CB orders transfer of tax appeals from high courts
A five-member Constitutional Bench headed by Justice Aminuddin Khan gave the order while hearing the appeals against super tax. The court ordered the registrars of both the Islamabad High Court (IHC) and the Lahore High Court (LHC) to provide list and records of the pending tax intra-court appeals.
At the outset of the hearing, Makhdoom Ali Khan, the lawyer for various companies, pointed out that cases were pending in the high courts. He added that the Supreme Court had the constitutional powers to transfer pending cases to it.
Sitting on the bench, Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar asked whether a written application would be required for the transfer of the cases. On that Makhdoom Ali Khan replied that under Article 186A, the Supreme Court had the constitutional authority to refer a case from a high court to the Supreme Court.
Khan further said in his arguments that the government could not directly impose the super tax, as it was mandatory to give a reason for such a levy. He added that there must be exceptional circumstances for levying the super tax.
The lawyer argued that the Supreme Court had declared additional tax as invalid in its several decisions, adding that imposing additional tax was also against fundamental rights. The court ordered the transfer of appeals and adjourned the hearing until Thursday (today).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Talal, JI leaders discuss ‘Balochistan Rights March'
LAHORE: Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry, a member of the government committee formed in connection with Jamaat-e-Islami Balochistan's 'Haq Do Balochistan Ko' long march, visited Mansoorah, here on Sunday afternoon. He met with Jamaat-e-Islami leaders including Naib Emir Liaqat Baloch and Secretary General Ameerul Azeem. The meeting focused on discussions regarding the long march. It was agreed that the government would provide full security to the March participants until they reach Multan and Lahore. The Minister of State said that in Lahore, the federal government's committee would engage in talks with the organizers of the Haq Do Balochistan Ko march. He expressed hope that the march would conclude in Lahore and that there would be no need to proceed to Islamabad. Jamaat-e-Islami leaders stated that the party is peaceful and struggles for public rights through legitimate and democratic means in accordance with the Constitution. They urged the government to provide security for the peaceful march. The Jamaat-e-Islami leaders also emphasized to the Minister of State that the march should be allowed to reach its final destination in Islamabad and that the government must show seriousness in addressing the demands of the wounded and deprived Baloch people. The Minister responded by saying that this was precisely why he had come to the party's headquarters in person. He added that the PML-N and the government have always given priority to resolving Balochistan's issues. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Senators decry judicial overreach
A 12-member panel, headed by Adviser to PM on NHLH Irfan Siddiqui, was constituted by PM. PHOTO: FILE Listen to article The Senate on Friday took exception to the Islamabad High Court's (IHC) move to issue stay orders on matters under discussion in parliamentary committees. Terming it a serious breach of privilege, the lawmakers called for the matter to be referred to the Senate's Committee on Rules of Procedure and Privileges. They also urged that the attorney general be summoned to explain the judiciary's overreach into parliamentary affairs. During the session, chaired by Senator Irfan Siddiqui, Senator Saleem Mandviwalla of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) objected to the stay orders issued by the IHC and Lahore High Court (LHC) against upper house proceedings. "I have never seen stay orders against parliamentary proceedings before. This should be taken seriously," he said, urging the Senate to summon the attorney general. "We never interfere in court proceedings, but judges issuing stay orders against committee actions is direct interference in Parliament. It's becoming a joke." Shahadat Awan supported the call. "We will seek input from the law minister and summon the attorney general for clarification and action." Senator Anusha Rehman said such actions violated Article 66 of the Constitution and constituted a breach of privilege. "Issuing a stay order against a member of Parliament is a direct attack on their privilege," she said, urging the House to refer the matter to the privileges committee and have those responsible appear before it. "No one can stop us from speaking in this House," she added. Senator Kamran Murtaza expressed concern over reports of lawyers being picked up in Balochistan. "If someone has committed a crime, they should be punished under the law," he said. The Presiding Officer responded that a report on the matter would be sought.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
PARTLY FACETIOUS: ‘Have we ever been rated as investment grade?'
'Hallelujah!' 'Hallelujah is Hebrew and can be broken down into two words – halel means joyous song, praise, and Yah is a shortened form of Yahweh or Jehovah, Allah.' 'Why did you do that?' 'Do what? I merely translated…' 'Why did you translate the Hebrew Yahweh into the Muslim Allah?' 'Dear me, learn to distinguish between Judaism as a religion and Zionism as a policy of a state that justifies genocide and…' 'It's hard given what Israel is doing, but anyway that's not why I said Hallelujah.' 'I know why you said it. Because we have been upgraded by Standard and Poor's from CCC (substantial risk) to B- (highly speculative) which, as per the definition on their website, retains us in the junk category.' 'I believe we would need six more upgrades to get out of the junk category and into the investment grade category.' 'Have we ever been rated as investment grade?' 'Never, I believe the highest rating we got was B+.' 'There you go so we need only two more upgrades to reach the historic high.' 'Why do you keep the bar so low?' 'Why do you take it up so high – I mean to me, it means that you are succumbing to hopelessness and last I heard this is not the Islamic way and…' 'I was merely trying to point out to the SPs that it's rather a long road and…' 'SPs?' 'Same Pagers – we need to aim higher than the historic high, and we need…' 'OK, but remember one thing. In a world gone crazy…' 'Yes, but there is change – the under 40s in the West including the US, and President Trump's support base are all challenging the Israel First Policy of successive US administrations…' 'That has not changed policy yet, that would require another twenty to thirty years, when these under 40s take over the reins of government and…' 'Hamm and you have Germany that allowed the US to blow up the Nordstream pipeline that had supplied cheap Russian fuel to German industries resulting in German deindustrialization, you have Ursula Von Der Layen, a German heading the European Union, hell-bent to compel member states to borrow hundreds of billions to set up a defence industry capable of fighting Russia, and…' 'Hatred does more harm to the hater than the hatee I reckon, and especially when there is unreasoning hatred….' 'I heard the cabinet collectively hates The Man Who Must Remain…' 'Good that you mentioned collective, because the 2016 Supreme Court verdict in the Mustafa Impex case insisted that the cabinet instead of the prime minister can take a decision…' 'Don't be facetious.' 'Hallelujah.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
