Joint provisional liquidators appointed to ‘Polo Stores' eastern European food shops
The High Court has appointed joint provisional liquidators to two companies behind the 'Polo Stores' franchise which imports and retails central and eastern European food supplies.
The court heard that due to a serious conflict between the two 50 per cent shareholders and directors, Alexandr Vakiy and Max Bulgakov, the companies were sliding into insolvency and there was a concern that the situation could affect the goodwill of suppliers.
Maxela Ltd and EastDeli Ltd were set up by Ukrainian citizens, Mr Vakiy and Mr Bulgakov who came to Ireland in the late 1990s and opened a number of grocery stores.
There are now 15 Polo Stores operated by Maxela across the country. EastDeli operates a store in rented premises in Clondalkin, Dublin.
READ MORE
On Tuesday, Cian McGoldrick BL, instructed by Darragh O'Donovan of Orpen Franks Solicitors, told Mr Justice Brian Cregan the winding up petition was brought on behalf of Mr Vakiy in order to safeguard the goodwill of the companies and because of material concern that the relationship with suppliers was being undermined,
In the petition, it is claimed the relationship between the two men previously broke down resulting in Mr Vakiy bringing shareholder oppression proceedings. Mr Bulgakov alleged Mr Vakiy was party to an extensive €18 million fraud, a claim strongly denied by Mr Vakiy who said no evidence emerged supporting any fraud on the companies in this amount.
The oppression proceedings were withdrawn earlier this month but the issues they had raised 'continue to seriously affect the management of the companies'.
Mr McGoldrick told the court Mr Bulgakov had unilaterally blocked access to online banking facilities which meant staff and suppliers could not be paid.
The firms have between €700,000 and €900,000 in working capital but supplier costs alone are €450,000 a week which means they could 'slide into insolvency' in a matter of two weeks, he said.
The petition states the companies are 'effectively paralysed due to an irreconcilable breakdown in the relationship of trust and collaboration between the two shareholders and directors'.
It is also claimed there has been a recent credible offer of interest from a third party operating in the same industry in acquiring the whole the business as going concern, or its core assets.
Mr Justice Cregan said he was satisfied to appoint Brendan O'Reilly and Mark Degnan of Interpath Advisory (Ireland) as joint provisional liquidators.
He was satisfied the companies are insolvent and unable to pay debts as they fall due and that there is a good prima facie case that it is likely the winding up order will be obtained. This was on the basis that the relationship between the two shareholders is hopelessly deadlocked and there is a serious conflict between them, he said.
He granted orders giving certain powers to control the company to the provisional liquidators and said the petition to appoint full liquidators can be heard next month.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Man (20s) dies after being struck by a car in Ballymun, Dublin
A man has died after being hit by a car in north Dublin in the early hours of Saturday. The incident occurred in Ballymun shortly before 5am, An Garda Síochána said. 'At approximately 4:55am, gardaí and emergency services were alerted to a road traffic incident involving a car and a pedestrian at Balbutcher Lane,' the force said in a statement. 'The pedestrian, a man aged in his 20s, was pronounced deceased at the scene.' READ MORE The road was closed on Saturday morning to allow Garda forensic collision investigators to carry out a technical examination of the scene. Local diversions were in place. An Garda Síochána appealed to anyone who may have witnessed the collision to come forward. 'Any road users or pedestrians who were in the vicinity of Balbutcher Lane and Balcurris Park areas of Ballymun, between 4am and 5am, and have camera footage (including dash-cam), are asked to make this available to investigating gardaí.' Gardaí at Ballymun station can be contacted on (01) 6664400 or through the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111. The young man killed in the incident is the 82nd person to die on the State's roads this year, with the total including 22 pedestrians.
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Where is the value in increasing the Help-to-Buy scheme threshold?
Pre-budget submissions are all about pleadings. Every special interest group in the State makes a pitch for more resources. They all consider their proposals to be in the wider public and economic interest. Some are worthy, many more are largely self-interested. This year the whole process appears to have kicked off earlier than usual, perhaps on the understanding that the largesse of recent years is unlikely to be repeated this time around. In the first place, there is no election. Worries for the medium-term health of Europe's most open economy in a climate where tariffs, trade wars and an absence of consistency on policy are increasingly the norm also will inevitably push Ministers towards a more cautious approach. And for what money is available, the need is to prioritise investment in infrastructure. Expensive upgrades to electricity, water and sewerage networks that are increasingly being cited by foreign direct investors among factors counting against Ireland Inc are needed. READ MORE An EY survey on Friday found that more than two-thirds of Irish businesses 'are worried about securing enough energy to meet future needs', which is an extraordinary number. Put together, it means more things are going to be a tough ask to get over the line. [ First-time buyers in Dublin now locked out of Help-to-Buy scheme, warns Savills Opens in new window ] It seems a strange time then for estate agent Savills to be picking CSO house price data to press for an increase in the upper threshold for the Help-to-Buy scheme. Savills says first-time buyers in Dublin are paying an average of €515,000 for a home, putting them beyond the €500,000 ceiling for Help-to-Buy. It wants that ceiling increased to at least €621,000 to take account of inflation, it says. First, averages are notoriously prone to manipulation by singular expensive property sales. Second, the more reliable median data from the same CSO note shows that prices exceed €460,000 only in Dún Laoghaire Rathdown among the four Dublin local authority areas. [ Developers are bluffing when they say lower prices would undermine viability of house building Opens in new window ] Then there is the maximum available tax refund under Help-to-Buy, which is €30,000. Ignoring that when calling for a higher ceiling is not making property more affordable for first-time buyers in general, only for the very wealthy. It is worth remembering that while the marketing speaks about providing a helping hand for first-time buyers – with even the scheme's name selected for the same reason – Help-to-Buy was from the start a scheme put together to help developers make the numbers stack up on building starter homes. That's not happening, as supply constraints (and prices rising at their fastest rate in 10 years) attest, so for the State – and those first-time buyers – what is the value of widening the incentive?
