logo
Supreme Court spares jail term for convict in POCSO case, cites systemic failures

Supreme Court spares jail term for convict in POCSO case, cites systemic failures

The Hindu24-05-2025
The Supreme Court on Friday (May 23, 2025) spared a convict, who married the victim, from undergoing a jail term under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, citing systemic failures and the need to ensure justice for the adolescent girl and her child.
A bench comprising Justices Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan invoked its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution, which empowers the top court to pass any order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it.
"This year we have completed 75 years of the Constitution on 26th January. The Constitution contemplates the State to be a welfare state. The Constitution guaranteed social and economic justice to all the citizens. In this case, there is a failure to provide both social and economic justice to the victim," the verdict said.
Failure of welfare state concept
The facts of the case indicate the failure of the concept of welfare state, it added.
"To remedy the situation in this case, it is the obligation of the State Government to act as the true guardian of the victim and her child and ensure that they settle down in life and lead a happy, healthy and constructive life ahead," it said.
The verdict came in a case that had captured national attention not only for the legal issues involved but also for the broader social questions it raised about adolescent rights, institutional accountability and child protection.
The case
The case arose from a 2018 incident in West Bengal, where a 14-year-old girl left her home to live with a 25-year-old man, who later fathered her child. The man was convicted by a Special POCSO court for aggravated sexual assault under Section 6 of the Act and relevant provisions of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
However, the Calcutta High Court controversially overturned the conviction, citing the consensual nature of their relationship and the current family circumstances.
The top court suo motu (on its own), and an appeal by the West Bengal government reversed the High Court's decision in August 2024. However, it deferred sentencing until further inquiry into the well-being of the victim and her child.
"Broadly, there are three issues which we are considering. The first issue is of sentencing the accused. The second issue is about the rehabilitation of the victim and her child. The third issue is a wider issue about adopting measures for adolescent well-being and child protection which goes to the root cause of the problem in our changing society," the verdict said.
Jail would deepen trauma
"Sending him to jail now would only deepen the trauma suffered by the victim," Justice Oka said and emphasised that the "true justice" in this case lies in family rehabilitation, not retribution.
"In law, we have no option but to sentence the accused and send him to jail for undergoing the minimum punishment prescribed by the Statute. However, in this case, the society, the family of the victim and the legal system have done enough injustice to the victim.
"She has been subjected to enough trauma and agony. We do not want to add to the injustice done to the victim by sending her husband to jail," the bench said.
The judgment said judges cannot shut their eyes to harsh realities.
"Now, at this stage, in order to do real justice to the victim, the only option left before us is to ensure that the accused is not separated from the victim. The State and the society must ensure that the family is rehabilitated till the family settles down in all respects," it said.
Case to not be treated as precedent
The verdict, however, made clear that "this case will not be treated as a precedent", describing it instead as "an illustration of the complete failure of our society and legal system".
"This case is an illustration of the complete failure of our society and our legal system. All that the system can do for the victim now, is to help her fulfil her desire of completing her education, settling down in life, providing a better education to her daughter and ensuring overall better living conditions for her family," it said.
The court-appointed panel's reports painted a grim picture of systemic lapses and flagged failure of village-level Child Protection Committees and poor implementation of welfare schemes like Kanyashree Prakalpa.
The panel said there was inaction from child welfare police officers and an absence of free legal aid and gender-sensitive counselling.
Hardship for victim
The verdict noted these shortcomings and said they have worsened the situation for the minor victim, who not only endured the original offence but also faced immense social, psychological and financial hardship.
Issuing a slew of directions, the bench directed the state government to provide full financial and educational support to the victim and her daughter. It also ordered that the victim be enrolled in a school and be supported up to the college level, if desired.
The bench directed the state government to ensure the child's nutrition and education under schemes like Mission Vatsalya, besides exploring the option of imparting vocational training and part-time employment to the victim post-school.
It asked the government to secure better housing and settle the family's debts with NGO or public support.
The bench has also directed the Union Ministry of Women and Child Development to form a committee of experts alongside senior state officers and amici curiae to suggest systemic improvements based on the recommendations of the court's own committee. The central ministry has to submit a report by July 25.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

School Assembly news headlines for today July 24, 2025: From sports to education, check 20+ national & international news
School Assembly news headlines for today July 24, 2025: From sports to education, check 20+ national & international news

