberies without a weapon were attributed to suspects in that age group. 'No business on the street' But it is difficult to assess the effectiveness of the curfews for minors in many places. During a recent nighttime patrol in Triel-sur-Seine, police officers stopped a group of minors who huddled together in a square 45 minutes after the start of the curfew. Some teenagers said they were unaware of the ban. Still, the head of the town's municipal police praised the measure. Anthony Rouet said the curfew "allows us to take preventive action before damage is done". So far his team had mostly been talking to teens about the night-time ban on being in the streets, not issuing them with tickets, he added. But he also acknowledged that, when police did report some teenagers to the judiciary, this had not deterred them from reoffending. "They weren't punished and came back and started vandalising and stealing again," said Rouet. Some parents support the ban. "At 17, you have no business being out on the street" at night, said Mickael Chapparelli, 35. But many think otherwise, another resident said. "Here, parents of most of the children who hang around until 2 am say it's no problem," said the resident, speaking to AFP on condition of anonymity. "And when they get into trouble, they say it's not their son." The mayor of Villecresnes, Patrick Farcy, lamented police staffing shortages. They do not respond to calls late at night except during the weekends, and street lighting is turned off in some areas to limit gatherings. He said authorities had reported around 40 violations of the curfew since the beginning of the summer, but not all parents had received the related fines. "Too much time passes between the offence being reported and the fine being issued," Farcy said. 'Psychological' The mayor of Pennes-Mirabeau outside the southern port city of Marseille said the effectiveness of the curfew was hard to estimate. Last year, he temporarily ordered children under 13 off the streets between 11 pm and 6 am, but has not reintroduced the ban this year. The mayor, Michel Amiel, said the effectiveness of the ban was "difficult to quantify." "It is mainly psychological," he added. Rights campaigners argue for more community engagement rather than bans. Nathalie Tehio, head of the French Human Rights League, called for the development of "educational measures" rather than "repressive" bans. Her group has taken legal action against the ban in Triel-sur-Seine. "This is not an effective response," she said. elt-jra-vxm-bdq-as/ah/ach © 2025 AFP
Euronews
5 hours ago
- Euronews
Diplomatic row between Paris and Madrid over Jewish teens escalates
Tensions are escalating between Paris and Madrid following comments by Spanish Transport Minister Oscar Puente in the case involving the removal of a group of French Jewish teenagers from a flight in Spain. The incident occurred on 23 July, when a group of around 40 teens was removed from a plane at Valencia airport. Last Friday, Oscar Puente posted and then later deleted on the social media platform X, criticising Spanish conservative politicians for allegedly failing to back the airline and instead "supporting the Israeli brats." The post quickly drew ire from the French government, which also denounced the behaviour of Spanish law enforcement officers towards one of the group's adult chaperones. Videos on social media showed police holding the female counsellor on the ground while they handcuffed her. "The French government firmly condemns the comments made by the Spanish Minister of Transport equating French children who were Jewish with Israeli citizens, as if this in any way justified the treatment to which they were exposed," said Benjamin Haddad, Minister for European Affairs and Aurore Bergé, Minister for the Fight against Discrimination. The airline Vueling justified its decision by citing behaviour that allegedly compromised flight safety. In a statement posted on X on Friday, the airline said the teenagers had tampered with oxygen masks and life jackets, despite being warned not to do so by the crew. The situation ultimately led to the involvement of Spanish law enforcement. However, the organiser of the summer camp the youngsters were attending contests this version of events and claims the group was removed "without just cause." A formal complaint is expected to be filed against the airline for "physical and psychological violence and discrimination on the grounds of religion."
France 24
3 days ago
- France 24
Alvaro Uribe: Colombia's first ex-president convicted of a crime
Today, opinion polls suggest the 73-year-old remains the most trusted politician in the South American country confronting an upsurge in violence. Born to a landowner in the western Antioquia department, Uribe was elected to Colombia's highest office at the height of the conflict between guerrillas fighting poverty and political marginalization, rightwing paramilitary groups set up to crush the leftists, and the military. He is himself accused of having had ties to paramilitary fighters who often had the backing of agrarian elites. Uribe denies the claims, which are at the heart of his criminal conviction Monday for witness tampering. As president, Uribe adopted a hard line against the Marxist-inspired Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), which he accused of killing his father in a botched 1983 kidnapping attempt. With US backing for his campaign, several FARC leaders were killed on Uribe's orders and soldiers were deployed en masse in operations that gave many Colombians a sense of security, although the violence never diminished. Uribe, a US- and British-educated lawyer who prides himself on being a workaholic who cannot sing, dance or tell jokes, counts a passion for horses among his few distractions. He is a staunch Roman Catholic who practices yoga in the morning and prays at night. Uribe entered politics after his father's death, serving as a senator, mayor of his hometown Medellin, and governor of Antioquia -- Colombia's most populated department. As president, he successfully pushed a constitutional change that allowed him to be re-elected for a second consecutive term -- a reform later overturned by Colombia's highest court. Arguing he needed continuity to see out his battle against armed insurgents and the drug trade they controlled, Uribe also tried, unsuccessfully, to secure a third presidential term. Betrayal Uribe earned praise from Washington for his tough anti-drug policies and strong economic growth as president. Detractors call him an authoritarian who failed the poor. After his presidency ended, Uribe served another term in Congress from 2014-2020 and has continued campaigning for the political right and his Democratic Center party since then. He was instrumental in the choice of his successor: Juan Manuel Santos, who would go on to win the Nobel Peace Prize for his efforts towards a peace deal with the FARC in 2016. For Uribe, this was the ultimate betrayal. His vehement rejection of the agreement that saw the FARC down arms in 2017 has been gaining ground as recent peace efforts have failed under President Gustavo Petro -- Colombia's first-ever leftist president, in office since 2022. Divisive figure A man of short posture and deliberate speech, Uribe is a divisive figure: loved and hated in equal measure. He is known for losing his temper, once being recorded insulting a journalist and threatening physical violence. Even fervent detractors recognize his oratory and administrative skills. But his legacy has been tainted by numerous corruption and espionage claims swirling around members of his entourage. Uribe is under investigation for more than 6,000 civilian executions and forced disappearances allegedly committed by the military under his command. He has also testified in a preliminary probe into a 1997 paramilitary massacre of subsistence farmers when he was governor of Antioquia from 1995 to 1997. During his life, Uribe claims to have survived 15 assassination attempts, including a rocket attack by former guerrillas on the day of his first inauguration. Uribe is married and has two grown sons who have had to answer claims that they rode on his presidential coattails to become successful entrepreneurs.