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Paul Coulson faces last stand in battle to retain control of Ardagh
Ten years ago last month, Dublin businessman Paul Coulson walked away from a €3 billion deal to buy a glass-bottle business being sold by French building materials group Saint-Gobain. It seemed a rare moment of restraint for a man in a hurry, having spent the previous 15 years turning a once sleepy Irish bottle company into a multibillion-euro packaging giant – Ardagh Group – through a series of purchases funded by debt raised in the high-cost, junk-bond market. It would not last long. Less than a year later, Coulson unveiled a similar-sized transaction, but one that would catapult Ardagh into the business of making cans for beers and fizzy drinks. Today, that business – Ardagh Metal Packaging (AMP), whose customers range from Coca-Cola and Heineken to Nestlé – has surfaced as a prized asset as Coulson and holders of some of wider group's $12.5 billion (€10.7 billion) of borrowings scramble to salvage what they can from an empire saddled with too much debt. Coulson effectively owns 36 per cent of Ardagh Group. READ MORE Ardagh Group has acknowledged for more than a year that it needs to reduce its liabilities, after both its glass and beverage cans businesses had been hit since the Covid-19 pandemic by inflation, soaring interest rates, and soft consumer demand on both sides of the Atlantic. The heavily-indebted business proposed in March that a group of senior unsecured bondholders write off much of the $2.32 billion they are owed in exchange for taking full ownership of the glass containers part of the business. The plan also envisaged Ardagh Group spinning its shares in AMP into new company (NewCo). This would be 80 per cent owned by Coulson and other existing Ardagh Group shareholders – with the unsecured creditors receiving the remaining 20 per cent. Holders of a further $1.79 billion of the group's riskiest debt, so-called payment-in-kind bonds issued by a holding company at the top of the Ardagh corporate tree, know they're toast, with these notes trading below 5 per cent of their original value. Talks with the unsecured creditors broke down in May after they pitched a proposal that would see them take 40 per cent, rather than 20 per cent, of AMP, which has seen its prospects improve in recent quarters, even as the glass containers arm of the group continues to grapple with weak demand. The unsecured creditors also wanted the $784 million of preference shares they were being offered in the NewCo to be increased to $1.07 billion. AMP, in which Ardagh Group has a 76 per cent stake, is listed on Wall Street, where investors have also recently come to appreciate the improving outlook for this business – even as the glass side struggles. The market value of AMP, which has $3.98 billion of ring-fenced borrowings, has jumped more than 45 per cent to $2.59 billion so far this year. This was driven by a spike in April when its chief, Oliver Graham, signalled that the business had 'turned a corner', helped by a rebound in demand for energy drinks, sparkling water and health segments. The value of Coulson's indirect 27 per cent stake in AMP has increased as a result to more than $700 million. This is well off the $1.7 billion it was worth when the stock debuted on the New York Stock Exchange almost four years ago. It is also a fraction of the now 73-year-old's €2.4 billion interest in the wider Ardagh Group when it peaked in April 2021 – before the group delisted and floated its beverage cans unit. It emerged last week that certain bondholders have offered Coulson – who remains on the board of the group, having retired as chairman in late 2023 – and other investors in Ardagh Group $250 million to hand over total control of the empire to creditors and walk away. Shareholders include management and investors that remained on board a tiny version of the current group that was listed in Dublin more than two decades ago. The bondholders clearly do not feel the need to keep Coulson on after a restructuring. This differs from the case of fellow former junk-bond darling, Denis O'Brien , when his overindebted Digicel mobile phone company ran out of road two years ago. Digicel had no equity value when its bondholders took control in a subsequent debt-for-equity swap. However, the creditors left O'Brien with a 10 per cent stake and stock warrants that would entitle him to a further 10 per cent, subject to the company meeting certain targets, knowing they needed him to maintain key relationships with regulators and politicians across its 25 emerging and, in some cases, frontier markets. The problem for Ardagh Group bondholders is the corporate web structure – including a company set up in April 2022, at a time when interest rates were soaring globally, under the group to hold its 76 per cent stake in AMP. This was designated a so-called unrestricted subsidiary, putting its assets out of reach of group creditors. The directors of that subsidiary sought fit last year to set up another unit to hold the prized asset. Bondholders thinking they can wave off Coulson and a small number of legacy investors in Ardagh Group with a $250 million check had better have the bottle for a battle.