Time of India

time11 minutes ago

  • Time of India

School Assembly news headlines for today July 24, 2025: From sports to education, check 20+ national & international news

School Assembly news headlines for today July 24, 2025: Here are today's School Assembly news headlines for July 24, 2025. Over 20 key national and international stories are making headlines, covering areas like sports, education, and current affairs. The Indian Air Force plans to retire all MiG-21 fighter jets by September, ending decades of service. The Supreme Court is set to hear Maharashtra's plea related to the 2006 Mumbai train blasts case. Parliament's Monsoon Session continues, marked by strong opposition protests. On the global front, peace talks between Russia and Ukraine are expected to resume soon. A major earthquake struck Russia's Kamchatka region, though no casualties have been reported. In sports, Australia's Mitchell Owen made history with a unique T20I record, while Indian chess players like Arjun Erigaisi continue to shine in international tournaments. These updates give students valuable insights and help them stay informed during today's school assembly. Today's national news headlines in English for school assembly, July 24, 2025 New Income Tax Bill halves word count, eases tax compliance while keeping rates unchanged. PM Modi begins four-day visit to UK and Maldives to strengthen trade, defence, education, and technology partnerships. Parliament adjourned for the third consecutive day amid Opposition demands on Bihar voter list and "Operation Sindoor" debate. Election Commission starts preparations for vice-presidential election after Jagdeep Dhankhar's resignation. Schools closed in multiple states including Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, and Andhra Pradesh due to festivals and heavy rainfall. Today's international news headlines in English for school assembly, July 24, 2025 UN's top court to deliver a non-binding opinion on climate responsibility with potential global legal impact. United States announces withdrawal from UNESCO, citing cultural and organizational concerns. India to resume issuing tourist visas to Chinese nationals after a five-year pause. Tensions rise between Thailand and Cambodia after a landmine incident on the border. Today's sports news headlines in English for school assembly, July 24, 2025 Sports Minister presents bill in Parliament to improve transparency in national sports bodies including BCCI. Kabaddi league in Uttar Pradesh valued at ₹238 crore after its inaugural season due to rural and digital audience growth. Aditya Mehta reaches quarterfinals of IBSF 6-Red Snooker Championships with a strong comeback. NCSSR holds first ethics committee meeting to enhance research standards in sports science. India-England Test series underway with the fourth test starting in Manchester. Today's education news headlines in English for school assembly, July 24, 2025 Schools in several states observe closures due to cultural festivals like Kanwar Yatra, Aadi Amavasai, and severe weather. Andhra Pradesh EAPCET Round 1 seat allotment results announced, impacting thousands of students. Over 1.09 lakh vacancies announced in Central Armed Police Forces with ongoing recruitment drives. Authorities seize over 4.7 lakh pirated NCERT textbooks, addressing educational content piracy. PayPal integrates UPI via new PayPal World platform facilitating easier international payments for Indian users. Today's state news headlines in English for school assembly, July 24, 2025 Karnataka traders protest 6,000 GST notices based on UPI data; officials clarify notices are not final. Bengaluru small business owners plan three-day protest over GST UPI notices; government launches 'Know GST' campaign. Kanwar Yatra enters final stage with devotees reaching Shiva temples for Jalabhishek rituals. Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan sworn in as 17th Chief Justice of Jharkhand High Court. Mumbai's Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj International Airport ranks among world's top 10 international airports in Travel + Leisure 2025 list. Top business and economic news headlines for July 24, 2025 Enforcement Directorate files case against Myntra for ₹1,654 crore FDI violation alleging misuse of wholesale model. RBI lifts restrictions on Religare Finvest Limited, allowing normal operations to resume. Infosys reports increased attrition rate of 14.4% in Q1 FY26; total headcount rises to 3.24 lakh employees. Indian government resumes issuing tourist visas to Chinese nationals after five years. IndiQube Spaces launches IPO with price band ₹225-237 per share, size ₹700 crore. Daily word and thought of the day for school assembly, July 24, 2025 For the school assembly on July 24, 2025, here are the daily word and thought of the day: Word of the Day for July 24, 2025: Quake — a verb meaning to tremble or shake, as the ground does in an earthquake. Thought of the Day for July 24, 2025: 'Many are the woes of the wicked, but the LORD's unfailing love surrounds the man who trusts in him.' — Psalm 32:10 (NIV). For more informative articles on historical and upcoming events from around the world, please visit Indiatimes Events.

Anti-doping bill now in line with WADA demand
Anti-doping bill now in line with WADA demand

Hindustan Times

time38 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

Anti-doping bill now in line with WADA demand

New Delhi: Sports minister Mansukh Mandaviya on Wednesday tabled the amended National Anti-Doping Bill in the Lok Sabha with a view to provide greater 'operational independence' to the National Anti-Doping Agency (NADA) as prescribed by World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA). Picture of the logo of World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA)taken on September 20, 2016 at the headquarter of the organisation in Montreal. (Photo by Marc BRAIBANT / AFP) (AFP) Among the highlights of the Bill is the retention of the contentious National Board for Anti-Doping in Sports, albeit its powers have been curtailed. The Board will no longer have the NADA appeals panel under its jurisdiction as was the case in the original act passed in 2022. These provisions were flagged by WADA as signs of government interference, leading to a delay in the Act's implementation. The Board, in the previous Bill, was empowered to constitute the appeal panel and 'oversee the activities' of NADA. That act could not be implemented as WADA objected to 'government interference' in NADA's functioning. The amended bill seeks to 'enhance institutional and operational independence of the National Anti-Doping Appeal Panel and the National Anti-Doping Agency to ensure autonomy in their decisions pertaining to operations, investigations and enforcement activities.' 'The Director General or any other staff member of the Agency shall have operational independence from any National Sports Federation, International Federation, National Olympic Committee, National Paralympic Committee or any Government department or agency with responsibility for sport or anti-doping,' the amended bill states. The amendments were imperative to ensure that India does not end up being suspended by WADA that has been keeping a close watch over NADA in recent years. The introduction of the amended bill comes shortly after India emerged as the top country in terms of total doping tests conducted in 2023 among nations that analysed 5,000 or more samples, according to WADA figures. In 2023, India's positivity rate stood at 3.8%, with 214 Adverse Analytical Findings (AAFs) out of 5,606 samples tested. This marked an increase in both sample size and positivity rate compared to 2022, when 3,865 tests yielded a 3.2% positivity rate.

Anti-ragging Act: Need two months to finalise draft amendments, Kerala HC told
Anti-ragging Act: Need two months to finalise draft amendments, Kerala HC told

Time of India

time39 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Anti-ragging Act: Need two months to finalise draft amendments, Kerala HC told

Kochi: The state govt has informed high court that it will take two months to finalise the draft amendments to the Prohibition of Ragging (Kerala) Act and Rules. Director general of prosecution (DGP) T A Shaji made this submission before the bench of Chief Justice Nitin Jamdar and Justice C Jayachandran in response to a petition by KeLSA, which sought a direction to the govt to reassess the Act and frame rules to ensure the effective eradication of ragging. During the hearing, the UGC and KeLSA submitted their suggestions regarding the draft Act and proposed Rules. The UGC recommended, among other things, the inclusion of autonomous colleges, affiliated colleges, hostels and lodges in the definition clause; the inclusion of hostel wardens in the anti-ragging committee; and ensuring that the proposed administrative actions under the Rules align with the UGC Regulations, 2009. KeLSA, in its suggestions, proposed changes to the definitions of 'ragging' and 'educational institutions.' They also recommended the inclusion of a provision for deemed abetment and the removal of the concept of 'freshers' from the draft. KeLSA clarified that deemed abetment would apply when the head of an educational institution or any responsible person fails to take timely and appropriate action upon receiving information or having knowledge of ragging, or wilfully conceals, suppresses, or fails to report such incidents. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Is it better to shower in the morning or at night? Here's what a microbiologist says CNA Read More Undo Such inaction or concealment, it said, should be treated as abetment of ragging and made punishable. KeLSA also suggested using 'any student' instead of 'freshers' in the draft so that protection against ragging applies not just to newly admitted students. Additionally, KeLSA informed HC that two ragging incidents were recently reported in the state. One allegedly took place at a Govt Higher Secondary School in Kaniyambetta, Kalpetta, Wayanad, where a Plus One student was instructed by five other students to shave his beard and report to school accordingly. Though he complied, retaining only his moustache, he was allegedly physically assaulted later. The second incident occurred in Malappuram district, where a Class IX student was reportedly bullied and physically assaulted by a newly admitted Class X student, along with others.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store